Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Twitch

MONSTER

Herdling

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Herdling
Item: Herdling
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2025

GenresAdventure, Indie, Action, Casual, Single Player

AvailableAug 21, 2025

PlatformNintendo Switch, PC, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 5

DeveloperOkomotive

Overview

Guide a herd of mysterious creatures on a stirring and beautiful journey into the mountains… and beyond.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Herdling captivates with its emotional bond between players and Calicorns, praised for its charming, dialogue-free narrative and rich environmental storytelling. However, critics are divided, citing a lack of depth, character development, and frustrating gameplay mechanics that undermine engagement. While the game evokes strong feelings of companionship and explores themes of grief, its vague plot and pacing issues leave many players craving more substance. Ultimately, it’s a bittersweet experience—emotionally resonant for some, yet disappointingly shallow for others.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

48%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

45%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of critics regarding the story of Herdling reveal several positive aspects that many reviewers appreciated. A common theme among the reviews is the emotional connection fostered between the player and the fantastical creatures known as Calicorns. For instance, Gamereactor UK highlights the "charming storyline" that emphasizes this bond despite the absence of dialogue. Critics like TechRadar Gaming and Shacknews also commend the game for its ability to evoke feelings of companionship and responsibility through its wordless narrative. The environmental storytelling is frequently praised, with Nintendo Life noting that the atmosphere and world design create a resonant emotional experience, while Eurogamer describes the narrative as bittersweet, effectively exploring themes of grief and loss. However, the critiques also point out significant shortcomings in the storytelling of Herdling. Many reviewers, such as Hey Poor Player and NintendoWorldReport, express feelings of disconnection from the story, citing a lack of depth and character development. Loot Level Chill emphasizes that the game’s focus on gameplay mechanics often undermines the narrative's impact, suggesting that players may struggle to engage with the story due to frustrating herd mechanics. Critics like GameBlast and Softpedia echo this sentiment, arguing that the narrative is vague and insufficiently developed, leaving players with unanswered questions about the protagonist and the world they inhabit. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates that while Herdling successfully creates an emotional atmosphere and offers a unique storytelling approach through environmental cues, it ultimately falls short in narrative depth and character engagement. Critics such as CGMagazine and PC Gamer point out the pacing issues and the lack of a definitive storyline, which detracts from the overall experience. While some reviewers find value in the open-ended nature of the story, allowing for personal interpretation, others feel that this vagueness hinders the game's potential to create a more profound connection with its audience. Thus, Herdling presents a mixed bag of storytelling that resonates emotionally for some while leaving others wanting more substance.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Tldr: Herdling impresses with intuitive controls and engaging herding mechanics, winning praise for its accessibility and emotional connection with Calicorns. However, critics slam its lack of depth, cumbersome movement, and overly simplistic puzzles, leading to a repetitive experience. While it suits casual players seeking a chill vibe, those craving complexity will likely be disappointed. The game shows promise but needs significant polish to elevate its gameplay.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

23%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

74%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Herdling has garnered a mix of positive feedback from critics, particularly regarding its intuitive controls and straightforward mechanics. Reviewers like Pure Nintendo and TechRadar Gaming praised the herding mechanics, highlighting their accessibility and the engaging nature of guiding the Calicorns through various environments. Critics such as Finger Guns and Gaming Nexus noted that the gameplay fosters a sense of connection with the creatures, enhancing the overall experience. The inclusion of light puzzles and challenges, as mentioned by Gamereactor UK and Hey Poor Player, adds a layer of engagement without overwhelming players, making it suitable for a broad audience. However, the gameplay has also faced significant criticism, particularly regarding its depth and execution. Many reviewers, including Loot Level Chill and Nintendo Life, pointed out issues such as cumbersome movement and clunky controls that detract from the overall experience. Critics like Eurogamer and GameBlast described the gameplay as shallow and lacking in complexity, leading to a less engaging experience as the game progresses. Furthermore, some critics noted that the puzzles were too simplistic and did not provide a sufficient challenge, which could lead to a sense of repetitiveness and tedium, as highlighted by KonsoliFIN and CGMagazine. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while Herdling offers a charming and accessible gameplay experience, it ultimately suffers from a lack of depth and polish. Many reviewers, including Shacknews and Metro GameCentral, acknowledged the potential for emotional engagement and enjoyment but emphasized that the gameplay mechanics need refinement to enhance fluidity and challenge. The game appears to cater well to casual players seeking a calm and contemplative experience, but those looking for more intricate gameplay may find it lacking. The combination of intuitive controls and light puzzles creates a foundation for enjoyment, yet the execution leaves room for improvement, as echoed by multiple critics across different platforms.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Herdling" impresses critics with its stunning painterly art style and vibrant visuals, especially on PC and PS5, enhancing exploration and immersion. However, the game falters on Nintendo Switch, suffering from washed-out graphics, blurry textures, and frame rate drops, ultimately overshadowing its artistic merits.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

