Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Twitch

MONSTER

Trials of Mana

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Trials of Mana
Item: Trials of Mana
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2020

GenresFantasy, Adventure, Action, Platformer, Shooter, Comedy, RPG, Top-Down Perspective, Anime and JRPG, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableApr 24, 2020

PlatformPC, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4

DeveloperXeen

Overview

Seiken Densetsu 3 is a 1995 action role-playing game developed and published by Square (now Square Enix) for the Super Nintendo Entertainment System. It is the sequel to the 1993 game Seiken Densetsu 2 (released outside Japan as Secret of Mana), and is the third game in the Mana series.

Elsewhere

8.0

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana impresses with its multiple protagonists and branching narratives that boost replayability, but the overall story falls flat. Critics slam its clichéd, superficial characters and disjointed plot, with many citing poor dialogue and lack of emotional depth. While it offers nostalgic charm for classic RPG fans, the game ultimately relies too heavily on familiar tropes, delivering a predictable experience that misses the mark on true innovation and character development. A missed opportunity for a more impactful narrative.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

27%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

64%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Trials of Mana has garnered some appreciation for its structure and the variety it offers through multiple protagonists. Critics like Hardcore Gamer and GameMAG highlight the branching narratives that allow players to experience different arcs based on their character choices, enhancing replayability. Additionally, some reviewers, such as Nintendo Insider and RPGamer, found the interactions between characters to be enjoyable, providing moments that keep players engaged. Even IGN Italia noted that despite its clichés, the story maintains engagement through twists and challenges, suggesting that there's a charm to its straightforward narrative that appeals to fans of the genre. However, the overall sentiment regarding the story is largely negative, with many critics pointing out significant flaws. Reviewers like 3DJuegos and COGconnected criticized the narrative for being clichéd and lacking depth, describing characters as "paper-thin" and the plot as disjointed. Metro GameCentral went further to mention the poor quality of dialogue and voice acting, which detracts from the overall experience. Many critics, including GamePro Germany and MMORPG.com, echoed sentiments of predictability and a lack of emotional engagement, indicating that the story feels outdated and simplistic, failing to innovate or captivate audiences. The consensus among critics is that while Trials of Mana offers a nostalgic experience for fans of classic RPGs, it ultimately falls short in delivering a compelling narrative. Many reviews, such as those from Push Square and PC Invasion, emphasize the story's reliance on familiar tropes and its lack of character development, leading to a predictable and linear experience. The game's attempts to provide unique character arcs and branching paths are often overshadowed by its overall simplicity and cliché-ridden plot, as noted by critics like GameCrate and Everyeye.it. Thus, while there are elements of charm and engagement, the story of Trials of Mana is viewed as a missed opportunity to create a more profound and impactful narrative.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana boasts a modernized, engaging combat system with strategic character switching and class changes praised by many, but faces criticism for repetitive gameplay, shallow early combat, and targeting issues. While some enjoy its accessibility and connection to the original, others find it lacking in depth and challenge, resulting in a mixed reception.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

