Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Amazon

Twitch

MONSTER

Sonic Superstars

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Sonic Superstars
Item: Sonic Superstars
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2023

GenresAdventure, Action, Platformer, Side View Perspective, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableOct 17, 2023

PlatformPC, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch

DeveloperArzest

Overview

Adventure through the mystical Northstar Islands in this all-new take on classic 2D Sonic high-speed action platforming. Play as Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and Amy Rose and harness all-new Emerald powers to move and attack in dynamic new ways. Navigate gorgeous, never-before-seen environments solo or with up to 3 other players and stop Dr. Eggman, Fang, and a mysterious new adversary from converting the islands' giant animals into Badniks before it's too late!

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars nails nostalgia with classic platforming, chaotic charm, and 90s-style visuals but relies on tired tropes, minimal dialogue, and a simplistic plot that prioritizes speed over substance—fans will love its throwback appeal, but it’s a hollow rehash of old ideas.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

28%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

72%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Sonic Superstars is widely praised for its nostalgic return to classic Sonic elements, with critics highlighting its straightforward yet effective narrative structure. Many reviewers, such as Checkpoint Gaming and GameSpot, emphasize the game’s focus on Dr. Eggman’s plans to dominate the Northstar Islands, a familiar premise that resonates with long-time fans. The inclusion of Chaos Emeralds as central plot devices, along with new characters like Fang the Hunter and Trip, adds variety while maintaining the series’ core identity. COGconnected and IGN Spain commend the game’s visual style, noting its hand-drawn art reminiscent of 90s cartoons and lush, exploratory zones that evoke the spirit of classic Sonic games. Additionally, Cultured Vultures and GameSpew appreciate the blend of traditional platforming with new mechanics, such as Chaos Emerald-powered abilities, which enhance exploration and replayability. However, several critics point out the story’s simplicity and lack of narrative depth. IGN criticizes the shift from speed-focused gameplay to platforming, calling it a disappointment, while MeuPlayStation and TheSixthAxis note the minimal dialogue and reliance on nostalgia rather than emotional engagement. The plot is frequently described as “light” or “uncomplicated,” with GamingTrend and Shacknews highlighting its lack of twists or complexity. Some reviewers, like IGN Spain, mention that the three-part story structure, while offering replayability through collectibles, feels repetitive. Additionally, Worth Playing and Movies Games and Tech note that the narrative prioritizes action over character development, with limited emotional appeal despite its charming visuals and familiar characters. Overall, critics agree that Sonic Superstars succeeds as a nostalgic homage to the series’ roots, balancing classic elements with modern touches. While the story is not groundbreaking, it effectively caters to fans seeking a straightforward adventure filled with exploration, Chaos Emeralds, and iconic villains like Dr. Eggman. Hardcore Gamer and Nintendojo praise its accessibility and engaging zones, while Impulsegamer and Noisy Pixel acknowledge the value of new characters in adding freshness. Despite criticisms about simplicity, the consensus leans toward appreciation for the game’s commitment to traditional Sonic gameplay, with many reviewers recognizing it as a worthy addition to the franchise that honors its legacy without overcomplicating its core appeal.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars captures classic 2D Sonic’s thrill with fluid controls and creative levels, but clunky modern twists and repetitive bosses muddy an otherwise nostalgic yet flawed experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