73%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

20%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The opinions regarding the graphics and visual design of "Herdling" reveal a strong appreciation for its artistic direction and environmental aesthetics across various platforms. Critics like TechRadar Gaming and GamingBolt commend the game for its gorgeous painterly art style and vibrant colors, which enhance the exploration experience. Similarly, CGMagazine and Finger Guns highlight the beautiful aesthetics and charming atmosphere, noting the effective combination of cel-shading and semi-realistic details that contribute to an immersive experience. Reviewers from platforms like WellPlayed and KonsoliFIN echo these sentiments, emphasizing the stunning visuals and picturesque landscapes that create a captivating world for players. However, the criticisms primarily focus on the performance of the game, especially on the Nintendo Switch. Critics such as Hey Poor Player and Loot Level Chill point out that the graphics appear washed out and blurry, detracting from the overall experience. Nintendo Life and Pure Nintendo also mention performance issues, including muddy textures and frame rate drops, which diminish the visual appeal. Additionally, Eurogamer Germany notes a lack of depth in visual perspective, suggesting that while the individual elements may be beautiful, the overall execution suffers from technical limitations. In summary, the overall consensus among critics is that "Herdling" boasts a visually appealing world with a unique art style that enhances the gaming experience, particularly on higher-end platforms like PC and PS5. However, the game's performance on the Nintendo Switch is a significant drawback, with multiple reviewers highlighting issues such as washed-out graphics and frame rate inconsistencies. While the artistic vision is celebrated, the technical execution leaves room for improvement, particularly for players on less powerful hardware.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Herdling's sound design and music receive high praise for enhancing gameplay with beautiful melodies and emotional orchestral elements, creating a rich atmosphere. Critics commend the dynamic soundtrack that adapts to gameplay, immersing players deeper into the experience. However, some note shortcomings, including minimal audio relevance and a lack of variety, suggesting the music sometimes fades into the background. Overall, while not perfect, the soundtrack significantly contributes to the game's emotional depth and player enjoyment.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

79%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

17%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Herdling have garnered a largely positive reception from critics, many of whom praised the game's soundtrack as a standout feature that significantly enhances the overall experience. Reviewers from outlets such as Nintendo Life and Pure Nintendo highlighted the beautiful melodies and orchestral elements that complement the emotional tone of the game, creating a rich atmosphere that resonates with players. TechRadar Gaming and Shacknews echoed this sentiment, noting that the soft and emotional sound design works harmoniously with the visuals, further immersing players in the game world. Critics like GamingBolt and XboxEra emphasized the dynamic nature of the music, which adapts to gameplay moments, enhancing emotional highs and lows and contributing to an immersive experience. However, some reviewers pointed out notable shortcomings in the sound design. Gamereactor UK criticized the minimal audio relevance, stating that the game lacks dialogue and significant sound design, relying heavily on worldbuilding for storytelling. Similarly, Loot Level Chill mentioned that music often fades into the background, only becoming prominent during specific moments, such as stampedes. CGMagazine also noted a lack of variety in the soundtrack, describing it as whimsical but lacking significant emotional highs or lows. These critiques suggest that while the music is generally well-received, there are instances where its impact may not be as pronounced as some players might hope. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Herdling's sound design and music are strong components of the game that significantly enhance the player's experience. While there are criticisms regarding the minimalistic approach to sound design and occasional lack of variety in the soundtrack, the majority of reviewers, including those from GameSpot and WellPlayed, agree that the music beautifully complements the game's themes and emotional depth. The positive remarks about the orchestral score and its ability to evoke feelings of freedom and companionship indicate that, despite some shortcomings, the sound design and music are integral to the game's success and enjoyment.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Herdling struggles with significant technical issues across platforms, particularly on the Nintendo Switch and PS5, where game-breaking bugs and frame rate drops plague the experience. While the Switch 2 shows potential and the Xbox Series X is visually appealing, critics agree that the game needs serious optimization to enhance immersion and enjoyment. Overall, technical shortcomings overshadow the few positive aspects noted by reviewers.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

