Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Amazon

Playstation

Twitch

MONSTER

MLB The Show 23

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of MLB The Show 23
Item: MLB The Show 23
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2023

GenresSimulation, Sports, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableMar 24, 2023

PlatformNintendo Switch, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X

DeveloperSan Diego Studio

Overview

Shock The Game. Own The Show.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23's Story mode shines with its focus on the Negro Leagues, earning praise for its educational depth and engaging storytelling, especially through Bob Kendrick's narration. Critics appreciate the homage to baseball legends, though some note the single-player focus can feel disjointed and gameplay innovations are lacking. Overall, it's a significant and commendable addition, making it essential for baseball fans despite some execution flaws.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

94%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story mode of MLB The Show 23 has garnered widespread acclaim from critics, particularly for its innovative focus on the history of the Negro Leagues. Reviewers such as CGMagazine and Game Informer praised the inclusion of legendary figures from this significant era, emphasizing the educational aspect of the game. The narration by Bob Kendrick was highlighted as a key strength, enhancing the storytelling experience and providing a rich historical context. Critics like Digital Chumps and New York Daily News noted how the game not only pays homage to baseball legends but also allows players to engage with their stories in a meaningful way. The documentary-style presentation, as mentioned by Everyeye.it and Push Square, further elevates the narrative depth, making it an engaging experience for players who appreciate the historical significance of baseball. However, some critics pointed out limitations within the Storylines mode. BaziCenter and Gaming Age expressed concerns about the single-player focus, suggesting that it can lead to a disjointed sense of progression. While the historical narratives are compelling, there were mentions of execution feeling less fleshed out compared to other game modes, as highlighted by Gaming Age. This sentiment was echoed by Dexerto, who noted that while the game exceeds expectations, it does not introduce remarkable gameplay innovations. This raises questions about the balance between historical storytelling and the overall gameplay experience, which some reviewers felt could be improved. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 23's Storylines mode is a significant and commendable addition to the franchise, with the majority praising its educational and engaging approach to the history of the Negro Leagues. Critics like Twinfinite and We Got This Covered emphasized that this mode enhances the game's narrative depth, making it a must-experience for both hardcore baseball fans and newcomers alike. Despite some criticisms regarding execution and gameplay limitations, the positive reception of the historical narratives suggests that the game successfully honors its roots while providing players with a unique and enriching experience.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23 impresses with refined gameplay mechanics, smooth animations, and new features like Captain Cards, making it accessible for new players and enjoyable for veterans. However, critics lament the lack of significant innovation, as many core mechanics feel repetitive and modes like Franchise and Road to the Show seem stale. While it's a polished baseball sim, returning players might find it underwhelming due to minimal new content.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

68%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

32%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of MLB The Show 23 has garnered a mix of praise and critique from various reviewers, highlighting several positive aspects. Critics such as Attack of the Fanboy and Digital Chumps commend the improvements in gameplay mechanics, particularly the changes to the attribute system, swing feedback, and fielding. Game Informer and IGN also note the smoothness of gameplay, enhanced animations, and the introduction of new features like Captain Cards and ranked co-op matches, which add depth to the overall experience. Furthermore, many reviewers, including GamersRD and PlayStation Universe, appreciate the game’s intuitive controls and the balance it strikes between accessibility for newcomers and depth for seasoned players, making it enjoyable across different skill levels. However, despite these improvements, several critics express dissatisfaction with the overall lack of significant innovation in the gameplay. BaziCenter and Gaming Age point out that returning players may find the experience repetitive, as core mechanics remain largely unchanged from previous iterations. Critics like Everyeye.it and SpazioGames echo this sentiment, noting that while there are some refinements, the gameplay feels stale, especially in modes like Franchise and Road to the Show. Additionally, some reviewers, such as The Loadout and Push Square, mention that while the gameplay is solid, the absence of new MLB rules and the limited changes to existing modes detract from the overall freshness of the experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 23 offers a polished and enjoyable baseball simulation, but it struggles to provide substantial new content for returning players. While many appreciate the incremental improvements in mechanics and the engaging gameplay experience, the repetition of familiar modes and the lack of major innovations leave some feeling underwhelmed. As noted by critics like CGMagazine and Wccftech, the game maintains its status as a solid entry in the series, yet it may not fully satisfy those seeking a transformative experience.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23 dazzles with stunning visuals and immersive stadium designs, earning praise for its detail and lighting improvements. However, some critics argue it lacks significant advancements over previous versions, feeling outdated and not fully meeting next-gen standards, especially on platforms like Nintendo Switch. While the game shines in certain areas, it still needs a major graphics overhaul to elevate its presentation.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

