Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Steam

Epic

Twitch

MONSTER

Darkest Dungeon II

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Darkest Dungeon II
Item: Darkest Dungeon II
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2023

GenresAdventure, Indie, Side View Perspective, RPG, Strategy, Military and Warfare, Single Player

AvailableMay 8, 2023

PlatformPC, PlayStation 5

DeveloperRed Hook Studios

Overview

The eagerly awaited follow-up to Red Hook's smash hit gothic horror RPG! DDII will test your mettle and drive you to the brink of madness. Armor yourself with purpose and provision your party for the journey ahead. It will be arduous.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II is largely praised for its dark fantasy setting and engaging narrative, with critics highlighting its emotional depth and character backstories. While the atmosphere and themes of hope and perseverance resonate well, some point out weaknesses in the central storyline and fragmented storytelling. Overall, it builds on its predecessor, offering a rich narrative that, despite some flaws, successfully captures its Lovecraftian essence while introducing fresh elements.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

80%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

20%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Darkest Dungeon II has garnered a largely positive reception among critics, who praise its dark fantasy setting and engaging narrative. Reviewers like But Why Tho? highlight the bleak atmosphere complemented by Wayne June's narration, which adds a sense of humanity to the grim world. CGMagazine notes that the plot reinvents the original, with a fresh journey that maintains connections to the series' lore while introducing new elements, such as the adventuring party's quest to restore hope. Other critics, such as IGN and Digital Chumps, commend the narrative's focus on character backstories and the emotional depth they provide, enhancing player connection to the heroes. The game's exploration of themes like perseverance, hope, and the psychological impacts of the characters' journeys is also well-received, with reviewers like Dexerto and PC Invasion emphasizing the importance of confronting one's past. However, not all feedback is entirely positive, as some critics have pointed out weaknesses in the storyline. GRYOnline.pl suggests that the game lacks a compelling central narrative compared to its predecessor, while Player 2 mentions that the fragmented storytelling can lead to players losing sight of the bigger picture. Critics like Gfinity argue that while the game adapts the original's world, it risks losing some of its spirit in the process. Additionally, some reviews, such as those from IGN Italia and INVEN, mention that the story can feel vague or lacking in depth, particularly regarding hero-player relationships, which may detract from the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Darkest Dungeon II successfully builds upon its predecessor's foundation, offering a rich and immersive narrative that intertwines with gameplay. While some reviewers express concerns about the clarity and cohesiveness of the story, many appreciate the depth of character development and thematic exploration. Critics like GamingTrend and Hobby Consolas highlight the engaging atmosphere and character-driven storytelling, suggesting that despite its flaws, the game effectively captures the essence of its dark, Lovecraftian roots while introducing new elements that keep the experience fresh and intriguing.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II impresses critics with its evolved gameplay, retaining beloved core elements while introducing engaging 3D combat and roguelike unpredictability. Reviewers praise its tactical depth and satisfying mechanics, but some note early-game repetitiveness and the absence of permadeath may dampen emotional investment. The steep learning curve could overwhelm newcomers, yet most agree it delivers a rewarding, addictive experience—solidifying it as a worthy successor to the original.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

90%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

10%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Darkest Dungeon II has garnered a largely positive reception from critics, who praise its evolution from the original game while maintaining the core elements that fans loved. Reviewers like PC Gamer highlight the fun tactical experience, noting improvements in combat with new 3D animations and a token system that enhances buffs and debuffs. Critics such as GamePro Germany and Digital Chumps appreciate the shift to roguelike elements, which introduces a layer of unpredictability and encourages strategic planning during runs. The turn-based combat system has been described as sharp and engaging, with many reviewers, including IGN and Game Informer, emphasizing the satisfaction derived from mastering the game's mechanics and the strategic depth involved in managing a party of heroes. However, not all feedback is entirely positive. Some critics, like Gfinity and PlayStation Universe, express concerns that the gameplay can feel repetitive, particularly in the early stages of runs, where the experience may not vary significantly. The absence of permadeath, while reducing frustration, has been noted by GamePro Germany as potentially hindering emotional investment in characters. Additionally, the complexity of the combat system, while praised by many, has led to critiques about the steep learning curve and the potential for overwhelming new players, as mentioned by KeenGamer and Metro GameCentral. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Darkest Dungeon II successfully builds upon its predecessor, offering a compelling and challenging gameplay experience that balances strategic decision-making with engaging mechanics. Many reviewers, such as Hobby Consolas and IGN Spain, appreciate the game's unique approach to character relationships and resource management, which adds depth to the gameplay. Despite some criticisms regarding repetitiveness and the learning curve, the majority of critics agree that the game presents a rewarding and addictive experience, making it a worthy successor in the franchise.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II impresses with a stunning 3D graphics upgrade, retaining its grim comic-inspired style while enhancing fluid animations and combat visuals. Critics praise its gothic aesthetic and haunting environments, capturing Lovecraftian themes effectively. However, some note the interface needs improvement for better readability and that certain character designs lack the original's charm. Overall, the game is hailed for its artistic direction, delivering a visually striking experience that deepens the dark atmosphere fans adore.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

