Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Twitch

MONSTER

MLB The Show 24

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of MLB The Show 24
Item: MLB The Show 24
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2024

GenresSimulation, Sports, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableMar 19, 2024

PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X

DeveloperSan Diego Studio

Overview

It’s your Show. Ready to own it? Set out on the road to baseball greatness – whatever it is you want to achieve, MLB® The Show™ 24 has got you covered. Earn your call up from the minors to the big leagues and prove you’ve got what it takes at the top. Learn from the legends of the sport, take inspiration from their heroics and use it to improve your game. Hold your nerve when it matters and earn the right to be called World Series champions. Chalk up the wins, pick yourself up after the losses. Whatever happens, know you left nothing in the dugout. Celebrating History with Storylines Celebrate and learn about baseball legends throughout the sport’s history. The Storylines mode transports you into baseball’s past to relive iconic moments of baseball’s unsung and unknown heroes. Experience career-defining moments through a combination of immersive gameplay that will educate and inspire you to make history of your own. Road to the Show Unlock your moment and build your career in the ultimate baseball role-playing experience. Become a ballplayer and journey from the minors to the majors to define your legacy. Franchise Lead your team to World Series glory as a team manager in Franchise mode. Experience new features providing more in-depth and dynamic gameplay from March to October.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24 scores big with critics thanks to its captivating narratives that blend baseball history and excitement, spotlighting the Negro Leagues and Derek Jeter's legacy. Reviewers celebrate its emotional depth and new women's career mode as a progressive leap for representation. However, some find the storytelling feels outdated, particularly in character design and dialogue. Overall, the game is hailed for its immersive and educational storytelling, making it a standout entry in the franchise.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

86%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

14%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The overall sentiment regarding the story of MLB The Show 24 is overwhelmingly positive, with critics praising its engaging narratives that blend historical context with the excitement of baseball. Reviewers like Atomix and CGMagazine highlight the introduction of significant storylines such as the Negro Leagues and Derek Jeter's career, which not only provide interesting narratives but also evoke nostalgia for fans. Critics from Game Informer and PlayStation Universe commend the well-crafted episodes that include personal anecdotes and tributes, enhancing the emotional depth of the game. Additionally, the inclusion of a new career mode for women, as noted by Player 2 and Push Square, is seen as a progressive step, allowing for a broader representation of baseball history and inspiring future generations. However, not all feedback is entirely positive. Shacknews points out that while the game introduces the ability to play as a woman and features distinct narratives, the overall storytelling still feels outdated, particularly in terms of character models and dialogue. This sentiment suggests that while the game has made strides in inclusivity, there are still areas that require refinement to meet modern standards in storytelling and character representation. Additionally, while the historical elements are appreciated, some critics may feel that the execution could benefit from a more contemporary approach. Despite these criticisms, the consensus among the majority of reviewers is that MLB The Show 24 successfully delivers a compelling narrative experience that resonates with both baseball enthusiasts and newcomers alike. Critics like WellPlayed and Worth Playing underscore the educational and immersive aspects of the storylines, particularly in their exploration of baseball legends and significant historical moments. Overall, the game is lauded for its ability to weave together engaging stories that not only entertain but also educate players about the rich history of baseball, making it a noteworthy installment in the franchise.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24 impresses with enhanced gameplay, diverse modes for all skill levels, and the exciting new 'Impact Plays' feature. Critics applaud upgrades like creating female players in Road to the Show and improved animations, though some call for more innovation in hitting and pitching mechanics. Concerns about Quick Time Events in defense and realism persist, but overall, it's a solid, engaging entry that builds on the franchise's strengths.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

