Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Amazon

Twitch

MONSTER

Pokemon Scarlet

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Pokemon Scarlet
Item: Pokemon Scarlet
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2022

GenresFantasy, Adventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, Open World, RPG, Anime and JRPG, Strategy, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableNov 18, 2022

PlatformNintendo Switch

DeveloperGame Freak

Overview

The Pokémon Scarlet and Pokémon Violet games, the newest chapters in the Pokémon series, are coming to Nintendo Switch later this year. With these new titles, the Pokémon series takes a new evolutionary step, allowing you to explore freely in a richly expressed open world. Various towns blend seamlessly into the wilderness with no borders. You’ll be able to see the Pokémon of this region in the skies, in the seas, in the forests, on the streets—all over! You’ll be able to experience the true joy of the Pokémon series—battling against wild Pokémon in order to catch them—now in an open-world game that players of any age can enjoy.

Elsewhere

6.9

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

73%

Mixed (50-79)

27%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Pokemon Scarlet has received a mix of positive and negative feedback from critics. Several reviewers, such as Video Chums and Pure Nintendo, praised the game for offering a surprisingly heartfelt and emotional narrative, with powerful emotional punches and deep character development. Critics like Gfinity and Press Start Australia appreciated the engaging exploration of themes not typically found in Pokemon games, with multiple unique narratives providing variation in gameplay. The introduction of new elements like Team Star and the academy setting in the Paldea region added depth and intrigue to the storytelling, appealing to both new and longtime fans of the series. On the other hand, some critics, including NME and Siliconera, expressed disappointment in the story of Pokemon Scarlet, highlighting its arbitrary nature and lack of depth. RPGamer criticized the story for being regrettably mediocre, with easily forgettable characters and paper-thin additions. Critics like COGconnected and Multiplayer.it pointed out that the game's removal of franchise conventions led to an unfocused adventure, while Gamepressure mentioned that the worldbuilding was criticized for being superficial. These criticisms indicate a lack of structure and depth in the storytelling, which may have left some players wanting more from the narrative experience. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the story of Pokemon Scarlet leans towards a mixed reception. While some reviewers appreciated the emotional depth, engaging character development, and unique narrative paths, others felt that the story lacked structure, depth, and memorable characters. The game's exploration of mature themes, introduction of new elements like Team Star, and non-linear progression were highlighted as strengths by critics. However, the overall sentiment suggests that there is room for improvement in future iterations to deliver a more cohesive and engaging storytelling experience that resonates with a wider audience.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics are divided on Pokemon Scarlet's story. Some praise its emotional depth, character development, and unique narratives, while others criticize its lack of structure and depth. The game introduces new elements like Team Star but falls short with forgettable characters and superficial worldbuilding. Overall, opinions vary, with some calling for improvements in future iterations to create a more cohesive and engaging storytelling experience.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

52%

Mixed (50-79)

48%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The Gameplay of Pokemon Scarlet has received a mix of positive and negative feedback from various critics. Many critics praised the game for introducing new mechanics and features that added depth and excitement to the traditional Pokemon experience. Critics like Universo Nintendo and XGN highlighted the engaging gameplay experience with diverse activities, such as Gym Battles, Titan Battles, and Team Star challenges. The introduction of innovative mechanics like Terastallizing and cooperative multiplayer raids was also well-received by reviewers such as Gameblog.fr and Multiplayer.it. The open-world design of the game, allowing for freedom to explore Paldea, encounter diverse Pokemon, and engage in various activities, was a standout feature appreciated by Vooks and PlaySense. On the other hand, several critics pointed out various shortcomings in the Gameplay of Pokemon Scarlet. Games.cz and Digital Trends criticized the linear and dialogue-heavy introduction, restrictive world accessibility, and grinding required for progression. The lack of side quests, outdated design choices, steep difficulty curve, and unexpected challenges in battles were also mentioned as negative aspects by critics like Games.cz and Digital Trends. Additionally, some critics, such as Comicbook.com and Screen Rant, noted issues with scaling, quality-of-life improvements, technical performance, and the underutilization of new mechanics like Terastallizing. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the Gameplay of Pokemon Scarlet is mixed. While the game received praise for introducing new mechanics, open-world exploration, and engaging gameplay experiences, there were concerns raised about the lack of side quests, scaling issues, and technical performance. Critics like IGN Italia and MMORPG.com appreciated the new gameplay mechanics and freedom offered in the game, while critics like Game Revolution and Shacknews highlighted the fresh experience provided by the mix of classic and modern Pokemon tropes. Despite some criticisms, the majority of reviewers acknowledged the efforts made to innovate and enhance the Pokemon gameplay experience in Pokemon Scarlet.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Pokemon Scarlet's gameplay has sparked mixed reviews among critics. Praise for its new mechanics and open-world design contrasts with criticisms of linearity, grinding, and technical issues. While some lauded its innovation and engaging experiences, others felt let down by scaling problems and underutilized features. Overall, opinions vary, with some highlighting the game's fresh take on classic Pokemon elements, while others point out its shortcomings.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

