Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Amazon

Steam

Twitch

MONSTER

The Sinking City

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of The Sinking City
Item: The Sinking City
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2019

GenresFantasy, Adventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, Shooter, Horror, Open World, Puzzle and Logic, RPG, Mystery, Single Player

AvailableJun 25, 2019

PlatformPC, Xbox One, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X

DeveloperFrogwares

Overview

The Sinking City is a game of investigation genre taking place in a fictional open world inspired by the works of H.P. Lovecraft. The player incarnates a private investigator in 1920s, who finds himself in a city of New England, Oakmont Massachusetts. It's currently suffering from extensive waterflood, and its cause is clearly supernatural.

Elsewhere

7.0

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

74%

Mixed (50-79)

26%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The Story of The Sinking City has received generally positive reviews from critics. Many reviewers praise the game for its Lovecraftian themes and atmosphere. Critics such as Video Chums, Pure Nintendo, TrueAchievements, NintendoWorldReport, PlayStation Country, Softpedia, PlayStation LifeStyle, Game Informer, Screen Rant, Switch Player, Push Square, Game Rant, CGMagazine, TheSixthAxis, Gamers' Temple, Impulsegamer, COGconnected, WellPlayed, Game Debate, and TheXboxHub all mention the game's intriguing and captivating story that draws inspiration from H.P. Lovecraft's works. They highlight the game's ability to successfully blend various tales together, creating a powerful atmosphere and a sense of mystery. The story's incorporation of Lovecraftian horror, supernatural elements, and investigative elements are also praised by critics, with TrueAchievements specifically mentioning the investigative elements as the game's best feature. However, there are some criticisms regarding the story of The Sinking City. Critics such as Game Informer, PC Gamer, Daily Star, and Impulsegamer mention some flaws in the story. Game Informer notes that while the main story is consistently entertaining, the ending is underwhelming. PC Gamer criticizes the lack of interesting cases and satisfying solutions, as well as the charmless protagonist who lacks wit or nuance. Daily Star criticizes the lack of character development for the protagonist, which impacts the overall story experience. Impulsegamer mentions that the open-world aspect of the game can feel empty and detract from the narrative experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that The Sinking City offers an engaging and atmospheric story that successfully captures the essence of H.P. Lovecraft's works. The game's incorporation of Lovecraftian themes, supernatural elements, and investigative gameplay are highly praised. However, some critics have pointed out flaws such as underwhelming endings, lack of interesting cases, and a protagonist lacking in depth. Despite these criticisms, the majority of reviewers appreciate the game's narrative roots and detective storytelling, making it a worthwhile experience for fans of Lovecraftian horror and mystery games.

TL;DR

story and narrative

The Sinking City impresses critics with its captivating Lovecraftian story, blending tales seamlessly and creating a powerful atmosphere. The incorporation of horror, supernatural elements, and investigative gameplay is highly praised. While some critics note flaws like underwhelming endings and lack of character development, the majority agree that the game offers an engaging narrative experience for fans of Lovecraftian horror and mystery games.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

90%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The opinions of the videogame critics regarding the gameplay of The Sinking City are varied. Many critics praise the detective elements and investigative mechanics of the game. They appreciate the focus on gathering evidence, piecing together clues, and solving mysteries. Critics like Video Chums, TrueAchievements, PlayStation Country, PlayStation LifeStyle, and Screen Rant highlight the well-implemented detective gameplay and deductive reasoning. They find the player-driven puzzles and deductions entertaining and rewarding, providing a sense of discovery. The investigations are described as interesting and engaging, forcing players to use their intuition and in-game archives to find locations and solve mysteries. However, the combat mechanics of The Sinking City receive consistent criticism from multiple critics. Guardian, TrueAchievements, Washington Post, Critical Hit, GameWatcher, Switch Player, Push Square, Game Rant, CGMagazine, Gamers' Temple, PC Gamer, Daily Star, Impulsegamer, Digital Chumps, WellPlayed, and Game Debate all mention issues with the combat. They describe it as clunky, unsatisfying, and the worst aspect of the game. The combat encounters are lackluster, aiming is unwieldy, and melee attacks are often preferred due to limited ammunition. Critics also mention that combat feels unnecessary, disrupts the flow of the game, and becomes increasingly necessary for detective work, which can be frustrating. Overall, the consensus of the critics regarding the gameplay of The Sinking City is that the detective elements and investigative mechanics are the highlight of the game. The focus on gathering evidence, piecing together clues, and solving mysteries is praised by many critics, including Guardian, Video Chums, PlayStation Country, PlayStation LifeStyle, and Screen Rant. However, the combat mechanics receive consistent criticism from multiple critics, with many describing it as clunky, unsatisfying, and the worst aspect of the game. Despite the negative feedback on combat, the engaging detective gameplay and rewarding sense of discovery contribute to the overall positive reception of the gameplay in The Sinking City.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Videogame critics praise The Sinking City for its immersive detective elements and investigative mechanics, with a focus on gathering evidence and solving mysteries. However, the combat mechanics receive widespread criticism for being clunky and disrupting the gameplay flow. Overall, while the detective gameplay shines, the combat falls short, impacting the overall gaming experience.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