70%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

27%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Trials of Mana has garnered a mix of praise from critics, highlighting several positive aspects. Many reviewers, such as SpazioGames and Multiplayer.it, commend the combat system for being modernized and engaging, with a focus on real-time action that allows for strategic planning and character customization. The ability to switch between characters during battles, as noted by IGN and Nintendo Enthusiast, adds a layer of flexibility and depth, making encounters feel unique. Critics like GameSpace and God is a Geek appreciate the seamless combat mechanics and the introduction of class changes, which enhance character progression and provide players with various strategies to explore. Additionally, the game’s engaging nature is emphasized by several reviewers, including USgamer, who notes improved battles and customization options compared to its predecessor. Conversely, several critics have pointed out significant drawbacks that detract from the overall experience. Gamers Heroes and DarkStation express concerns about the combat being repetitive and lacking depth, particularly in the early stages of the game. DarkStation specifically mentions that the class changes, which could add complexity, come too late to make a substantial impact on the gameplay experience. Critics like GameSkinny and Metro GameCentral also highlight issues with the targeting system and a lack of engaging side quests, making the gameplay feel one-dimensional. Furthermore, reviewers such as Impulsegamer and PCMag mention frustrations with the camera and AI, which can hinder the overall combat experience, leading to a sense of inconsistency in gameplay. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed, with a clear divide between those who appreciate the modernized combat system and those who find it lacking in depth and challenge. While many reviewers, including IGN Japan and RPGamer, recognize the engaging nature of the gameplay and its connection to the original title, others like Vgames and BaziCenter point out that the simplicity and ease of the combat may not satisfy players seeking a more complex experience. Ultimately, Trials of Mana presents a blend of enjoyable mechanics and significant flaws, leading to a gameplay experience that, while fun for some, may not resonate with all players.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana dazzles with its vibrant, colorful art style, earning praise for its whimsical world and faithful 2D-to-3D transition. Critics highlight the appealing character designs and nostalgic charm, but many lament its repetitive environments, dated textures, and technical flaws like framerate drops and stiff animations. While visually captivating, the game falls short of modern standards, illustrating a charming yet technically limited experience that doesn't fully satisfy contemporary RPG expectations.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

42%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

53%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Trials of Mana have garnered a mix of praise from critics, particularly for their vibrant and colorful aesthetic. Many reviewers, such as IGN and Video Chums, highlight the game's "gorgeous, colorful art style" and "whimsical world," noting that the transition from 2D to 3D has been executed in a way that retains the charm of the original game. Critics like Gamer.nl and GameMAG appreciate the vibrant color palette and the character designs, which are described as well-rendered and appealing. The game is also recognized for its attention to detail in environments and character models, with some critics, including COGconnected and Player 2, noting that the graphics elevate the storytelling and evoke nostalgia for the original title. However, despite the colorful visuals, many critics point out significant shortcomings in the game's graphical execution. Reviewers such as GamePro Germany and Hobby Consolas express disappointment with the repetitive environments and low-quality textures, describing the graphics as "dated" and lacking depth. DarkStation and Gameblog.fr echo these sentiments, mentioning that while the graphics are bright and colorful, they appear flat and technically limited. Critics like PC Invasion and The Games Machine emphasize that the visuals feel generic and budget-conscious, leading to a sense of underwhelming immersion. Additionally, issues such as framerate drops, popping textures, and stiff animations are frequently mentioned, particularly in the Nintendo Switch version, as noted by GamingTrend and Nintenderos. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Trials of Mana presents a visually appealing experience that captures the essence of its predecessor but falls short of modern standards in terms of technical execution. While many reviewers appreciate the game's charm and colorful design, they also highlight the repetitive nature of environments and the dated quality of textures and animations. Critics like Meristation and Game Informer acknowledge the game's visual appeal while also noting its limitations, suggesting that while it is a significant upgrade from the original, it does not fully meet the expectations set by contemporary RPGs. This duality in sentiment illustrates that Trials of Mana is a visually delightful game that ultimately struggles with technical execution and depth.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana shines with a remastered soundtrack that critics laud for its orchestration and nostalgic appeal, offering a delightful audio experience. However, the English voice acting has received widespread criticism for being amateurish and detracting from the game, prompting many to recommend the Japanese option instead. Overall, the game highlights a stark contrast between exceptional music and disappointing voice work, undermining its audio cohesiveness.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

