MonsterCritic
Fairy Tail 2 cover image
Links
Playstation Icon
Playstation
Twitch Icon
Twitch

66

MONSTER

Star Icon

Fairy Tail 2

2024
GenresAdventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, RPG, Military and Warfare, Single Player, Multiplayer
AvailableDec 11, 2024
PlatformPlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, PC
DeveloperGust
Overview

The sequel to the 2020 "FAIRY TAIL" console game has finally arrived! Play as Fairy Tail guild members such as protagonists Natsu or Lucy, and experience first-hand how the dramatic events unfold in the series' climactic Alvarez Empire Arc. Enjoy epic battles against Zeref, the Emperor of the Alvarez Empire, his team of elites, the Spriggan 12, and the Black Dragon Acnologia.

Elsewhere
Score icon

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

63

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2 nails the Alvarez Empire arc with epic battles and emotional fan-service, but its rushed pacing, inaccessible plot, and repetitive combat alienate newcomers, prioritizing nostalgia over clarity or innovation.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

63

Positive Reviews (80-100)

17%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

67%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

17%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Fairy Tail 2 receives praise for its faithful adaptation of the Alvarez Empire arc from the original anime and manga, with critics like GameSpew and Wccftech highlighting its engaging narrative, dramatic scenes, and epic battles that align with the source material. GameGrin notes that the game improves on the first title’s storytelling, while Vandal appreciates the inclusion of a new epilogue by the series’ creator, adding a sense of closure. The game’s focus on character interactions and well-executed anime-style combat sequences, as mentioned by GamingTrend and PlaySense, contributes to its entertainment value, particularly for fans familiar with the series. Additionally, the condensed narrative emphasizing character dynamics over plot detail, as observed by Digitally Downloaded, is seen as a strength for those who prioritize emotional engagement over intricate world-building. These positives underscore the game’s dedication to capturing the spirit of Fairy Tail’s lore while delivering a visually and emotionally resonant experience. However, the story faces significant criticism for its accessibility issues and narrative shortcomings. Multiple reviewers, including GameGrin, God is a Geek, and MeuPlayStation, point out that newcomers struggle with the plot due to pacing problems, missing context, and an overreliance on prior knowledge of the series. Noisy Pixel and Multiplayer.it specifically call out rushed character development and a lack of depth, while Digitally Downloaded and Pure Nintendo note that the focus on combat overshadows storytelling. The abundance of campfire scenes, criticized by God is a Geek and others, is seen as filler that fails to enrich the narrative. Additionally, some changes to the original arc, as highlighted by Oyungezer, create confusion, and the game’s repetitive battles and predictable themes, as mentioned by XboxEra, may feel unoriginal to those outside the fandom. These issues collectively suggest a narrative that prioritizes nostalgia over clarity or innovation. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Fairy Tail 2 is a mixed experience, heavily tailored to existing fans while posing challenges for newcomers. While it succeeds in translating the Alvarez Empire arc’s intensity and emotional beats—particularly praised by GameSpew, Wccftech, and Vandal—the execution often falls short in terms of pacing, character depth, and contextual clarity. Reviews like those from GameGrin and PlaySense acknowledge improvements over the first game but stress that the story’s complexity and reliance on prior knowledge may alienate casual players. Meanwhile, critics such as Multiplayer.it and RPGamer highlight the incomplete feel of the adaptation, with key moments and characters omitted. Despite these flaws, the game’s dedication to its source material and its ability to deliver thrilling battles and familiar character dynamics keep it appealing to core fans, even if it fails to fully satisfy those seeking a self-contained or more nuanced narrative.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Fairy Tail 2 nails the Alvarez Empire arc with epic battles and emotional fan-service, but its rushed pacing, inaccessible plot, and repetitive combat alienate newcomers, prioritizing nostalgia over clarity or innovation.