61%

Negative (0-49)

34%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

In analyzing the opinions of several videogame critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Pokemon Scarlet, there are some positive aspects highlighted. Critics like The Enemy and RPGamer praise the game for its strong art direction, diverse biomes, visually unique locations, and captivating views of the Paldea region. Additionally, DualShockers and Gamepressure appreciate the creative designs of the new Pokémon introduced in the game, with RPGamer specifically mentioning the alluring visuals and impressive Pokémon designs present in the game. On the other hand, the negative aspects of the Graphics and Visual Design of Pokemon Scarlet are prevalent in the critiques of various reviewers. Critics such as TheGamer, Game Informer, Pure Nintendo, and Game Revolution point out technical issues like poor performance, unexpected frame drops, low-resolution textures, glitches, and model collision problems. Furthermore, critics like Checkpoint Gaming, CGMagazine, and GameSkinny criticize the game for lacking environmental detail, poor texture quality, tiny draw distance, and graphical errors, impacting the overall visual experience negatively. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the Graphics and Visual Design of Pokemon Scarlet leans towards the negative side. While some reviewers appreciate the vibrant visuals, diverse character designs, and captivating world design, the majority highlight significant technical issues such as frame rate drops, texture pop-ins, graphical glitches, and inconsistent performance. The game's visual shortcomings, including poor rendering, clunky mechanics, and unfinished visuals, seem to overshadow its positive aspects for many critics. Despite some improvements in Pokémon designs and world-building, the prevalent sentiment is that the technical flaws and visual setbacks detract from the overall immersive experience of Pokemon Scarlet on the Nintendo Switch.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics praise Pokemon Scarlet for its vibrant art direction and captivating world design, but technical issues like poor performance and graphical glitches overshadow its positives. The game's visuals impress with diverse biomes and creative Pokémon designs, yet reviewers criticize its low-resolution textures and inconsistent graphics. Overall, critics lean towards a negative consensus due to significant technical flaws detracting from the immersive experience on the Nintendo Switch.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

79%

Mixed (50-79)