59%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

36%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Sonic Superstars is widely praised for its faithful recreation of classic 2D Sonic mechanics, with many critics highlighting its emphasis on speed, momentum, and platforming precision. Reviews from VG247 and IGN commend the game’s ability to replicate the feel of early Sonic titles, noting the balanced controls, diverse zones, and character-specific abilities that add variety. TechRadar Gaming and Digital Chumps praise the return to "classic Sonic" while introducing modern elements like Chaos Emeralds, which unlock unique powers and encourage exploration. The game’s level design is often lauded for its creativity, with COGconnected and Multiplayer.it noting well-crafted stages that reward experimentation and hidden secrets. Additionally, the inclusion of multiple playable characters—each with distinct abilities—enhances replayability, as highlighted by Hobby Consolas and Atomix, who appreciate the strategic depth it brings to traversal and combat. However, several critics point to significant flaws in the gameplay, particularly around boss battles, level design, and pacing. Vooks and Destructoid criticize the game’s boss encounters as tedious, repetitive, and overly challenging, with some reviewers like GGRecon and Checkpoint Gaming noting that these fights disrupt the otherwise fast-paced flow. Issues with level design are also recurring, with Gameblog.fr and Wccftech pointing to underutilized mechanics, cheap hits, and poorly integrated gimmicks that detract from the experience. The Chaos Emeralds, while adding replayability, are seen as inconsistent in impact—VG247 mentions they “do not feel impactful,” while Pure Xbox and Nintenderos note their occasional clunkiness. Additionally, some mechanics like Tails’ flight or Knuckles’ climbing (as critiqued by TheSixthAxis) are deemed unpolished, further complicating the gameplay. Overall, critics agree that Sonic Superstars successfully captures the essence of classic 2D Sonic while introducing modern twists, but these additions often come with trade-offs. While GamesRadar+ and COGconnected praise its “well-produced” design and variety of modes, the consensus leans toward a mixed experience where the positives—like fluid controls and character diversity—are tempered by frustrations with boss battles, level pacing, and inconsistent mechanics. VG247 and God is a Geek highlight that the game’s ambition to blend old and new is commendable but occasionally falls short, leaving players divided between its nostalgic charm and modern missteps. Despite these critiques, many reviewers acknowledge it as a worthwhile entry for Sonic fans seeking a mix of tradition and innovation.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Sonic Superstars captures classic 2D Sonic’s thrill with fluid controls and creative levels, but clunky modern twists and repetitive bosses muddy an otherwise nostalgic yet flawed experience.

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars dazzles with vibrant 3D visuals and a nostalgic yet modern art style, but inconsistent lighting, clunky camera work, and repetitive zones undermine its polish, leaving a mixed legacy of ambition and missed potential.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

68%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

32%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Sonic Superstars received widespread praise for their vibrant, colorful aesthetics and successful blending of classic 2D Sonic charm with modern 3D elements. Critics like IGN Adria highlighted the game’s "stunning stages" and "decent fidelity," while GameSpew noted the "snazzy 3D visuals" that merge a "classic Sonic feel with a modern look." The art style was frequently lauded for its creativity, with VGC commending its ability to "transition classic Sonic into 3D while maintaining the feel of the Genesis era," and Push Square praising the "vibrant new art style" and "crystal clear image quality." Specific zones like Cyber Station and underwater areas were highlighted as visually distinct, with GameSpot calling them "colorful environments" and Hobby Consolas noting a "fusion of vintage cartoon style and original Sonic design." Many reviewers also appreciated the expressive character animations and detailed environments, such as MeuPlayStation’s "impeccable graphics" and Digital Chumps’ description of levels as "alive and immersive." However, several critics pointed out flaws in the game’s visual consistency and technical execution. GamingBolt criticized the "inconsistent lighting" and "distracting" visuals, while GGRecon noted a mix of "stunning stages" and others that felt "outdated." The camera system was another point of contention, with NintendoWorldReport criticizing its "claustrophobic" design for obscuring obstacles, and Game Informer mentioning "unexpected hazards" that could frustrate players. Some reviewers also highlighted level design issues, such as Noisy Pixel’s observation that the game felt "safe and middle in quality," and TheSixthAxis pointing to "background repetition" and "level design issues." Additionally, TechRadar Gaming noted a lack of "charm compared to sprite-based graphics of the past," while Forbes mentioned a "lack of definition" compared to 2D pixel art. These critiques suggest that while the game’s visuals are ambitious, they occasionally fall short in polish and creativity. Overall, the critical reception leans positive, with most reviewers acknowledging Sonic Superstars as a significant visual upgrade for the franchise. While there were concerns about inconsistency and technical shortcomings, the majority praised its ability to modernize Sonic’s aesthetic without losing its core identity. IGN Japan noted that the game "captures the classical feel of Sonic the Hedgehog," while COGconnected highlighted its "hand-drawn art style reminiscent of 90s cartoons." Even critics with reservations, like Vgames, acknowledged a "mix of visually appealing and outdated graphics" that "refreshes the gameplay experience." The consensus seems to be that Sonic Superstars successfully balances nostalgia with innovation, offering a vibrant, engaging visual experience despite its flaws. As GameSpot concluded, the game’s "excellent visual design" and creative zones make it a standout entry in the series, even if some aspects of its presentation could have been more refined.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars’s soundtrack is a nostalgic love letter to classic Sonic, praised for its energetic retro charm and thematic flair, but criticized for lacking memorable hooks and consistency, splitting opinions between heartfelt homage and underwhelming execution.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