72

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2 delivers blistering, flashy combat with a sleek ATB system and dynamic character swaps, but its repetitive battles, shallow strategy, and grind-heavy mechanics undermine long-term appeal—a polarizing mix of vibrant action and formulaic flaws.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

72

Positive Reviews (80-100)

42%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

8%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Fairy Tail 2 receives praise for its evolution and dynamic combat mechanics, with several critics highlighting its fast-paced and engaging systems. GameGrin and GameSpew commend the active time battle (ATB) system, noting its intuitive design and the ability to switch characters mid-fight, which adds variety and strategic flexibility. God is a Geek and Noisy Pixel emphasize the real-time action, flashy magic attacks, and addictive mechanics rooted in depleting enemy break gauges, while MeuPlayStation and PlaySense appreciate the hybrid approach blending turn-based and action elements, offering dynamic battles and character progression. Additionally, Nintendo Life and RPG Fan acknowledge improvements over its predecessor, with the new ATB-inspired combat and exploration systems providing a more immersive experience. Critics like SpazioGames and Hooked Gamers also praise the tactical depth, party customization, and the fun power fantasy of customizable magic abilities, suggesting the game successfully modernizes its core mechanics for a more interactive experience. However, the gameplay faces criticism for its repetitiveness and lack of depth, with multiple reviewers pointing out formulaic encounters and shallow strategic options. GameOver.gr and GamingTrend describe the combat as simplistic, with "lifeless" or "formulaic" battles that fail to deliver meaningful challenges. Oyungezer and XboxEra specifically call out the regression in tactical elements, noting that normal battles feel repetitive and that poor enemy AI turns fights into endurance tests. Player 2 mentions a reduction in playable characters compared to the previous game, while RPGamer criticizes "feature bloat" and inconsistent pacing. Digitally Downloaded and Vandal also highlight issues with grindy mechanics, such as enemy shields and a lack of variety in side quests, which detract from the overall engagement. These critiques suggest that while the combat system is visually appealing and accessible, it struggles to maintain long-term interest or complexity. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed, with a clear emphasis on the game’s improved combat systems and accessibility, but recurring concerns about repetition and depth. The shift to real-time or hybrid combat mechanics is seen as a positive step by many, including GameGrin, Noisy Pixel, and SpazioGames, who praise its fluidity and variety. Yet, the lack of strategic complexity, predictable enemy behavior, and repetitive structures are frequently cited as drawbacks, particularly by GameOver.gr, Oyungezer, and XboxEra. While some reviewers, like God is a Geek and Nintendo Life, appreciate the rewarding progression and exploration, others, such as Digitally Downloaded and Vandal, feel the experience falls short of expectations. The game’s strengths lie in its fast-paced action and character customization, but its weaknesses—especially in balancing depth with engagement—create a polarizing reception that reflects both its potential and its shortcomings.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Fairy Tail 2 delivers blistering, flashy combat with a sleek ATB system and dynamic character swaps, but its repetitive battles, shallow strategy, and grind-heavy mechanics undermine long-term appeal—a polarizing mix of vibrant action and formulaic flaws.

68

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2 dazzles with cel-shaded anime flair and vibrant animation, but cheap models, blurry textures, and clunky performance sink its polish, delivering a mixed bag of nostalgia and underwhelming tech.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

68

Positive Reviews (80-100)

