Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Amazon

Xbox

Twitch

MONSTER

The Evil Within

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of The Evil Within
Item: The Evil Within
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2014

GenresAdventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, Shooter, Horror, Open World, Puzzle and Logic, Stealth, Single Player

AvailableOct 13, 2014

PlatformPC, Xbox One, PlayStation 4

DeveloperTango Gameworks

Overview

The Evil Within is an action survival horror game that draws inspiration from the Resident Evil series with a grimy look with exaggerated gore. The game was directed by Shinji Mikami, the creator of Resident Evil & a former Resident Evil 4 director. You must navigate through the hostile game world with limited resources, this requires to use your wits to survive and correctly manage your resources as you encounters various terrors and dangers throughout the game. The environments may also change without warning in real-time based on your actions, adding more variables to the game.

Elsewhere

7.8

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

34%

Mixed (50-79)

52%

Negative (0-49)

14%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of the critics regarding the story of The Evil Within are quite varied. Some critics, such as Cheat Code Central and Guardian, appreciate the exploration of themes like moral doubt, questioning of identity, and the unreliability of the world. They find the narrative to be compelling and chilling, with the game delving into alternate realities and psychological horror. Additionally, Gamestyle mentions that the story becomes highly engaging once it gets going, with the inclusion of pages from the protagonist's past adding depth to the overall narrative. However, there are several critics who express disappointment with the story. ActionTrip and Digital Spy both criticize the lack of motivation and answers to important questions, making the story feel pitiful and convoluted. Destructoid and DarkStation also mention that the story lacks exposition and character development, with DarkStation specifically noting that the plot becomes unfocused and fails to properly convey the player's purpose in different areas. GameSpot goes as far as calling the story genuinely bad and lacking self-awareness, while Worth Playing criticizes the poor development of characters and the convoluted nature of the plot. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the story of The Evil Within has its strengths and weaknesses. While some appreciate the exploration of psychological horror and the chilling atmosphere, others find the plot confusing and lacking in key elements such as character development and clear motivation. The game seems to divide opinions, with some critics enjoying the narrative's twists and turns, while others find it disappointing and lacking in substance. It is worth noting that while some critics, like GameTrailers and Game Over Online, praise the game for its horror elements and unique boss encounters, others, such as GameFront and Telegraph, criticize the story for its lack of clear direction and uninteresting protagonist.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics are split on The Evil Within's story: some praise its exploration of psychological horror and chilling atmosphere, while others criticize its lack of character development and confusing plot. Some find it compelling with engaging twists, while others deem it convoluted and lacking substance. Opinions vary, with some lauding the horror elements and unique boss encounters, while others lament the lack of clear direction and uninteresting protagonist.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

55%

Mixed (50-79)

41%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The opinions of the critics regarding the gameplay of The Evil Within are generally positive. Many critics, such as ActionTrip, Destructoid, Cheat Code Central, and DarkStation, highlight the similarities to Resident Evil 4 and praise the gameplay mechanics. They mention the importance of upgrading weapons, using crafting materials, and the hybrid of stealth and action gameplay. DarkStation specifically mentions the high difficulty, brutal enemies, and scarce resources that make each encounter challenging. Digital Spy also commends the game for its balance of old and new elements, including restrictive ammo and health management, stealth mechanics, and a good mix of action and exploration. Guardian and Impulsegamer emphasize the focus on limited resources, headshots, and tactics, as well as the inclusion of stealth and traps. However, there are some negative opinions regarding the gameplay of The Evil Within. GameFront criticizes the game for being confused about whether it wants to be a third-person shooter or a horror game, resulting in a lackluster experience in both aspects. Toronto Sun describes the gameplay as unoriginal, uninspired, and repetitive, with poorly placed checkpoints and frustrating item retrieval after death. Game Over Online mentions that the protagonist's controls can be janky and sluggish at times, while NZGamer points out issues with limited sprinting and camera problems during combat. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the gameplay of The Evil Within is tense, demanding, and satisfying. The game successfully incorporates elements of stealth, action, and resource management, creating a sense of dread and tension. The gameplay mechanics, reminiscent of Resident Evil 4, receive praise for their strategic options, variety of ideas, and the ability to weave sneaking into combat. The limited resources, high stakes, and challenging encounters contribute to the overall positive reception of the gameplay. While there are some criticisms regarding the game's lack of specialization in certain areas and technical issues, the majority of critics appreciate the gameplay experience offered by The Evil Within.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics generally praise The Evil Within's gameplay for its tense, demanding, and satisfying experience, highlighting elements like upgrading weapons, crafting, and a mix of stealth and action gameplay. Some critics note similarities to Resident Evil 4 and commend the high difficulty, scarce resources, and strategic options. However, there are negative comments about confusion in gameplay direction, unoriginality, and control issues. Overall, critics find the gameplay engaging despite some flaws, with a strong focus on limited resources, tense encounters, and a good balance of old and new mechanics.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