46%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

41%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

13%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Sonic Superstars received largely positive acclaim, with many critics praising its nostalgic charm and energetic compositions. Digital Chumps highlighted the soundtrack as "nearly perfect," noting its alignment with the "nostalgic sounds of older Sonic games," while GameSpot commended it as a "delightful" effort by composers Tee Lopes and Jun Senoue. IGN praised the music for matching each stage’s theme perfectly, calling it "phenomenal," and Impulsegamer celebrated standout tracks like Pinball Carnival and Speed Jungle, which "keep the classic feel of the 16-bit era." Others, such as VGC, lauded the retro-inspired tracks that evoke nostalgia, while GamingTrend noted the soundtrack's "amazing" resemblance to the Genesis' sound chip. These reviews underscore a strong appreciation for the game’s ability to blend modern production with the iconic sonic identity of classic Sonic titles. However, several critics found the music lacking in memorability and consistency. Game Informer called the soundtrack "unremarkable," with only a few standout tracks, while GamingBolt criticized it as "one of the worst in the franchise" due to poor mixing. GGRecon described the music as "grating and irritating," citing repetitive track restarts after deaths, and MeuPlayStation found the soundtrack "forgettable," arguing it hindered concentration rather than enhancing the experience. TechRadar Gaming noted inconsistency, with some tracks falling flat, while NintendoWorldReport criticized it for feeling like an "imitation" of classic Genesis soundtracks. Additionally, Vandal and VG247 pointed to a lack of iconic melodies, with the latter noting that some stages had "wack music." These critiques highlight concerns about the soundtrack’s ability to match the emotional impact of earlier Sonic games. Overall, the reception of Sonic Superstars’s sound design and music is mixed but leans toward appreciation for its nostalgic execution. While many critics, including IGN, GameSpot, and ZTGD, celebrated its energetic, retro-inspired compositions, others like Game Informer and GamingBolt found it underwhelming or inconsistent. The divide often stemmed from expectations tied to the series’ legacy: some praised the soundtrack’s homage to classic Sonic while acknowledging its limitations, whereas others felt it failed to capture the same magic. Despite this, the majority of reviews—particularly from outlets like Digital Chumps, Press Start Australia, and Pure Xbox—agreed that the music effectively complements the gameplay, even if it doesn’t reach the heights of the franchise’s best entries. The consensus ultimately reflects a game that honors its roots but struggles to fully innovate or resonate with all audiences.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars shines on PS5/Switch with silky 60fps and smooth controls, but glitches, co-op issues, and uneven difficulty plague all platforms—yet minor hiccups don’t dim its strong technical performance.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

38%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

57%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Sonic Superstars across platforms received generally positive feedback, with notable strengths on the PlayStation 5 (PS5), Nintendo Switch, and Xbox Series X. On PS5, multiple critics praised its smooth gameplay, including a locked 60fps experience (CGMagazine, Everyeye.it, GamesRadar+, TheGamer) and responsive controls (Forbes, Push Square). The Switch version was highlighted for its "rock-solid" 60fps performance (Nintendojo, Nintendo Life), with Vooks noting "smooth framerates overall," despite some limitations compared to other platforms. Xbox Series X received commendations for stability, with Pure Xbox acknowledging the game as "generally stable" despite occasional design flaws. The PS5 and Switch versions also saw praise for their fluidity, with The Games Machine noting the game was "always fluid and responsive." However, technical issues were reported across all platforms. On PS5, critics like Gameblog.fr highlighted imprecise controls and uninspired level design, while GamingTrend mentioned "performance drops and visual glitches." Hardcore Gamer pointed to collision issues and co-op camera problems in multiplayer, and IGN Adria criticized the Unity engine and "unnecessary battle mode." PlaySense noted occasional framerate drops during boss intros and unsmooth 4-player co-op, while Press Start Australia cited "wonky hit detection" as an infrequent annoyance. On Switch, Vooks mentioned choppy later boss fights, and Nintendo Life reported "occasional crashes in online sessions." Xbox Series X faced criticism for "questionable design choices" and "spikes in difficulty," though these were deemed less impactful than other platform-specific issues. Overall, the consensus among critics was that Sonic Superstars delivered strong technical performance, particularly on PS5 and Switch, with minimal major flaws. While some platforms experienced minor hiccups—such as loading screen jitters (Forbes, Push Square) or co-op instability (Hardcore Gamer)—these were often overshadowed by the game’s smooth 60fps operation and responsive controls. The Xbox Series X version, though less scrutinized, was noted for its stability despite design quirks. Critics like TheGamer emphasized that it was "the best-performing Sonic game at launch in some time," reflecting a broadly positive reception for technical execution across platforms, with minor issues deemed acceptable given the game’s overall polish and fun gameplay.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars blends collectible-driven replayability with clunky multiplayer, offering charm through characters and bonus modes but undermined by a short campaign, repetitive gameplay, and underdeveloped mechanics that fail to match Sonic Mania’s depth.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