34%

Mixed (50-79)

59%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of The Sinking City are varied. Some critics, such as PlayStation Country and WellPlayed, appreciate the visual enhancements and improved textures on the PS5, with PlayStation Country specifically mentioning the lovely uprated visuals to 4k. The game's environmental details and macabre ambience are also praised by God is a Geek and Gamers' Temple, who highlight the impressive visuals and eerie atmosphere created by the flooded streets and desolate surroundings. The world-building and atmosphere of The Sinking City, as mentioned by Game Informer and CGMagazine, are also commended, with the latter stating that the world accurately captures the essence of H.P. Lovecraft's stories. However, several critics express concerns and criticisms regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of The Sinking City. Video Chums, Pure Nintendo, and TrueAchievements all mention technical issues, graphical glitches, and subpar character designs. Pure Nintendo specifically points out rough environmental graphics and poor character models lacking texture, while TrueAchievements states that textures, colors, and character movements feel dated. PlayStation LifeStyle and Game Rant highlight specific graphical issues, such as dull textures, lifeless character eyes, frequent hangs, poor draw distance, and pop-in. These criticisms suggest that the game's visuals may not meet the expectations of some players, with certain aspects feeling unfinished or lacking polish. Overall, the consensus among the critics is mixed. While some critics appreciate the improved visuals, atmospheric details, and world-building, others express disappointment with technical issues, subpar character designs, and dated graphics. The positive aspects of the Graphics and Visual Design of The Sinking City seem to be the atmospheric immersion, the capturing of Lovecraftian elements, and the impressive environmental details. However, the negative aspects, including technical issues, graphical glitches, and subpar character designs, detract from the overall experience. It is important for players to consider these varying opinions and decide for themselves whether the Graphics and Visual Design of The Sinking City align with their preferences and expectations.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics have mixed opinions on The Sinking City's graphics and visual design. Some praise the enhanced visuals, eerie atmosphere, and world-building that capture H.P. Lovecraft's essence. However, others criticize technical issues, graphical glitches, and subpar character designs, with concerns about dated graphics and unfinished elements. The game's atmospheric immersion and environmental details are highlights, but issues like lifeless character eyes and poor textures detract from the experience. Players should consider these varied views before forming their own expectations of The Sinking City's graphics and visual design.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

56%

Mixed (50-79)

33%

Negative (0-49)

11%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of The Sinking City are a mix of positive and negative feedback. Several critics, such as Pure Nintendo and Softpedia, praise the voice acting in the game, noting that it adds to the adventure and terrifying atmosphere. The solid voice acting and interesting personalities of the NPCs, as mentioned by Impulsegamer, also contribute to the dark and weird atmosphere. TheXboxHub specifically mentions that the voice work and performances are excellent, while Game Debate highlights the immersive sound design that includes sounds, visions, and monsters, adding to the horror atmosphere. These positive opinions indicate that the game successfully utilizes voice acting to enhance the overall experience and create a sense of immersion. However, not all critics share the same sentiment. Game Informer criticizes the uneven voice performances and cutscenes, which they believe take a toll on immersion. PC Gamer mentions that the soundtrack is forgettable and droning, adding to the sense of gloom in the game. These negative opinions suggest that there are aspects of the Sound Design and Music that could have been improved upon to enhance the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that The Sinking City has strong voice acting and immersive sound design, which contribute to the atmospheric and terrifying nature of the game. The positive feedback from Pure Nintendo, Softpedia, Impulsegamer, Game Debate, and TheXboxHub supports this consensus. However, the negative feedback from Game Informer and PC Gamer highlights areas where the Sound Design and Music could have been better executed. Despite these criticisms, the overall sentiment leans towards the positive, with the majority of critics appreciating the efforts made to create a dark and immersive audio experience in The Sinking City.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics have mixed opinions on the Sound Design and Music of The Sinking City. Positive feedback praises the voice acting for enhancing the atmosphere, while negative feedback criticizes uneven performances and forgettable soundtracks. Overall, critics agree that the game excels in voice acting and immersive sound design, though improvements could be made. Positive reviews highlight the game's dark and immersive audio experience, while negative reviews point out areas for enhancement.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