49%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The overall sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of MLB The Show 23 is predominantly positive, with many critics praising the game's visual fidelity and attention to detail. Attack of the Fanboy highlights the impressive look of the game across all platforms, while BaziCenter notes the high-quality player models and stadium designs that position it among the best in the sports genre. COGconnected and Digital Chumps both emphasize the gorgeous visuals and realistic stadium recreations that enhance the immersive experience of attending a baseball game. Critics like GamersRD and IGN also commend the improvements in lighting and textures, contributing to a visually stunning presentation that draws players into the atmosphere of major league ballparks. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the game's graphics, particularly concerning the perceived lack of significant advancements over previous iterations. Critics like ComicBook and Everyeye.it express disappointment with the overall graphics, citing that they feel outdated and fail to meet next-gen standards. Additionally, several reviews, including those from Push Square and SpazioGames, suggest that the visuals still resemble last-generation titles, indicating a need for a comprehensive overhaul. The criticisms extend to the Nintendo Switch version, where reviewers like Nintendo Life and TouchArcade mention graphical downgrades that detract from the overall presentation compared to other platforms. In summary, while MLB The Show 23 boasts impressive visuals and immersive stadium designs, there is a clear divide among critics regarding the game's graphical fidelity. Many reviewers appreciate the enhancements in animations and lighting, as noted by Game Informer and God is a Geek, while others argue that the graphics engine shows its age, with a lack of significant improvements compared to previous titles. The consensus appears to be that while the game excels in certain areas, it still has room for growth to meet the expectations of next-gen gaming, particularly in player models and overall visual presentation.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23 impresses with improved sound design and a diverse soundtrack, enhancing the gaming experience. Critics praise realistic audio and a new engaging announcing team, but many find the commentary repetitive and generic, detracting from immersion. The Nintendo Switch version's sound quality also falls short. Overall, while significant strides have been made, there's still room for improvement, especially in commentary and inclusivity.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

42%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of MLB The Show 23 have garnered a mix of positive feedback from various critics, highlighting significant improvements and enhancements over previous iterations. Critics like IGN and God is a Geek praised the audio for capturing the essence of baseball, with realistic sound effects and immersive audio that enhance the overall gaming experience. The addition of a new announcing team has been well-received, with reviewers from ComicBook and Everyeye.it noting that the dialogue is less repetitive and more engaging, contributing positively to the game's presentation. Additionally, the soundtrack has been highlighted by Atomix and Pure Xbox for its diversity and inclusion of iconic artists, which adds to the game's atmosphere and enjoyment. Conversely, several critics pointed out notable weaknesses in the sound design, particularly regarding the commentary. Attack of the Fanboy and Gaming Age criticized the commentary for being generic and repetitive, detracting from the overall audio experience. Digital Chumps echoed this sentiment, stating that while the commentary adds excitement, it suffers from a lack of variety. Furthermore, Twinfinite described the commentary as feeling flat compared to other sports games, indicating that it falls short of expectations. Critics like Gaming Age also noted that the sound design on the Nintendo Switch version was inferior to that on other platforms, with less crisp crowd noises and a different feel for the sound of the ball. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 23 has made significant strides in its sound design and music, though it still has room for improvement, particularly in the commentary aspect. While many reviewers, such as IGN and Hardcore Gamer, praised the immersive audio and enhancements in sound effects, others like Digital Chumps and Twinfinite pointed out the repetitiveness of the commentary as a drawback. The soundtrack received a generally positive reception, but the lack of Spanish commentary noted by Atomix suggests that there are still areas for further development. In summary, MLB The Show 23's sound design and music are a mixed bag, showcasing both commendable advancements and persistent challenges.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23 shines with Bob Kendrick's praised narration of Negro League storylines, adding depth and educational value, while the general commentary falls flat with repetitiveness and lack of engagement. Critics are divided: Kendrick's work is a standout, but the overall voice acting needs improvement for a more consistent experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