17%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The opinions of multiple reviewers regarding the Sound Design and Music of Pokemon Scarlet are overwhelmingly positive. Critics such as CGMagazine, God is a Geek, and RPGamer praise the game's soundtrack, describing it as excellent, phenomenal, and outstanding, respectively. The music is highlighted for enhancing the story, gameplay, battles, and overall experience. Toby Fox's contributions to the soundtrack are particularly lauded, with Gameblog.fr mentioning the positive impact on the game's artistic direction. Reviewers like Gfinity and Shacknews commend the audio quality, noting catchy music, immersive environmental sounds, and standout pieces like the Gym leader theme. The music is described as enhancing the feeling of adventure, contributing positively to the gameplay experience, and creating a dynamic atmosphere in late-game environments, as noted by PlaySense and Screen Rant. On the downside, some critics point out the absence of voice acting in Pokemon Scarlet as a significant drawback. GameOver.gr, Metro GameCentral, and Universo Nintendo highlight this issue, mentioning that the lack of voiceovers can be distracting, take away from the immersion, and be a point of criticism in key scenes. Additionally, GameOver.gr notes technical issues like lack of quality control, framedrops, and game crashes impacting the overall immersive experience. JeuxActu mentions the lack of voice acting and some music in certain parts as minor issues compared to visual shortcomings. MGG also notes that despite the strong music, the open world may feel empty, which could potentially detract from the overall experience for some players. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding the Sound Design and Music of Pokemon Scarlet. The majority of reviewers appreciate the exceptional quality of the soundtrack, with praise for its ability to enhance various aspects of the game. The work of composer Toby Fox is highlighted as a significant strength, with his music adding depth, variety, and delight to the adventure. While some critics point out the lack of voice acting and potential technical issues, these drawbacks are generally overshadowed by the positive aspects of the sound design and music. The overall sentiment is that the sound design and music in Pokemon Scarlet contribute significantly to the immersive and enjoyable gameplay experience, making it a standout feature of the game.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics rave about the exceptional Sound Design and Music in Pokemon Scarlet, praising the soundtrack as excellent, phenomenal, and outstanding. Toby Fox's contributions are particularly lauded for enhancing the game's artistic direction. Despite some criticism for the lack of voice acting and technical issues, the majority agree that the music elevates the story, gameplay, and overall experience. Overall, the consensus is overwhelmingly positive, with the sound design and music adding depth and delight to the adventure in Pokemon Scarlet.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

71%

Negative (0-49)

29%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The lack of voice acting in Pokemon Scarlet has received mixed opinions from the critics. DarkZero mentions that while the absence of voice acting in cutscenes may initially feel odd, players can adjust to it as they progress through the game. This suggests that some players may appreciate the opportunity to imagine the characters' voices themselves, adding a personal touch to the experience. Additionally, My Nintendo News sees the potential for improvement in future generations, indicating that the inclusion of voice acting could enhance the overall immersion and storytelling of the game. On the negative side, GameOver.gr, RPGamer, TheSixthAxis, Universo Nintendo, and Wccftech all express disappointment in the absence of voice acting in Pokemon Scarlet. RPGamer notes that the lack of voice acting is notable, especially considering the strong graphics and music present in the game. TheSixthAxis specifically highlights the absence of voice acting as a negative aspect, suggesting that it may detract from the overall quality of the gameplay experience. Universo Nintendo criticizes the lack of voice acting in key scenes, indicating that it may have hindered the emotional impact of those moments for players. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the absence of voice acting in Pokemon Scarlet is a significant drawback. While some reviewers like DarkZero and My Nintendo News acknowledge that players can adapt to this limitation, the majority of critics, including GameOver.gr, RPGamer, TheSixthAxis, Universo Nintendo, and Wccftech, view the lack of voice acting as a missed opportunity to enhance the game's narrative and emotional depth. The general sentiment leans towards disappointment regarding this aspect of the game, with suggestions for improvement in potential future iterations to incorporate voice acting for a more immersive and engaging gameplay experience.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics are divided on the absence of voice acting in Pokemon Scarlet. Some like DarkZero and My Nintendo News believe players can adjust and even enjoy imagining voices, adding a personal touch. However, GameOver.gr, RPGamer, TheSixthAxis, Universo Nintendo, and Wccftech express disappointment, noting that voice acting could enhance immersion and storytelling. Overall, most critics see the lack of voice acting as a significant drawback, hindering the game's emotional impact and narrative depth.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

33%

Negative (0-49)