33%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

56%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

11%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The critics generally acknowledge that Sonic Superstars offers several elements that contribute to its replay value, particularly through its variety of gameplay mechanics and collectibles. Multiple reviewers highlight the inclusion of Chaos Emeralds, bonus stages, and Time Attack modes as incentives for revisiting levels, with some noting that these features encourage exploration and optimization of paths (e.g., Digital Chumps and LevelUp). The game’s multiple playable characters with unique abilities, such as distinct movement styles or special powers, also add depth, allowing players to approach stages differently (Cultured Vultures, Push Square, Wccftech). Additionally, the post-game content—such as secret characters, alternate routes, and unlockable customization options—extends the experience, with Hobby Consolas emphasizing that the game’s length can double when accounting for all collectibles and modes. The Battle Mode and cooperative play, while criticized in some quarters, are seen as providing variety, particularly for fans of competitive or social gameplay (SpazioGames, Pure Xbox). However, several critics point to significant flaws that undermine the game’s replayability. Issues with multiplayer execution dominate these critiques, with Destructoid and NintendoWorldReport criticizing the online battle mode as poorly designed, tedious, or lacking engagement. The short campaign length (often cited as 5–6 hours) and repetitive gameplay elements are also recurring complaints (Gameblog.fr, Finger Guns). Some reviewers note that boss fights feel overly long and uninspired, while the Emerald Powers—intended to add variety—are deemed underutilized or irrelevant in certain contexts (NintendoWorldReport, Game Informer). Additionally, the slow reward progression for collectibles and the shallow nature of Battle Mode (as highlighted by Game Informer and IGN Japan) create frustration. Even when the game offers potential for replayability, critics like GamingBolt and Vgames argue that these elements feel underdeveloped compared to classics like Sonic Mania, limiting long-term appeal. Overall, the consensus among reviewers is mixed but leans toward a balanced assessment: while Sonic Superstars has clear potential for replay value through its collectibles, character variety, and bonus content, its execution falls short in key areas. Critics like Hobby Consolas and Multiplayer.it note that the game’s post-game modes and exploration incentives can make it feel substantial, but others, such as Destructoid and Vgames, argue that its lack of depth and poor multiplayer design prevent it from being a standout title. The game seems to occupy a middle ground—offering enough content for casual fans but failing to fully capitalize on its ideas. As Wccftech and COGconnected observe, the replay value is there for completionists and enthusiasts of 2D platformers, but the frustrations with gameplay mechanics and multiplayer leave many feeling it could have been better. Ultimately, Sonic Superstars is seen as a game with ambition but uneven execution when it comes to sustaining long-term engagement.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

