Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Twitch

MONSTER

Trials of Mana

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Trials of Mana
Item: Trials of Mana
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2020

GenresFantasy, Adventure, Action, Platformer, Shooter, Comedy, RPG, Top-Down Perspective, Anime and JRPG, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableApr 24, 2020

PlatformPC, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 4

DeveloperXeen

Overview

Seiken Densetsu 3 is a 1995 action role-playing game developed and published by Square (now Square Enix) for the Super Nintendo Entertainment System. It is the sequel to the 1993 game Seiken Densetsu 2 (released outside Japan as Secret of Mana), and is the third game in the Mana series.

Elsewhere

8.0

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

36%

Mixed (50-79)

56%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of the critics regarding the story of Trials of Mana are varied, showcasing both positive and negative aspects. Several critics, such as Easy Allies and Hardcore Gamer, appreciate the game's multiple storylines depending on the hero chosen, adding depth to the narrative and providing replay value. RPG Fan also praises the engaging storyline with different villainous factions related to the heroes of choice, contributing to replayability. Additionally, RPG Site highlights the innovative storytelling with multiple intertwining plotlines, interesting character interactions, and standout moments for certain characters like Kevin. These elements contribute positively to the overall storytelling experience of Trials of Mana. On the other hand, critics like COGconnected and Slant Magazine criticize the story for having paper-thin characters, disjointed narratives, and lacking substance or meaningful choices. PC Invasion mentions that the narrative is simple, familiar, and populated with one-dimensional archetypes, with aggravating dialogue and poor presentation in cutscenes. Metro GameCentral goes as far as to describe the storytelling as weak, with awful dialogue and voice-acting that limit the game's appeal considerably. These criticisms point towards a lack of depth, emotional engagement, and coherence in the storytelling of Trials of Mana, which may hinder the overall experience for some players. Overall, the consensus among the critics leans towards a mixed reception of the story in Trials of Mana. While some reviewers appreciate the game's multiple storylines, character interactions, and replay value, others highlight issues such as one-dimensional characters, cliched elements, and weak storytelling. The game's loyalty to the original plot, diverse character choices, and different narrative outcomes based on player decisions are acknowledged positively. However, the lack of emotional engagement, underdeveloped narratives, and predictable plot twists are noted as drawbacks by several critics. Ultimately, the reception of the story in Trials of Mana appears to be subjective, with some critics finding enjoyment in its simplicity and charm, while others feel it falls short in delivering a compelling and immersive narrative experience.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics have mixed opinions on Trials of Mana's story. Some praise its multiple storylines and engaging narratives with replay value, while others criticize the paper-thin characters, disjointed plots, and lack of substance. Positive aspects include innovative storytelling and standout moments for certain characters, while negative points highlight weak dialogue and underdeveloped narratives. Overall, the game's storytelling is subjective, appealing to some for its charm but falling short for others in delivering a compelling narrative experience.

Gameplay Mechanics

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

74%

Mixed (50-79)

22%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Trials of Mana has received praise from several critics for its engaging combat mechanics and character customization options. Critics like Gamer.nl and NintendoWorldReport have highlighted the fast-paced and challenging nature of the combat, with real-time battles that require strategy and timing. The inclusion of unique abilities for each character, a variety of class types, and the rewarding class change system have been commended for adding depth to the gameplay experience. Additionally, the game's action-oriented battles, dynamic combat, and seamless combat transitions have been lauded by critics such as GameSpace and DualShockers. On the other hand, some critics have pointed out various shortcomings in the gameplay of Trials of Mana. DarkStation and Windows Central have criticized the combat for being shallow, simple, and lacking in depth, especially in the early stages of the game. Issues with the targeting system, repetitive combat arenas, and lack of exploration opportunities have been mentioned by GameSkinny and Slant Magazine as detracting from the overall gameplay experience. Additionally, GameSpot highlighted that while the combat system is enjoyable, certain elements surrounding the battle mechanics can be confusing or obtuse, affecting the overall immersion. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the gameplay of Trials of Mana is mixed. While some reviewers like Game Informer and RPG Site appreciate the variety of combat styles, character progression, and strategic depth offered by the game, others such as DarkStation and Windows Central find the combat to be lacking in complexity and engagement. Despite differing opinions on specific aspects of the gameplay, the majority of critics acknowledge the game's strengths in terms of character customization, class progression, and real-time combat mechanics. Ultimately, Trials of Mana seems to offer a blend of enjoyable action-oriented battles and strategic depth, albeit with some room for improvement in terms of combat complexity and exploration opportunities.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Critics praise Trials of Mana for its engaging combat mechanics, character customization, and real-time battles that require strategy and timing. Some find the combat shallow and repetitive, while others appreciate the variety of combat styles and character progression. Overall, opinions are mixed, with a consensus on the game's strengths in character customization and real-time combat, despite some room for improvement in combat complexity and exploration opportunities.

