Resident Evil 4

The majority of critics praised the story of Resident Evil 4 as a compelling evolution of the original, highlighting its enhanced character development, refined narrative structure, and faithful yet modernized approach. Many reviewers noted that the remake retains the core plot—Leon Kennedy’s mission to rescue Ashley Graham from a cult in rural Spain—while adding depth to characters like Luis Serra (Gameblog.fr, VG247) and Ashley herself (PC Gamer, WellPlayed). The narrative was described as “thrilling” (Gamereactor UK), “engaging” (GamingTrend), and “fresh yet familiar” (GamingAge), with improvements in pacing, logic, and emotional resonance. Critics like GameSpew and Push Square emphasized the expanded lore and dynamic between Leon and Ashley, while GamingBolt praised its balance of over-the-top action with a more grounded tone. The story’s B-movie charm was also celebrated for being “refined for coherence” (Gameblog.fr) and “modernized without losing its essence” (AppTrigger). However, some critics found the narrative lacking in certain aspects. DualShockers criticized the plot as “self-serious” and “lacking in engaging characters,” arguing that the changes felt inconsistent and failed to capture the original’s charm. Windows Central and Merlin’in Kazanı pointed to implausibility and a lack of immersion, with the latter calling it “one of the weakest in the series.” Others, like Screen Rant and Ragequit.gr, noted that while characters like Luis gained depth, the overall story felt less memorable than the original, with “corny” dialogue and a reduced sense of humor. PC Gamer also mentioned that the narrative became more straightforward compared to the original’s uneven pacing, though this was seen as a minor flaw in an otherwise polished experience. Despite these criticisms, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with most acknowledging the story as a strong, if not revolutionary, update to the classic. While some reviewers felt the narrative leaned too heavily on action over horror (JeuxActu) or missed opportunities for deeper innovation (DualShockers), the majority praised its balance of familiarity and refinement. GameRant and Gamer.no highlighted the “smart changes” and “exciting twists,” while IGN France noted that the story’s “mature character portrayals” elevated it beyond the original. Even critics who pointed out flaws, like Wccftech and Movies Games and Tech, acknowledged that the narrative remained largely faithful to its roots. Ultimately, the remake was seen as a successful reimagining that honored the source material while delivering a more cohesive and engaging experience for both newcomers and veterans.

The gameplay of Resident Evil 4 receives widespread acclaim from critics, with many praising its modernized mechanics, enhanced combat, and refined design. Reviewers highlight the introduction of dynamic systems like the knife parry (noted by Siliconera and God is a Geek), which adds strategic depth and tension to encounters, while Shacknews and PC Gamer commend the improved aiming mechanics and accessibility options that make combat more engaging. The game’s shift toward action-oriented gameplay, including running while shooting (Telegraph) and streamlined inventory management (Digitally Downloaded), is seen as a significant evolution. Additionally, the integration of stealth elements (Eurogamer Poland, TheXboxHub) and new enemy behaviors enhances strategic variety, with Twinfinite noting that combat remains "satisfying to play." Many critics, such as SpazioGames and GameGrin, praise the game’s near-perfect balance of survival horror and action, emphasizing its immersive exploration and refined level design. Despite these positives, some critiques focus on specific flaws or trade-offs. Gamereactor UK criticizes the "subpar" shooting mechanics, while Screen Rant laments the cumbersome crafting system and loss of original gameplay quirks. Digitally Downloaded and Softpedia point to clunky controls and uneven balance, with the latter noting that stealth mechanics and knife durability feel underdeveloped. We Got This Covered and Hey Poor Player mention frustrations like the absence of a dedicated dodge feature or the added complexity of weapon degradation. Additionally, some reviewers, such as Metro GameCentral and PC Gamer, argue that the game feels "more generic" or "less unpredictable" compared to the original, suggesting that modernization occasionally diluted its unique charm. These critiques often highlight minor inconsistencies but rarely overshadow the overall enthusiasm for the gameplay overhaul. The majority of critics agree that Resident Evil 4 is a standout title, with its gameplay improvements significantly elevating the experience. While some nuances—like control responsiveness (Gamereactor Finland) or balance issues (Softpedia)—are debated, the consensus leans heavily toward praise. IGN Adria and Game Informer emphasize that the game successfully blends modern mechanics with the original’s essence, while PlayStation LifeStyle and Checkpoints Gaming highlight its enriched exploration and extended content. Even critics with reservations acknowledge the game’s ambition and execution, with SpazioGames calling it "nearly perfect" and TheXboxHub noting that "the survival horror experience is enhanced." Ultimately, the gameplay of Resident Evil 4 is celebrated as a bold, successful evolution that honors its legacy while appealing to both newcomers and veterans.