56%

Mixed (50-79)

44%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The overall sentiment towards the voice acting in The Sinking City is largely positive, with several critics praising its contribution to the game's atmosphere and immersion. Pure Nintendo, Softpedia, Switch Player, and Impulsegamer all express positive opinions, highlighting the strong voice-acting that adds to the overall experience. Softpedia specifically mentions the great characterization and voice acting that enhances the terrifying atmosphere of the game. PlayStation Country also commends Charles Reed's weary delivery as a highlight, suggesting that it effectively captures the character's emotions and adds depth to the narrative. TheXboxHub goes even further, describing the voice work and performances as excellent, with a commanding delivery and a wide range of voice talent. However, not all critics share the same sentiment. Game Informer mentions that the voice performances are uneven, which takes a toll on immersion. TheSixthAxis criticizes the lack of meaningful interaction and choice despite acknowledging the well-done voice acting. These criticisms suggest that while the voice acting may be of a high standard, there are certain aspects that hinder the overall experience for some players. Taking into account the opinions of the various critics, the consensus leans towards positive sentiments regarding the voice acting in The Sinking City. The majority of critics appreciate the quality of the voice work and how it adds to the game's atmosphere and immersion. While there are some criticisms regarding uneven performances and limited interaction, these do not overshadow the overall positive reception. The voice acting in The Sinking City is generally seen as a strong aspect of the game, contributing to its overall appeal and enhancing the player's experience.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics generally praise the voice acting in The Sinking City for enhancing the game's atmosphere and immersion. Positive reviews highlight strong performances that add depth and contribute to the terrifying atmosphere. While some critics note uneven performances and limited interaction, the consensus is that the voice acting is a strong aspect of the game that enhances the player's experience.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

24%

Mixed (50-79)

43%

Negative (0-49)

33%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of technical performance, The Sinking City received mixed reviews across different gaming platforms. Starting with the positives, the PlayStation 5 version of the game was generally praised for its smooth 4K/60fps performance, with only rare stuttering issues that did not impact the gameplay experience (PlayStation LifeStyle). The Nintendo Switch version also received some positive feedback, with critics mentioning stable performance and quality-of-life changes (Impulsegamer). Additionally, the Xbox Series X version was noted to have improved technical performance, including faster loading times and fewer glitches, resulting in a more immersive experience (TheXboxHub). However, the negatives outweighed the positives for the technical performance of The Sinking City on other platforms. The PlayStation 4 version was heavily criticized for its occasional drop in performance and technically average execution (Guardian). Video Chums described the same version as having awful load times and major performance issues. Similarly, the Xbox One version was criticized for long load times, screen-tearing, and occasional framerate drops (TrueAchievements, Game Informer, Gamers' Temple). The Nintendo Switch version faced significant technical problems, including screen tearing, stuttering, long load times, slow menus, and aggressive render distances (Pure Nintendo, NintendoWorldReport, Critical Hit). Considering the overall consensus of the critics, it is evident that The Sinking City faced numerous technical issues across different gaming platforms. The PlayStation 5 version received some positive remarks for its technical performance, while the Nintendo Switch version had a mix of stable performance and technical problems. However, the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions were heavily criticized for their technical shortcomings, including performance issues, long load times, and screen-tearing. The Xbox Series X version showed improvements in technical performance compared to its predecessor, but still had occasional framerate drops and glitches. It is worth noting that some critics, such as God is a Geek, found the game worth exploring despite these flaws. Overall, the technical performance of The Sinking City varied significantly across platforms, with the PlayStation 5 version generally being the most positively received in terms of technical performance.

