Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster cover image

Links

Steam

Twitch

MONSTER

Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster
Item: Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2024

GenresAction, Shooter, Single Player, First Person Perspective

AvailableFeb 28, 2024

PlatformNintendo Switch, PC, Xbox One, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4

DeveloperNightdive Studios

Overview

Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster will use Nightdive Studio’s proprietary KEX engine, support up to 4K resolution at 120FPS, feature modern gamepad support, remastered cutscenes, and add trophies and achievements to the original game experience. Players assume the role of Kyle Katarn, a mercenary hired by the Rebel Alliance to discover and destroy the Galactic Empire’s Dark Trooper project, a clandestine military operation created to develop Force-sensitive stormtroopers and battle droids. Star Wars: Dark Forces features several memorable locations from the original trilogy, including the interior of a Star Destroyer and Jabba the Hutt’s desert yacht, as well as new locations unique to the game. Star Wars: Dark Forces has enjoyed a sizable cult following in the decades since its original release, having been added to the Steam storefront back in 2009 and even being partially canonized in official Star Wars lore with the introduction of the Dark Troopers in the second season of The Mandalorian.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Nostalgic, story-driven shooter nails Star Wars' spirit with Kyle Katarn's rebel missions and cinematic flair, but its simplistic plot, Legends lore ties, and 90s-era design feel dated, offering retro charm over modern depth—still a must-play for fans craving classic action.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

77%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

23%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The reviews of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster highlight its strengths as a nostalgic and engaging entry in the Star Wars universe. Critics like ZTGD and Movies Games and Tech praise the game for introducing Kyle Katarn, a compelling protagonist whose missions align with classic Star Wars themes, such as rebellion against the Empire and iconic locations. Nintendo Insider emphasizes that the narrative captures the essence of the original trilogy’s spirit, while PC Gamer commends its cinematic storytelling and level design, which set a benchmark for FPS games. The game’s mission structure, featuring clear objectives and cutscenes (as noted by Nintendo Life and Riot Pixels), adds depth beyond simple combat, offering players agency and immersion. These elements collectively position the story as a solid foundation for Star Wars lore, appealing to fans of the franchise’s rich history. However, some critics point to limitations in the narrative’s complexity and modern relevance. Pure Xbox notes that the plot is “simple” and focused on shooting without significant character development or setup, which may disappoint players seeking deeper storytelling. CGMagazine criticizes the game’s relegation to Legends lore, suggesting it lacks the weight of canon-adjacent material, while GameStar mentions the original plan to feature Luke Skywalker, which was altered for canonical consistency—a change that some might view as a missed opportunity. Additionally, GamingBolt and Metro GameCentral observe that the storytelling feels less cinematic by today’s standards, though they acknowledge its engaging characters and familiar Star Wars elements. These critiques highlight the game’s adherence to 1990s-era design, which, while nostalgic, may not satisfy modern expectations for narrative depth or innovation. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster succeeds as a fun, story-driven shooter that effectively bridges the gap between classic Star Wars lore and early FPS mechanics. While it has its flaws—such as simplistic plot structures and outdated storytelling techniques—it remains a beloved entry for fans who appreciate its contributions to the franchise’s expanded universe. Nintendo Life and PC Gamer underscore its significance in shaping narrative-driven gameplay, while ZTGD and Worth Playing emphasize its role in setting up Kyle Katarn’s adventures within the Star Wars timeline. Despite mixed reactions on modern polish, the game is widely regarded as a worthwhile experience for both retro enthusiasts and newcomers seeking an accessible, action-packed story.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

A nostalgic throwback to 90s FPS glory, Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster charms with vertical, puzzle-filled levels, tactile combat, and faithful classic mechanics—yet its outdated design, frustrating mazes, and simplistic gameplay feel relics of a bygone era, offering a rewarding but dated adventure for retro fans.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