30%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

52%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

17%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The Graphics and Visual Design of Fairy Tail 2 received praise for its efforts to translate the anime’s iconic style into a 3D format. Critics like GameGrin highlighted noticeable improvements in visual fidelity, animation, and lighting, noting that the game effectively recreates the source material’s aesthetic. GameSpew and GamingTrend commended the vibrant visuals and well-animated cutscenes, with the latter emphasizing the successful use of cell shading to showcase "vibrant colors and well-done landscapes." God is a Geek (PS5) and Worth Playing both lauded the "gorgeous visuals" and "stylish and vivid animation," respectively, while XGN appreciated the game’s ability to capture the anime’s essence through "fitting character reactions and animations." Pure Nintendo praised the "modern cartoony look" that enhances character diversity and combat liveliness, and Digitally Downloaded (Switch) acknowledged the game’s large, exploratory worlds despite hardware limitations. These positive remarks underscore the game’s commitment to honoring its source material’s art direction and energetic tone. However, several critics pointed out significant technical and artistic shortcomings. GameOver.gr and Multiplayer.it criticized the "cheap character models" and "poorly executed 3D modeling," while PlaySense and Vandal noted issues like "blurry edges," "inconsistent shadow effects," and "empty environments." Nintendo Life and RPG Fan highlighted "splotchy shadows," "low-res textures," and "low-budget graphics," with the latter struggling to convey the scale of action sequences. SpazioGames and Wccftech described the visuals as "subpar for the current generation" and "lacking detail in locations," respectively, while XboxEra criticized "poor visual performance," "slow loading menus," and "low framerates." These critiques often focused on technical limitations, repetitive level design, and a lack of polish, which detracted from the overall experience despite the game’s stylistic ambitions. The overall consensus among critics is mixed, with a clear divide between the game’s artistic aspirations and its technical execution. While many praised its cel-shaded visuals, vibrant color palette, and faithful recreation of the anime’s style—especially on PS5 and PC—others found the graphics underwhelming, citing low-resolution textures, outdated character models, and performance issues. Digitally Downloaded (Switch) and XboxEra (PC) both noted platform-specific limitations, with the former suggesting the visuals might be better on other systems. The game’s visual design seems to strike a balance between nostalgia and modern expectations, but its inconsistencies and technical flaws prevent it from fully realizing its potential. Ultimately, Fairy Tail 2 is seen as a visually ambitious title that captures the spirit of the anime but falls short in delivering a polished, high-fidelity experience across all platforms.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Fairy Tail 2 dazzles with cel-shaded anime flair and vibrant animation, but cheap models, blurry textures, and clunky performance sink its polish, delivering a mixed bag of nostalgia and underwhelming tech.

75

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2’s sound design and music masterfully channel the anime’s spirit with dynamic battle themes, nostalgic melodies, and stellar voice acting, boosting immersion for fans. Yet, the lack of an English dub, tonal mismatches, and reliance on familiar tracks without innovation left some critics underwhelmed. A triumph for purists, but its conservative approach misses chances to evolve, prioritizing nostalgia over risk.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

75

Positive Reviews (80-100)

42%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

58%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Fairy Tail 2 received generally positive feedback from critics, with many highlighting their ability to evoke the spirit of the original anime. GameGrin praised the "extensive voice acting" led by the original Japanese cast, which they argued "enhances the overall experience," while GamingTrend noted that the inclusion of anime-era tracks "makes it feel like watching the show," effectively reinforcing the game’s nostalgic and immersive atmosphere. Vandal described the sound design as "solid," emphasizing the blend of "rock and relaxing melodies" that align with the series’ tone, and RPGamer commended the audio department for "great voice acting and music that evokes the anime's soundtrack effectively." Additionally, RPG Fan and XGN both celebrated the "top-notch" and "dynamic" battle themes, as well as the "appropriate voice acting and sound effects" that complemented the anime-inspired visuals. These reviews collectively underscore the game’s success in translating the original series’ audio identity into a cohesive and engaging experience. However, some critics pointed out notable drawbacks. Multiplayer.it noted that while the music was "pleasant," it often felt "mismatched with the story's tone," despite its "good variety" in combat scenarios. SpazioGames, while praising the "faithful" soundtrack, did not highlight the sound design itself, suggesting it may lack depth beyond the music. The absence of an English dub was a recurring negative, with PlaySense and RPG Fan explicitly stating that it "may disappoint some players," and Player 2 acknowledging that the "lack of English voice acting may deter some." Vandal also mentioned that the audio "doesn’t innovate beyond the original," implying a reliance on familiar elements without significant evolution. These critiques indicate that while the audio quality is strong, certain aspects—particularly accessibility and originality—fell short of expectations for some audiences. Overall, the consensus among critics leans toward appreciation for Fairy Tail 2’s sound design and music, which effectively channel the anime’s essence through faithful compositions and strong voice acting. While most reviewers praised the nostalgic and atmospheric elements, the lack of an English dub and occasional tonal mismatches in the music were seen as limitations. The game’s audio department is viewed as a highlight for fans of the original series, but its reliance on established themes and absence of innovation, as noted by Vandal, suggests it prioritizes familiarity over creative risk. Despite these critiques, the majority of reviews emphasize that the sound design and music significantly enhance the game’s immersion and emotional resonance, making them a key strength for those seeking a faithful adaptation.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Fairy Tail 2’s sound design and music masterfully channel the anime’s spirit with dynamic battle themes, nostalgic melodies, and stellar voice acting, boosting immersion for fans. Yet, the lack of an English dub, tonal mismatches, and reliance on familiar tracks without innovation left some critics underwhelmed. A triumph for purists, but its conservative approach misses chances to evolve, prioritizing nostalgia over risk.