46%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Trials of Mana have garnered a range of positive feedback from critics, particularly regarding the remastered soundtrack. Many reviewers, such as Hardcore Gamer and We Got This Covered, praised the orchestration of the music, highlighting it as a significant enhancement over the original compositions. The ability to switch between the remastered and classic 16-bit soundtracks has been noted as a fantastic feature by critics like PCMag and IGN, adding to the nostalgic experience while providing a modern twist. The soundtrack's energy and variety have also been appreciated, with critics like Twinfinite and SpazioGames noting how it enhances the gameplay experience and contributes positively to the game's atmosphere. However, the reception of the voice acting has been overwhelmingly negative across multiple reviews. Critics such as DarkStation and Metro GameCentral described the English voice acting as amateurish and poorly directed, with dialogue that often feels unnatural and detracts from the overall experience. Specific characters, like Charlotte, have been singled out for their irritating performances, as noted by Windows Central and GameSpot. The localization issues, particularly in the English dub, have led many reviewers to recommend the Japanese voice option instead, as highlighted by Destructoid and Ragequit.gr. Overall, the voice acting appears to be a significant flaw in an otherwise well-received audio experience. The overall consensus among critics indicates that while the music and sound design of Trials of Mana are largely celebrated for their quality and nostalgic value, the voice acting remains a major point of contention. Critics like Game Informer and GamePro Germany have pointed out that the poor localization and inconsistent performances negatively impact the game's narrative engagement. Despite the impressive remastered soundtrack, which many reviewers, including Hardcore Gamer and MMORPG.com, found delightful and immersive, the dissatisfaction with the voice acting suggests a missed opportunity for a more cohesive audio experience. This dichotomy between the music and voice acting highlights the game's strengths and weaknesses in its audio presentation.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana’s voice acting has divided critics. While some praise its emotional depth and character variety, the English dub is widely criticized for inconsistency and poor quality, with descriptors like "stilted" and "amateurish" frequently used. Many reviewers recommend the Japanese voice track for a more authentic experience, emphasizing that the English performances detract from the game’s storytelling. Overall, disappointment prevails regarding the voice acting quality.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

58%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

35%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Trials of Mana has garnered a mixed reception from critics, with some reviewers highlighting its strengths. Atomix praised the voice acting as “excellent,” noting that it adds emotional depth to the characters and enhances the storytelling, despite some visual limitations. Similarly, Video Chums commended the cast for fleshing out distinct personalities, suggesting that the performances contribute positively to the overall experience. Additionally, RPGamer acknowledged that the English voice acting is serviceable, indicating that while it may not be perfect, it fulfills its role in the game's narrative. However, the negatives surrounding the voice acting are pronounced and frequently discussed among critics. Many reviewers criticized the English dub for its inconsistency and poor quality. For instance, BaziCenter described the voice acting as “odd and sometimes absurd,” which disrupts the narrative flow. Game Informer echoed this sentiment by labeling the English dub as stilted and noting the poor accents. Furthermore, critics like DualShockers and GamePro Germany pointed out that the performances range from mediocre to outright bad, with some characters exhibiting awkward pacing and lackluster delivery, which detracts from character engagement. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards disappointment regarding the voice acting in Trials of Mana. While some reviewers, such as SpazioGames and Hardcore Gamer, recommend the Japanese voice acting for a more authentic experience, the English dub is largely viewed as subpar. The general sentiment is that the English performances often lack the emotional resonance needed to elevate the storytelling, with many critics, including GameSpot and Metro GameCentral, describing the voice acting as amateurish and contributing to weak dialogue. As a result, the mixed reception indicates that while there are moments of praise, the overall quality of voice acting in Trials of Mana leaves much to be desired.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana shines on PS4 with smooth 60 fps and quick loading times, earning praise for its technical performance. In stark contrast, the Nintendo Switch version struggles with inconsistent frame rates below 30 fps, frequent graphical glitches, and loading delays, significantly detracting from gameplay. Overall, the PS4 version delivers a superior experience, while the Switch falls short.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

