MonsterCritic
Forgive Me Father 2 cover image
Links
Steam Icon
Steam
Epic Icon
Epic
Twitch Icon
Twitch

76

MONSTER

Star Icon

Forgive Me Father 2

2025
GenresFantasy, Adventure, Indie, Action, Shooter, Single Player, First Person Perspective
AvailableSep 23, 2025
PlatformPlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X
DeveloperByte Barrel
Overview

Embark on a journey into the darkest nightmares to restore your sanity. Blast your way through hordes of possessed enemies, unlock an arsenal of deadly weapons and get ready to face even more Lovecraftian madness in this action-packed FPS sequel.

Score icon

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

64

TL;DR

Boldly explores psychological horror through Lovecraftian motifs but falters with clunky writing, fragmented storytelling, and a confusing structure that polarizes critics between admiration for its ambition and frustration over its incoherent execution.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

64

Positive Reviews (80-100)

17%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

67%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

17%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The reviews for Forgive Me Father 2 highlight its ambitious narrative and thematic depth, particularly its exploration of psychological horror through Lovecraftian motifs. Critics like Movies Games and Tech praise the game’s immersive atmosphere, noting how the Priest’s disjointed journey through a surreal world creates a sense of unease and intrigue. Impulsegamer emphasizes the intimate portrayal of guilt and acceptance, suggesting the story delves deeper into the protagonist’s psyche than its predecessor. Additionally, TheXboxHub commends the game’s “deep narrative with Lovecraftian themes,” pointing to twisted environments like a university and war trenches as clever reflections of the protagonist’s fractured memories. These elements collectively showcase the game’s strengths in crafting an atmospheric, introspective experience that resonates with fans of psychological horror. However, several critics point to significant flaws in execution. PlayStation Country criticizes the narrative for its “forced dialect” and lack of emotional depth, while PlayStation Universe lambasts the story as “poorly written” with cringey dialogue and a clichéd plot involving mental asylum tropes. COGconnected notes that the fragmented storytelling—reliant on missable journal entries and sardonic dialogue—can feel alienating, and TheXboxHub acknowledges that the narrative risks being overshadowed by fast-paced gameplay. The game’s reliance on text clippings and disjointed structure, as highlighted by Movies Games and Tech, further complicates its accessibility, leaving some players frustrated by its confusing and messy presentation. These critiques underscore a disconnect between the game’s ambitious vision and its implementation. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed but leans toward appreciation for the game’s thematic ambition despite its flaws. While Impulsegamer and TheXboxHub celebrate its psychological depth and Lovecraftian atmosphere, others like PlayStation Universe and PlayStation Country find it underwhelming due to poor writing and execution. The fragmented storytelling and reliance on player interpretation divide opinions, with some finding it engaging (as noted by COGconnected) and others dismissing it as inaccessible or unpolished. Ultimately, Forgive Me Father 2 seems to polarize reviewers, offering a unique but uneven experience that prioritizes mood over coherence, leaving its success dependent on players’ tolerance for ambiguity and experimental narrative design.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Boldly explores psychological horror through Lovecraftian motifs but falters with clunky writing, fragmented storytelling, and a confusing structure that polarizes critics between admiration for its ambition and frustration over its incoherent execution.

79

TL;DR

Forgive Me Father 2 nails tight, inventive combat with fluid movement and wild weapons but falters as repetitive pacing and clunky systems dull its shine—a polished yet formulaic follow-up that prioritizes style over substance.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