73

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2’s Japanese voice acting is a standout, praised for its authenticity and emotional depth, but the lack of an English dub hampers accessibility, marking it as a fan-focused triumph with a significant drawback.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

73

Positive Reviews (80-100)

27%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

73%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Fairy Tail 2 receives largely positive feedback from critics, with many highlighting its strong alignment with the original anime’s spirit. GameGrin and Vandal both emphasize that the game retains the original Japanese cast, which fans of the anime will appreciate for its authenticity and familiarity. MeuPlayStation praises the emotional depth added by the voice performances, particularly in dramatic moments, while XGN notes that the actors deliver expected character reactions and humor, staying true to the source material. RPGamer also commends the Japanese voice cast for bringing the characters to life, reinforcing the game’s connection to the beloved series. These reviews collectively underscore that the voice acting enhances immersion and captures the essence of the anime, making it a highlight for enthusiasts. However, several critics point out the lack of an English dub as a significant drawback. Multiplayer.it and PlaySense explicitly mention that exclusive Japanese voice acting may limit accessibility for non-Japanese speakers, with PlaySense noting this as a potential downside for some players. RPG Fan and Player 2 echo this sentiment, with RPG Fan expressing disappointment that the English dub from the anime isn’t included, and Player 2 acknowledging the absence but stating it’s a familiar trade-off in Gust RPGs. While XboxEra praises the voice acting’s charm, they also critique the narrative’s lack of engagement, which indirectly highlights the importance of clear, expressive dialogue in storytelling. These critiques suggest that the game’s voice acting, though technically strong, could alienate players who prefer or rely on English audio. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the Japanese voice acting in Fairy Tail 2 is a standout feature, effectively translating the anime’s energy and character dynamics into the game. While most reviewers agree that the original cast’s performances are authentic and impactful, the absence of an English dub is a recurring concern, particularly for those outside Japan or unfamiliar with the language. Despite this, many critics recognize the trade-off as a deliberate choice to honor the source material, with GameGrin and XGN emphasizing its value for fans. The mixed reactions reflect a balance between celebrating the voice acting’s quality and acknowledging its accessibility limitations, ultimately positioning it as a strong but niche aspect of the game’s appeal.

TL;DR

voice acting

Fairy Tail 2’s Japanese voice acting is a standout, praised for its authenticity and emotional depth, but the lack of an English dub hampers accessibility, marking it as a fan-focused triumph with a significant drawback.