44%

Mixed (50-79)

52%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of The Evil Within are varied. Some critics, such as Cheat Code Central and DarkStation, appreciate the dark and oppressive environments that contribute to the horror atmosphere. The use of lighting and character models is praised by DarkStation, while Digital Spy mentions the immersive and atmospheric experience created by the grainy visual filter and widescreen presentation. Impulsegamer also highlights the visually impressive aspects of the game on the PlayStation 4, including well-animated characters and eerie lighting. GameTrailers describes the environments as richly detailed and immersive, with a classical aesthetic that evokes fear and saturates the senses in terrible nightmares. Eurogamer mentions the disorientating camera filters and shifts that create an unnerving atmosphere. Overall, the positive aspects of the Graphics and Visual Design include the dark theme, immersive lighting, detailed character models, and the creation of a creepy and unsettling atmosphere. However, there are also negative opinions regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of The Evil Within. Destructoid criticizes the game for looking dated and having giant black bars on the screen. Critical Hit mentions broken textures and weird glitches, while Game Informer finds the texture pop-in distracting. Guardian describes the graphics as serviceable rather than beautiful, with a designed-in level of clunkiness. Toronto Sun goes as far as calling the game one of the worst-looking current-generation games, citing technical issues and poorly placed checkpoints. The forced letterboxing is also mentioned as a drawback by Worth Playing and ZTGD. These negative aspects include dated visuals, technical issues, clunky graphics, and limitations in the view of the environment due to letterboxing. In terms of the overall consensus of the critics, there is a mix of positive and negative opinions regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of The Evil Within. While some critics appreciate the immersive atmosphere, detailed character models, and richly detailed environments, others criticize the dated visuals, technical issues, and limitations in the view of the environment. The positive aspects mentioned by critics such as Cheat Code Central, DarkStation, and Impulsegamer contribute to the overall immersive and creepy experience of the game. However, the negative aspects mentioned by critics like Destructoid, Critical Hit, and Game Informer highlight the technical shortcomings and limitations in the visual design. Overall, the Graphics and Visual Design of The Evil Within receive a mixed reception from the critics, with some praising certain aspects while others criticize various elements.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics have mixed opinions on The Evil Within's Graphics and Visual Design. Some applaud the dark atmosphere, immersive lighting, and detailed character models, while others criticize dated visuals, technical issues, and limitations like letterboxing. Positive feedback highlights the creepy experience, while negative points mention glitches and clunky graphics. Overall, opinions are split on the game's visual presentation.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

75%

Mixed (50-79)

25%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of The Evil Within are generally positive. DarkStation and GameSpot both praise the game for its menacing audio flourishes and impactful sound design that adds to the horror experience. They highlight the dark shadows and enemy sounds that create a chilling atmosphere, contributing to the overall sense of horror. Gamestyle also commends the game for its solid adventure and music that caters to horror fans. Hardcore Gamer specifically mentions the effective use of classical composition indicating save points, which adds to the immersive experience. Impulsegamer emphasizes the highlight of voice acting and memorable sound effects that contribute to the twisted storyline. However, there are some mixed opinions among the critics. Gameplanet mentions the repeated strain of Debussy's Clair De Lune in safe rooms, creating a sense of relief for the player. While this may be seen as a positive by some, others might argue that it becomes repetitive or predictable over time. Eurogamer highlights the use of sound effects and music to contribute to the sense of mental fragility and unease, with the melody of Clair de Lune playing from virtual gramophones. This suggests that the game effectively uses music to enhance the psychological aspects of the horror experience. However, some critics may argue that the reliance on a single piece of music could limit the variety and impact of the overall soundtrack. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the Sound Design and Music of The Evil Within are strong aspects of the game. The positive aspects mentioned by DarkStation, GameSpot, Gamestyle, Hardcore Gamer, Impulsegamer, and Eurogamer highlight the immersive and chilling atmosphere created by the soundwork. The use of menacing audio flourishes, impactful sound design, and voice acting talent contribute to the overall experience. While there are some mixed opinions regarding the repetition of certain musical elements, the general sentiment is that the sound design and music enhance the horror and psychological aspects of the game.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics praise The Evil Within for its menacing audio and impactful sound design, creating a chilling horror experience with dark shadows and eerie enemy sounds. While some find the repeated use of Debussy's Clair De Lune predictable, overall, the sound design and music are strong points, enhancing the immersive atmosphere and psychological elements of the game.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