95%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of MLB The Show 24 has received a largely positive reception from critics, highlighting several key enhancements that enrich the overall experience. Many reviewers, such as Atomix and MeuPlayStation, praised the variety of gameplay modes that cater to both newcomers and seasoned players, emphasizing the accessibility and enjoyment factor. The introduction of the 'Impact Plays' feature, noted by But Why Tho? and God is a Geek, adds a layer of excitement and control, particularly in defensive situations. Furthermore, the Road to the Show mode has seen significant upgrades, including the ability to create female players and the addition of the MLB Draft Combine, which critics like CGMagazine and Digital Chumps found to be refreshing and engaging. The game also boasts improved animations and controls, with GamingTrend noting over 400 new animations that enhance the responsiveness and realism of the gameplay. Despite the overall acclaim, some critics pointed out areas where MLB The Show 24 could improve. Game Informer mentioned that while the gameplay is solid, it lacks innovative changes to the hitting and pitching mechanics that have characterized previous entries in the series. Additionally, while the defensive mechanics have been enhanced, some reviewers, including Push Square, expressed concerns that the reliance on Quick Time Events (QTEs) for defensive plays might detract from the overall experience. VideoGamer also highlighted issues with the realism of defense mechanics and hitting, suggesting that while improvements have been made, there are still aspects that feel lacking or monotonous over time. In summary, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 24 delivers a strong and enjoyable gameplay experience, marked by significant improvements and new features that enhance both realism and accessibility. The majority of reviewers, such as GamersRD and WellPlayed, found the gameplay to be engaging and well-crafted, with particular praise for the Road to the Show mode and the introduction of female players. While there are some criticisms regarding the need for more innovative mechanics and the potential over-reliance on QTEs, the overall sentiment remains positive, indicating that MLB The Show 24 is a solid entry in the franchise that builds upon its predecessors while offering fresh experiences for players.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24 impresses with realistic graphics and player animations, earning praise for its detailed stadiums and inclusivity, such as the inclusion of women in career mode. However, critics note shortcomings like dated textures, stiff character models, and occasional glitches. While the game marks a significant graphical leap, it still has room for improvement to fully capitalize on current console capabilities.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

43%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of MLB The Show 24 have garnered a largely positive reception from critics, highlighting significant advancements in realism and detail. Many reviewers, such as Digital Chumps and Worth Playing, praised the game for its impressive player animations and facial expressions, noting that the visuals are among the best in sports gaming. The attention to detail in stadiums, uniforms, and player likenesses was also commended, with COGconnected emphasizing the strong representation of the baseball era. Critics like God is a Geek and Impulsegamer appreciated the enhancements in lighting and the incorporation of historical moments, which contribute to an engaging and immersive experience. Additionally, the inclusion of women in the career mode and improved crowd sounds were highlighted as positive steps towards inclusivity and realism. Despite the overall acclaim, several critics pointed out notable shortcomings in the game's graphics and visual design. Atomix and MeuPlayStation expressed disappointment that the visuals felt constrained by the game's multi-generational nature, suggesting that the current console capabilities could have been better utilized. Push Square criticized the dated textures for grass and dirt, while Movies Games and Tech echoed this sentiment, mentioning subpar textures that detract from the overall visual quality. Some reviewers, like Shacknews, pointed out issues with character models, describing them as stiff and unarticulated, indicating a need for further refinement in animation and design. Furthermore, the occasional glitches and immersion-breaking moments, as noted by Game Informer, detracted from the otherwise polished presentation. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 24 represents a significant step forward in graphical fidelity and visual design, yet it still has room for improvement. While many reviewers, including GamingTrend and PlayStation Universe, recognized the game's advancements over previous titles, they also acknowledged lingering issues that prevent it from reaching its full potential. The combination of impressive animations and realistic details alongside criticisms of texture quality and animation fluidity suggests that while the game is a triumph in many respects, it still faces challenges that developers must address in future iterations.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24's sound design and music receive widespread acclaim for creating an immersive gaming experience, with critics praising its realistic audio and diverse soundtrack featuring artists like Stevie Wonder. However, some reviews flag issues like a less varied soundtrack, localization concerns, and occasional mismatches between crowd sounds and gameplay. Overall, despite these flaws, the sound elements significantly enhance the game.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