41%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

56%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall reception of Sonic Superstars highlights its nostalgic charm and modern refinements, with several critics praising its ability to blend classic 2D Sonic gameplay with fresh elements. IGN notes that the game offers a “slightly different flavor” of Sonic, emphasizing new abilities, exploration, and multiple routes, while also applauding its “phenomenal soundtrack” and “enjoyable gameplay elements.” Similarly, The Games Machine praises the game’s level design and gameplay for reaching “new heights,” calling it “true to the classic Sonic gameplay.” CGMagazine commends its “successful redemption of past attempts at modernizing the 2D Sonic experience,” while GamesRadar+ describes it as a “very nice game” that balances nostalgia with modern touches. These positives underscore the game’s appeal to longtime fans, particularly those who appreciate its retro aesthetic and structured platforming. However, several critics point out significant shortcomings that detract from the experience. GamingBolt calls it a “disappointment for long-time Sonic fans,” while NintendoWorldReport criticizes its failure to meet the standards of Sonic’s Genesis era, citing flaws in gameplay, design, and music. Destructoid and TheSixthAxis both note that the game lacks the excitement of past entries, with TheSixthAxis specifically highlighting frustrating boss battles. IGN points out a “lack of speed” and questionable hazard placements, while Push Square criticizes the co-op mode for not integrating well with gameplay. Additionally, Worth Playing mentions it falls short of Sonic Mania, and Multiplayer.it notes that battle modes and customization could be improved. These critiques reflect a recurring theme of unmet expectations despite the game’s technical strengths. Despite mixed reactions, the overall consensus leans toward viewing Sonic Superstars as a solid, if imperfect, entry in the Sonic franchise. While some critics like Multiplayer.it and ZTGD praise its fresh ideas and enjoyable gameplay, others such as GamingBolt and NintendoWorldReport express frustration over its failure to innovate or deliver on promises. The game’s balance of nostalgia and modernization is widely acknowledged, with IGN Spain calling it a “fitting tribute” to Sonic’s legacy and Nintendo Life noting it as a “great entry point for both longtime fans and new players.” Ultimately, while the game has its flaws, many reviewers agree it captures the essence of classic 2D Sonic adventures, even if it doesn’t fully surpass them. The divide in opinions reflects a series that remains beloved but faces high expectations, with Sonic Superstars offering a competent foundation for future iterations.

TL;DR

Sonic Superstars mixes nostalgic 2D joy with modern tweaks but stumbles on sluggish pace, frustrating bosses, and clunky co-op, leaving fans divided between charm and unmet expectations.

MONSTER

Reviews

141 reviews found

GamingTrend

PlayStation 5

Oct 16, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars represents some of the best 2D platforming has to offer. It has constant surprises while still offering a ton of room for mastery. The game is a delight from start to finish and beyond.

Read full review

Movies Games and Tech

Xbox Series X

Nov 7, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars is praised for capturing the brilliance of 90s adventure platform titles with a modern twist, offering challenging and creative gameplay, beautiful visuals, and engaging audio. It is recommended for families or friends looking for a nostalgic yet fresh experience.

Read full review

GameCritics

PlayStation 5

Oct 18, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars is praised for being a proper follow-up and evolution of old school entries, introducing new ideas while crafting one of the finest 2D platformers around. It sets a new blueprint for Sonic's 2D adventures.

Read full review

IGN Spain

PlayStation 5

Oct 13, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars successfully brings back the nostalgia of the classic Sonic games while adding new elements and content. It is a fitting tribute to Sega's iconic blue hedgehog and offers plenty of enjoyment for players, whether they choose to play alone or with friends and family. The game strikes a balance between being fresh and familiar, providing a comfortable and fun experience for fans of the franchise.

Read full review

GAMINGbible

PlayStation 5

Oct 17, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars successfully reinvents the 2D Sonic formula with fresh ideas and mechanics, despite some flaws. Recommended for both new and longtime fans of the series.

The Games Machine

PlayStation 5

Oct 13, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review praises the gameplay and level design of Sonic Superstars, stating that it reaches new heights in this type of game. It also mentions that the game remains true to the classic Sonic gameplay.

Read full review

Hobby Consolas

PlayStation 5

Oct 13, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars is a great game that delivers the sensations that fans of the classic Sonic games wanted, while also offering modern incentives and features. It shines brightly, just like a Chaos Emerald.

Read full review

Digital Chumps

PlayStation 5

Oct 13, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars is described as a fantastic reinvigoration of some of the best facets of the Sonic series. It is praised for appealing to multiple audiences and being reminiscent of the Genesis days while being futureproofed for newer players to enjoy. It is acknowledged that it is not a perfect Sonic game.

Read full review

Ragequit.gr

Nov 14, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars is praised for its 2D platforming gameplay and level design but criticized for tedious boss fights, with hopes for improvement in a potential sequel.

Read full review

LevelUp

PlayStation 5

Oct 15, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sonic Superstars successfully captures the essence of the classic Sonic games while introducing new elements that make it a worthy addition to the franchise.

Read full review