53%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

40%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster receives praise for its nostalgic charm and classic FPS mechanics, with several critics highlighting its engaging, fast-paced action and level design. ZTGD emphasizes that the game builds on the foundation of Doom, featuring complex vertical levels, hidden alcoves, and a variety of weapons that keep combat dynamic. Nintendo Life applauds the "true pleasure" of its environments, objectives, and combat mechanics, while Eurogamer praises its "tightly designed shooter" with tactile combat and maze-like maps that hold up well today. The remaster’s focus on exploration, such as navigating vertical spaces and solving light-based puzzles (as noted by NintendoWorldReport), adds depth, and critics like Movies Games and Tech acknowledge its preservation of the original’s "classic FPS experience." These elements collectively create a rewarding, if somewhat retro, adventure that appeals to fans of old-school shooters. However, several reviewers critique the game’s outdated design choices and simplistic mechanics. XboxEra calls the gameplay "simplistic and not deep," criticizing maze-like level layouts that feel frustrating to navigate despite improvements in aim assist. CGMagazine and Riot Pixels note a lack of weapon variety and flighty controls, while Nintendo Insider and GamingBolt highlight "frustrating design elements" and "outdated aspects" that may challenge modern players. The remaster’s reliance on key-hunting mechanics (as mentioned by Worth Playing) and its occasionally unclear objectives also draw criticism, with some finding the lack of distinct markers for tasks to be a drawback. Additionally, the absence of multiplayer and repetitive backtracking (as noted by PC Gamer) detracts from its appeal, suggesting that while the core gameplay is functional, it struggles to meet modern expectations. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among reviewers leans toward appreciation for Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster as a nostalgic homage to classic FPS design. While some, like Pure Xbox and Nintendo Life, celebrate its "moreish" 12-hour adventure and satisfying gunplay, others acknowledge its flaws as inherent to its retro roots. The game’s blend of verticality, puzzles, and fast-paced combat (as highlighted by GameStar and Metro GameCentral) resonates with fans of the genre, even if its level design and mechanics feel dated. Ultimately, critics agree that while it may not innovate, the remaster successfully captures the spirit of a bygone era, offering a worthwhile experience for those seeking a throwback to 90s FPS gameplay.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster’s visuals are a triumph, blending retro charm with modern polish—4K textures, remastered cutscenes, and toggleable graphics earn universal praise, though minor usability hiccups and gameplay quirks fade beside its stellar upgrades.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

93%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The majority of reviewers praised the graphics and visual design of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster as a significant upgrade while respecting its retro roots. Critics highlighted the game’s enhanced visuals, including crisp 4K resolution, improved textures, lighting, and remastered cutscenes that breathe new life into the 1995 original. Pure Xbox noted the “modernized controls” and “option to toggle between updated visuals and original ‘90s graphics,” emphasizing the flexibility for fans. XboxEra and ZTGD commended Nightdive Studios’ efforts, with the latter praising the “smooth performance” and “option to switch between pixelated and modern visuals.” Nintendo Life and Nintendo World Report echoed this, noting the “completely revamped aesthetics” while maintaining fidelity to the original design. The remaster’s ability to blend retro charm with modern polish was a recurring highlight, as seen in Nintendo Insider’s praise for “beautifully redrawn HD visuals” and Eurogamer’s acknowledgment of a “professional overhaul” that retains the game’s “original feel.” While the consensus leaned overwhelmingly positive, some critics pointed to minor drawbacks. CGMagazine noted that “level layout issues impact experience,” though this pertains more to gameplay than visuals. Nintendo Insider critiqued the “process could be more user-friendly” when toggling between visual styles, a small but notable inconvenience. Additionally, while most reviewers celebrated the remaster’s technical improvements, a few acknowledged that the original pixel art’s charm was preserved, which might not appeal to all. For instance, Worth Playing observed that the game retains “original pixel art charm,” and GameStar highlighted the “mix of sprites and polygon objects” as a nod to its 1990s origins. These critiques were largely overshadowed by the widespread acclaim for the visual upgrades. Overall, the critical reception of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster’s graphics and visual design was overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers across platforms (Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, PC, PS5) agreeing that Nightdive Studios successfully modernized the title without losing its essence. The ability to toggle between retro and updated visuals, along with improved textures, lighting, and cutscenes, was universally praised. Critics like PC Gamer and GamingBolt emphasized the “vast improvements” in resolution and “rebuilt assets,” while Nintendo World Report and Movies Games and Tech celebrated the “stunning visual experience” achieved through a blend of 2D and 3D elements. Despite minor critiques about usability or gameplay structure, the remaster’s visuals were consistently deemed a triumph, setting a high bar for retro FPS revivals and satisfying both nostalgic fans and modern audiences.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Praised for modernizing Star Wars: Dark Forces’ audio while preserving its soul, the remaster’s enhanced soundscapes and nostalgic retro profiles earned acclaim for immersion and clarity, though MIDI limitations and dated voice acting linger as minor flaws in an otherwise stellar upgrade.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster received widespread praise for their ability to modernize the original experience while preserving nostalgic elements. Critics like Pure Xbox highlighted the updated sounds and controller rumble effects, which enhanced immersion and gave the game a more contemporary feel. ZTGD noted the inclusion of multiple audio profiles that mimic old PC sound cards, evoking a retro charm that appeals to longtime fans. Movies Games and Tech emphasized how enhanced audio revitalized the game’s memorable music and sound effects, creating an immersive Star Wars atmosphere. Additionally, GameStar and Riot Pixels praised the soundtrack’s quality, with the latter specifically commending Clint Bajakian’s compositions, even if the remaster struggled to replicate the original’s interactive music engine. The clarity of voices and sounds, as noted by Worth Playing, further solidified the audio’s success in balancing modernization with fidelity to the source material. Despite these positives, some critics pointed out limitations, particularly regarding the MIDI-based soundtrack. Nintendo Insider acknowledged the charm of the original MIDI music but suggested it could benefit from more options, while Metro GameCentral criticized its aging quality, noting that the MIDI tracks sometimes sounded off. The voice acting also faced scrutiny; Metro GameCentral described it as “amateurish” despite being impressive for its time. Additionally, Riot Pixels highlighted that the remaster’s interactive music engine fell short of the original’s complexity, a minor but notable drawback. While most reviewers appreciated the nostalgic elements, these critiques underscored the challenges of modernizing retro audio systems without compromising their historical character. Overall, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with the remastered sound design and music celebrated for bridging the gap between nostalgia and modern gaming standards. The majority of reviews—such as those from GameStar, Pure Xbox, and Worth Playing—emphasized how the audio enhancements elevated the experience without losing the original’s essence. While some noted the limitations of MIDI and voice acting, these were seen as minor trade-offs in an otherwise successful remaster. The ability to preserve the game’s retro charm while improving clarity and immersion, as highlighted by ZTGD and Movies Games and Tech, solidified the audio as a key strength of the project, making it a standout effort for fans of the original.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster earns universal acclaim for technical polish, with Xbox/PS5 excelling in 4K/120fps stability, Switch offering retro-modern toggle flexibility, and PC shining with 4K/120fps and widescreen options. Minor hiccups—frame drops, save issues, Steam Deck battery life—exist but are overshadowed by Nightdive’s masterful modernization of a classic.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