67%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of the positives for Pokemon Scarlet on the Nintendo Switch, some critics noted improvements in character models and environments, as mentioned by Press Start Australia. Metro GameCentral also highlighted that while the game experienced ordinary frame rate drops and camera issues, these aspects were improved compared to previous titles. Additionally, Wccftech mentioned that despite facing technical issues like low frame rates and visual glitches, the gameplay itself managed to mitigate the impact of these problems. On the negative side, the overwhelming consensus among critics is that Pokemon Scarlet on the Nintendo Switch suffers from severe technical issues. CGMagazine, TheGamer, and Game Informer all pointed out problems such as blurry visuals, low frame rates, disappearing Pokemon, frame drops, Play-Doh-like visuals, glitches, and poor performance. Critics like Game Rant and Siliconera also highlighted frequent performance issues, graphical oddities, freezes, and crashes that significantly detract from the overall experience. The technical problems extend to issues with textures, animations, camera problems, and stability concerns, as mentioned by various critics such as Digital Trends, IGN France, and XGN. Overall, the critics' consensus on the technical performance of Pokemon Scarlet across all platforms, particularly the Nintendo Switch, is overwhelmingly negative. The game is criticized for its poor optimization, inconsistent frame rates, numerous bugs, and various technical issues that hinder gameplay immersion and enjoyment. Critics like GameOver.gr and Shacknews emphasized severe performance issues, including frame drops, texture pop-ins, crashes, and even freezes, which significantly impact the overall experience. The general sentiment is that the game's rushed production schedule, lack of polish, and technical instability have led to a disappointing gameplay experience for both reviewers and players alike.

TL;DR

technical performance

Critics praise slight improvements in visuals and gameplay mechanics in Pokemon Scarlet for Nintendo Switch but unanimously slam the game for severe technical issues like low frame rates, glitches, and poor optimization, leading to a disappointing and frustrating gameplay experience.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

16%

Mixed (50-79)

77%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The Replay Value of Pokemon Scarlet has garnered positive feedback from several critics. COGconnected appreciates the ability to tackle any gym and the three distinct story paths, providing more reasons to explore. Digital Trends and Digitally Downloaded also commend the open-world exploration, diverse challenges, and the freedom to tackle objectives in any order, enhancing the replay value. Game Informer notes the meaningful additions to the franchise and converging storylines as factors that contribute to the game's replayability. Additionally, Gamepressure highlights the post-game content such as creating competitive teams, trading online, and completing the Pokedex, ensuring continued engagement beyond the main story. On the other hand, some critics point out certain limitations that may impact the Replay Value of Pokemon Scarlet. GAMINGbible mentions the lack of side quests and limited additional activities beyond the main narrative, which could reduce the replay value for players seeking more content. GamesRadar++ expresses concerns about the lack of a clear end goal, leading to aimlessness and a lack of stakes, potentially affecting the replayability of the game. GamingTrend criticizes the lack of depth and failure to deliver a truly memorable adventure experience, which could impact the game's overall replay value for players. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards a positive assessment of the Replay Value of Pokemon Scarlet. Critics like Gamepressure and COGconnected appreciate the game's diverse challenges, freedom to explore, and engaging gameplay mechanics that contribute to its replayability. However, concerns raised by critics such as GamesRadar++ and GamingTrend regarding the lack of clear goals, depth, and additional content beyond the main narrative suggest areas for improvement. Despite these criticisms, the general sentiment is that Pokemon Scarlet offers a compelling experience with enough variety in gameplay and post-game content to warrant multiple playthroughs, making it a worthwhile addition to the Pokemon franchise for fans and newcomers alike.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics praise Pokemon Scarlet for its high replay value due to diverse challenges, open-world exploration, and engaging gameplay mechanics. They appreciate the ability to tackle any gym, three distinct story paths, and post-game activities like creating competitive teams and completing the Pokedex. However, some critics express concerns about limitations such as lack of side quests and depth, which may impact the game's replayability. Overall, while there are areas for improvement, the consensus is positive, with critics noting the game's compelling experience and variety in gameplay make it worthwhile for fans and newcomers.