67%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

33%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of MLB The Show 24 have received considerable praise from various critics, highlighting the game's immersive auditory experience. Atomix commended the "immersive sound design" alongside a "diverse soundtrack" that features a range of genres and artists, while COGconnected emphasized the "phenomenal sound design" that authentically captures the essence of a baseball game, including realistic bat sounds and crowd reactions. Everyeye.it noted the impressive audio quality, particularly the realistic crowd sounds and 3D audio capabilities on the PS5, which enhance the overall gaming experience. Game Informer also praised the bold and soulful music selection, featuring renowned artists like Stevie Wonder and A Tribe Called Quest, which complements the gameplay effectively. Overall, many critics agree that the sound design significantly contributes to the immersive atmosphere of the game. However, not all reviews are entirely positive, with some critics pointing out notable shortcomings. GamersRD expressed disappointment with the soundtrack compared to previous years, suggesting a decline in musical variety. MeuPlayStation raised concerns about the lack of localization for non-English speakers and repetitive English commentary, which detracts from the overall sound experience. Additionally, WellPlayed pointed out issues with crowd sounds and music not always aligning with the on-screen action, particularly during historical segments. These criticisms indicate that while the sound design has strong elements, there are areas that could benefit from improvement. Despite the mixed reviews, the overall consensus among critics leans towards a positive reception of MLB The Show 24's sound design and music. Critics like Push Square and XboxAddict rated the sound design highly, noting its contribution to the immersive gaming experience. While there are valid concerns regarding the soundtrack's depth and localization issues, the majority of reviewers appreciate the game's ability to create an engaging auditory environment. The combination of high-quality sound effects, a diverse soundtrack, and notable voice acting, as highlighted by Impulsegamer, suggests that MLB The Show 24 successfully enhances the gameplay experience through its sound design, even if there are areas for further refinement.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24's voice acting, led by Bob Kendrick and Derek Jeter, receives strong praise for its authentic and immersive storytelling, enhancing the game's historical narratives. Critics highlight Kendrick's passionate narration and Jeter's personal touch as standout elements. However, some feedback points to awkward execution and pacing issues in the narrative moments, suggesting room for improvement. Overall, the voice work is seen as a key strength that elevates the player experience, despite minor criticisms.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

43%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in MLB The Show 24 has garnered a largely positive reception from critics, particularly highlighting the contributions of Bob Kendrick and Derek Jeter. CGMagazine commends the authenticity brought to the game through Kendrick's narration, while Game Informer emphasizes how his work enhances the depth of the historical narratives presented in the Storylines mode. Similarly, GamingTrend notes that Jeter's voice-over intro adds a personal touch, enriching the overall narrative experience. Critics like WellPlayed and Worth Playing echo these sentiments, praising Kendrick for infusing passion and educational value into the storytelling, which ultimately provides players with an engaging and informative tour of baseball history. However, not all feedback is entirely favorable. Shacknews presents a contrasting viewpoint, noting that while the voice acting incorporates proper pronouns, the overall execution of the narrative moments feels archaic and awkward. This criticism suggests that despite the strong performances by Kendrick and Jeter, there may be inconsistencies in how the voice acting integrates with the game's overall presentation. Such feedback raises concerns about the pacing and delivery of the narrative, which could detract from the immersive experience that other critics have praised. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards a favorable view of the voice acting in MLB The Show 24, particularly in the context of its historical storytelling. The contributions of Bob Kendrick and Derek Jeter are widely recognized as enhancing the game's authenticity and emotional resonance. While there are some criticisms regarding the execution of certain narrative elements, the positive feedback from critics like Game Informer and WellPlayed suggests that the voice acting significantly enriches the player's experience, making it a noteworthy aspect of the game.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24 receives mostly positive reviews for its technical performance on PS5, praised for smooth gameplay and 400 new animations. However, bugs and inconsistent player behavior mar the experience. Xbox Series X faces criticism for lack of innovation. While the game showcases a solid foundation, it still has areas needing improvement and innovation in future versions.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