46%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

54%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster receives strong praise across platforms, with notable highlights for each system. On Xbox Series X, critics like Pure Xbox and ZTGD commend its flawless 4K performance, stable frame rates, and modernized controls, emphasizing seamless optimization. For the Nintendo Switch, NintendoWorldReport praises sharp image quality, smooth frame rates, and toggle options between retro and modern engines, while Nintendo Insider highlights solid performance despite minor frame rate discrepancies tied to refresh rates. On PC, PC Gamer and GamingBolt (for PS5) laud high-end features like 4K/120fps support, widescreen compatibility, and accessibility improvements, with Metro GameCentral noting meticulous attention to detail in remastered assets. The PS5 version also shines, as GamingBolt and Metro GameCentral praise its near-flawless 4K/120FPS performance and enhanced visuals. Negatives are more nuanced but present across platforms. On the Nintendo Switch, Movies Games and Tech points to room for improvement in menus and maps, while Nintendo Life notes minor frame rate drops during combat—though these are deemed trivial. Riot Pixels on PC highlights technical issues like a lack of proper save systems and object shaking on modern monitors, and Worth Playing criticizes the Steam Deck’s short battery life and absence of cloud saves. While Xbox Series X and PS5 receive few direct criticisms, some PC reviewers, like Eurogamer, mention presentational flaws such as overlapping sprites and blocky 3D objects. These issues are framed as minor blemishes rather than major drawbacks. Overall, the remaster is widely celebrated for its technical upgrades, with platform-specific strengths underscoring its accessibility and polish. The Xbox Series X and PS5 versions excel in performance consistency and modernization, while the Nintendo Switch offers a solid experience despite hardware limitations. On PC, the game’s flexibility in resolution and rendering modes is a standout feature, though technical hiccups persist. Critics like PC Gamer and Metro GameCentral highlight that the remaster successfully revitalizes the classic title, balancing nostalgia with modern enhancements. While minor flaws exist across platforms, the consensus leans overwhelmingly positive, reflecting Nightdive Studios’ efforts to preserve the game’s legacy while adapting it for contemporary audiences.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster shines with nostalgic perks—vault unlocks, remastered visuals, secrets, and retro charm—but its short length, outdated mechanics, and lack of multiplayer limit appeal beyond die-hard fans.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