36%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in MLB The Show 23 has garnered significant praise, particularly for the contributions of Bob Kendrick, who narrates the Negro League storylines. Critics such as COGconnected, ComicBook, and IGN have highlighted Kendrick's narration as "immaculate," "captivating," and "passionate," emphasizing how it adds depth and authenticity to the storytelling. This sentiment is echoed by multiple reviewers, including the New York Daily News, which notes that Kendrick delivers profound insights into the players' careers, enriching the overall experience. The historical context provided by Kendrick's narration not only enhances the gameplay but also serves as an educational tool, making it a standout feature of the game. On the flip side, several critics have pointed out weaknesses in the overall commentary beyond Kendrick's contributions. Digital Chumps noted that while the Negro Leagues mode is commendable for its historical insight, the general commentary lacks variety, suggesting a repetitive nature that can detract from the gaming experience. Gaming Age echoed this sentiment by labeling the voice acting as a weak point, specifically criticizing the commentary duo of Jon 'Boog' Sciambi and Chris Singleton for their repetitive anecdotes. Twinfinite also mentioned a lack of chemistry and engagement in the overall commentary, indicating that while certain aspects shine, others fall short of expectations. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates a divided sentiment regarding the voice acting in MLB The Show 23. While Bob Kendrick's narration has been universally praised for its depth and emotional resonance, the general commentary has received mixed reviews, with many critics noting its repetitiveness and lack of engagement. Critics like Everyeye.it have acknowledged improvements in the voice acting, suggesting that the game is on the right track, but the feedback from Gaming Age and Digital Chumps highlights that there is still room for growth in enhancing the overall commentary experience. Thus, while the game excels in certain areas, it faces challenges in delivering a consistently engaging auditory experience throughout.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23 generally impresses with solid performance, especially on PS5 and Xbox Series X, but critics highlight issues like CPU stamina on PS5, minor online hiccups, and noticeable limitations on the Nintendo Switch. While the game runs smoothly overall, improvements are needed in online play and for the Switch version, which struggles with graphics and frame rates.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

32%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

68%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of MLB The Show 23 has garnered a generally positive reception across various gaming platforms. On the PlayStation 5, several critics, including COGconnected and GamersRD, noted that the game runs smoothly with minimal frame drops and good loading times, indicating solid technical stability. Digital Chumps highlighted improvements in the online experience, emphasizing enhanced stability and balance, while PSX Brasil reported no significant performance or stability issues, suggesting a seamless experience. The overall impression from these reviews indicates that the game performs well on current-gen consoles, with SpazioGames also affirming a stable technical performance. However, there are notable negatives that critics have pointed out for each platform. On the PS5, Everyeye.it raised concerns about CPU player stamina, which may necessitate a patch, while Game Informer mentioned occasional technical hiccups that could break immersion. The Loadout specifically pointed out performance issues in online modes, such as slowdowns during crucial moments. For the Xbox Series X, SECTOR.sk acknowledged minor technical issues, including long loading times and online infrastructure problems, while Shacknews reported latency issues in online matches. On the Nintendo Switch, the limitations of the console were evident, with Gaming Age noting that players and stadiums appeared lackluster, and Nintendo Life mentioned frame rate troubles that felt sluggish compared to other platforms. TouchArcade echoed concerns about lingering technical issues from the previous version, although they did not significantly detract from the gameplay experience. Overall, the consensus among critics across all platforms is that while MLB The Show 23 showcases solid technical performance, particularly on the PS5 and Xbox Series X, there are still areas for improvement. The PlayStation 5 version is generally viewed as stable, but some critics, like Game Informer and The Loadout, highlighted issues that could disrupt gameplay. The Xbox Series X version is praised for its performance but faces minor issues, particularly in online play. The Nintendo Switch version, while playable, suffers from noticeable technical limitations that affect the overall experience. This mixed feedback suggests that while the game is a step forward, it still has room for refinement, particularly in addressing online performance and optimizing for the Switch.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 23 excels in replay value with its diverse modes like Diamond Dynasty and new features such as Storylines and the World Baseball Classic, keeping players engaged for hours. However, some critics argue that returning fans might find it repetitive due to a lack of significant innovations from previous versions. While it's a solid entry for both newcomers and veterans, it may fall short for those craving fresh updates.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

56%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

42%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of MLB The Show 23 is largely positive, with many critics praising the game's extensive variety of modes and features that encourage ongoing engagement. Reviewers like Attack of the Fanboy and Game Informer highlight the numerous reasons to continue playing beyond the initial excitement of spring training, noting that modes such as Diamond Dynasty, Franchise, and Road to the Show provide ample content to explore. Critics like ComicBook and PSX Brasil emphasize the depth of Diamond Dynasty, which offers extensive content and seasonal updates that can keep players engaged for hundreds of hours. Additionally, the introduction of new modes like the Storylines and the World Baseball Classic is seen as a significant enhancement to replay value, providing diverse gameplay experiences that cater to a wide range of player preferences. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the game's replay value, particularly concerning the perceived lack of significant changes from previous iterations. Critics such as BaziCenter and Gaming Age express concerns that long-time fans may find the experience monotonous due to the absence of substantial innovations. While many reviewers acknowledge that the various modes can keep players busy, some, like Hardcore Gamer and Digital Chumps, point out frustrations with certain aspects of gameplay, such as the Challenge Mode and the reset of previous progress in Diamond Dynasty, which may detract from the overall enjoyment. Furthermore, some critics, including Nintendo Life and SECTOR.sk, mention that the replay value may not be compelling enough for players who have recently experienced the previous version of the game. In summary, the consensus among critics indicates that MLB The Show 23 offers a rich array of modes and features that contribute to its replay value, though some players may feel limited by the lack of significant updates. While many reviewers, including COGconnected and We Got This Covered, appreciate the ongoing nature of Diamond Dynasty and the engaging content it provides, others caution that the game may not feel fresh enough for returning players. Overall, MLB The Show 23 appears to be a solid entry in the series, with enough content to satisfy both new and returning players, but it may not fully meet the expectations of those seeking groundbreaking changes.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

