Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4

The reviews of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 highlight a few positive aspects of the game's narrative approach, particularly its emphasis on cultural and nostalgic elements. Critics like Cultura Geek and Digital Chumps praise the game for capturing the counter-culture essence of the late 90s and early 2000s skateboarding scene, which resonates with fans of the original series. TierraGamer and CD-Action note the inclusion of humorous, quirky objectives and cutscenes that echo the original titles' goofy charm, while Eurogamer points to specific moments like the Alcatraz mission with its secret tapes and prisoner escape, showcasing how narrative is woven into gameplay. Additionally, Nintendo Life acknowledges that the shift in THPS 4’s structure to a timed mission format, though controversial, maintains a fast-paced flow that some find effective. These perspectives suggest that while the game lacks a traditional story, it retains a sense of playful, era-specific identity that appeals to long-time fans. However, the majority of critics express disappointment with the game’s minimal narrative depth and its failure to preserve the original titles’ storytelling elements. Atomix and Critical Hits criticize the lack of a substantial campaign, particularly in THPS 4, which they argue has been oversimplified and stripped of its original context. DBLTAP and Hobby Consolas note that the career mode feels hollow, diminishing player investment in character customization and the game’s unique identity. TierraGamer and GameSpot point to the absence of NPCs and iconic missions, which they feel dilutes the original’s charm, while Restart.run laments the two-minute timer in THPS 4 as a chore that erodes the sense of exploration. Game8 and New Game Network also highlight the lack of narrative depth, with the latter criticizing the removal of character-driven mission intros that gave the original THPS 4 its personality. These critiques collectively underscore a perception that the game’s story is underdeveloped and fails to engage players beyond its core mechanics. The overall consensus among critics is that Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 prioritizes gameplay and nostalgia over a traditional narrative, which is both a strength and a limitation. While Cultura Geek and MeuPlayStation celebrate the game’s connection to skate culture and its ability to evoke personal memories, many others, such as Game Informer and Gamepressure, argue that the lack of narrative context alienates newcomers and weakens the experience for veterans. The structural changes, like the shift to timed missions in THPS 4, are seen as divisive: Nintendo Life and TechRadar Gaming view them as necessary for pacing, but Hobby Consolas and Restart.run find them jarring. Despite these mixed reactions, the game’s story is largely considered secondary to its core skateboarding mechanics, with most reviewers agreeing that it doesn’t fully replicate the original titles’ narrative richness. The collection’s success hinges on its ability to deliver the spirit of the original games, even if that means sacrificing a more conventional storyline.

The majority of critics praised the gameplay of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 as a faithful yet refined evolution of the series’ core mechanics. Reviewers like GamesRadar+ and TierraGamer highlighted the fluidity and satisfaction of the skating experience, noting the precise controls and deep combo systems that cater to both newcomers and veterans. IGN France and Impulsegamer emphasized the addictive nature of the gameplay, with its nerveous, high-speed trick execution and momentum-driven challenges. The inclusion of new features such as Skitch (as mentioned by Worth Playing and GameStar) and Pro Goals (cited by IGN Benelux and ZTGD) added layers of complexity and replayability, while the classic two-minute timer and goal-oriented structure remained a strong foundation. PlaySense and New Game Network appreciated the balance between nostalgia and innovation, with modifiers and accessible tutorials making the game approachable without diluting its challenge. The game’s ability to retain the "pure grit" of the original series, as described by Gamereactor UK, was frequently cited as a key strength, reinforcing its timeless appeal. However, several critics pointed out notable drawbacks. Shacknews and MondoXbox criticized THPS 4’s structural changes, particularly the timed goal system, which they felt diminished the free-roaming flexibility of earlier entries. CGMagazine and Push Square noted that some levels felt "diminished" or "altered" in ways that disrupted the original experience, while Hobby Consolas and Voxel mentioned outdated controls and minor inconsistencies, such as the Spine Transfer mechanic. Worth Playing and CD-Action highlighted that the game lacked significant improvements over previous titles, with the retry system and mission design occasionally frustrating players. Additionally, Restart.run and Invader expressed disappointment with THPS 4’s new format, arguing it reduced the variety of tasks and shifted focus away from the series’ signature creativity. These critiques, while present, were often framed as minor issues against the backdrop of the game’s overall strengths. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among reviewers was overwhelmingly positive, with the gameplay being deemed "very good" by the majority. IGN, GameBlast, and Checkpoint Gaming celebrated its engaging, high-skill ceiling, and the seamless integration of classic and modern elements. While some fans missed the free-roaming aspects or found certain mechanics frustrating, the game’s polished controls, refined animations, and nostalgic yet updated design (as noted by Voxel and MeuPlayStation) were widely appreciated. The addition of Pro Goals, new stages, and customizable options (mentioned by IGN Benelux and Eurogamer Germany) reinforced its appeal, even as a few critics acknowledged its limitations. Ultimately, the gameplay was seen as a strong tribute to the series’ legacy, with its addictive core and technical depth earning it a place as a standout entry in the franchise.