54

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2’s tech performance is a mixed bag—PS5 and PC offer smoother runs but suffer from frame drops, crashes, and graphical flaws; Nintendo Switch struggles with inconsistent frame rates, clunky UI, and long load times. While no platform is flawless, the game’s lack of improvement over its predecessor and persistent hiccups across all systems fail to meet modern action RPG standards, despite minor platform-specific wins.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

54

Positive Reviews (80-100)

21%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

36%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

43%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Fairy Tail 2 varies across platforms, with some critics highlighting positive aspects. On the PS5, GameGrin praised the game for its smooth performance and minimal loading screens, creating a seamless exploration experience, while PlaySense noted that it generally runs at a stable 60fps, which is a strong point for a console version. Player 2, reviewing the PC version, commended its good framerate and stability, and Wccftech acknowledged that it runs well with high settings and resolution, despite minor hiccups. For the Nintendo Switch, Digitally Downloaded suggested the game might struggle with detail and frame rates, though this was framed as a potential limitation rather than a definitive flaw. These reviews indicate that the game’s technical execution is more consistent on the PS5 and PC, with the Switch version showing some early concerns but not as many outright negatives as others. However, the negatives for Fairy Tail 2 are more pronounced. On the PS5, GameOver.gr criticized the game for low-quality graphics and animations, while MeuPlayStation and PlaySense pointed to frame drops during specific encounters and boss fights, respectively. Multiplayer.it and Vandal also noted technical limitations and performance fluctuations, with the latter highlighting a lack of content in exploration phases. The Nintendo Switch version faced more direct issues: Nintendo Life reported inconsistent frame rates and struggles with fast movements, and RPG Fan detailed long loading times, clipping issues, and a problematic UI on the Switch Lite, alongside localization errors. On PC, RPGamer and SpazioGames raised significant concerns, with the former citing frequent crashes and the latter criticizing weak character textures despite well-crafted cutscenes. Wccftech also mentioned low framerates and slow menu loading, underscoring the platform’s mixed reception. Overall, the technical performance of Fairy Tail 2 is a mixed bag, with the PS5 version receiving the most balanced feedback. While it has frame drops and some graphical shortcomings, its smoothness and stability are often praised, as seen in GameGrin’s and PlaySense’s reviews. The Nintendo Switch version, however, faces more systemic issues, including performance inconsistencies and UI problems, which RPG Fan and Nintendo Life emphasized. The PC port, though capable of high settings, struggles with crashes, texture quality, and framerates, as noted by RPGamer and SpazioGames. Despite these differences, the consensus among critics is that the game’s technical execution is a major concern, with the PS5 version being the most polished but still falling short of expectations. The lack of significant improvements over its predecessor, as mentioned by Multiplayer.it, and the presence of performance hiccups across all platforms suggest that Fairy Tail 2 fails to meet the technical standards expected of a modern action RPG, despite some individual platform-specific strengths.

TL;DR

technical performance

Fairy Tail 2’s tech performance is a mixed bag—PS5 and PC offer smoother runs but suffer from frame drops, crashes, and graphical flaws; Nintendo Switch struggles with inconsistent frame rates, clunky UI, and long load times. While no platform is flawless, the game’s lack of improvement over its predecessor and persistent hiccups across all systems fail to meet modern action RPG standards, despite minor platform-specific wins.

57

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2’s replay value hinges on fan-service DLC and post-credits content, but repetitive quests, minimal side content, and a linear structure make it a play-and-forget title. Unlockable episodes and a bonus epilogue add depth, yet its reliance on prior knowledge and lack of innovation limit appeal to a niche audience—leaving general players unimpressed.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

57

Positive Reviews (80-100)