TL;DR

technical performance

The Sinking City's technical performance had mixed reviews. PlayStation 5 version praised for smooth 4K/60fps, while Nintendo Switch had stable performance. Xbox Series X improved, but PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions faced criticism for glitches and long load times. Nintendo Switch had significant technical problems. Critics had varying opinions, with some finding the game worth playing despite flaws. Overall, PlayStation 5 version was most positively received for technical performance.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

14%

Mixed (50-79)

86%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of The Sinking City are generally positive. Video Chums highlights the game's many decisions and side cases that change the story, offering replay value. Softpedia also mentions that the game offers multiple cases that can be solved differently, with each choice having consequences. Impulsegamer adds that the game offers different conclusions to investigations and endings depending on player actions. These positive opinions indicate that the game provides players with a variety of choices and outcomes, encouraging multiple playthroughs to explore different paths and storylines. However, there are also some negative aspects mentioned by the critics. Game Informer notes that the main quest is a little too long, which may deter some players from replaying the game multiple times. TheXboxHub mentions that the game is quite hefty in terms of the hours required, which could be seen as a negative for those who prefer shorter, more concise experiences. These criticisms suggest that the game's length and time commitment may limit its replay value for certain players. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that The Sinking City offers a good amount of replay value. Pure Nintendo describes the game as fascinating and replayable, while Game Debate mentions the open world and multiple mysteries to investigate, providing replay value for those interested in the detective experience. The positive opinions from Video Chums, Softpedia, and Impulsegamer further support this consensus. Despite the mentioned negatives, the overall sentiment is that the game's various choices, consequences, and multiple endings make it worth revisiting for players who enjoy exploring different storylines and outcomes.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics praise The Sinking City for its replay value due to numerous decisions and side cases that alter the story, offering diverse endings based on player actions. However, some critics mention the game's lengthy main quest and time commitment as potential drawbacks for replayability. Overall, critics agree that the game's multiple choices and outcomes make it worth replaying for players interested in exploring various paths and storylines.

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive (80-100)

20%

Mixed (50-79)

77%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The Sinking City has received a mixed reception from critics, with both positive and negative aspects highlighted in their reviews. One of the strengths of the game that several critics mentioned is its originality and thought-provoking nature. Critics such as Guardian and Screen Rant praised the game for its ambitious blending of cosmic horror and detective pulp, creating a unique and infectious atmosphere. The story and investigative elements were also commended by TrueAchievements and Washington Post, who found the game's tackling of racism and its worthwhile narrative to be commendable. Additionally, the game's immersion and atmosphere were highly praised by Switch Player and Impulsegamer, who found the game to excel in creating an engrossing experience. However, the game was not without its flaws, as several critics pointed out. Technical issues were a common complaint, with Video Chums, Pure Nintendo, and NintendoWorldReport all mentioning problems with graphics and technical performance. The combat and handling were also criticized by critics such as Switch Player and PC Gamer, who found them to be lacking. Repetitive navigation and combat were mentioned by TheSixthAxis and Gamers' Temple as detracting from the overall experience. Additionally, some critics, like Game Rant and CGMagazine, felt that the game fell short of its pre-release hype and had puzzling game design choices. Overall, the consensus among critics is that The Sinking City is a game with both strengths and weaknesses. While it may not be a game for everyone, it is recommended for fans of Lovecraftian horror and detective-driven gameplay, as mentioned by Impulsegamer and Digital Chumps. The game's immersive world and strong story were praised by critics such as TheSixthAxis and Game Debate. However, the technical issues and subpar graphics, as well as the repetitive navigation and combat, were mentioned as drawbacks by several critics. Despite its flaws, the game still managed to captivate and engage players, making it a worthwhile experience for horror and mystery fans, as noted by TrueAchievements and PlayStation Country.

TL;DR

Critics have mixed feelings about The Sinking City. Positive points include its originality, engaging storyline, and immersive atmosphere blending cosmic horror and detective pulp. However, technical issues, subpar graphics, repetitive gameplay, and lackluster combat were major drawbacks. While not perfect, the game is recommended for Lovecraftian horror and detective game enthusiasts.

MONSTER

Reviews

211 reviews found

COGconnected

PlayStation 5

Mar 5, 2021