27%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

73%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The Replay Value of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster is largely praised for its curated extras and nostalgic appeal. Critics like Pure Xbox highlight the unlockable content in the vault, such as promo materials and toggleable visuals, while also noting the enhanced controller rumble effects that add depth to gameplay. Nintendo Life emphasizes the game’s wealth of secrets, hidden items, and customization options, which encourage multiple playthroughs. Similarly, ZTGD and NintendoWorldReport commend the remaster for its additional audio profiles, concept art, design documents, and a playable prototype level, all of which enrich the experience. Eurogamer and Metro GameCentral also praise the mission design and secret-hunting mechanics, suggesting that revisiting the game remains engaging due to these elements. The inclusion of remastered visuals and modernized controls (as noted by Worth Playing) further bolsters its appeal for fans seeking a polished yet classic experience. However, several critics point out limitations that could hinder replayability for broader audiences. XboxEra argues that the game’s short length and simplistic gameplay may not satisfy modern players, while PC Gamer notes that its mid-1990s FPS design might feel outdated compared to contemporary standards. Riot Pixels explicitly states that the lack of multiplayer and only 14 levels limit replay value, though they acknowledge fans might still enjoy secrets and achievements. Nintendo Insider also raises concerns about the $30 price tag being a barrier for some, despite the game’s content. Additionally, Metro GameCentral mentions that certain levels feel overly long, which could detract from the overall experience. These critiques suggest that while the remaster succeeds in preserving its core charm, it may not fully cater to players seeking extended or modernized gameplay. Overall, critics agree that Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster offers a compelling replay value for fans of the original and those drawn to its nostalgic elements, but its appeal is somewhat niche. The remastered extras, secrets, and improved controls (as highlighted by Pure Xbox, Nintendo Life, and Worth Playing) are seen as strong positives that justify revisiting the game. However, the lack of multiplayer, short length, and dated mechanics (noted by XboxEra, PC Gamer, and Riot Pixels) mean it may not resonate with all players. The consensus leans toward a balanced view: while the remaster is a worthwhile experience for Star Wars enthusiasts and retro fans, its replayability hinges on individual preferences for classic FPS design and the value of its added content.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

67%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

31%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall verdict of Star Wars: Dark Forces Remaster is overwhelmingly positive, with critics praising its faithful yet modernized approach to a classic FPS. Reviewers like ZTGD and Nintendo Life highlight the remaster’s enhanced visuals, smooth technical performance, and accessibility options, calling it a "quality remaster" that successfully bridges nostalgia with contemporary gaming standards. PC Gamer and Worth Playing emphasize its care in preserving the original’s charm while refining gameplay and presentation, making it a must-play for fans of the franchise. The game’s ability to respect its legacy while offering modern upgrades—such as improved controls and level design—has been widely appreciated, with Nintendo World Report noting it as "the best way to experience the game." These critiques underscore the remaster’s success in revitalizing a 1990s title without losing its core identity. However, some critics point out limitations that may deter broader appeal. XboxEra and Eurogamer note that the original game’s mechanics and level design feel outdated by today’s standards, with GamingBolt acknowledging "frustrating" aspects despite enhanced visuals. Metro GameCentral critiques the music and level length as drawbacks, while CGMagazine highlights flaws in gameplay and level design, suggesting the remaster isn’t without its imperfections. Additionally, XboxEra argues that the game may not justify purchase for players unfamiliar with the original, as it relies heavily on nostalgia. These criticisms reflect a divide between fans of the classic title and those seeking more modernized experiences, though they don’t overshadow the general acclaim. The consensus among critics is that Dark Forces Remaster is a commendable effort that delivers a polished, nostalgic experience for Star Wars enthusiasts. While it doesn’t revolutionize the genre or surpass other remakes like System Shock, its attention to detail and respect for the original’s legacy have earned praise from multiple outlets, including Nintendo Insider and Riot Pixels. The game’s accessibility features and modernized elements make it more approachable for new players, though its appeal is strongest for those with a connection to the 1990s FPS era. Ultimately, as GameStar noted, the remaster succeeds in balancing reverence for the past with contemporary improvements, offering a satisfying package that honors its roots while standing up to modern scrutiny.

TL;DR

A nostalgic yet polished remaster that balances 90s charm with modern tweaks, earning praise for visuals, controls, and accessibility—though its outdated mechanics and reliance on nostalgia may limit broader appeal.

MONSTER

Reviews

47 reviews found

Nintendo Life

Nintendo Switch

Feb 28, 2024