
79
MONSTER
It’s your Show. Ready to own it? Set out on the road to baseball greatness – whatever it is you want to achieve, MLB® The Show™ 24 has got you covered. Earn your call up from the minors to the big leagues and prove you’ve got what it takes at the top. Learn from the legends of the sport, take inspiration from their heroics and use it to improve your game. Hold your nerve when it matters and earn the right to be called World Series champions. Chalk up the wins, pick yourself up after the losses. Whatever happens, know you left nothing in the dugout. Celebrating History with Storylines Celebrate and learn about baseball legends throughout the sport’s history. The Storylines mode transports you into baseball’s past to relive iconic moments of baseball’s unsung and unknown heroes. Experience career-defining moments through a combination of immersive gameplay that will educate and inspire you to make history of your own. Road to the Show Unlock your moment and build your career in the ultimate baseball role-playing experience. Become a ballplayer and journey from the minors to the majors to define your legacy. Franchise Lead your team to World Series glory as a team manager in Franchise mode. Experience new features providing more in-depth and dynamic gameplay from March to October.
Game analysis
Monster Scorecard
EXPAND ALL
Story and Narrative
Expand for full analysis
84
Critics raved about MLB The Show 24's Story mode for its powerful historical storytelling, emotional depth, and bold exploration of baseball’s legacy, from the Negro Leagues to Derek Jeter’s iconic journey. While technical hiccups like outdated visuals and dialogue lingered, the mode’s progressive strides—like its first female-focused Road to the Show—and immersive narratives cemented it as a standout achievement, balancing nostalgia, education, and innovation despite minor flaws.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY
Story Score
84
Positive Reviews (80-100)
81%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
19%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
0%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.
TL;DR
story and narrative
Critics raved about MLB The Show 24's Story mode for its powerful historical storytelling, emotional depth, and bold exploration of baseball’s legacy, from the Negro Leagues to Derek Jeter’s iconic journey. While technical hiccups like outdated visuals and dialogue lingered, the mode’s progressive strides—like its first female-focused Road to the Show—and immersive narratives cemented it as a standout achievement, balancing nostalgia, education, and innovation despite minor flaws.
Gameplay Mechanics
Expand for full analysis
86
MLB The Show 24 crushes with polished gameplay, fresh Road to the Show features, jaw-dropping animations, and immersive DualSense magic—though QTEs, repetitive mechanics, and Switch glitches linger as thorns in an otherwise stellar diamond.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY
Gameplay Score
86
Positive Reviews (80-100)
88%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
12%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
0%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.
TL;DR
gameplay mechanics
MLB The Show 24 crushes with polished gameplay, fresh Road to the Show features, jaw-dropping animations, and immersive DualSense magic—though QTEs, repetitive mechanics, and Switch glitches linger as thorns in an otherwise stellar diamond.
Graphics and Visual Design
Expand for full analysis
75
MLB The Show 24 dazzles with lifelike details and immersive baseball authenticity on PS5, but dated textures, stiff animations, and Switch performance flaws reveal missed potential amid incremental progress.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS
Visual Score
75
Positive Reviews (80-100)
50%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
46%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
4%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.
TL;DR
graphics and visual design
MLB The Show 24 dazzles with lifelike details and immersive baseball authenticity on PS5, but dated textures, stiff animations, and Switch performance flaws reveal missed potential amid incremental progress.
Music and Sound Design
Expand for full analysis
81
Praise for MLB The Show 24’s immersive sound design, diverse soundtrack, and PS5 3D audio, but criticism over repetitive commentary, localization gaps, and mismatched crowd effects undermine an otherwise stellar auditory experience.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN
Sound Score
81
Positive Reviews (80-100)
67%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
33%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
0%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.
TL;DR
music and sound design
Praise for MLB The Show 24’s immersive sound design, diverse soundtrack, and PS5 3D audio, but criticism over repetitive commentary, localization gaps, and mismatched crowd effects undermine an otherwise stellar auditory experience.
Voice Acting
Expand for full analysis
76
MLB The Show 24's voice acting, led by Bob Kendrick and Derek Jeter, is hailed for authenticity and historical depth, with critics praising its emotional and educational impact—except for one outlier that called it archaic.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING
Acting Score
76
Positive Reviews (80-100)
57%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
43%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
0%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.
