Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One cover image

Links

MONSTER

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Item: Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2021

GenresAdventure, Indie, Action, Third Person Perspective, Open World, Simulation, Puzzle and Logic, Mystery, Single Player

AvailableNov 16, 2021

PlatformPC, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4

DeveloperFrogwares

Overview

In this story-driven detective thriller, a young Sherlock Holmes struggles to prove himself as he navigates an exotic, dangerous island in the Mediterranean to investigate the mystery of his mother’s death. As Sherlock, your legacy is written by the decisions you make in this open world. Deception, violence, and deduction are just a few resources in your arsenal—your mysterious companion and sounding board, Jon, is another. Whether you choose brute force to solve problems or stay one step ahead of your enemies by using your wits to spot vulnerabilities, you decide what each situation demands as you hone your investigative skills. It’s time to confront your past so you can become the legend you’re destined to be.

Elsewhere

7.7

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One boasts a compelling narrative exploring Sherlock's youth and emotional journey, earning praise for character dynamics and a well-structured arc. However, critics criticize its simplistic central mystery, vague storytelling, and disruptive open-world design. While the game captures Sherlock's essence, it ultimately struggles with pacing and depth, leaving players wanting a more engaging experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

70%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

29%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The reviews for Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One highlight several positive aspects of the game's story. Many critics praise the narrative for its exploration of Sherlock's youth and the emotional journey he undertakes to uncover the truth about his mother's death. For instance, PlayStation Universe describes the narrative as engaging, emphasizing the compelling mystery that draws players in. Similarly, Jeuxvideo.com notes that the story improves in the second half, becoming darker and more engaging, culminating in a touching conclusion. Critics like PC Gamer and Cultured Vultures commend the unique character dynamics, particularly the relationship between Sherlock and his imaginary companion, Jon, which adds depth to the narrative. The game is also appreciated for its well-structured narrative arc and the emotional weight it carries, as highlighted by Player 2 and GamingTrend. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the execution of the story. Many reviewers, including GamingBolt and Multiplayer.it, express disappointment with the overall depth and engagement of the central mystery, describing it as simplistic and lacking in substance. Critics like Twinfinite and GameSpot point out that the narrative can feel vague and frustrating, with unresolved plot points leading to a sense of dissatisfaction. Additionally, some reviewers mention that the open-world design disrupts coherent storytelling, as highlighted by BaziCenter, which detracts from the overall narrative experience. The presence of unrelated side cases is also seen as a padding issue that detracts from the main story, as noted by GamingBolt. Overall, the consensus among critics reveals a mixed sentiment towards the story of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. While many appreciate the emotional depth and character development, particularly in exploring Sherlock's past and motivations, there are significant concerns about the narrative's execution and coherence. Critics like Screen Rant and NME recognize the potential of the story but suggest that it falls short in delivering a consistently engaging experience. The game successfully captures the essence of Sherlock Holmes' character and his early detective work, yet it struggles with pacing and depth, leading to a narrative that, while promising, ultimately leaves some players wanting more.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One impresses with its engaging investigative gameplay and open-world exploration, earning praise for its unique mechanics like the Mind Palace and diverse side quests. However, critics slam its frustrating combat and repetitive world design, leading to a mixed reception. While the core detective elements shine, execution flaws hold it back, highlighting a need for improvement in future installments.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

26%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

73%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One has garnered a range of positive feedback from critics, particularly regarding its engaging investigative mechanics and the freedom it offers players. Reviewers like Wccftech and Worth Playing highlight the game’s solid detective work, allowing players to gather clues, interact with NPCs, and utilize Sherlock's unique skills, such as the Mind Palace mechanic. The open-world design is praised for enabling exploration and offering a variety of side quests, which can enhance the overall experience, as noted by GameMAG and God is a Geek. Critics also appreciate the introduction of new gameplay elements, such as disguises and a multi-path system that encourages different approaches to solving cases, as mentioned by TheXboxHub and MondoXbox. However, the gameplay is not without its flaws, as many critics point out significant shortcomings, particularly in combat mechanics and the open-world design. Twinfinite and Gamer.no criticize the combat system as poorly executed and frustrating, detracting from the core detective experience. Additionally, the open-world structure is seen by some, like PlayStation Universe and BaziCenter, as unnecessary, leading to feelings of emptiness and repetitiveness in side activities. Critics such as GamingBolt and Screen Rant echo these sentiments, noting that while the investigative elements are engaging, they can become stale over time due to a lack of variety and clumsy mechanics. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One successfully captures the essence of detective work and offers a fresh take on the series, it struggles with execution in certain areas, particularly combat and open-world navigation. Many reviewers, including IGN Italia and Gaming Age, emphasize that the game feels like a mixed bag, where the core investigative mechanics shine but are often overshadowed by poorly implemented combat and repetitive side quests. The game is recognized for its ambition and potential, yet it leaves room for improvement in future iterations, suggesting that a more streamlined experience could enhance the detective fantasy that fans expect from a Sherlock Holmes title.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One dazzles with its vibrant visuals and immersive Mediterranean setting, earning praise for its architectural beauty and artistic direction. However, technical flaws like texture pop-in, frame rate drops, and character glitches tarnish the experience, with some critics deeming the graphics outdated. While the game shows promise, it ultimately falls short of modern standards, highlighting a need for better optimization in future installments.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