The majority of critics praised Resident Evil 4’s graphics and visual design, highlighting its technical prowess and atmospheric enhancements. Many lauded the game’s use of the RE Engine, noting its ability to create immersive, detailed environments that elevate the horror experience. For instance, IGN Italia and XboxEra emphasized the engine’s power in crafting dark, immersive settings with exceptional lighting and shadow effects, while Push Square and TheSixthAxis celebrated the game’s “stunning 4K graphics” and “richly designed environments.” The remake’s visual overhaul was consistently praised for its darker aesthetic, improved textures, and meticulous attention to detail. Gamer.no and MeuPlayStation noted the game’s “significantly improved” visuals compared to the original, with TheGamesMachine comparing it favorably to Resident Evil 2’s remake. Critics also highlighted the enhanced character models, gore effects, and environmental storytelling, with Everyeye.it praising “high-quality lighting, character models, and gore effects.” These reviews collectively underscore the game’s success in modernizing its visuals while maintaining a cohesive horror atmosphere. Despite the widespread acclaim, some critics pointed to minor technical and artistic shortcomings. AusGamers argued that the RE Engine didn’t fully showcase its potential compared to Resident Evil 2 Remake, while DualShockers noted inconsistencies in visual polish, with “stunning” areas juxtaposed against “unfinished” or cluttered environments. Issues like over-detailed scenes causing confusion about interactable objects and minor graphical glitches (e.g., Gameblog.fr’s criticism of rain effects and resolution issues) were mentioned. Wccftech and Impulsegamer also noted that the art style, while effective, felt less refined than its predecessor, with some areas appearing “grungy” or lacking the same level of detail. Additionally, Cubed3 observed that performance varied based on resolution and frame rate settings, and GamingBolt mentioned that certain particle effects could feel jarring. These critiques, while significant, were often framed as minor flaws in an otherwise strong visual package. Overall, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with most agreeing that Resident Evil 4’s graphics and visual design represent a major leap forward. The game’s ability to balance nostalgia with modernization—such as Stevor’s observation of its “darker and more intense aesthetic” and JeuxActu’s praise for “richer, more detailed environments”—was widely celebrated. While some critics noted technical imperfections or artistic trade-offs, these were generally overshadowed by the game’s achievements. VG247 and GameSpot highlighted its “cutting-edge design” and “stunning visuals,” while PCMag emphasized its accessibility without sacrificing quality. The visual upgrades not only enhanced the horror elements but also solidified the remake as a benchmark for the RE Engine, with many reviewers—like Xbox Tavern and Digital Spy—calling it one of the best-looking games on next-gen consoles. The minor criticisms, though valid, did little to detract from the overall acclaim for its visual ambition and execution.