38%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

63%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of MLB The Show 24 has received generally positive feedback from critics, particularly for the PlayStation 5 platform. Reviewers from Everyeye.it, Game Informer, GamingTrend, Movies Games and Tech, and Player 2 have all noted that the game runs smoothly, with stable performance and improved consistency. Game Informer highlighted the introduction of 400 new animations and logic improvements, which contribute to a more immersive experience. Additionally, Movies Games and Tech emphasized the game's stable resolution, while Player 2 confirmed the absence of major glitches or bugs, indicating a strong technical foundation. Overall, the PS5 version appears to deliver a solid gaming experience, showcasing the developers' efforts to enhance gameplay. However, not all feedback is entirely positive, particularly concerning the PS5 version. VideoGamer pointed out the presence of bugs, including issues with player ratings and glitches that affect gameplay, which detracts from the overall experience. While the game is praised for its stable performance, the occasional unrealistic mistakes by star players, as noted by Game Informer, suggest that there are still areas needing refinement. On the Xbox Series X platform, Multiplayer.it criticized the game for lacking significant technological advancements and innovation, indicating a stagnation in the series' evolution on this platform. The overall consensus among critics for MLB The Show 24 is a mixed but largely favorable sentiment, especially for the PS5 version. While the game excels in stability and performance, with multiple reviewers praising its seamless gameplay, there are notable criticisms regarding bugs and a lack of innovation, particularly on the Xbox Series X. The transition to a multi-platform release has introduced some challenges, as highlighted by Everyeye.it, but many critics acknowledge that the game has managed to redeem itself with a solid technical performance overall. As such, while MLB The Show 24 demonstrates strong potential, there remains room for improvement and innovation in future iterations.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24 boasts strong replay value with diverse gameplay modes like Diamond Dynasty and Road to the Show, praised for their customization and engaging content. While some critics note a lack of major innovations and potential repetitiveness, the overall sentiment is positive, highlighting the game's depth and appeal to baseball fans. It's a solid investment for those seeking variety and ongoing updates, despite some concerns about stagnation in certain modes.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

82%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

18%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The consensus among critics regarding the replay value of MLB The Show 24 is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the extensive variety of gameplay modes and the engaging content that keeps players returning. Critics like Atomix and Digital Chumps highlight the extensive customization options and the addictive nature of modes such as Diamond Dynasty and Road to the Show. The inclusion of new features, such as the Custom Game Entry in Franchise Mode noted by But Why Tho?, and the ongoing content updates mentioned by CGMagazine, further enhance the game's replayability. Additionally, the introduction of diverse elements like female players and the historical context of the Negro Leagues, as pointed out by GamersRD, adds depth and variety to the gameplay experience. However, some critics did express concerns regarding certain aspects of replay value. MeuPlayStation mentions that players seeking significant innovation might find the game lacking in major updates, suggesting that the incremental improvements may not justify a purchase for everyone. God is a Geek also notes that while modes like Diamond Dynasty are enjoyable, Franchise mode remains relatively unchanged, which could lead to a sense of stagnation for some players. VideoGamer points out that challenges in Storylines mode might lead to repetitive gameplay, indicating that not all aspects of the game are equally engaging for every player. Overall, the critics largely agree that MLB The Show 24 offers a robust replay value, making it a worthwhile investment for baseball fans. The variety of modes, from Diamond Dynasty to Road to the Show and the engaging storylines, cater to a wide audience, as emphasized by Worth Playing and GamingTrend. While there are some criticisms regarding the lack of significant innovations and potential repetitiveness in certain modes, the majority sentiment remains that the game successfully provides a rich and engaging experience that encourages players to dive back in repeatedly throughout the year.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

