Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

MONSTER

Return to Monkey Island

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Return to Monkey Island
Item: Return to Monkey Island
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2022

GenresAdventure, Comedy, Side View Perspective, Puzzle and Logic, Point & Click, Casual, Single Player

AvailableSep 19, 2022

PlatformNintendo Switch, PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X

DeveloperTerrible Toybox

Overview

Return to Monkey Island, the long-awaited follow-up to the legendary Secret of Monkey Island and Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge by Ron Gilbert's Terrible Toybox in collaboration with Devolver Digital and Lucasfilm Games, coming 2022.

Elsewhere

8.2

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Return to Monkey Island has received mostly positive reviews for its nostalgic charm, clever writing, and successful continuation of Guybrush Threepwood's adventures, appealing to both veterans and newcomers. Critics praise its whimsical humor and engaging storytelling, but some express concerns about narrative coherence and depth, with mixed reactions to the ending. Overall, it's a fitting tribute to the series that balances humor and adventure, though not without its flaws.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

89%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

10%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Return to Monkey Island has garnered a largely positive reception from critics, many of whom appreciate its nostalgic elements and clever writing. Reviewers like Guardian and Game Informer highlight the whimsical and self-referential humor that permeates the narrative, effectively capturing the essence of the original games while introducing new themes and characters. Critics such as Stevivor and GameMAG emphasize the satisfying continuation of Guybrush Threepwood's adventures, noting how the game successfully ties up loose ends from the previous installments. The blend of familiar locales, beloved characters, and engaging storytelling resonates well with long-time fans, as seen in reviews from XboxAddict and Everyeye.it, who commend the game for its ability to appeal to both veterans and newcomers alike. However, not all reviews are glowing, as some critics express concerns regarding the story's coherence and depth. Riot Pixels and Destructoid point out that the narrative can feel inconsequential and overly reliant on callbacks to previous games, which may alienate new players. The ending has also drawn mixed reactions, with IGN Italia and GameMAG mentioning that it might leave some players divided or disappointed. Additionally, GameOver.gr notes narrative gaps that detract from the overall experience, suggesting that while the humor and nostalgia are present, the storytelling may not fully satisfy all audiences. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Return to Monkey Island successfully revives the charm of the series while providing a nostalgic yet fresh narrative experience. While some reviewers raise valid concerns about coherence and depth, the majority, including Digital Chumps and Wccftech, celebrate the game's ability to blend humor, adventure, and character development. The game is seen as a fitting tribute to the legacy of Monkey Island, offering a satisfying continuation of Guybrush's journey that resonates with both long-time fans and new players alike.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Return to Monkey Island impresses with its blend of classic point-and-click mechanics and modern enhancements, earning praise for engaging puzzles and an intuitive interface. Critics commend its accessibility for new and returning players, with adjustable difficulty settings. However, some point to simplified puzzles and repetitive elements that may disappoint longtime fans seeking a greater challenge. Overall, the game successfully modernizes the franchise while maintaining its charm, appealing to both casual gamers and series enthusiasts. It's a worthy continuation of the beloved series, balancing nostalgia with contemporary gaming.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

77%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

23%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Return to Monkey Island has received a largely positive reception from critics, who praise its blend of classic point-and-click mechanics with modern enhancements. Many reviewers, such as PC Games and Game Informer, highlight the engaging puzzles that are creatively intertwined with the narrative, making the gameplay feel cohesive and rewarding. The intuitive interface and the inclusion of a hint system have been commended by several critics, including GameGrin and GamesHub, as they enhance accessibility for both newcomers and veterans of the series. Additionally, the option to choose between different difficulty modes, as noted by PlayStation Universe and Hobby Consolas, allows players to tailor their experience according to their skill levels, ensuring that the game caters to a broad audience. Despite the overall praise, some critics have pointed out notable shortcomings in the gameplay. Riot Pixels and SpazioGames express concerns about the simplification of puzzles, suggesting that this may detract from the challenge and exploration that fans expect from a Monkey Island title. Critics like GameMAG mention that while a harder mode is available, the general trend toward easier puzzles could disappoint those seeking a more traditional experience. Furthermore, Metro GameCentral notes that some puzzle types can feel repetitive, which could lead to a sense of monotony for players who prefer more variety in their challenges. The overall consensus among critics is that Return to Monkey Island successfully modernizes the classic adventure game formula while maintaining its charm and humor. While there are criticisms regarding the simplification of gameplay and puzzle design, the majority of reviews reflect a positive sentiment, emphasizing the game's accessibility, engaging puzzles, and thoughtful quality-of-life improvements. Critics such as Destructoid and Worth Playing highlight the balance between challenge and enjoyment, suggesting that the game strikes a commendable equilibrium that appeals to both casual players and series enthusiasts. Ultimately, Return to Monkey Island is seen as a worthy continuation of the beloved franchise, successfully merging nostalgia with modern gaming sensibilities.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Return to Monkey Island sparks a mixed bag of reactions regarding its graphics. Many praise the vibrant, modern art style for capturing the series' whimsy, while others criticize it as unattractive and a departure from classic pixel art. Critics are divided; some say the new visuals enhance the experience, while loyal fans lament the loss of the original charm. Overall, it’s a beautiful but contentious evolution that may alienate long-time supporters.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