31%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

63%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One have garnered a mix of praise from various critics, particularly for the game's vibrant and detailed representation of the fictional Mediterranean island of Cordona. Many reviewers, such as God is a Geek and PlaySense, highlight the game's beautiful settings and impressive architecture, which contribute to a rich and immersive atmosphere. Critics like Jeuxvideo.com and Adventure Gamers commend the game's artistic direction, noting that the visuals, including well-executed cutscenes and detailed character models, enhance the overall experience. The lively environment, as described by Wccftech and GamingTrend, adds to the game's appeal, with some reviewers appreciating the day-night cycle that brings an additional layer of dynamism to the setting. However, despite these positive aspects, a significant number of critics have pointed out various technical issues that detract from the game's visual experience. Reviewers such as Pure Xbox and Push Square emphasize problems like texture pop-in, frame rate drops, and character glitches, which undermine the overall polish expected from a modern title. Critics like BaziCenter and Gaming Age describe the graphics as outdated and reminiscent of earlier generations, indicating a lack of refinement in character models and animations. Additionally, the repetitive nature of NPC dialogue and the perceived emptiness of the open world, as noted by Gamer.no and TrueAchievements, further detracts from the immersive experience that the visuals aim to create. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One features visually appealing environments and a charming aesthetic, it is marred by technical shortcomings that hinder the experience. Many reviewers acknowledge the game's artistic achievements, with SpazioGames and Vandal noting improvements over previous titles, yet they also highlight the need for better optimization and polish. The mixed reception indicates that while the game has potential in its visual design, it ultimately falls short of the standards set by higher-budget productions, leaving critics like GamingBolt and Eurogamer Italy to call for a more refined approach in future installments.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One boasts an immersive sound design and atmospheric music, earning praise for enhancing the game's late 19th-century vibe and showcasing strong voice performances, particularly from Alex Jordan. However, critics highlight issues like clumsy voice acting, repetitive dialogue, and synchronization problems, leading to a mixed reception. While the audio contributes significantly to the gameplay, its inconsistencies prevent it from reaching a uniformly high standard.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

55%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

34%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One have garnered a mix of positive feedback from various critics, particularly regarding the immersive atmosphere they create. Reviewers from IGN France and Jeuxvideo.com praised the musical score for effectively enhancing the game's ambiance, with the latter noting that the sound design complements the immersive experience. In addition, Gamer.no and Vandal highlighted strong voice performances, especially from Alex Jordan, which contribute charm and depth to the characters. Critics like TheXboxHub and Movies Games and Tech also commended the soundtrack for its dynamic and era-specific qualities, suggesting that it successfully transports players to the late 19th century. Overall, there is a consensus that the sound design and music play a significant role in building the game's atmosphere. However, the reviews also reveal notable criticisms regarding the sound design and music, particularly concerning the quality of voice acting and the repetitiveness of dialogue. Critics from BaziCenter and Gamer.no pointed out issues with clumsy voice performances and dull, repetitive dialogue, which detracts from the immersive experience expected in a detective game. Cultured Vultures described the music as grating during combat, while Worth Playing noted that the voice-overs often range from mediocre to bad, especially for minor characters. Additionally, synchronization issues were mentioned by GamingBolt and PlaySense, indicating that while some performances shine, inconsistencies exist that affect the overall audio experience. In conclusion, the overall sentiment among critics regarding the sound design and music of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is a blend of appreciation and critique. While many reviewers, including WellPlayed and XboxAddict, recognize the high-quality voice acting and effective atmospheric music, there are persistent concerns about the repetitiveness of dialogue and the inconsistency of voice performances. The game succeeds in creating an immersive environment, as noted by Adventure Gamers and Generación Xbox, but it also faces challenges that prevent it from achieving a uniformly high standard in audio quality. This duality suggests that while the sound design and music contribute positively to the gameplay experience, they are not without their flaws, leading to a mixed reception overall.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Voice acting in "Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One" is a mixed bag. Critics rave about Alex Jordan's compelling portrayal of young Sherlock and the engaging banter with his imaginary friend, Jon, which adds charm to the narrative. However, repetitiveness in dialogue from minor characters and clumsy voice acting detract from the overall immersion. While the main performances shine, inconsistencies in quality across the cast leave the experience feeling uneven.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