79

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

43%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Forgive Me Father 2 receives generally positive feedback from multiple reviewers, who highlight its strong foundation in core mechanics and engaging combat. ComicBook praises the "fundamentally solid" gunplay with "tight" controls and unique weapon designs, while PlayStation Universe notes "satisfying gunplay" and a "fast-paced" tempo. Impulsegamer emphasizes fluid movement and a variety of weapons, including "unique eldritch tools," and TheXboxHub commends the game’s "relentless" pace and "varied enemies." The intuitive weapon wheel system (Movies Games and Tech) and customizable loadouts (Impulsegamer) further enhance the experience. Many critics also appreciate the smoother difficulty curve compared to its predecessor, with TheXboxHub and Impulsegamer noting improved progression and exploration. However, several reviewers point out significant drawbacks that detract from the gameplay. ComicBook criticizes the "repetitive" latter half of the game and a restrictive upgrade system that limits variety, while PlayStation Country notes the slower movement and lack of fast-paced intensity seen in 90s shooters. COGconnected highlights weapon balance issues, where certain tools overshadow others, reducing exploration of the arsenal. Additionally, Movies Games and Tech mentions the absence of a quick melee button, and PlayStation Universe points out that the progression system feels "simpler" than the first game, with fewer unlockable weapon upgrades. These critiques suggest that while the gameplay is enjoyable, it struggles to maintain innovation or depth throughout its runtime. Overall, critics agree that Forgive Me Father 2 delivers a strong core experience with fluid mechanics and engaging combat but faces challenges in sustaining variety and complexity. The positives—such as tight gunplay (ComicBook, PlayStation Universe), dynamic movement (Impulsegamer, TheXboxHub), and creative weapon designs—are balanced by criticisms of repetition, restrictive systems (ComicBook, PlayStation Country), and uneven balance (COGconnected). While some reviewers like Impulsegamer and TheXboxHub praise its improvements over the original, others feel it falls short in innovation. The consensus leans toward a solid but imperfect gameplay experience that excels in execution but struggles with long-term engagement.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Forgive Me Father 2 nails tight, inventive combat with fluid movement and wild weapons but falters as repetitive pacing and clunky systems dull its shine—a polished yet formulaic follow-up that prioritizes style over substance.

86

TL;DR

Forgive Me Father 2 dazzles with bold comic-book visuals, eerie Lovecraftian flair, and razor-sharp art direction, earning universal acclaim for its striking aesthetic. Critics rave about dynamic lighting, detailed environments, and a unique 2D-in-3D style, though minor issues like monochrome clashing, map monotony, and underwhelming monster designs surface—yet these pale next to the game’s visionary charm. A masterclass in horror-meets-comedy visuals.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

86

Positive Reviews (80-100)

100%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

0%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Forgive Me Father 2 received widespread acclaim, with multiple critics praising its distinctive art direction and thematic cohesion. ComicBook highlighted the game’s bold comic book-style visuals, noting strong color contrasts and a unique aesthetic that aligns perfectly with its Lovecraftian themes. Similarly, Movies Games and Tech lauded the dark comic-style visuals, emphasizing how detailed enemies, weapons, and environments are enhanced by excellent lighting and shadow work. PlayStation Country praised the striking use of bold black lines, a moody green palette, and boxy geometry that aids navigation, while COGconnected celebrated the 2D-sprite-in-3D-world approach, which blends high-contrast shading with disturbingly detailed enemies. TheXboxHub also noted improvements in models, environments, and creative lighting, with comic book panels effectively enhancing the game’s aesthetic appeal. These elements collectively create a visually immersive experience that stands out in the genre. While the majority of reviews were positive, some critics pointed to specific drawbacks. PlayStation Country mentioned that the monochrome effect during abilities slightly detracts from clarity, while PlayStation Universe noted that some maps feel dull and technical issues like clipping persist. Impulsegamer critiqued the reduced variety in monster designs, observing that they lean more toward twisted human reflections rather than the grotesque eldritch horrors expected in Lovecraftian lore. These critiques suggest that while the game’s visual identity is strong, certain execution flaws—such as environmental monotony and technical inconsistencies—impact the overall experience. However, these issues were not universally emphasized, and many critics acknowledged them as minor compared to the game’s broader strengths. Overall, the consensus among reviewers was overwhelmingly positive, with most praising Forgive Me Father 2 for its innovative visual style and thematic depth. Critics like ComicBook, Movies Games and Tech, and TheXboxHub highlighted how the comic book-inspired design effectively complements the game’s horror elements, creating a memorable aesthetic. While some noted technical or design shortcomings—such as those mentioned by PlayStation Universe and Impulsegamer—the majority viewed these as minor blemishes on an otherwise impressive visual package. The game’s ability to balance dark humor with Lovecraftian dread through its art direction has clearly resonated with reviewers, cementing its reputation as a visually striking entry in the genre.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Forgive Me Father 2 dazzles with bold comic-book visuals, eerie Lovecraftian flair, and razor-sharp art direction, earning universal acclaim for its striking aesthetic. Critics rave about dynamic lighting, detailed environments, and a unique 2D-in-3D style, though minor issues like monochrome clashing, map monotony, and underwhelming monster designs surface—yet these pale next to the game’s visionary charm. A masterclass in horror-meets-comedy visuals.