78%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

22%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding MLB The Show 24 from critics is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising it as an exemplary entry in the franchise. Reviewers like Atomix and But Why Tho? highlight the game's comprehensive and enjoyable experience, making it a must-have for baseball fans of all levels. The inclusion of the Storylines mode, which showcases forgotten Negro League legends, and the addition of female players are particularly lauded, as noted by But Why Tho?. Critics like COGconnected and Digital Chumps emphasize the game's tradition of excellence, with engaging storylines and gameplay that is described as the finest sports simulation available. Additionally, Everyeye.it and God is a Geek commend the improved gameplay mechanics and technical advancements, further solidifying the game as one of the best sports simulations of the year. Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some critics have pointed out areas for improvement. CGMagazine mentions menu interface shortcomings, while GamersRD notes that some changes could have been implemented in previous versions, indicating a sense of missed opportunities. MeuPlayStation expresses that while the game delivers a familiar experience with enhancements, it may not satisfy those seeking major innovations. Additionally, some reviewers, such as Shacknews, acknowledge that outdated elements still linger, which could detract from the overall experience. These critiques suggest that while the game excels in many areas, there are aspects that could benefit from further refinement. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 24 is a strong and engaging title that successfully builds upon its predecessors. The majority of reviewers, including GamingTrend and PlayStation Universe, agree that it offers a well-rounded package that appeals to both newcomers and veterans alike. The game's respectful treatment of baseball history, engaging storylines, and accessibility are frequently highlighted, making it a top choice for fans of the sport. While there are some criticisms regarding innovation and certain outdated features, the positive reception indicates that MLB The Show 24 is a solid addition to the franchise, continuing its legacy of excellence in sports gaming.

TL;DR

MLB The Show 24 receives rave reviews from critics, praised for its engaging gameplay, the introduction of the Storylines mode highlighting Negro League legends, and inclusion of female players. While it’s celebrated as a top-tier sports simulation, some reviewers note a lack of major innovations and outdated elements. Nonetheless, it remains a must-have for baseball fans, offering a well-rounded experience that honors the sport's history.

MONSTER

Reviews

55 reviews found

XboxAddict

Xbox Series X

May 20, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 continues the legacy of excellence with a strong tribute to history, immersive gameplay, and thrilling challenges, earning a high overall score.

Read full review

GamingTrend

PlayStation 5

May 22, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 is praised as an excellent sports sim, building on previous successes while providing a complete and enjoyable experience.

Read full review

But Why Tho?

PlayStation 5

Mar 20, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 is praised as another excellent update in one of the best sports game franchises, with the Storylines mode highlighting forgotten Negro League legends and the addition of female players enhancing the experience. The refreshed look contributes to making it the complete baseball package.

Read full review

COGconnected

PlayStation 5

Apr 5, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 continues the tradition of excellence in the franchise, with entertaining storylines, fantastic audio, and gameplay that shines as the finest sports simulation on the market.

Read full review

PlayStation Universe

PlayStation 5

Mar 22, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 hits a walk-off homerun for anyone even slightly a baseball fan, offering a great gaming experience with new modes, inclusive features, and engaging gameplay.

Read full review

Digital Chumps

PlayStation 5

Mar 29, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 is spectacular this year, hitting more than it misses. It takes bold chances that pay off, setting an example of how to do a sports game well.

Read full review

God is a Geek

PlayStation 5

Mar 22, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 is the best the series has been, offering a refined and bombastic experience. Perfect for both new and returning players with its diverse modes and improved gameplay mechanics.

Read full review

Movies Games and Tech

PlayStation 5

Apr 18, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 is a solid baseball simulator with enjoyable gameplay and various modes, though it could improve visually.

Read full review

WellPlayed

PlayStation 5

Apr 22, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB: The Show 24 is praised for its respectful treatment of baseball history, engaging storylines, and accessibility for new players. It stands out as a top choice for both newcomers and veterans of the series.

Read full review

Game Informer

PlayStation 5

Mar 27, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 24 doesn't revolutionize the series but excels in providing an engaging experience for fans of baseball simulation games. With solid gameplay, impressive visuals, and compelling storylines, it offers a well-rounded package for players.

Read full review