6%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

71%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

24%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The reviews for Fairy Tail 2 highlight several positive aspects of its replay value, particularly for fans of the franchise. Critics like MeuPlayStation and XGN note that DLC characters and post-credits content, such as the Key to the Unknown storyline, add layers of engagement for dedicated players. PlaySense and SpazioGames also point to post-game content, character interactions, and unlockable episodes, which can entice fans to revisit the game. Additionally, RPG Fan emphasizes that unlockable character episodes and a bonus epilogue provide extra incentives for those already familiar with the series. These elements suggest that while the core experience may lack depth, the game offers enough tailored content to justify multiple playthroughs for enthusiasts. However, the negatives surrounding replay value are more pronounced, with many critics criticizing the game’s lack of variety and engagement. GamingTrend and Multiplayer.it argue that the game’s predictable structure and minimal side content fail to sustain interest, while Vandal and Worth Playing highlight repetitive quests and a lack of exploration as major drawbacks. Digitally Downloaded and Pure Nintendo describe the game as a “play-and-forget” experience, emphasizing its short length and limited appeal for newcomers. GameGrin and GameSpew also note that the game’s complexity and reliance on prior knowledge of the franchise may alienate players unfamiliar with Fairy Tail, further reducing its replayability. These critiques collectively underscore a design that prioritizes narrative over sustained gameplay. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Fairy Tail 2 has limited replay value for general audiences but may retain some appeal for fans of the series. While MeuPlayStation and XGN acknowledge that DLC and post-credits content add value, most reviewers, including Digitally Downloaded and XboxEra, conclude that the game’s linear structure, repetitive gameplay, and lack of meaningful side content make it a one-time experience. The divide between fan-specific incentives and broader accessibility issues suggests that the game’s replayability is heavily dependent on prior familiarity with the Fairy Tail universe, leaving it with a niche appeal rather than broad longevity.

TL;DR

replay value

Fairy Tail 2’s replay value hinges on fan-service DLC and post-credits content, but repetitive quests, minimal side content, and a linear structure make it a play-and-forget title. Unlockable episodes and a bonus epilogue add depth, yet its reliance on prior knowledge and lack of innovation limit appeal to a niche audience—leaving general players unimpressed.

Overall verdict

Overall Verdict

66

MONSTER

Star Icon

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

66

Positive Reviews (80-100)

19%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

78%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

3%

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment among critics towards Fairy Tail 2 leans positively for fans of the franchise, with several reviewers highlighting its improvements over the original and its engaging gameplay. GameGrin praised it as a "significant improvement" with "enjoyable gameplay and a beloved cast," while GameSpew and God is a Geek emphasized its appeal to series fans, noting its "engaging RPG experience" and "dynamic and engaging experience" with "strategic combat." XGN called it a "must-play for fans," applauding its "faithful adaptation of the anime" and post-credits content. Many critics, including GamingTrend and MeuPlayStation, acknowledged the game’s stronger content for dedicated followers, with Noisy Pixel praising its "improved exploration and fast-paced combat" and "character-focused moments." These positives underscore the game’s strengths in delivering a polished, fan-service-heavy RPG that resonates with those already familiar with the source material. However, the game faces significant criticism for its accessibility issues, pacing, and technical flaws, which detract from its broader appeal. GameOver.gr and Multiplayer.it argued that Fairy Tail 2 is "primarily aimed at die-hard fans" and a "missed opportunity" for a wider audience, while GamingTrend and PlaySense pointed to "pacing issues" and "technical shortcomings" that hinder enjoyment. Critics like Noisy Pixel and SpazioGames highlighted "rushed pacing" and "poor performance," with Hooked Gamers noting "lacklustre environments" and "confusing story elements." Additionally, Oyungezer outright dismissed the game as "recommended to be avoided," and RPGamer criticized its "technical problems" and "struggles with identity as an adaptation." These critiques collectively paint a picture of a game that, while enjoyable for fans, struggles with execution and accessibility for newcomers. The overall consensus among critics is that Fairy Tail 2 is a competent, fan-focused sequel that delivers on nostalgia and gameplay but falls short in addressing broader appeal. While GameGrin, Vandal, and Nintendo Life acknowledged its improvements and "heartwarming character interactions," the recurring themes of limited exploration, repetitive elements, and reliance on prior knowledge (as noted by Pure Nintendo and RPG Fan) suggest it remains a niche experience. Despite its flaws, the game’s strengths in combat, character design, and franchise loyalty—highlighted by critics like XGN and God is a Geek—ensure it remains a worthwhile purchase for dedicated fans. However, the mixed reception underscores a divide between those who prioritize fan service and those who seek a more universally accessible RPG, leaving Fairy Tail 2 as a polarizing but ultimately satisfying entry for its target audience.