TL;DR
voice acting
MLB The Show 24's voice acting, led by Bob Kendrick and Derek Jeter, is hailed for authenticity and historical depth, with critics praising its emotional and educational impact—except for one outlier that called it archaic.
Technical Performance
Expand for full analysis
66
PlayStation 5 shines with stable performance and polish, while Xbox Series X lags in innovation and Nintendo Switch battles persistent technical hiccups despite fixes—gameplay remains uneven across platforms.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE
Tech Score
66
Positive Reviews (80-100)
27%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
45%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
27%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.
TL;DR
technical performance
PlayStation 5 shines with stable performance and polish, while Xbox Series X lags in innovation and Nintendo Switch battles persistent technical hiccups despite fixes—gameplay remains uneven across platforms.
Replay Value
Expand for full analysis
83
MLB The Show 24 delivers unmatched replay value via deep customization, evolving modes like Diamond Dynasty’s cornerstone cards, and addictive Road to the Show with iconic moments. Seasonal updates and RPG-driven Storylines keep players hooked, while microtransaction-free rewards boost engagement. Yet, repetitive Storylines, technical hiccups, and predictable mechanics in Franchise Mode linger as flaws. Despite minor gripes, its diverse, constantly refreshed experience cements it as a must-play for baseball fans—proving depth trumps novelty.
SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE
Replay Score
83
Positive Reviews (80-100)
72%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
28%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
0%
Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.
TL;DR
replay value
MLB The Show 24 delivers unmatched replay value via deep customization, evolving modes like Diamond Dynasty’s cornerstone cards, and addictive Road to the Show with iconic moments. Seasonal updates and RPG-driven Storylines keep players hooked, while microtransaction-free rewards boost engagement. Yet, repetitive Storylines, technical hiccups, and predictable mechanics in Franchise Mode linger as flaws. Despite minor gripes, its diverse, constantly refreshed experience cements it as a must-play for baseball fans—proving depth trumps novelty.
Overall Verdict
79
MONSTER
OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION
Monster Score
79
Positive Reviews (80-100)
77%
Mixed Reviews (50-79)
23%
Negative Reviews (0-49)
0%
Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.
TL;DR
MLB The Show 24 is a masterclass in baseball simulation—polished, immersive, and brimming with storytelling depth, historical reverence, and visual splendor. While technical hiccups on Switch and missed opportunities dampen its sheen, it remains a must-play for fans, blending tradition with innovation for a 'walk-off homerun' of a gaming experience.
79
MONSTER
Reviews
56 reviews found95
XboxAddict
May 20, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 continues the legacy of excellence with a strong tribute to history, immersive gameplay, and thrilling challenges, earning a high overall score.
Read full review
90
GamingTrend
May 22, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 is praised as an excellent sports sim, building on previous successes while providing a complete and enjoyable experience.
Read full review
90
But Why Tho?
Mar 20, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 is praised as another excellent update in one of the best sports game franchises, with the Storylines mode highlighting forgotten Negro League legends and the addition of female players enhancing the experience. The refreshed look contributes to making it the complete baseball package.
Read full review
90
COGconnected
Apr 5, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 continues the tradition of excellence in the franchise, with entertaining storylines, fantastic audio, and gameplay that shines as the finest sports simulation on the market.
Read full review
90
PlayStation Universe
Mar 22, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 hits a walk-off homerun for anyone even slightly a baseball fan, offering a great gaming experience with new modes, inclusive features, and engaging gameplay.
Read full review
90
Digital Chumps
Mar 29, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 is spectacular this year, hitting more than it misses. It takes bold chances that pay off, setting an example of how to do a sports game well.
Read full review
90
God is a Geek
Mar 22, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 is the best the series has been, offering a refined and bombastic experience. Perfect for both new and returning players with its diverse modes and improved gameplay mechanics.
Read full review
90
Movies Games and Tech
Apr 18, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 is a solid baseball simulator with enjoyable gameplay and various modes, though it could improve visually.
Read full review
90
WellPlayed
Apr 22, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB: The Show 24 is praised for its respectful treatment of baseball history, engaging storylines, and accessibility for new players. It stands out as a top choice for both newcomers and veterans of the series.
Read full review
84
Game Informer
Mar 27, 2024
AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details
MLB The Show 24 doesn't revolutionize the series but excels in providing an engaging experience for fans of baseball simulation games. With solid gameplay, impressive visuals, and compelling storylines, it offers a well-rounded package for players.
Read full review