The majority of critics praised the sound design and music of Resident Evil 4 as a standout element that significantly enhanced the game’s atmosphere and immersion. Many highlighted the effective use of audio to amplify tension and horror, with reviewers like TrueGaming noting "excellent sound design" and "atmospheric music that enhances the gameplay experience." The remastered audio also received acclaim for its immersive qualities, such as MGG’s observation that "new arrangements enhance the tension during gameplay," while GameGrin and IGN Spain appreciated the updated themes that retained the original’s essence. Additionally, Xbox Achievements and Carole Quintaine emphasized how the sound design created an "eerie atmosphere" and "heightened tension," with PlaySense praising the "realistic sound effects and voice acting" that deepened immersion. The use of 3D audio on the PS5, as noted by Atomix, further contributed to a more engaging horror experience, while GamingBolt and Easy Allies highlighted impactful sound effects that bolstered the game’s intensity. However, some critics pointed out specific shortcomings. DualShockers criticized the "muted sound effects of weapons," which they felt detracted from the experience, and GameGrin expressed disappointment that the new version omitted much of the original soundtrack. Voice acting received mixed feedback, with ComicBook and GamesBeat noting inconsistencies, particularly in characters like Ada Wong, whose voice actress faced criticism from XboxAddict for not matching the original’s tone. Additionally, Gamereactor Finland mentioned that "the music has not aged as well," while GAMES.CH acknowledged "satisfying sound effects" but noted that some aspects of the audio felt less impactful. These critiques, though present, were relatively minor compared to the overall positive reception. Despite these isolated criticisms, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with most agreeing that the sound design and music elevated Resident Evil 4’s horror and gameplay. GameSpot and WellPlayed highlighted how the audio "complements the gameplay" and "amplifies the horror elements," while Meristation praised the "exceptional" sound effects and voice acting for Leon. Even critics who noted minor flaws, like IGN Adria’s mention of optional original music in the Deluxe edition or Vandal’s observation of a more "melodic" soundtrack, acknowledged the overall quality. The combination of atmospheric soundscapes, immersive audio cues, and effective musical compositions solidified the remaster’s audio as a key strength, with only a few voices pointing to areas for improvement.

The voice acting in Resident Evil 4 receives significant praise for its improved performances, natural dialogue, and enhanced character depth. Many critics highlight the revitalized delivery of key characters, with Leon's portrayal noted as more relatable and engaging, balancing humor and seriousness (e.g., GGRecon and Attack of the Fanboy). The remake’s dialogue is often described as more believable, with VG247 and Impulsegamer emphasizing greater nuance and humanity in interactions. Specific characters like the Merchant also receive positive feedback, with Finger Guns and Metro GameCentral appreciating his new lines and comedic flair. Additionally, GameGrin and PlaySense commend the improved chemistry between Leon and Ashley, while VG247 and Gamer.no note a more competent dialogue flow that retains some of the original’s charm. The Italian localization is generally well-received, with Everyeye.it acknowledging its quality despite occasional lapses in impact. However, several critics criticize the voice acting for losing the original’s nostalgic charm and failing to match the iconic performances of earlier entries. DualShockers calls it “lackluster,” with characters sounding disinterested, while NPR and Screen Rant lament the diminished originality in characterizations. The casting changes, particularly Ada Wong’s new actress (criticized by Vgames and XboxAddict) and the Stranger Merchant’s overly comical tone (AusGamers), are seen as missteps. Some reviewers also note that the darker tone of the remake strips characters of their personality, with Stevivor and Hardcore Gamer pointing to a loss of charm. Additionally, Player 2 and Gamepressure highlight the cheesy dialogue and repetitive interactions, which some find jarring despite being part of the game’s identity. Overall, the consensus leans toward a mixed but generally positive reception, with critics acknowledging improvements in acting quality while debating their impact on the game’s legacy. While many praise the enhanced realism and character development (VG247, Impulsegamer, PlaySense), others feel the remake sacrifices the original’s quirks for a more grounded approach (NPR, Screen Rant, DualShockers). The changes in voice casting, particularly for Ada Wong and the Merchant, divide opinions, with some seeing them as necessary evolutions and others as missed opportunities. Despite these divides, the majority agree that the voice acting contributes meaningfully to the remake’s narrative and immersion, even if it doesn’t fully replicate the charm of its predecessor (IGN Adria, Eurogamer Germany, Gamer.no).