Graphics and Visual Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

44%

Mixed (50-79)

52%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The critics generally praised the graphics and visual design of Trials of Mana for its vibrant colors, detailed character models, and beautiful environments. Critics like Player 2 and DualShockers appreciated the refreshing and colorful visual design, reminiscent of classic RPGs like Ys VIII, with detailed characters and stunning 3D interpretations of the original 2D look. The game's transition to 3D was commended by Impulsegamer for breathing new life into the 25-year-old game, with modern and inviting visuals that capture the charm of the original while enhancing the overall visual and audio experience, as noted by MMORPG.com. On the negative side, some critics pointed out various issues with the graphics and visual design of Trials of Mana. Gamer.nl and DarkStation criticized the dated visuals, with landscapes and settlements described as uninteresting and character animations feeling stiff and misaligned. Slant Magazine and USgamer highlighted the cartoonish and generic 3D makeover that lacked the charm of the original pixel art, while Easy Allies mentioned rough textures and prevalent pop-in that detracted from the overall visual experience. Overall, the critics' opinions on the graphics and visual design of Trials of Mana were mixed. While some critics appreciated the colorful and vibrant 3D remake that captured the essence of the original game, others found the graphics lacking compared to more modern JRPGs or criticized specific aspects like character animations and repetitive environments. Despite the varied opinions, the general consensus seems to lean towards acknowledging the game's efforts in modernizing the classic title while also acknowledging its shortcomings in certain areas, ultimately making Trials of Mana a visually appealing but imperfect experience for players, as reflected in the diverse range of opinions provided by the critics.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Critics praised Trials of Mana for its vibrant graphics and detailed character models, reminiscent of classic RPGs, but some criticized the dated visuals and stiff animations. The game's transition to 3D was lauded for breathing new life into the classic title, although some found the 3D makeover lacking the charm of the original pixel art. Overall, opinions on the graphics were mixed, with some appreciating the colorful remake while others found it lacking compared to modern JRPGs. Critics noted the game's efforts in modernizing the classic title but also highlighted its imperfections, resulting in a visually appealing yet imperfect experience for players.

Music and Sound Design

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

46%

Mixed (50-79)