74%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

17%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Herdling varies significantly across different gaming platforms, with some positive aspects noted by critics. On the Nintendo Switch, despite the overall concerns, some reviewers like NintendoWorldReport observed that performance is generally smooth on the Switch 2, indicating a potential for better experiences on newer hardware. On PC, critics such as CGMagazine highlighted seamless controls and a generally playable experience, even if some gameplay mechanics felt awkward. Meanwhile, XboxEra pointed out that while the game is not technically amazing, it is visually appealing on the Xbox Series X, suggesting that aesthetic qualities may make up for some technical shortcomings. However, the negatives for each platform are quite pronounced. The Nintendo Switch version is widely criticized for various technical issues, with Gamereactor UK noting game-breaking bugs and camera problems that severely hinder gameplay. Other critics like Loot Level Chill and Nintendo Life echoed similar sentiments, mentioning blurry visuals, frame rate drops, and immersion issues. On PC, while some reviews were positive, Eurogamer Germany pointed out stability problems on the Steam Deck, and Softpedia mentioned graphical glitches that detract from the experience. The PlayStation 5 version also faced scrutiny, with critics like Gaming Nexus and KonsoliFIN highlighting persistent frame rate issues and control problems that could detract from enjoyment, although Metro GameCentral noted a generally stable experience. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates that Herdling suffers from significant technical performance issues across most platforms, particularly on the Nintendo Switch and PS5. While there are some bright spots, such as the stable performance on the Switch 2 and the visual appeal on the Xbox Series X, the overwhelming feedback suggests that technical shortcomings, including frame rate drops and bugs, hinder the overall experience. Critics like Gamereactor UK and WellPlayed emphasize that these issues are frustrating enough to impact immersion and enjoyment, making it clear that the game requires further optimization and refinement to meet player expectations.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics view Herdling as a charming, emotionally engaging experience, boosted by collectibles and randomized elements that offer some replayability. However, its short 4-6 hour gameplay and simplistic mechanics dampen enthusiasm for multiple playthroughs, leading many to see it as a one-time adventure rather than a game worth revisiting.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

61%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

30%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions regarding the replay value of Herdling present a mixed but somewhat positive view from several critics. Some reviewers, like TechRadar Gaming and Finger Guns, highlight aspects that enhance replayability, such as the presence of collectibles and the randomization of Calicorns, which can lead to unique experiences in each playthrough. Additionally, critics like GameSpot and Shacknews emphasize the emotional journey and connection with the creatures, suggesting that these elements may draw players back for a second experience. This emotional engagement is noted as a significant factor that could encourage revisits, as it allows players to relive their journey and the bonds formed with the calicorns. On the other hand, a substantial number of critics express concerns about the game's replay value due to its short length and simplistic gameplay mechanics. Reviews from Gamereactor UK, Eurogamer, and GameBlast point out that the game is relatively brief, with playtimes averaging around 4-6 hours, which inherently limits the incentive for players to return after completing it. Many critics, including Softpedia and KonsoliFIN, also note that the lack of depth in gameplay and the linear nature of the experience contribute to a feeling of repetitiveness, making it less likely for players to want to replay the game once they have finished it. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while Herdling offers a charming and emotionally resonant experience, its replay value is significantly hampered by its short duration and straightforward mechanics. Critics such as Eurogamer Germany and TheSixthAxis reinforce this viewpoint by stating that the game feels more like a one-time experience rather than one that invites multiple playthroughs. While there are elements that can enhance replayability, such as emotional connections and collectible content, the overarching sentiment leans towards the idea that the game may not hold players' interest for long-term engagement.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

58%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

42%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment surrounding "Herdling" is notably positive, with many critics highlighting its charm and emotional depth. Reviewers such as Gamereactor UK and Pure Nintendo appreciate the game's unique premise and beautiful landscapes, noting that it offers a heartfelt adventure that resonates emotionally. Critics like Finger Guns and GameSpot emphasize the engaging narrative and the bond between the characters and their animals, describing it as a memorable experience that showcases the artistic potential of video games. The game's soundtrack and atmosphere have also received praise, with TechRadar Gaming noting its stunning visuals and sound, which contribute to the overall enchanting experience. However, despite its many strengths, "Herdling" is not without its flaws. Multiple critics, including Nintendo Life and Hey Poor Player, point out significant technical issues, particularly on the Nintendo Switch, which detract from the overall experience. Janky controls and performance problems are recurring themes in the reviews, with critics like TheSixthAxis and Metro GameCentral mentioning that these issues hinder the gameplay experience. Additionally, some reviewers, such as Eurogamer Germany and Gamekult, criticize the game's pacing and simplistic gameplay, suggesting that it lacks the depth and challenge found in other titles within the genre. The overall consensus among critics is that "Herdling" is a charming and emotionally engaging experience that is worth trying, especially for those who appreciate narrative depth and artistic expression. While many reviewers acknowledge its gameplay shortcomings and technical issues, they also recognize the game's potential and beauty. Critics like Gaming Nexus and WellPlayed highlight that, despite its flaws, "Herdling" offers a unique adventure that can resonate with players, making it a commendable indie title. Ultimately, the game appears to be more suited for players who value atmosphere and emotional storytelling over challenging gameplay.

TL;DR

"Herdling" is a charming indie game lauded for its emotional depth and beautiful landscapes, captivating critics with its heartfelt narrative and artistic potential. However, it suffers from notable technical issues, especially on the Nintendo Switch, with janky controls and pacing complaints. Despite these flaws, it’s recommended for players who prioritize atmosphere and storytelling over challenging gameplay.

MONSTER

Reviews

63 reviews found

GameSpot

Aug 21, 2025