The technical performance of Resident Evil 4 across platforms generally receives positive feedback, though with nuanced variations. On Xbox Series X, critics like Windows Central and Pure Xbox praise its "excellent" performance, noting an uncapped frame rate targeting 60 FPS and minimal texture issues that don’t detract from the experience. The PS5 version is similarly lauded for stability, with Gamereactor UK highlighting a "crisp and fluid 60 frames-per-second" and God is a Geek commending lightning-fast load times. For PC, reviews such as those from PCMag and GameGrin emphasize smooth performance at high settings, with no significant drops in frame rate, while TouchArcade notes the game runs seamlessly on Steam Deck. Overall, all platforms are described as technically polished, with many critics acknowledging Capcom’s efforts to optimize for modern hardware. However, technical issues persist across platforms. On Xbox Series X, XboxEra and TheXboxHub report texture pop-in, performance drops, and input inaccuracies like analog stick dead zones affecting aiming. DualShockers notes that the PS5 version struggles in performance mode on lower-end hardware, with outdated textures and cumbersome controller controls, though PC offers a better experience. On PS5, TrueGaming mentions object clipping and visibility issues in dark areas, while MGG points to frame drops in demanding scenes. For PC, Multiplayer.it and New Game Network highlight stability problems in windowed mode and early crashes, though these improve later. While most platforms avoid major flaws, these critiques reveal that technical polish varies depending on hardware and settings. The overall consensus among critics is largely positive, with the game’s technical performance being a strong suit across all platforms. IGN Japan and Gaming Nexus note no significant issues on PS5, while XboxAddict and MondoXbox affirm smooth gameplay on Xbox Series X/S. However, minor graphical glitches, frame rate inconsistencies, and control quirks are recurring themes, particularly on older hardware or specific configurations. Despite these issues, the majority of reviews—such as those from GamingTrend (PS5) and PCMag (PC)—highlight the game’s technical stability and optimization, suggesting that while not flawless, Resident Evil 4 delivers a polished experience tailored to each platform’s capabilities.

The majority of critics praised Resident Evil 4’s replay value, highlighting its robust post-game content and engaging mechanics that encourage multiple playthroughs. Many reviewers emphasized features like New Game+, which allows players to carry over upgrades and tackle challenges with improved skills (GamesHub, PC Invasion). Side quests, unlockables, and collectibles were frequently cited as incentives for revisiting the game, with critics like Digital Spy noting money systems and upgrades, and Giant Bomb applauding "unexpected moments" that keep players engaged. The inclusion of Mercenaries mode (even if delayed) and crafting systems (GamesBeat, Digital Chumps) added layers of variety, while difficulty settings and customizable playstyles (Inverse, GameCritics) catered to both newcomers and veterans. IGN Japan and Gamer Escape specifically praised the game’s ability to offer fresh experiences through exploration and resource management, ensuring players return for new challenges and secrets. However, several critics pointed out notable drawbacks that tempered the replay value. DualShockers criticized the game’s repetitive pacing and "tedious" sections, making it hard to justify multiple playthroughs despite its merits. Others, like Meristation and PlayStation LifeStyle, lamented the absence of Mercenaries mode at launch, a staple of the original that many felt was essential for long-term engagement. IGN Japan and GamesHub also noted that post-story content, while present, didn’t match the depth of earlier entries in the series. Additionally, some reviewers, such as GameWatcher (PS5) and XboxEra, acknowledged that while the remake felt "substantial," it fell short of the original’s legendary replayability. These critiques suggest that while the game offers plenty to explore, its structure and missing features occasionally hindered its potential. Overall, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive about Resident Evil 4’s replay value, with most agreeing that its post-game content, mechanics, and adaptability made it worth revisiting. Critics like Giant Bomb, GameSpot, and The Gamer highlighted how features such as New Game+, challenges, and dynamic difficulty kept players engaged long after the main story concluded. Even those who pointed out flaws, such as DualShockers and Meristation, acknowledged that the game’s strengths—like its "smart changes" (Giant Bomb) and "fresh experience" (LevelUp)—outweighed its shortcomings. While not perfect, the remake’s blend of nostalgia-driven mechanics and modern innovations solidified its reputation as a title with strong replayability, appealing to both longtime fans and new players alike.