46%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The Sound Design and Music of Trials of Mana have garnered a mix of positive and negative feedback from critics. Many critics praised the soundtrack for its exceptional quality, with several noting the remixed and reorchestrated versions of the original compositions as standout features. CGMagazine appreciated the music's fidelity to the original while COGconnected highlighted the new compositions as complete and potent, steering away from the SNES soundtrack. Critics like MMORPG.com and TheSixthAxis commended the beautifully remade soundtrack with full orchestration, providing players with the option to switch between the modern and classic 16-bit versions. The music was often described as fantastic, delightful, and top-notch, enhancing the overall gaming experience with energetic battle themes and catchy melodies. On the flip side, the English voice acting in Trials of Mana received consistent criticism from multiple reviewers. Many critics, such as Destructoid, Game Informer, and RPG Fan, pointed out issues with inconsistent performances, odd character choices, and stilted delivery that detracted from the immersion. GameSpot and DarkStation specifically highlighted problems with hokey, amateurish, and even irritating voice acting, with some singling out specific characters like Charlotte for their lackluster performances. Worth Playing and GameSpace noted that the voice acting felt stilted and awkward, impacting the audio experience negatively. These criticisms were echoed across various reviews, indicating a widespread concern with the English voiceovers in the game. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of Trials of Mana leans towards the positive side despite the criticisms directed at the English voice acting. The exceptional quality of the soundtrack, featuring remixed, orchestral arrangements that pay homage to the original compositions, was a highlight for many reviewers. The option to switch between modern and classic soundtracks was also well-received, offering players a nostalgic experience with updated music. However, the inconsistent and subpar English voice acting was a recurring issue that dampened the overall audio experience for several critics. Despite this drawback, the majority of critics appreciated the effort put into the music design, with some even lauding it as superb and epic. The ability to customize the music and enjoy the delightful orchestral arrangements added depth to the gameplay, contributing positively to the overall reception of Trials of Mana.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics praised Trials of Mana for its exceptional soundtrack, featuring remixed classics and full orchestration. The option to switch between modern and classic versions was a hit. However, the English voice acting received consistent criticism for inconsistent performances and awkward delivery, detracting from the overall audio experience. Despite this, the majority of reviewers appreciated the top-notch music design, enhancing gameplay with energetic themes and catchy melodies.

Voice Acting

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

Mixed (50-79)

65%

Negative (0-49)

32%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Trials of Mana received mixed reviews from critics. Some positive aspects highlighted by reviewers include the distinct personalities brought out by the voice cast, as mentioned by Video Chums. Additionally, PlayStation LifeStyle appreciated how the voice acting added to the campy storytelling, fitting the characters well. Furthermore, USgamer praised Faerie's voice actor for being invested in the role, showcasing some standout performances within the cast. On the negative side, numerous critics criticized the English voice acting for being inconsistent and lacking emotional depth. CGMagazine and COGconnected both noted issues with clumsy and awkward deliveries, with some characters sounding unenthusiastic or even irritating. TheGamer and Twinfinite went as far as describing the voice acting as terrible and nearly unwatchable, pointing out miscasting and lackluster performances that detracted from the narrative experience. Specific characters like Charlotte received repeated criticism for their voice acting, such as in Windows Central and GameSpot's reviews, with mentions of annoyance and obnoxiousness affecting the overall immersion. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards a negative view of the voice acting in Trials of Mana. While there were some commendable performances and moments that added to the storytelling and character dynamics, the general sentiment is that the English voice cast fell short in consistency, emotional delivery, and matching character personalities. The recommendation to switch to the Japanese voice option was a common thread among reviewers like Game Informer, GameSpew, and Nintendo Insider, suggesting that the alternative language track provided a more immersive and coherent experience for players. The criticisms regarding the voice acting in Trials of Mana seem to outweigh the positive aspects, indicating that it may be an aspect of the game that could have been improved to enhance the overall enjoyment for players.

TL;DR

voice acting

Critics had mixed reviews on the voice acting in Trials of Mana, praising some standout performances but heavily criticizing the English cast for inconsistency and lack of emotional depth. Many described it as terrible and nearly unwatchable, with specific characters like Charlotte receiving repeated criticism for being annoying and obnoxious. The consensus leans towards a negative view, with recommendations to switch to the Japanese voice option for a more immersive experience. Overall, the voice acting in Trials of Mana fell short of expectations and could have been improved for better player enjoyment.

Technical Performance

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

21%

Mixed (50-79)