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive (80-100)

36%

Mixed (50-79)

62%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

In analyzing the opinions of the critics regarding the Overall Verdict of Pokemon Scarlet, it is evident that the game has received a mix of positive and negative feedback. Critics such as Game Rant, Comicbook.com, and Universo Nintendo praise the game for its engaging storylines, innovative gameplay mechanics, and advancements in the Pokemon franchise. The introduction of new features, open-world design, and captivating world exploration are highlighted as standout elements that contribute to the overall enjoyment of the game. Additionally, critics like Video Chums and Pure Nintendo appreciate the immersive experience, heartfelt story, and addicting gameplay that Pokemon Scarlet offers, showcasing the game's potential to be a significant evolution for the series. On the other hand, several critics point out the technical issues and performance problems that hinder the overall experience of Pokemon Scarlet. TheGamer, COGconnected, and GameOver.gr express disappointment in the poor performance, lack of polish, and technical deficiencies that detract from the game's potential to be the best Pokemon title. Critics like Siliconera and Dexerto acknowledge the presence of performance issues that impact the gameplay, suggesting that post-launch bug fixes may improve the overall experience. The lack of quality control in development, rushed production, and unforgivable performance problems are highlighted as major drawbacks by critics such as Game Informer and Worth Playing, indicating that the game falls short of expectations due to these issues. Overall, the consensus among the critics leans towards recognizing the potential and ambition of Pokemon Scarlet while also acknowledging its shortcomings. While the game introduces new elements, engaging storylines, and a refreshing change from previous Pokemon titles, it is clear that technical issues, lack of polish, and rushed production have hindered its full potential. Critics like Guardian and Gfinity emphasize the frustration stemming from poor execution and technical shortcomings, despite the game's addictive gameplay and entertaining story. The general sentiment suggests that while Pokemon Scarlet and Violet offer a promising future for the franchise and showcase advancements in gameplay, the presence of performance issues and lack of quality control prevent it from being a standout title in the Pokemon series.

TL;DR

Critics are divided on Pokemon Scarlet. Some praise its engaging storylines and innovative gameplay, while others criticize its technical issues and lack of polish. Despite its potential, the game falls short due to rushed production and performance problems, leaving room for improvement.

MONSTER

Reviews

126 reviews found

100

The Enemy

Nintendo Switch

Nov 17, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Significant advancement in the Pokémon series, surpassing predecessors and signaling a promising future for the franchise.

Read full review

100

Digitally Downloaded

Nintendo Switch

Nov 23, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite some minor limitations and technical issues, the reviewer had a wonderful time with Pokemon Violet and Scarlet, finding the game to be a fulfilling return to what drew them into the Pokemon franchise.

Read full review

Screen Rant

Nintendo Switch

Nov 17, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pokémon Scarlet & Violet is a must-play adventure with compelling highs and technically uneven lows, showcasing the evolution of the series with a bright future ahead.

Read full review

App Trigger

Nintendo Switch

Dec 11, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The reviewer enjoyed their time playing Pokemon Scarlet and Violet, despite the flaws. They gave it a score of 8.5/10.

Read full review

MGG

Nintendo Switch

Nov 17, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Offers a refreshing experience in the expansive region of Paldea with an open-world gameplay and engaging scenarios. Promises a bright future for the franchise despite sacrifices in graphics and technical aspects.

Game Informer

Nintendo Switch

Nov 21, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite technical shortcomings and some filler content, the game offers meaningful additions to the franchise and serves as an effective thesis statement for the series' future.

Read full review

Impulsegamer

Nintendo Switch

Dec 5, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite its flaws in presentation, Pokemon Scarlet is described as a ton of fun with engaging gameplay and addicting mechanics.

Read full review

DualShockers

Nintendo Switch

Nov 28, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game takes risks and offers a mix of innovative and fun changes. It has flaws and limitations, but there is still much to appreciate for Pokemon fans.

Read full review

GamesHub

Nintendo Switch

Nov 17, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pokemon Scarlet and Violet are an essential leap forward in storytelling and gameplay mechanics, making them some of the best modern games in the franchise.

Read full review

Gamepressure

Nintendo Switch

Nov 23, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Scarlet and Violet are considered the best Pokemon games in a long time, offering a fun, engaging, and fluid experience despite some limitations due to hardware, highlighting a new generation of Pokemon games.

Read full review