16%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

77%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Trials of Mana has garnered a mix of positive feedback across different gaming platforms, particularly on the PlayStation 4. Reviewers such as IGN Italia and Game Informer noted that the game runs smoothly at a stable 60 fps, with minimal loading times and solid transitions, contributing to an overall enjoyable experience. Critics like Hardcore Gamer and Gamers Heroes echoed this sentiment, highlighting quick loading times and a generally smooth performance without major crashes or frame drops. Even when minor issues arose, such as occasional texture pop-ins mentioned by God is a Geek and SpazioGames, the PS4 version was largely praised for its technical execution. Conversely, the Nintendo Switch version of Trials of Mana faced significant criticism regarding its technical performance. Reviewers like IGN and GameMAG pointed out that the Switch struggles to maintain a consistent frame rate, often dipping below 30 fps during intense battles and cutscenes. Critics such as Cubed3 and GamingTrend echoed these concerns, citing issues like lower resolution and frequent frame drops that detracted from the overall experience. Moreover, texture loading delays and pop-ins were frequently mentioned, with Nintendo Life and Vgames noting that these technical flaws could disrupt immersion, particularly in a game designed to evoke nostalgia. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while the PS4 version of Trials of Mana delivers a robust technical performance, the Nintendo Switch version suffers from notable shortcomings that impact gameplay. The PS4's stable frame rates and quick loading times are contrasted sharply with the Switch's inconsistent performance and graphical issues. Critics like Easy Allies and RPG Fan highlighted that despite the PS4's strengths, there are still areas for improvement, particularly in texture loading and AI behavior. As a result, while the game is playable across platforms, the experience varies significantly, with the PS4 version being the clear winner in terms of technical performance.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Trials of Mana boasts strong replay value with diverse characters and a New Game+ mode, praised for encouraging multiple playthroughs. However, critics highlight gameplay repetition, ease, and limited side content as drawbacks that may dampen long-term interest. While nostalgic and enjoyable, its appeal is mixed—great for character exploration, but potentially tedious for players seeking more challenge.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

62%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

37%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of Trials of Mana is predominantly positive, with many critics highlighting the game's structure that encourages multiple playthroughs. Reviewers like Nintendo Insider and DualShockers praise the variety in character choices, which significantly affect the storyline and gameplay dynamics. The inclusion of a New Game+ mode, as noted by critics such as Easy Allies and Worth Playing, further enhances replayability by allowing players to carry over stats and explore alternative paths. Additionally, the post-game content, including epilogues and class changes, adds depth and complexity, making the experience richer for those willing to invest the time. However, several critics express concerns about the repetitive nature of the gameplay, which may detract from the overall replay value. For instance, The Games Machine and Game Informer point out the excessive ease of the game and the need for backtracking, which can feel tedious after multiple playthroughs. Critics like Vgames and Gameblog.fr also mention a lack of side quests and deeper narrative elements, suggesting that while the game offers multiple character routes, the overall experience might not be compelling enough to entice players back for additional runs. This sentiment is echoed by others who note that despite the engaging combat and character choices, the game's structure may lead to a sense of monotony. In conclusion, while Trials of Mana is recognized for its replay value through character diversity and branching storylines, critics are divided on the game's ability to maintain player interest over multiple playthroughs. The consensus indicates that while the game provides a nostalgic and enjoyable experience, as highlighted by RPGamer and NintendoWorldReport, the repetitive gameplay and lack of substantial side content may limit its appeal for some players. Overall, Trials of Mana presents a mixed bag of replayability—offering significant potential for those invested in exploring various character arcs, yet potentially falling short for those seeking a more varied and challenging experience.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