42%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The overall sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of Return to Monkey Island is largely positive, with many critics praising the game's vibrant and colorful art style. Reviewers like GamingTrend and PlayStation Universe highlight the charm and modernity of the visuals, noting that the art direction effectively captures the whimsical nature of the series. The game is described as having a "gorgeous, vibrant, and eye-popping aesthetic" (GamingBolt), with detailed environments that enhance immersion and storytelling. Critics such as SpazioGames and The Independent commend the unique artistic choices, including the cubist and abstract styles that modernize the franchise while respecting its roots. The lively character designs and animated cutscenes contribute to a visually appealing experience that resonates well with both new and returning players. However, not all reviews are as favorable, as several critics express dissatisfaction with the new art style. Riot Pixels criticizes the visuals for being unattractive and not meeting modern standards, while Impulsegamer specifically mentions a dislike for the cubist approach, finding character designs less appealing. Critics like God is a Geek and PC Games note that the departure from the classic pixel art style has sparked controversy, with some fans feeling that the new graphics do not live up to the charm of previous installments. The mixed reactions are echoed by GAMES.CH, who reports negative feedback on the style and quality, indicating that the artistic direction may not appeal to everyone. Overall, the consensus among critics reveals a division in opinion regarding the graphics and visual design of Return to Monkey Island. While many appreciate the bold and distinct new art style, with reviewers like VG247 and Metro GameCentral noting that it grows on players over time, others remain critical of the departure from the series' legacy. The game successfully modernizes its visual identity, as highlighted by critics like Game Informer and Digital Chumps, but the contrasting reactions suggest that while the new aesthetic resonates with a significant portion of the audience, it may alienate long-time fans who preferred the original pixelated charm.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Return to Monkey Island shines with its nostalgia-evoking sound design and music, praised for its Caribbean score and the return of original composers, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere. Critics laud the voice acting, especially Dominic Armato as Guybrush, adding depth. However, some note a lack of standout new compositions, feeling the reliance on familiar melodies overshadows innovation. Overall, the audio elements are celebrated for enriching the game's charm, balancing nostalgia with fresh appeal.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

90%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

10%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Return to Monkey Island have garnered significant praise from a majority of critics, highlighting the game's ability to evoke nostalgia while maintaining a fresh and engaging atmosphere. Critics such as IGN and NME noted the delightful Caribbean score, which successfully transports players back to the charm of the original games. The return of original composers, as mentioned by GamingBolt and Jeuxvideo.com, has been particularly celebrated, with many reviewers appreciating how the reworked soundtrack captures the essence of the series while introducing modern elements. The use of instruments like flutes and marimbas, as pointed out by GamesHub, contributes to a joyful and whimsical ambiance, enhancing the overall experience of the game. The voice acting, especially by Dominic Armato reprising his role as Guybrush Threepwood, has also been highlighted by critics like Destructoid and Ragequit.gr, adding authenticity and depth to the characters. Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some critics expressed reservations regarding the originality of the music. Riot Pixels pointed out that while the music is pleasant, it tends to be memorable primarily when it features familiar old melodies, suggesting a lack of impactful new compositions. Similarly, GameOver.gr noted that while the remixes of classic themes are well-executed, there are no standout new tracks that leave a lasting impression. New Game Network echoed this sentiment, mentioning that the humor and musical references to previous games sometimes weigh down the experience, indicating a reliance on nostalgia rather than innovation. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the sound design and music of Return to Monkey Island are strong components of the game, effectively enhancing the nostalgic experience while still appealing to new players. The majority of reviews reflect a commendation for the quality of the music and voice acting, with critics like XboxEra and WellPlayed emphasizing how the audio elements contribute significantly to the game's charm and atmosphere. While there are some critiques regarding the originality of the compositions, the general sentiment remains positive, with many reviewers celebrating the successful blend of classic and new elements that make the game a delightful return to the beloved franchise.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Return to Monkey Island" boasts acclaimed voice acting, especially Dominic Armato's standout performance as Guybrush Threepwood, praised for its humor and charm. Critics highlight the engaging character chemistry and nostalgic return of original voice actors. However, some note a lack of energy in performances and the absence of localized voice options. Despite minor critiques, the overall sentiment is that the voice work significantly enhances the game, solidifying its success.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