11%

Mixed (50-79)

67%

Negative (0-49)

22%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The opinions of the critics regarding the voice acting of The Evil Within are quite varied. Some critics, such as Hardcore Gamer and Impulsegamer, commend the voice acting and consider it a highlight of the game. They appreciate the talented actors who lend their voices to the twisted storyline, suggesting that the voice acting adds depth and immersion to the game. Additionally, Impulsegamer specifically mentions that the voice acting is impressive, further emphasizing the positive aspects of the performances. However, not all critics share the same sentiment. Game Informer criticizes the voice acting, describing it as cheesy and heavy-handed. This suggests that the performances may lack subtlety and nuance, potentially detracting from the overall experience. IGN also expresses negative opinions about the player character's voice acting, describing it as emotionless and cool to the point of parody. This criticism implies that the voice acting may fail to convey the necessary emotions and depth required for the character, potentially hindering the player's connection with the protagonist. Overall, the consensus among the critics seems to be mixed. While some critics appreciate the voice acting and consider it commendable, others criticize it for various reasons. Toronto Sun, for example, describes the voice acting as terrible, with characters reacting inappropriately to horrifying scenes. This suggests a lack of authenticity and immersion in the performances. On the other hand, ZTGD acknowledges that the voice acting is not stellar, but still finds it interesting. This indicates that while the performances may not be exceptional, they still manage to capture the attention of the audience. games(TM) takes a more negative stance, criticizing the voice acting as po-faced tedium and woeful. This implies that the performances may lack the necessary energy and engagement required to captivate the players. In conclusion, the opinions regarding the voice acting of The Evil Within are quite divided. While some critics appreciate the talent and commendable performances, others criticize the lack of emotion and authenticity. The overall consensus suggests that the voice acting may have its strengths and weaknesses, with some critics finding it interesting despite its flaws. Ultimately, the impact of the voice acting on the overall experience of the game may vary depending on individual preferences and expectations.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics are split on the voice acting in The Evil Within. Some praise the talented actors for adding depth and immersion, while others criticize it as cheesy and lacking emotion. Opinions range from commendable to terrible, with some finding it interesting despite its flaws. Overall, the voice acting's impact on the game experience is subjective and varies among critics.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

88%

Negative (0-49)

13%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of the technical performance on PC, the critics had mixed opinions. ActionTrip noted that the AI can be both annoyingly aware and dimwitted, while Destructoid mentioned performance issues and limited resolution options. These criticisms suggest that the PC version of The Evil Within may not have been optimized to its full potential. However, it is worth noting that Destructoid still found the game playable, indicating that the technical issues did not completely hinder the overall experience. Moving on to the PlayStation 4 platform, several critics highlighted various technical issues. Critical Hit mentioned broken textures and weird glitches, while DarkStation pointed out texture pop-ups, clipping, and occasional framerate stutters. Digital Spy criticized the inconsistent checkpointing and auto-save system, which disrupted the sense of tension. Additionally, Telegraph mentioned frame rate dips, disappearing prompts, and long load times. These criticisms collectively suggest that the PlayStation 4 version of the game suffered from technical shortcomings that affected the overall gameplay experience. As for the Xbox One platform, Game Over Online mentioned occasional frame rate sputters, while Toronto Sun criticized technical issues that caused the player to get stuck on the environment. IGN also noted texture pop-up and clipping issues in both the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions. These criticisms indicate that the Xbox One version of The Evil Within also had its fair share of technical problems, although they may not have been as severe as those on the PlayStation 4. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that The Evil Within had various technical issues across all gaming platforms. Texture pop-ups, frame rate drops, clipping, and long load times were common complaints. However, it is important to note that some critics, such as Impulsegamer, mentioned that these technical issues did not significantly impact gameplay. Despite the technical shortcomings, the game still managed to provide an enjoyable experience for many players. However, it is clear that the technical performance of The Evil Within could have been improved to provide a smoother and more immersive gaming experience on all platforms.