88%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

12%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Darkest Dungeon II have garnered widespread acclaim from critics, who praise the game's successful transition from its original 2D aesthetic to a more dynamic 3D presentation. Reviewers like But Why Tho? and Gameblog.fr highlight the retention of the grim, comic-inspired style while introducing fluid animations and visually captivating combat sequences. Critics such as GameGrin and Hardcore Gamer emphasize the gothic art style and the atmospheric depth that enriches the experience, with IGN noting the stylish presentation and impactful animations that enhance character interactions. The game’s environments have been described as beautifully bleak and hauntingly beautiful, with Everyeye.it and Gfinity specifically mentioning the Lovecraftian themes that are visually represented through distinct character designs and grotesque enemy portrayals. Despite the overwhelmingly positive reception, some critics have pointed out areas for improvement. For instance, Gamereactor UK mentions that while the visuals have been updated, the user interface could benefit from enhancements to improve readability and sophistication. Additionally, IGN Spain and PlayStation Universe express concerns that certain character designs may have lost some of the charm that defined the original game, suggesting a slight disconnect in the transition to 3D. Critics like INVEN have also noted that while the graphics are impressive, the interface could detract from the overall experience, indicating that technical aspects of the design may not be as polished as the visuals. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Darkest Dungeon II presents a significant upgrade in graphics and visual design, successfully capturing the essence of its predecessor while adding new layers of depth and dynamism. The majority of reviewers, including PC Gamer and Metro GameCentral, commend the game for its visually stunning and immersive environments, with many noting the effective blend of gothic and Lovecraftian aesthetics. While some minor criticisms exist regarding interface and character charm, the overwhelming sentiment is that the game excels in its artistic direction, making it a visually striking sequel that enhances the dark atmosphere fans have come to love.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II receives high praise for its immersive sound design and music, with critics highlighting the haunting ambiance and intense, Victorian-inspired scores. Voice actor Wayne June's narration adds depth and dark humor, enhancing the game's emotional impact. However, some reviewers note a lack of variety in sound effects and music, which could detract from the experience for some players. Overall, the audio elements are deemed crucial to the game's atmosphere, solidifying its success despite minor critiques.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

84%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

16%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Darkest Dungeon II have garnered significant praise from critics, who highlight the game's ability to create an immersive and atmospheric experience. Many reviewers, such as But Why Tho? and GameGrin, commend the sensory sounds, including the rattling of wooden wheels and the cries of the undead, which contribute to a haunting ambiance. The music, described by CGMagazine as "intense and bombastic," complements the fast-paced gameplay and evokes a Victorian feel, reminiscent of Bloodborne. The return of voice actor Wayne June has been a standout feature, with critics like Movies Games and Tech and RPGamer noting his deep, gravelly narration that adds gravitas and dark humor to the game. Overall, the sound effects, music, and voice acting work in harmony to enhance the game's narrative and emotional impact, as noted by critics like KeenGamer and Shacknews. However, not all opinions are entirely favorable. Some critics, particularly IGN Spain, pointed out a lack of variety in the sound effects and music, which they felt detracted from the overall immersive experience. Vandal echoed this sentiment, suggesting that while the soundtrack maintains the intense atmosphere of the first game, it could benefit from greater diversity. Additionally, GamePro Germany mentioned that the German version's reliance on subtitles instead of voice acting might impact immersion for non-English-speaking players. These critiques suggest that while the sound design is strong, there are areas where it could be improved to cater to a broader audience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Darkest Dungeon II excels in sound design and music, creating a captivating atmosphere that enhances the gameplay experience. The majority of reviewers appreciate the chilling ambiance and the effective use of sound effects and music, with many praising Wayne June's narration as a key element of the game's appeal. Critics like Digital Chumps and PlayStation Universe emphasize the importance of audio in establishing the game's mood, while Multiplayer.it highlights the richness and atmospheric quality of the sound design. Despite some criticisms regarding variety, the prevailing sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, indicating that the audio aspects of Darkest Dungeon II significantly contribute to its success as a sequel.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