The majority of critics praised the graphics and visual design of Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 + 4, highlighting its modernized aesthetic and nostalgic charm. Many reviewers emphasized the game’s enhanced visuals, with TechRadar Gaming noting that the remake “looks significantly better than the originals” and IGN Spain calling the graphics “more beautiful and detailed than ever.” The use of modern engines like Unreal Engine 4 and 5 was frequently lauded, with Atomix and Gameblog.fr praising the vibrant, detailed levels and improved lighting effects. Areajugones and CGMagazine highlighted the successful balance between retaining the original’s essence and updating it for contemporary standards, while GameSpot and GameStar commended the “beautifully redone” levels and immersive environments. Critics also noted the game’s ability to evoke nostalgia while feeling fresh, as seen in Eurogamer’s observation of “recreated environments and animations that evoke nostalgia while feeling fresh.” These improvements, combined with enhanced textures, animations, and color palettes, were seen as major upgrades that elevate the series’ visual appeal. Despite the overall positivity, some critics pointed out specific shortcomings. COGconnected described the visuals as “serviceable” and less impressive than the gameplay, while GamersRD noted a “step back” from the previous remaster, citing “some characters [that] are well-detailed” but others lacking polish. CD-Action criticized the game for being “disappointing for a modern title,” with “familiar assets and textures that do not meet next-gen expectations.” Issues like lower-quality NPC models (e.g., Vooks and GameInformers), graphical artifacts (Hobby Consolas), and frame drops (Multiplayer.it) were also mentioned. Finger Guns and GameInformers pointed to “graphical downgrades” in character models and menu screens, while XboxEra noted the game’s reliance on a “new graphics engine” that, while effective, occasionally struggled with consistency. These critiques, though minor, suggest that while the visual overhaul was largely successful, some elements fell short of expectations. Overall, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with the majority celebrating the game’s visual upgrades as a significant step forward. While a few reviewers expressed reservations about specific details, the vast majority emphasized that Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 + 4 successfully modernized the series’ look without losing its core identity. IGN, GamePress, and Checkpoint Gaming all highlighted the “slick 4K visuals” and “polished look,” while Digital Chumps and Movies Games and Tech praised the “vibrant colors” and “lifelike animations.” Even critics who noted minor flaws, like Voxel and MeuPlayStation, acknowledged the game’s “clean and colorful” design and “competent” graphics. The combination of nostalgia, technical improvements, and attention to detail solidified the game’s visual appeal, making it a standout entry in the series and a satisfying experience for both longtime fans and newcomers.

The Sound Design and Music of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 received praise for its energetic and genre-diverse approach, with many critics highlighting the inclusion of new tracks that align with the game’s skate culture. GameSpot and GamesRadar+ noted that the soundtrack blends memorable original songs with fresh selections, enhancing the game’s atmosphere and maintaining its iconic vibe. Cultura Geek emphasized the curated mix of classic and contemporary punk rock, while Voxel acknowledged that the new tracks "fit well with the game," even if they lacked the cultural resonance of past entries. Some reviewers, like TheXboxHub and Restart.run, appreciated the balance of old and new, with the latter praising the soundtrack for bridging generational gaps and resonating with skate culture. Additionally, Loot Level Chill highlighted the nostalgic feel of the music, suggesting it successfully recreates the thrill of discovering new artists, and Shacknews lauded it as "excellent" with a "slamming soundtrack" that elevates gameplay. These positives underscore the effort to modernize the series while preserving its core energy. However, the soundtrack faced significant criticism for its reduced presence of iconic original tracks, which many felt undermined the game’s nostalgic appeal. Multiple outlets, including New Game Network, IGN, Gameliner, and CGMagazine, pointed out that only 10 classic songs from the originals were included, a stark contrast to the expansive, culturally defining playlists of earlier titles. Vooks and Atomix specifically noted the absence of 69 original tracks, with Vooks calling it a "notable absence" despite the new selections. Critics like Hobby Consolas and MeuPlayStation argued that the minimal retention of original music dulled the cultural authenticity, while Gaming Nexus and Push Square lamented that the new songs, though decent, lacked the impact of the classics. Gamepressure and IGN Adria echoed this sentiment, stating that the "disconnect between familiar levels and an unfamiliar soundtrack" diminished the experience. Licensing issues and commercial decisions, as mentioned by LevelUp and Critical Hits, further fueled frustration, with some tracks replaced by "brand deals" that felt less organic to the series’ identity. The overall consensus among critics is a mixed but leaning negative assessment, with the soundtrack’s modernization efforts sparking debate. While several reviewers, such as GameSpot and GamesRadar+, acknowledged the new music’s quality and its ability to enhance gameplay, the majority expressed disappointment over the limited return of original tracks. IGN and Gameliner emphasized the poor balance of nostalgia versus novelty, and NintendoWorldReport noted that the mix of old and new "may disappoint fans expecting the original music." Despite this, some critics like Gameblog.fr and TierraGamer appreciated the inclusion of both key originals and fresh songs, while COGconnected praised the opening video’s nostalgic feel. The lack of cultural depth and the perceived prioritization of commercial partnerships over legacy tracks, as critiqued by Game Informer and Critical Hits, left many fans feeling the soundtrack fell short of the series’ storied history. Ultimately, while the new selections had merit, the absence of the original classics overshadowed the experience for most reviewers, creating a polarizing reception.