72%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Trials of Mana on the PS4 platform has received a mix of feedback from critics. Positive aspects highlighted by reviewers include quick and snappy loading times within areas, consistent framerate without noticeable drops, and generally smooth gameplay. Hardcore Gamer noted the smooth performance with occasional texture pop-ins that were not bothersome. However, negative aspects mentioned by Easy Allies and Impulsegamer include outdated models, blurry textures, prevalent pop-in, frequent loading screens, and odd AI behavior for companions in towns. Worth Playing also criticized issues with the camera and poor AI affecting the gameplay experience on the PS4 platform. On the Nintendo Switch platform, critics have pointed out both positives and negatives regarding the technical performance of Trials of Mana. GameCrate and NintendoWorldReport praised the smooth gameplay experience, with GameCrate mentioning simple but gorgeous in-battle effects and easy-to-navigate menus. However, negative aspects such as occasional framerate drops, texture pop-in, slow-loading textures, and inconsistent performance were highlighted by various critics. Nintendo Life mentioned that occasional performance problems like pop-in and slow-loading textures can disrupt immersion, while GamingTrend reported framerate issues and inconsistent performance on the Switch version. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding the technical performance of Trials of Mana across all platforms leans towards a mixed reception. While some reviewers like Gamers Heroes and God is a Geek noted smooth performance without major technical issues, others such as RPG Fan and RPG Site criticized poor optimization, framerate drops, lagging texture loads, and long loading times. The varying opinions suggest that the technical performance of Trials of Mana is somewhat inconsistent, with some platforms showcasing smoother gameplay experiences than others. IGN's review of the Switch version highlights struggles to maintain a stable framerate and frame drops, particularly in cutscenes, while PCMag commended the stable frame rate on PC with occasional stuttering. Ultimately, the technical performance of Trials of Mana seems to be a point of contention among critics, with both positive and negative aspects influencing the overall reception of the game.

TL;DR

technical performance

Critics have mixed feelings about Trials of Mana's technical performance on PS4 and Switch. While some praise its smooth gameplay and loading times, others criticize outdated visuals, texture pop-ins, and AI issues. The overall consensus is that the game's performance varies across platforms, with some experiencing smoother gameplay than others. Critics highlight both positives and negatives, making the technical performance a point of contention among reviewers.

Replay Value

Click for more details

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

65%

Mixed (50-79)

33%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of several critics regarding the replay value of Trials of Mana are overwhelmingly positive. Critics such as DualShockers, Easy Allies, and RPG Site praise the game for offering a significant amount of replayability through different storylines based on protagonist choice, party composition affecting the story, and extensive dialogue variety. The branching class system, alternate events, and New Game Plus feature provide incentives for multiple playthroughs, as highlighted by Easy Allies and RPGamer. The ability to select different characters and experience their unique stories and fighting styles, as mentioned by Game Informer and Worth Playing, adds depth and variety to the gameplay experience. On the other hand, some critics express concerns about the repetitive nature of the gameplay, which may hinder the overall replay value of Trials of Mana. Critics like Slant Magazine and Gamer.nl mention the repetitive gameplay loop in the second half of the game, while GameSpew notes that there is little reason to replay the game with different characters as the main content remains unchanged. Additionally, GameSpot points out that some choices may lead to less satisfying experiences, potentially limiting the overall enjoyment of multiple playthroughs. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Trials of Mana offers substantial replay value through its diverse character choices, class changes, multiple endings, and post-game content. Critics such as CGMagazine, Hardcore Gamer, and MMORPG.com highlight the game's multiple playthroughs with different character choices, training options, and class setups as a draw for players to explore different paths and customize their experience. While there are some concerns about repetitive gameplay elements, the majority of critics appreciate the depth and variety that Trials of Mana offers, making it a worthwhile experience for players looking to immerse themselves in a rich and replayable RPG adventure.

TL;DR

replay value

Critics rave about Trials of Mana's replay value, praising its diverse storylines, party compositions, and class system for multiple playthroughs. However, some critics caution about repetitive gameplay that could dampen replayability. Despite this, the game offers significant depth and variety through character choices and class setups, making it a must-play for RPG enthusiasts seeking a rich and customizable experience.

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive (80-100)

53%

Mixed (50-79)