91%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in "Return to Monkey Island" has received widespread acclaim from critics, with many praising the performances of the returning cast, particularly Dominic Armato as Guybrush Threepwood. Critics like Stevivor and Hardcore Gamer highlighted Armato's portrayal as spot-on, capturing the character's essence and humor. The performances have been described as "top-notch" (GameSpot) and "fantastic" (WellPlayed), contributing significantly to the game's charm and overall experience. The chemistry between characters, especially noted by critics like GAMINGbible, enhances the narrative and humor, making the interactions feel engaging and lively. The nostalgic element of having original voice actors return was also emphasized by several reviewers, including Vandal and Atomix, who noted that this aspect adds depth and authenticity to the game. Despite the overall positive reception, some critics pointed out certain drawbacks. Riot Pixels mentioned that while the returning actors are appreciated, their performances sometimes lack energy, giving a sense of tiredness to the characters. Additionally, the absence of localized voice acting options, such as German voiceovers, was noted as a downside by PC Games and others. While the dialogue is generally well-received, New Game Network observed that it can be verbose, which might not appeal to all players, though it can be skipped for those who read quickly. These critiques suggest that while the voice acting is strong, there are areas that could benefit from improvement. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the voice acting in "Return to Monkey Island" is a significant strength of the game, with the majority expressing that it enhances the experience. Critics like XboxEra and IGN emphasized the quality of performances, with Armato's return being a focal point of praise. The voice acting effectively brings the characters to life, contributing to the humor and charm that fans of the series have come to love. Despite some minor criticisms regarding energy levels and localization, the general sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, affirming that the voice work plays a crucial role in the game's success.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Return to Monkey Island shines with smooth, polished performance across all platforms, earning high praise for its bug-free experience and intuitive controls. Critics highlight solid 60fps on Xbox Series X and fast loading on PC, while Switch players report a generally smooth experience despite minor frame drops. Some minor issues exist, like item-clicking problems on Xbox and clunky inventory on PC, but these don't overshadow the overall positive reception. This game is a strong, well-optimized entry for both new and longtime fans.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

73%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

27%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Return to Monkey Island has received overwhelmingly positive feedback across various platforms. On the PS5, critics like PSX Brasil and Softpedia praised the game's smooth operation and polished experience, highlighting the absence of bugs or crashes. Push Square also noted the intuitive controls, which contribute to a comfortable gaming experience. On the Xbox Series X, GamersRD reported a stable 60fps performance, while XboxEra emphasized the game's stability on PC, mentioning zero bugs and fast loading times. Similarly, Nintendo Switch players enjoyed a generally smooth experience, with GamePro Germany and Nintenderos confirming the game’s polished technical aspects and absence of significant issues, even in handheld mode. However, some minor technical issues were reported across platforms. On the Xbox Series X, Xbox Tavern mentioned a minor problem with clicking on items in tight spaces, which, while not detrimental, indicates room for improvement. On the Nintendo Switch, Vgames noted noticeable frame drops despite the game running at 60fps, which could affect the experience for some players. Additionally, on PC, while the overall performance was solid, critics like Games.cz pointed out issues with key mapping, and PC Gamer mentioned clunky inventory interactions that could frustrate some users. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the technical performance of Return to Monkey Island is very good across all platforms, with most reviewers highlighting the smooth gameplay and lack of significant technical issues. The game appears to be well-optimized, providing a polished experience that caters to both new players and long-time fans of the series. Critics like IGN Italia and Stevivor reinforced this sentiment by noting the game's smooth operation even on older hardware and the effective user interface. While there are minor issues reported, they do not significantly detract from the overall enjoyment of the game, solidifying Return to Monkey Island as a commendable entry in the franchise.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Return to Monkey Island" boasts replay value with multiple endings, collectibles, and a hint system that both veterans and newcomers can enjoy. Critics praise its nostalgic charm but warn some may feel dissatisfied due to repetitive puzzles and a reliance on series knowledge, potentially alienating newcomers. Overall, it’s a nostalgic hit for fans but may fall short for those unfamiliar with the franchise.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