73

TL;DR

Critics praise Forgive Me Father 2's sound design for its high-energy metal soundtrack and immersive effects, yet note tonal inconsistency and minor glitches, with some calling for better thematic cohesion.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

73

Positive Reviews (80-100)

43%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

57%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Forgive Me Father 2 receive largely positive feedback from several reviewers, who highlight their effectiveness in enhancing the game’s intensity and atmosphere. ComicBook praises the “booming metal music” and “electric guitar riffs” during battles, which align with the game’s action-driven sequences, while Movies Games and Tech notes that enemy sounds create tension and the music balances “intensity and eeriness.” PlayStation Country commends the seamless transition between grim ambience and combat-oriented metal tracks, and PlayStation Universe describes the “energetic metal anthems” as a strong complement to the fast-paced gameplay. Additionally, COGconnected emphasizes impactful weapon sound effects like shotgun blasts and flamethrowers, which add visceral depth to combat. TheXboxHub also appreciates how heavy metal and rock music align with the game’s frantic pace, paired with a “gruff, noir tone” in voice-overs that reinforce the atmosphere. However, some critics point out notable flaws or inconsistencies. Impulsegamer criticizes the score as “inconsistent,” arguing that the reliance on metal during intense moments clashes with the Lovecraftian setting, and notes a lack of cohesion between the music and the game’s overall tone. PlayStation Country mentions an audio glitch causing static noise, which was resolved by restarting, though this appears to be a minor technical issue. While most reviewers focus on surface-level elements, few delve into deeper aspects like audio variety or technical quality—COGconnected and TheXboxHub, for instance, avoid discussing the musical score beyond its immediate impact. These critiques suggest that while the sound design is effective in many ways, it lacks refinement in certain areas, particularly in maintaining thematic consistency. Overall, the critics agree that Forgive Me Father 2’s sound design and music successfully amplify the game’s action and horror elements, with a strong emphasis on metal-driven tracks and immersive effects. However, there is a shared acknowledgment of limitations, such as the occasional overreliance on metal themes (as noted by Impulsegamer) and minor technical hiccups (like PlayStation Country’s glitch). While some reviewers, like Movies Games and Tech and PlayStation Universe, praise the atmospheric contributions, others feel the music could better align with the game’s narrative tone. Despite these critiques, the consensus leans toward appreciation for the sound design’s role in creating an engaging, high-energy experience, even if it doesn’t fully address all aspects of audio depth or cohesion.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics praise Forgive Me Father 2's sound design for its high-energy metal soundtrack and immersive effects, yet note tonal inconsistency and minor glitches, with some calling for better thematic cohesion.