The voice acting in Darkest Dungeon II is widely praised, especially Wayne June's captivating narration, which adds warmth and depth to the game's dark themes. Critics commend its emotional weight and immersive quality, although some note the narrator's lines can feel overly dramatic. A few critiques highlight the lack of voice acting in the German version, but overall, the voice work is seen as a standout feature that enhances the storytelling experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

74%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

26%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Darkest Dungeon II has garnered widespread acclaim from critics, with a particular emphasis on the performance of Wayne June, who reprises his role as the narrator. Reviewers from outlets such as But Why Tho? and Gamepressure highlight June's gravelly voice as a source of warmth amidst the game's bleak atmosphere, enhancing the overall immersion and emotional weight of the narrative. Critics like Jeuxvideo.com and Digital Chumps note how the exceptional voice acting elevates the storytelling experience, with IGN describing the narrator's melodramatic lines as both overwrought and enjoyable. The fully voiced narration is praised across the board, with GameGrin and Gamereactor UK emphasizing how it complements the game's themes and adds depth to character interactions. While the majority of reviews are positive, some critiques do emerge. For instance, IGN mentions that the narrator's lines can be seen as excessively melodramatic, potentially detracting from the overall experience for some players. Additionally, RPG Fan points out that while the narrator's deep observations are noted, there is a lack of further detail regarding the voice acting, suggesting that some aspects may not resonate as strongly with every player. Furthermore, GamePro Germany highlights a limitation in the German version of the game, which lacks voice acting, indicating that the experience may not be uniformly impactful across different language versions. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive, with many agreeing that the voice acting in Darkest Dungeon II significantly enhances the game’s atmosphere and storytelling. Critics like PlayStation Universe and Push Square assert that the quality of the narrator's performance is among the best in video games, solidifying Wayne June's role as a pivotal element of the game's success. The collective sentiment suggests that the voice acting not only enriches the gameplay experience but also serves as a crucial component in conveying the game's dark themes and emotional depth.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II impresses on PC with stunning visuals, solid performance, and improved gameplay from early access, earning high praise. Critics note minor issues like translation flaws and lack of high-end optimization. However, the PS5 version faces mixed reviews due to UI problems, stutters, and crashes, highlighting the need for further refinements on console. Overall, it's a strong game but with room for enhancement, especially for console players.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

44%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

56%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Darkest Dungeon II has garnered a predominantly positive reception from critics, especially on PC. Reviewers such as GRYOnline.pl and IGN Italia highlight the game's stability and responsiveness, praising its visually stunning art style and excellent audio design. The evolution from early access is noted by GRYOnline.pl, who appreciates the improvements in character relationships and gameplay mechanics. SECTOR.sk also commends the immersive battles and revamped monsters, indicating that the game successfully maintains the high standards set by its predecessor. Overall, the PC version is seen as a polished experience that enhances the core gameplay elements. However, there are some criticisms regarding the PC version, albeit minor. Meristation points out translation issues that can detract from the experience, while The Games Machine mentions that the graphics are not particularly demanding on PC hardware, suggesting a lack of optimization for high-end systems. These aspects, while not severely impacting the overall enjoyment, indicate areas where the game could improve to meet the expectations of all players. On the PlayStation 5, the sentiment is more mixed. Finger Guns notes some console-centric hiccups, particularly with the UI and menu navigation, which detracts from the overall experience. GamePro Germany echoes this sentiment, mentioning occasional stutters and crashes that disrupt gameplay, especially during critical moments like revealing character relationships. GamingTrend further emphasizes the clunky menu navigation designed for mouse and keyboard, which can frustrate players accustomed to a more fluid console experience. Overall, while the technical performance on PC is largely praised, the PS5 version faces challenges that could hinder the experience for console players, leading to a consensus that, while the game excels in many areas, it still has room for improvement, particularly on console platforms.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II boasts strong replay value, thanks to its roguelite mechanics, diverse characters, and unlockable abilities that keep gameplay fresh. Critics praise the strategic depth and permanent upgrades that encourage experimentation. However, some worry that optimal team compositions and randomness may hinder creativity and long-term engagement, while others find the grind frustrating. Overall, despite some concerns, the game is lauded for its rich, compelling experience that invites players back for more strategic challenges.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