Summary unavailable

The technical performance of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 across different platforms has generally been praised by reviewers, with many highlighting its stability and smooth gameplay. On the Nintendo Switch 2, several critics, including Nintendo Life, Loot Level Chill, and Vooks, noted that the game runs at a solid framerate both docked and handheld, with no crashes reported during gameplay. Nintendo Insider also pointed out that the Switch 2 version shows improved technical performance compared to the original Switch, with fewer compromises and better stability. On the PS5, COGconnected, Digital Chumps, and Push Square emphasized the game's rock-solid frame rate and smooth performance, while Gameblog.fr and PlayStation Universe acknowledged some minor issues like collision problems and screen tearing, which were seen as relatively minor and expected to be fixed. On PC, Eurogamer Germany and Worth Playing reported that the game runs smoothly on platforms like Steam Deck and offers stable online play with high frame rates, despite some optimization and minor bug issues. However, there were notable technical concerns reported on certain platforms. On the Nintendo Switch 2, Atomix and NintendoWorldReport expressed frustration with frequent crashes and significant stability issues, which they felt detracted from the experience. DBLTAP also mentioned login problems and black screen loading, though they still considered the overall experience good. On the PS5, But Why Tho? noted minor screen tearing, while The Games Machine pointed out persistent camera control issues that affected gameplay. On PC, IGN France and Multiplayer.it highlighted minor collision and landing issues, as well as optimization problems in some maps, which could impact the experience for more demanding players. SECTOR.sk and TechRadar Gaming also mentioned glitches and occasional bugs, though these were generally seen as tolerable. Overall, the critics reached a broad consensus that Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 + 4 delivers strong technical performance across platforms, with the PS5 and PC versions being particularly well-received for their stability and frame rates. The Nintendo Switch 2 had mixed feedback, with some reviewers praising its performance while others raised concerns about crashes and loading issues. Despite minor technical hiccups, most critics agreed that the game is well-optimized and enjoyable, with many noting that patches and updates have helped address initial problems. The positive reception of the game's technical aspects, especially on the PS5 and PC, suggests that the core experience is solid, even if some platform-specific issues remain.

The majority of critics highlight the strong replay value of Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 + 4, emphasizing its engaging mechanics, diverse modes, and creative tools. Reviewers like GameSpew, Eurogamer Germany, and Gamer.no praise the game’s online multiplayer, Create-A-Park feature, and Pro Goals, which encourage players to revisit levels and experiment with custom skateparks or trick combinations. GamesRadar+ and IGN Spain note the player-created levels and varied challenges as key drivers of longevity, while Gaming Nexus and Gameliner highlight the community-driven content and hidden collectibles that keep players invested. The inclusion of multiple skaters, unlockables, and objectives—such as GAMES.CH’s mention of customization and Digital Chumps’s reference to user-generated parks—creates a dynamic experience that appeals to both casual and dedicated fans. These elements collectively suggest a game that rewards exploration and mastery, with GameStar and MeuPlayStation pointing to the depth of challenges and level editor as standout features. However, some critics express concerns about limitations in replayability compared to earlier entries in the series. IGN France and Inverse argue that the game’s nostalgic appeal is strong but not enough to retain new players, as it lacks the expansive unlockable content of the originals. Gamer.no and GamingTrend note that the excitement fades after completing campaigns, with post-game content feeling repetitive or underdeveloped. DBLTAP and CGMagazine mention that the absence of a compelling narrative or substantial new features reduces long-term engagement, while Nintendo Life points to slow matchmaking in multiplayer as a potential drawback. These critiques suggest that while the game’s core systems are robust, its ability to sustain interest beyond initial playthroughs may depend on player familiarity with the series or tolerance for its repetitive elements. Despite these reservations, the overall consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive regarding replay value. Most reviewers, including Gamer.no, Gameblog.fr, and XboxEra, acknowledge that the game’s variety of modes, challenges, and creative tools ensures hours of engagement, even if it doesn’t surpass the original remasters. While some, like IGN France and Inverse, caution that it may not appeal to newcomers, the majority agree that features such as Create-A-Park, online multiplayer, and hidden objectives make it a compelling revisit for fans. IGN and Checkpoint Gaming specifically highlight the cross-game level integration and improved customization as innovations that enhance replayability. Though not perfect, the game’s ability to balance nostalgia with modern mechanics and community-driven content has earned it a reputation as a highly replayable title for its target audience, with critics like Vooks and But Why Tho? underscoring its enduring appeal through multiplayer and creative flexibility.