46%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

In analyzing the opinions of the critics regarding the Overall Verdict of Trials of Mana, it is evident that there are several positive aspects highlighted by reviewers. Critics such as RPGamer and MMORPG.com commend the game for successfully blending old-school charm with modern upgrades, offering improved gameplay and visuals while staying true to the original. The combat system is often praised for being engaging and enjoyable, with GameCrate noting that the game captures the essence of the original while introducing modern graphics and updated gameplay, providing a satisfying and comforting RPG experience. Additionally, the game's character customization, vibrant visuals, and epic music, as mentioned by We Got This Covered, contribute to a fun and immersive gaming experience. On the other hand, there are notable criticisms raised by critics regarding Trials of Mana. Some reviewers, like DarkStation and Slant Magazine, express disappointment in the rushed and cheaply made aspects of the game, as well as its reliance on old-school conventions that may lead to a dull and repetitive experience. Issues with voice acting, story depth, and character development are highlighted by Twinfinite and Worth Playing, pointing out flaws that detract from the overall enjoyment of the game. Additionally, GamingTrend and Windows Central mention technical issues and the lack of multiplayer as drawbacks that hinder the game's potential. Overall, the consensus among critics regarding Trials of Mana leans towards a positive reception with some reservations. While the game is praised for its engaging combat, improved visuals, and faithful remake of the original, there are concerns about its storytelling, voice acting, and repetitive gameplay elements. Critics like Easy Allies and Digitally Downloaded appreciate the game's interesting and improved experience compared to the original, highlighting its high replay value and modernized features. However, the mixed opinions from critics such as DarkStation and GameSpot suggest that while Trials of Mana excels in certain aspects like combat and visuals, it falls short in delivering a fully immersive and flawless experience for all players. Ultimately, the game seems to cater well to fans of the Mana series and action RPG enthusiasts, but may not offer enough to captivate a broader audience beyond its nostalgic appeal.

TL;DR

Critics praise Trials of Mana for its mix of old-school charm and modern upgrades, engaging combat, and immersive visuals, while some criticize its rushed aspects, old-school conventions, and lack of depth in storytelling and character development. The game appeals to fans of the Mana series and action RPG enthusiasts, but falls short of delivering a flawless experience for all players.

MONSTER

Reviews

133 reviews found

GameCrate

Nintendo Switch

Apr 29, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is praised as a fantastic remake that successfully captures the essence of the original game while introducing modern graphics and updated gameplay, offering a good RPG experience that is easy to access, fun, enjoyable, and replayable, making it a satisfying and comforting RPG experience.

Digitally Downloaded

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review praises Trials of Mana as one of the best remake attempts in recent years, with a modern feel that could appeal to a broader audience. The reviewer expresses hope for similar treatment of other games like Chrono Trigger or Final Fantasy VI.

Read full review

Hardcore Gamer

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a fantastic remake that surpasses the other Mana remakes. It offers a fun combat system, beautiful visuals, great music, and replay value. It is highly recommended for action RPG fans.

Noisy Pixel

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a traditional JRPG that retains the fantasy appeal of the original while updating systems for accessibility. Despite some issues with AI companions, it offers a satisfying adventure with plenty to explore.

Read full review

RPG Fan

PlayStation 4

Apr 28, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana offers expanded storytelling, exciting combat, and loving recreation of artistic elements, harkening back to nostalgic gaming experiences, despite some flaws. A fun and joyous experience overall.

NintendoWorldReport

Nintendo Switch

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The Trials of Mana remake is a compelling and worthwhile investment, with a brisk pace, vivid presentation, and multiple playable characters. It may lack variety and depth in some areas, but it is a definitive version of the classic game.

Read full review

Nintendo Enthusiast

Nintendo Switch

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a wonderful remake of a classic JRPG that most Westerners never experienced. From the story to the soundtrack to the gameplay, old fans and new will find something to love in this game.

Wccftech

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is praised for its modernization of the classic tale, offering a fresh experience despite some flaws in combat difficulty and voice acting.

Read full review

MMORPG.com

PlayStation 4

Apr 29, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a fantastic remake of an Action RPG that stays true to the original while offering improvements in gameplay and visuals. Despite some shortcomings in story depth and character abilities, the game's charm and replay value make it enjoyable for both new players and old fans.

Read full review

Video Chums

PlayStation 4

Apr 24, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a gorgeous and delightful action RPG that's full of imagination and heart. It has rewarding combat and character progression, outstanding visuals, music, and voice acting, and a lengthy adventure with loads of replay value. However, the combat takes a while to get interesting and retreading the same paths becomes tiresome. Some portions could use more variety.

Read full review