66%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

34%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of Darkest Dungeon II is largely positive, with many critics highlighting the game's roguelite mechanics as a significant factor in its replayability. Critics like IGN and Hardcore Gamer emphasize the variety of hero types, unlockable abilities, and the potential for different outcomes in each run, which keeps the gameplay fresh and engaging. The introduction of permanent bonuses and upgrades, as noted by Digital Chumps and PlayStation Universe, further enhances the incentive for players to dive back into the game. Additionally, the diverse character compositions and strategic depth, as mentioned by TheSixthAxis and Gameblog.fr, provide players with ample opportunities to experiment and refine their strategies over multiple playthroughs. However, several reviewers also express concerns regarding the game's replayability. Gfinity points out that the rapid discovery of optimal team compositions can stifle creativity, making the game feel less replayable compared to its predecessor. Critics like Gamereactor UK and PC Gamer mention issues with the game's progression and randomness, suggesting that improvements are needed to maintain long-term engagement. Furthermore, some players may find the grind and reliance on luck, highlighted by IGN and Twinfinite, to be frustrating, potentially detracting from the overall enjoyment of repeated runs. Despite these criticisms, there is a strong consensus among reviewers that Darkest Dungeon II offers a compelling experience with significant replay value. Many critics, including Hobby Consolas and Game Informer, affirm that the game encourages exploration and experimentation, making it appealing for players who enjoy deep, strategic gameplay. While there are concerns about certain aspects of the game that could hinder replayability, the majority of reviews suggest that the game's complexity, variety, and roguelite elements provide a rich and engaging experience that can keep players coming back for more.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

78%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

21%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding Darkest Dungeon II from critics is largely positive, highlighting several key strengths that contribute to its appeal. Many reviewers praised the game's visual presentation and artistic direction, with titles like IGN Italia emphasizing its "masterful artistic direction." Critics such as KeenGamer and Gameblog.fr noted the engaging gameplay, improved visuals, and haunting soundtrack, which collectively enhance the immersive experience. The game is recognized for its challenging yet rewarding mechanics, with PC Gamer describing it as a "gloomy road trip" with excellent combat. Additionally, Malditos Nerds commended the innovation within the roguelike genre while maintaining the essence of its predecessor, making it a worthwhile experience for both new players and fans of the original. However, the game is not without its drawbacks, as several critics pointed out issues that may hinder the experience for some players. Gamereactor UK criticized the game's reliance on randomness and underwhelming progression, suggesting it may be a tough sell at present. Similarly, GamePro Germany mentioned that while the game offers a solid experience, it does not quite reach the heights of its predecessor. Many reviewers, including GamingTrend and Metro GameCentral, noted that the longer playtime and less intense experience could be drawbacks for players expecting a direct sequel. Furthermore, the steep learning curve and some balance issues were highlighted by critics like Softpedia and Checkpoint Gaming, indicating that the game may not be suitable for all players. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among critics is that Darkest Dungeon II is a commendable sequel that successfully builds upon the foundation laid by its predecessor. Many reviewers, including Game Informer and RPGamer, emphasized the game's depth and engagement, suggesting that it offers a unique and rewarding experience for those willing to embrace its challenges. Critics like PlayStation Universe and PC Invasion acknowledged the significant departures from the original while still appealing to fans of the series. Ultimately, while there are valid concerns regarding certain aspects of the game, the majority of critics agree that Darkest Dungeon II is a well-crafted title that stands out in the roguelike genre, making it a solid recommendation for players seeking a challenging and immersive experience.

TL;DR

Darkest Dungeon II is largely praised by critics for its stunning visuals, engaging gameplay, and haunting soundtrack, delivering a challenging and immersive experience. While it retains the essence of its predecessor and innovates within the roguelike genre, some reviewers point out issues like randomness, underwhelming progression, and a steep learning curve that may deter some players. Overall, it’s seen as a commendable sequel that appeals to both newcomers and fans, making it a solid choice for those ready to tackle its challenges.

MONSTER

Reviews

103 reviews found

The Games Machine

May 8, 2023