TL;DR

Fairy Tail 2 is a fan-service-packed RPG with tight combat and nostalgia, but technical issues, uneven pacing, and narrow appeal make it a polarizing, niche experience—worth it for devotees, a miss for others.

66

MONSTER

Star Icon

Reviews

68 reviews found

80

XGN

PlayStation 5

Dec 11, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a must-play for fans of the series, offering a dynamic and engaging experience with strategic combat, faithful adaptation of the anime, and additional post-credits content.


80

Digitally Downloaded

Nintendo Switch

Dec 16, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a competent JRPG that may not stand out among its peers but offers comfort food gaming for fans of the genre.

Read full review

Full review

79

RPG Fan

Nintendo Switch

Dec 11, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a decent action RPG that will mainly appeal to fans of the anime/manga series. While it has its strengths in gameplay and character adaptation, technical and graphical limitations may hinder broader enjoyment.

Read full review

Full review

78

Vandal

PlayStation 5

Dec 27, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a commendable sequel that improves upon its predecessor, offering an enjoyable experience for fans of the franchise, despite some technical shortcomings and limited exploration content.


75

Hooked Gamers

PC

Feb 12, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is enjoyable for fans of Fairy Tail but may not attract newcomers. It has fun combat and great art direction, but suffers from lacklustre environments and confusing story elements.

Read full review

Full review

75

Worth Playing

PlayStation 5

Dec 11, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a lovely RPG for fans of the franchise, offering an enjoyable experience with over-the-top combat and RPG mechanics. It heavily relies on fan service and may not appeal to those unfamiliar with the series.

Read full review

Full review

75

GameGrin

PlayStation 5

Dec 13, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a significant improvement over its predecessor, offering enjoyable gameplay and a beloved cast, though pacing issues and accessibility for newcomers remain concerns.

Read full review

Full review

70

Nintendo Life

Nintendo Switch

Dec 11, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is a middle-of-the-road licensed game that offers improvements over its predecessor, with lively combat, rewarding exploration, and heartwarming character interactions making it worthwhile for franchise fans.

Read full review

Full review

70

GameSpew

PlayStation 5

Dec 11, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Fairy Tail 2 is an enjoyable RPG that fans of the series will appreciate, though newcomers may struggle without prior knowledge of the characters and story.

Read full review

Full review
Similar Games
left arrow
left arrow
sliderImage
Star Icon

80

Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes

2022
sliderImage
Star Icon

82

Monster Hunter Rise

2021
sliderImage
Star Icon

78

Tom Clancy's The Division 2

2019
sliderImage
Star Icon

72

Dragon Ball Z: Kakarot

2020
sliderImage
Star Icon

79

Yakuza Kiwami

2017
sliderImage
Star Icon

74

Darksiders Genesis

2019
sliderImage
Star Icon

82

Nioh

2017
sliderImage
Star Icon

78

Like a Dragon Gaiden: The Man Who Erased His Name

2023
sliderImage
Star Icon

83

Dragon Age: Inquisition

2014
sliderImage
Star Icon

84

Monster Hunter Rise: Sunbreak

2022
sliderImage
Star Icon

79

Granblue Fantasy: Relink

2024
sliderImage
Star Icon

81

Nioh 2

2020
sliderImage
Star Icon

72

No Straight Roads

2020
sliderImage
Star Icon

73

Fire Emblem Warriors

2017
sliderImage

75

Darksiders II: Deathinitive Edition

2015
sliderImage

71

Warriors Orochi 4

2018
sliderImage

87

Destiny 2: The Witch Queen

2022
sliderImage

78

Dragon Quest Heroes II

2017
sliderImage

72

God Eater 2: Rage Burst

2016

About

Contact Us

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Navigation

Home

Search

Games


Follow Us

© 2025 MonsterCritic