NA

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

NA

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

technical performance

Description unavailable

NA

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

replay value

Description unavailable

Overall verdict

Overall Verdict

76

MONSTER

Star Icon

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

76

Positive Reviews (80-100)

74%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

26%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The reviews for Forgive Me Father 2 highlight several strong positives, particularly its creative design and atmospheric appeal. Critics like Movies Games and Tech and PlayStation Universe praise its immersive Lovecraftian experience, with the former emphasizing its "immersive Lovecraftian experience" and "replayability," while the latter notes "satisfying combat and atmospheric environments." ComicBook acknowledges the game’s "unique visual design" and "creative weapon mechanics," and COGconnected applauds its "unmatched visual style" and "engaging gameplay," despite technical hiccups. Impulsegamer and TheXboxHub also commend the sequel’s improved mechanics, deeper narrative, and innovative weapons, with the latter calling it a "well-executed" follow-up that blends old-school shooter elements with fresh ideas. These critiques collectively underscore the game’s strengths in style, creativity, and genre-specific immersion. However, several critics point to significant flaws that temper its appeal. ComicBook criticizes the "restrictive systems," "repetitive gameplay," and "uneven difficulty," calling it a missed opportunity as a sophomore title. PlayStation Country notes "limited movement" and technical issues, while PlayStation Universe highlights a "poor story" and "simplified progression system." COGconnected adds that console performance is hindered by "technical flaws," and Impulsegamer suggests the game remains "largely more of the same" despite improvements. These critiques reveal a recurring theme of unmet potential, with some reviewers feeling the game struggles to elevate beyond its predecessor’s formula or address core gameplay shortcomings. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Forgive Me Father 2 is a competent but uneven entry in the Lovecraftian FPS genre. While it excels in visual design, atmospheric storytelling, and combat innovation—praised by Movies Games and Tech, TheXboxHub, and Impulsegamer—it faces criticism for technical issues, repetitive mechanics, and narrative shortcomings. The game seems to split opinions between those who appreciate its creative risks and nostalgic charm (e.g., COGconnected) and those who feel it fails to fully realize its potential (e.g., ComicBook). Despite these divides, most agree it’s a worthwhile experience for fans of the genre, even if it falls short of being a groundbreaking sequel.

TL;DR

Forgive Me Father 2 dazzles with Lovecraftian immersion, creative weapon design, and atmospheric thrills but stumbles on repetitive mechanics, technical flaws, and a underdeveloped narrative, splitting fans between praise for its bold risks and frustration over unmet potential.

76

MONSTER

Star Icon

Reviews

27 reviews found

90

TheXboxHub

Xbox Series X

Sep 23, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The sequel is praised as well-executed, smoother, and more exciting than the first, with innovative weapons and a compelling story. It successfully blends old-school shooter elements with fresh ideas.


85

Movies Games and Tech

PlayStation 5

Oct 14, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review praises the game’s immersive Lovecraftian experience, combat, and replayability. It’s recommended for fans of boomer shooters and Lovecraftian horror, with high enthusiasm despite minor criticisms.


80

COGconnected

Xbox Series X

Oct 6, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

A creatively refined retro-shooter with unmatched visual style and engaging gameplay, but hindered by technical flaws on console. Recommended for fans of Lovecraftian horror who can tolerate performance issues.


72

Impulsegamer

Xbox Series X

Sep 29, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

A decent sequel that builds on the original's strengths with improved mechanics, more varied environments, and a deeper narrative. It balances style, violence, and Lovecraftian themes effectively, though it remains largely more of the same.


70

PlayStation Universe

PlayStation 5

Sep 23, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite flaws like poor story, technical issues, and a simplified progression system, the game delivers an enjoyable Lovecraftian FPS experience with satisfying combat and atmospheric environments.

Similar Games
Similar Games

Games you might also enjoy

left arrow
right arrow
Popular Right Now
Popular Right Now

Trending games the community is playing

left arrow
right arrow
Recently Reviewed
Recently Reviewed

Games with full Monster Scorecards

left arrow
right arrow

About

Contact Us

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Navigation

Home

Search

Games


Follow Us

© 2025 MonsterCritic