84%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

16%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding MLB The Show 23 from various critics is largely positive, with many praising the game for its engaging gameplay and the introduction of the new Storylines mode, particularly the focus on the Negro Leagues. Critics such as Game Informer and We Got This Covered highlight it as one of the best installments in the franchise, emphasizing the thoughtful additions and improvements that enhance the overall experience. The game is described as a solid baseball simulation that appeals to both long-time fans and newcomers, with many reviewers noting the polished gameplay, beautiful graphics, and a wealth of modes available. Notably, the Storylines mode has been recognized as a standout feature, bringing historical context to the game and enriching the player's experience, as noted by critics from Digital Chumps and New Game Network. However, despite the praise, several critics have pointed out the game's shortcomings, particularly regarding the lack of significant innovations compared to its predecessor. For instance, Digitally Downloaded and Gaming Age express concerns that MLB The Show 23 feels more like an update rather than a fresh installment, with minimal changes in modes outside of Diamond Dynasty. Additionally, some reviewers, such as Hardcore Gamer and Everyeye.it, mention graphical shortcomings and the absence of recent MLB rule changes, which could deter new players from fully embracing the title. The Road to the Show mode also received criticism for not meeting expectations, as noted by Dexerto and Twinfinite, indicating that there are areas where the game could have pushed boundaries further. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 23 is a commendable entry in the series, successfully delivering an enjoyable baseball experience while introducing valuable new features. While some reviewers like BaziCenter and Gaming Age highlight the lack of substantial innovations, the majority agree that the game still stands as the best baseball simulation available, with a strong recommendation for fans of the sport. Critics such as CGMagazine and PlayStation Universe reinforce the idea that, despite its flaws, MLB The Show 23 is a solid choice for baseball enthusiasts, showcasing the franchise's commitment to quality and authenticity in sports gaming.

TL;DR

TL;DR: MLB The Show 23 receives largely positive reviews, praised for engaging gameplay and the standout Storylines mode focused on the Negro Leagues. Critics hail it as one of the best in the series, with polished graphics and a wealth of modes. However, some note it feels more like an update than a true innovation, with criticisms on graphical issues and a lack of new MLB rule changes. Despite these shortcomings, it’s still regarded as the best baseball simulation available, highly recommended for fans.

MONSTER

Reviews

65 reviews found

GamersRD

PlayStation 5

Mar 28, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 23 is an excellent game with polished gameplay, beautiful graphics, and a wealth of modes, though it lacks some recent rule changes.

Read full review

We Got This Covered

PlayStation 5

Apr 3, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 23 is praised as the best installment yet, successfully refreshing the franchise with new features and a deep connection to baseball history.

Read full review

IGN Adria

PlayStation 5

Apr 11, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review overall praises MLB The Show 23 as the best edition so far, with improvements in various aspects and positive reception from fans.

Read full review

But Why Tho?

Xbox Series X

Apr 14, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The overall verdict is positive, with the game being praised for revamping the formula and the importance of the Storylines: Negro Leagues mode.

Read full review

COGconnected

PlayStation 5

Apr 3, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 23 is the best baseball simulation game on the market, providing an authentic representation of the sport. Despite minor issues, it is an excellent package.

Read full review

Comicbook.com

PlayStation 5

Apr 7, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 23 is likely one of the strongest entries that we've received in quite some time.

Read full review

ComicBook

PlayStation 5

Apr 7, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 23 is one of the strongest entries in the series, with the Storylines mode being a standout feature, though some aspects feel stagnant.

Read full review

NintendoWorldReport

Nintendo Switch

Mar 28, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

An incredible baseball game with flexible gameplay and real-life players.

Read full review

TheXboxHub

Xbox Series X

Apr 24, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 23 is highly recommended for anyone interested in baseball, with its accessible gameplay, fantastic presentation, and the greatest baseball game of all time.

Read full review

PlayStation Country

PlayStation 5

Apr 12, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The reviewer likes MLB The Show 23 a lot and sees themselves playing it for a long time.

Read full review