28%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

68%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of various critics regarding the replay value of "Return to Monkey Island" present a range of positive aspects that highlight the game's appeal, particularly for fans of the series. Many reviewers, such as Atomix and Nintenduo, note that the game offers multiple endings, varying difficulty modes, and collectibles, which can enhance the replay experience. Critics like Shindig and Player 2 emphasize that the inclusion of a hint system and different puzzle solutions encourages players to revisit the game to explore alternative pathways. Additionally, the nostalgic elements and character interactions are praised for providing an engaging experience, with some reviewers, including Nintendo Life and Ragequit.gr, suggesting that the game effectively caters to both veterans and newcomers, making it enjoyable for a broader audience. Conversely, several critics express concerns regarding the game's replay value, indicating that it may be limited for certain players. GameMAG and Wccftech point out that the lack of new elements and the reliance on nostalgia could leave some players feeling unsatisfied after completing the game. Critics like Metro GameCentral and SomosXbox mention that repeated puzzle templates and a sense of repetition might deter players from wanting to experience the game again. Furthermore, GameSpot and SpazioGames highlight that the game's heavy reliance on series knowledge can alienate newcomers, which could further diminish replayability for those unfamiliar with the franchise. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while "Return to Monkey Island" offers some replay value through its various features, the enjoyment largely depends on the player's familiarity with the series. While many reviewers, including GamingTrend and Xbox Achievements, acknowledge the game’s potential for multiple playthroughs due to its achievements and difficulty settings, others caution that the experience may not be as rewarding for those who are not well-versed in the series' lore. The game appears to be a love letter to longtime fans, but its appeal may wane for newcomers, leading to a mixed sentiment regarding its overall replay value.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

95%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding "Return to Monkey Island" is predominantly positive, with many critics praising its nostalgic value and successful integration of modern gameplay elements. Critics like Softpedia and GamesHub highlight the game's charm and engaging characters, while others, such as TheGamer and Hardcore Gamer, commend its ability to blend new ideas with the beloved essence of the original series. The game is described as a delightful adventure, with well-crafted puzzles and humor that resonate with both longtime fans and newcomers. The visuals and voice acting have also received accolades, contributing to an immersive experience that many reviewers found enjoyable and memorable. However, not all reviews are favorable, and some critics express disappointment with certain aspects of the game. Riot Pixels and GameMAG, for instance, describe the experience as lacking innovation and failing to meet the high expectations set by its predecessors. Critics like Checkpoint Gaming and SpazioGames note that while the game is fun, it may not challenge seasoned players enough, and some puzzles lack standout quality. Additionally, there are mentions of pacing issues and a divisive ending that could leave some players feeling unsatisfied, as indicated by critics like Launcher and Checkpoint Gaming. Overall, the consensus among critics leans heavily towards a positive reception for "Return to Monkey Island." While a few reviewers express concerns about innovation and challenge, the majority celebrate the game as a worthy continuation of the franchise that successfully captures the spirit of its roots. Critics such as Metro GameCentral and Game Informer emphasize the game's humor and nostalgic charm, making it a must-play for fans of the series. Ultimately, the game is viewed as a heartfelt tribute to the original titles, with many calling it a significant and enjoyable addition to the point-and-click adventure genre.

TL;DR

TL;DR: "Return to Monkey Island" is largely praised for its nostalgic charm, engaging characters, and modern gameplay integration, making it a delightful adventure for both fans and newcomers. Critics laud its humor, visuals, and voice acting, although some express disappointment over a lack of innovation and challenge. While a few reviews mention pacing issues and a divisive ending, the overall consensus is positive, celebrating it as a worthy continuation of the beloved franchise.

MONSTER

Reviews

143 reviews found

100

Ragequit.gr

Oct 7, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Return to Monkey Island is a nostalgic and self-aware adventure that pays homage to the series' legacy while offering accessible gameplay and polished presentation, making it a must-play for fans and newcomers alike.

Read full review

100

Player 2

Sep 19, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Return to Monkey Island is praised as an impeccable return to the franchise, capturing the essence of the series while providing closure and contentment to fans. It is described as perfect and everything it could have been, living up to high expectations.

Read full review

100

Adventure Gamers

Oct 4, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Return to Monkey Island is a must-play for fans of the series and newcomers alike, offering a delightful adventure experience with top-notch storytelling, gameplay, graphics, and sound design.

Read full review

100

NME

Sep 20, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

A masterclass bursting with metatextual mischief, delivering heart, laughter, and adventure.

Read full review

100

GameGrin

Dec 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is described as a triumph that lives up to expectations and is highly recommended.

Read full review

100

GamesHub

Sep 19, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Return to Monkey Island is a comforting and charming game that stays true to its identity, offering great characters and amusingly esoteric puzzles. The return of Gilbert and Grossman makes it an attraction worth exploring.

Read full review

Impulsegamer

Oct 19, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The reviewer recommends the game to fans of the original game/s, describing it as a nostalgic joy that will warm the heart.

Read full review

XboxAddict

Xbox Series X

Jan 3, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is highly praised with an overall score of 9.5/10, indicating a strong recommendation for both fans and newcomers.

Read full review

The Games Machine

Sep 19, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The reviewer highly praises the game, stating it successfully brings back the essence of the original series while providing a fresh experience.

Read full review

PSX Brasil

PlayStation 5

Nov 22, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Return to Monkey Island successfully blends nostalgia with modern gameplay elements, creating a cohesive and relevant experience that honors the franchise's legacy while elevating it.

Read full review