63%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

27%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in "Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One" has garnered a generally positive reception from critics, particularly in the portrayal of the main characters. Reviewers from GamingBolt and WellPlayed praised the quality of the performances, highlighting how the voice acting enhances character interactions and the narrative experience. Alex Jordan's portrayal of young Sherlock Holmes has received significant acclaim, with critics such as GameGrin and AusGamers emphasizing the emotional depth he brings to the character. The dynamic between Sherlock and his imaginary friend Jon is frequently noted as a strong point, with critics from Shacknews and Cultured Vultures pointing out how their banter adds charm and depth to the game. However, the voice acting is not without its criticisms. Several reviewers, including BaziCenter and Worth Playing, pointed out issues with repetitiveness in the dialogue, particularly among minor characters, which detracts from the immersion in a narrative-driven game. Gamer.no described the voice acting as clumsy, noting stiff animations and artificial expressions that further undermine the experience. This sentiment is echoed by critics like TrueGaming, who mentioned that some characters provided unhelpful commentary during investigations, leading to a lack of engagement. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates a mixed reception regarding the voice acting in "Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One." While many praise the performances of the main characters and the engaging dynamics between them, there are notable concerns about the repetitiveness of lines and the quality of minor roles. Critics such as COGconnected and Vandal highlight the disparity in voice acting quality, suggesting that while the lead performances are strong, the overall execution suffers from inconsistencies. Therefore, while the game succeeds in delivering compelling character interactions, it falls short in maintaining a uniformly high standard across the entire voice cast.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One struggles on PS5 with severe technical flaws like unstable frame rates and visual glitches, overshadowing its few positives. Critics agree these issues hinder gameplay significantly. The PC version performs better with stable frame rates, while the Xbox Series X falls in between. Overall, the game shows potential but suffers from serious technical shortcomings across platforms.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

56%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

36%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In analyzing the technical performance of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One across different gaming platforms, it's evident that the PS5 version garners a mix of opinions, with some critics acknowledging certain positives. For instance, PlaySense notes that the game is "surprisingly technically advanced for its budget," highlighting excellent load times on the PS5. Additionally, SpazioGames mentions that there are noticeable improvements over previous titles, suggesting that the game has made strides in some technical aspects despite its issues. Furthermore, PlayStation Country mentions that while there are technical hiccups, the game shows promise in its overall execution. However, the negatives for the PS5 version heavily overshadow the positives. A significant number of critics, including BaziCenter and Finger Guns, report serious technical issues, such as unstable frame rates and noticeable frame drops, particularly in populated areas. Cultured Vultures points out shadow and texture pop-in issues that detract from visual quality, while GameSpot and Push Square echo concerns regarding stuttering frame rates and visual glitches. The consensus among critics like Gamer.no and WellPlayed emphasizes that these technical shortcomings significantly hinder the overall gameplay experience, making it frustrating for players. On the other hand, the PC version of the game presents a more favorable picture, with several critics like Wccftech and The Games Machine noting solid performance, including stable frame rates and high resolutions on modern hardware. However, some reviews, such as those from IGN Italia and TrueGaming, highlight that technical issues still persist, particularly with optimization and glitches. The Xbox Series X version reflects a similar sentiment, with critics like AusGamers and Hey Poor Player expressing concerns about significant technical limitations and frame rate issues. Overall, while the PS5 version seems to struggle with numerous technical flaws, the PC version appears to perform better, with the Xbox Series X landing somewhere in between. The general consensus across all platforms suggests that while the game has potential, its technical performance leaves much to be desired, impacting the overall player experience.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One has strong replay potential thanks to its rich world and over 30 side cases, with multiple dialogue paths enhancing the experience. However, critics warn of a lack of engaging content in the open world, repetitive combat, and minimal impact from player choices, which could dampen long-term appeal. While the game offers enticing side activities, its linear structure may not provide enough variety for multiple playthroughs.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

26%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

67%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions regarding the replay value of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One reveal several positive aspects that critics appreciate. Many reviewers highlight the game's rich world and the abundance of side cases and mysteries that players can engage with. For instance, Finger Guns notes the wealth of side quests and optional activities that enhance the game's content, while PC Gamer emphasizes the significant replay value stemming from over 30 side cases that encourage players to explore and solve additional mysteries. Furthermore, Generación Xbox mentions the high replayability due to multiple dialogue options and potential different outcomes in investigations, which can entice players to revisit the game to experience various narrative paths. However, there are notable criticisms that detract from the game's overall replay value. Critics such as BaziCenter and IGN point out that the open world lacks engaging content and interesting diversions, which diminishes the incentive for players to return after completing the main story. Additionally, GamingBolt and SpazioGames echo concerns about the repetitive nature of combat and the limited impact of player choices on the narrative, which could lead to a sense of monotony upon replaying. The consensus among several reviewers, including Gamer.no and PC Invasion, suggests that while there are numerous side activities, the overall structure of the game may feel linear and repetitive, limiting its long-term appeal. Overall, the critics present a mixed sentiment regarding the replay value of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. While many acknowledge the game's potential for replayability through its side quests and investigative gameplay, several also caution that the lack of meaningful consequences from player choices and the repetitive nature of some gameplay elements may deter players from revisiting it extensively. Critics like GameSpot and WellPlayed highlight the engaging side cases, but the overarching sentiment is that the game may not offer enough variety and depth to encourage multiple playthroughs, particularly for those seeking a more dynamic experience.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