TL;DR

technical performance

Critics had mixed opinions on The Evil Within's technical performance across platforms. PC version had AI and resolution issues, PS4 suffered from glitches and texture problems, while Xbox One had frame rate and clipping issues. Despite these problems, some found the game playable, but overall, technical shortcomings impacted the gameplay experience. Improvements could have enhanced the game for a smoother and more immersive experience on all platforms.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

22%

Mixed (50-79)

78%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of The Evil Within are generally positive. Many critics highlight the game's additional unlockable modes and features as a positive aspect of its replay value. DarkStation mentions that the game offers new weapons, difficulties, and a new game plus mode, including the challenging 'AKUMA' mode, which provides the ultimate test of survival horror skills. Eurogamer also praises the post-completion bonuses that will thrill players. GameTrailers specifically mentions that completing the game unlocks New Game+ with extra difficulty settings and special weapons not seen in the campaign. These additional features and modes provide players with incentives to revisit the game and enhance their gameplay experience. However, there are some mixed opinions regarding the replay value of The Evil Within. Critical Hit states that the game's upgrade system is excellent but not fully explored, suggesting that there may be missed opportunities in terms of fully utilizing the replay value potential. Gameplanet mentions that the game's trial and error gameplay may frustrate some players, which could potentially impact their desire to replay the game. These criticisms indicate that while the game offers replay value, there may be certain aspects that could have been improved or refined to enhance the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that The Evil Within has good replay value. The additional unlockable modes, post-completion bonuses, and challenging encounters are mentioned by several critics as positive aspects that contribute to the game's replayability. Guardian highlights the increased difficulty as a factor that adds to the replay value, and Impulsegamer emphasizes the satisfaction of successfully completing the game as a reward in itself. While there are some minor criticisms regarding the game's upgrade system and trial and error gameplay, the overall sentiment is that The Evil Within offers enough incentives and features to keep players coming back for more, particularly for hardcore gamers seeking a challenge. Worth Playing specifically mentions the New Game+ unlocks as a reason to revisit the game, further supporting the notion of its replay value.

TL;DR

replay value

The Evil Within offers a thrilling replay value with unlockable modes, challenging encounters, and post-completion bonuses that keep players hooked. Critics praise the game's additional features but note some missed opportunities in fully exploring its potential. Despite minor criticisms, the consensus is that the game provides enough incentives for hardcore gamers seeking a challenge to keep coming back for more.

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive (80-100)

53%

Mixed (50-79)

44%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The Evil Within has received a mix of positive and negative reviews from critics. Several critics praised the game for its immersive and terrifying nature, with DarkStation stating that it is a game that the survival horror genre desperately needed. The beautifully designed enemies, superb gameplay, and terrifying environments come together to give horror fans a fascinating and memorable experience. Eurogamer also described it as a generous and enjoyable experience. The game's interesting creature designs and fun shooting mechanics were also highlighted by ActionTrip. Gamestyle praised it as a gorefest that grabs you from the start and doesn't let go throughout, making it a solid adventure for horror fans. However, there were also several criticisms raised by the critics. The story, characters, and AI issues were mentioned as bringing down the overall experience by ActionTrip. Cheat Code Central also noted the frustrating difficulty and unfairness at times as off-putting. Push Square mentioned unfair difficulty spikes and technical issues that undo its outstanding art direction. Toronto Sun described the game as unoriginal, uninspired, and plodding, with only a few scares and decent combat at best. Worth Playing mentioned that while the game is enjoyable, it is not a must-play experience and has flaws alongside its good aspects. Overall, the consensus among the critics is mixed. While some critics praised The Evil Within for its immersive and terrifying nature, superb gameplay, and fascinating enemies, others criticized it for its story, characters, AI issues, frustrating difficulty, and lack of originality. However, there is a general agreement that the game is a return to form for the survival horror genre, effectively creating tension and fear. It is recommended for fans of the genre who enjoy old-school third-person action games with horror elements. Despite its flaws, The Evil Within is considered a worthy investment and a bold and seductive survival horror experience by several critics, including Impulsegamer and Hardcore Gamer.

TL;DR

The Evil Within: A polarizing horror game that delivers immersive terror and superb gameplay, praised for its fascinating enemies and gorefest experience. However, critics highlight flaws in story, characters, AI, and frustrating difficulty spikes. Overall, a mixed reception but a bold return to survival horror that will appeal to fans of the genre.

MONSTER

Reviews

143 reviews found

GameTrailers

Xbox One

Oct 14, 2014