53%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment surrounding "Trials of Mana" as expressed by various critics presents a mixed but predominantly positive view of the remake. Many reviewers, such as Nintendo Life and IGN Japan, commend the game for successfully capturing the essence of the original while modernizing gameplay mechanics and visuals. Critics like DualShockers and GameMAG highlight the engaging combat and impressive graphics, suggesting that the game offers a solid entry point for both newcomers and fans of the franchise. Additionally, GameCrate praises it as a fantastic remake that balances nostalgia with accessibility, making it enjoyable and replayable. The charm of the game, along with its vibrant fantasy world and strong soundtrack, is frequently mentioned, indicating that it retains much of the appeal that made the original beloved. However, the criticisms of "Trials of Mana" are notable and often focus on its shortcomings. Several reviewers, including GamePro Germany and Gamers Heroes, express disappointment, stating that the remake fails to capture the original's spirit and may only appeal to die-hard fans. DarkStation and Metro GameCentral criticize the game for its rushed feel, lack of depth in storytelling, and removal of co-op gameplay, which limits its overall engagement. Additionally, many critics point out technical issues, such as poor voice acting and dated visuals, which detract from the overall experience. The repetitive gameplay loop and simplistic combat mechanics are also highlighted as significant drawbacks by critics like Gamer.nl and Windows Central. In summary, while "Trials of Mana" is generally viewed as a successful remake that honors its roots and offers enjoyable gameplay, it is not without its flaws. The consensus among critics is that the game appeals primarily to fans of the original and those who appreciate classic JRPGs, but it may struggle to attract new players due to its technical shortcomings and lack of innovation. Critics like Cubed3 and Easy Allies suggest that, despite its imperfections, the game sets a new standard for remakes, indicating a hopeful outlook for future titles in the genre. Overall, "Trials of Mana" is seen as a charming yet flawed homage to a classic, with a nostalgic appeal that resonates with many players.

TL;DR

"Trials of Mana" is a mixed but mostly positive remake, praised for capturing the original's essence while modernizing gameplay and visuals. Critics commend its engaging combat, vibrant world, and nostalgic appeal, making it enjoyable for fans and newcomers alike. However, shortcomings such as a rushed feel, shallow storytelling, technical issues, and repetitive gameplay limit its broader appeal. While it sets a hopeful standard for future remakes, it primarily resonates with die-hard fans of the original JRPG.

MONSTER

Reviews

131 reviews found

GameCrate

Nintendo Switch

Apr 29, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is praised as a fantastic remake that successfully captures the essence of the original game while introducing modern graphics and updated gameplay, offering a good RPG experience that is easy to access, fun, enjoyable, and replayable, making it a satisfying and comforting RPG experience.

Hardcore Gamer

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a fantastic remake that surpasses the other Mana remakes. It offers a fun combat system, beautiful visuals, great music, and replay value. It is highly recommended for action RPG fans.

Digitally Downloaded

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review praises Trials of Mana as one of the best remake attempts in recent years, with a modern feel that could appeal to a broader audience. The reviewer expresses hope for similar treatment of other games like Chrono Trigger or Final Fantasy VI.

Read full review

Cubed3

Nintendo Switch

May 13, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is praised as the best remake of 2020, successfully honoring its source material while expanding on its mechanics and design. It sets a new standard for video game remakes despite some technical issues on the Switch.

Read full review

Noisy Pixel

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a traditional JRPG that retains the fantasy appeal of the original while updating systems for accessibility. Despite some issues with AI companions, it offers a satisfying adventure with plenty to explore.

Read full review

TheXboxHub

Xbox Series X

Oct 31, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is described as a delightful experience with engaging story, enjoyable combat, and charming presentation, making it a must-play for RPG fans.

Read full review

RPG Fan

PlayStation 4

Apr 28, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana offers expanded storytelling, exciting combat, and loving recreation of artistic elements, harkening back to nostalgic gaming experiences, despite some flaws. A fun and joyous experience overall.

Nintendo Enthusiast

Nintendo Switch

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is a wonderful remake of a classic JRPG that most Westerners never experienced. From the story to the soundtrack to the gameplay, old fans and new will find something to love in this game.

Wccftech

PlayStation 4

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Trials of Mana is praised for its modernization of the classic tale, offering a fresh experience despite some flaws in combat difficulty and voice acting.

Read full review

NintendoWorldReport

Nintendo Switch

Apr 22, 2020

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The Trials of Mana remake is a compelling and worthwhile investment, with a brisk pace, vivid presentation, and multiple playable characters. It may lack variety and depth in some areas, but it is a definitive version of the classic game.

Read full review