49%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

In analyzing the overall sentiment surrounding Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, it is clear that many critics appreciate the game for its compelling narrative and engaging gameplay. Reviewers from outlets like Adventure Gamers and Wccftech highlight the game’s intriguing story and strong character development, suggesting that it offers a captivating detective experience. Additionally, Video Chums describes it as a "masterpiece of a detective game," emphasizing the enjoyment derived from its open-world adventure. Critics also note the ambitious scope of the game, with PC Gamer mentioning its balance of serious themes with playful elements, and Cultured Vultures praising it as Frogwares' best game to date. The relationship between Sherlock and Jon, as noted by WellPlayed, is also highlighted as a significant aspect of the narrative. However, while the game has its strengths, many critics point out a range of technical issues and gameplay shortcomings that detract from the overall experience. Critics like Twinfinite and Worth Playing express frustration with the unnecessary open-world elements and vague gameplay prompts, which can lead to a disjointed investigative experience. Performance issues are a common theme, with Screen Rant and IGN noting frustrating puzzles and technical problems that hinder immersion. Additionally, GamingBolt and BaziCenter emphasize that the game suffers from pacing problems and a lack of depth in certain areas, which may leave players feeling underwhelmed. The repetitive investigation mechanics and empty open-world design are also mentioned by several critics, including Jeuxvideo.com. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is a mixed bag that, while offering a solid narrative and engaging gameplay, is marred by technical flaws and design missteps. Critics like GameSpot and GamingTrend acknowledge the game’s potential and compelling investigative elements, yet they also recognize the significant issues that prevent it from being a definitive entry in the series. Many reviewers, such as Gaming Nexus and Everyeye.it, suggest that despite its flaws, the game remains enjoyable for fans of the franchise. Ultimately, while it may not reach the heights of previous titles, Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One presents a worthwhile experience for those willing to overlook its shortcomings.

TL;DR

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One impresses with its engaging narrative and character development, earning praise as a captivating detective experience. However, technical issues, vague gameplay prompts, and pacing problems hinder its potential, leading many critics to view it as a mixed bag. While it may not eclipse previous titles, fans of the franchise may still find enjoyment by overlooking its flaws.

MONSTER

Reviews

115 reviews found

100

XBLA Fans

Xbox Series X

Feb 23, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

A highly recommended game with a lot of content and a lower price point compared to AAA titles.

100

GameGrin

Nov 16, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review considers Sherlock Holmes Chapter One as one of the reviewer's favorite games of all time, praising its graphics, gameplay mechanics, and emotional story. The reviewer highly recommends the game to anyone with even a mild interest in it.

Read full review

Video Chums

PlayStation 5

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is a masterpiece of a detective game that delivers a thoroughly enjoyable open-world adventure.

Read full review

Player 2

PlayStation 5

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Overall, the game is considered the best in the series so far, with a satisfying story and gameplay, despite some frustrating mechanics.

Read full review

Ragequit.gr

Nov 16, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is considered a really good, perhaps even excellent game, appreciated for its writing, gameplay, and visual design.

Read full review

XboxAddict

Xbox Series X

Nov 16, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Overall, the game is well-received with a score of 8.8/10, praised for its story, gameplay, visuals, and sound design.

Read full review

Generación Xbox

Xbox Series X

Dec 6, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is a commendable entry in the franchise, showcasing a youthful version of the detective with a strong narrative, impressive visuals, and engaging gameplay.

Read full review

Xbox Tavern

Xbox Series X

Dec 3, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is a fascinating and fantastic game for fans of Sherlock Holmes and investigative adventures. It has charm, wit, excitement, and chilling crimes. The inclusion of sensitive content raises questions about the developer's intentions, but overall, it is a thoroughly enjoyable game.

Read full review

CGMagazine

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The reviewer considers Sherlock Holmes Chapter One to be their favorite game of the year, praising its charm, elegance, and respect for Doyle's original character.

Wccftech

Nov 15, 2021

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One is a significant step forward for the series, featuring a great story, charming characters, and engaging gameplay mechanics. It is highly recommended for fans of the series and adventure games.

Read full review