Sundered

The story of Sundered: Eldritch Edition is widely praised for its atmospheric depth, Lovecraftian themes, and immersive world-building. Critics like IGN and GameCrate highlight the game’s ability to evoke a haunting mood through sparse yet evocative storytelling, with the latter noting that the narrative unfolds gradually, allowing players to piece together the world’s mysteries. The branching choices leading to multiple endings are another strong point, as noted by Nintendo Life, which emphasizes the engaging twists and dark atmosphere. TrueAchievements and Cubed3 commend the game’s focus on player agency, with Eshe’s journey through a labyrinthine, cosmic horror landscape offering a sense of exploration and moral ambiguity. The cryptic, poetic language delivered by the Cthulhu-like voice (as highlighted by IGN) adds to the game’s eerie charm, while New Game Network praises its Lovecraftian inspiration and survival-focused narrative. However, several critics point to the story’s lack of clarity and depth as a significant drawback. TheXboxHub and TrueAchievements criticize the incomplete narrative, with the former noting that the conclusion feels disconnected from earlier hints, leaving players confused. Destructoid and GameGrin argue that the plot is overly vague, with minimal exposition and a focus on atmosphere at the expense of coherent storytelling. The abrupt endings, as mentioned by TrueAchievements and PC Games, are seen as unsatisfying, while Digitally Downloaded and COGconnected acknowledge the story’s abstract nature but question its originality. Additionally, GameSpot points out that the narrative relies heavily on players scavenging for lore, which can feel frustratingly fragmented. These critiques suggest that while the game excels in creating an immersive, mysterious tone, it occasionally sacrifices clarity and emotional engagement for stylistic choices. Overall, critics agree that Sundered: Eldritch Edition prioritizes atmosphere and player interpretation over traditional storytelling, resulting in a polarizing but memorable experience. While IGN, GameCrate, and Nintendo Life appreciate the game’s thematic richness and choice-driven structure, others like Destructoid and PC Games feel it lacks the narrative depth to fully justify its ambitious setting. The consensus leans toward acknowledging the story’s strengths in mood and world-building but recognizing that its deliberate ambiguity may not resonate with all players. Despite mixed reactions, the game’s unique approach to storytelling—blending Lovecraftian horror with Metroidvania mechanics—has left a lasting impression, making it a standout title for fans of atmospheric, puzzle-driven narratives.

The gameplay of Sundered receives praise for its dynamic blend of Metroidvania exploration, roguelike elements, and skill-based combat. Critics highlight the game’s procedural generation, which creates varied environments and challenges, as a standout feature. IGN notes the “semi-roguelike 2D platformer” structure, emphasizing classic Metroidvania tasks like unlocking shortcuts and acquiring abilities through shrines. GameSpot commends the “smooth and responsive” combat system, likening it to games like Devil May Cry, with complex combos and fluid animations that reward mastery. The skill tree and progression system also draw positive remarks, with Nintendo Life praising its “tight” mechanics and the ability to spend earned currency on upgrades. Additionally, GameStar and DualShockers appreciate the mix of exploration and chaos, noting how procedurally generated rooms and mini-bosses add unpredictability. These elements create a gameplay loop that many find engaging and replayable, particularly for fans of challenging, skill-driven experiences. However, several critics point to repetitive mechanics and frustrating design choices as major drawbacks. Destructoid and PC Games criticize the “repetitive nature of combat” and limited enemy variety, while GameGrin describes battles as devolving into “button mashing.” The procedural generation, though praised for its randomness, is also seen as a double-edged sword: ZTGD notes that “overwhelming enemy spawning mechanics” and floaty jumping can hinder enjoyment, while TrueAchievements mentions cramped rooms and enemies attacking through walls. Other issues include the lack of checkpoints (GameCritics) and the punishing backtracking required after death (BaziCenter). Additionally, some reviewers, like Hooked Gamers, find the combat “flawed and confusing,” despite acknowledging the enjoyable boss fights. These criticisms suggest that while Sundered offers depth, its execution occasionally undermines player satisfaction through repetition and uneven difficulty curves. Overall, critics agree that Sundered is a compelling but polarizing experience. The game’s core mechanics—procedural generation, skill trees, and fast-paced combat—are widely praised for their innovation and replayability, with outlets like IGN and GameSpot highlighting its addictive qualities. However, the repetitive enemy encounters, lack of variety, and frustrating design choices (noted by Destructoid, PC Games, and others) create a divide in reception. While some players appreciate the challenge and depth, others find the gameplay loop exhausting or unfair. Despite these flaws, the consensus leans toward appreciation for Sundered’s ambition and its ability to blend Metroidvania exploration with roguelike unpredictability, making it a standout title for fans of the genre despite its imperfections.

The overwhelming majority of critics praise Sundered: Eldritch Edition for its striking hand-drawn graphics and unique visual design, highlighting its ability to create a vivid, immersive world. Reviewers consistently laud the game’s gorgeous hand-drawn aesthetic, with many noting its blend of fantasy, sci-fi, and Lovecraftian influences. For instance, IGN describes the visuals as “stunning hand-drawn set pieces” with “towering statues” and “fine details of smoke from explosions,” while GameCrate compares the art style to “anime and The Last Unicorn.” The game’s distinct regional styles are a standout feature, with Game Informer noting that the three main areas each have “distinct styles,” and God is a Geek praising the “wonderful boss designs” and “stunning artwork.” Critics like New Game Network and Push Square emphasize the hauntingly beautiful environments and expertly designed enemies, while Cubed3 and GameSpace highlight the macabre, Lovecraftian enemy designs that add to the game’s eerie atmosphere. The visual design is widely seen as a core strength, with Critical Hit calling it “the most outstanding feature” of the game. Despite the praise, several critics point out notable flaws in the game’s visual execution. Metro GameCentral criticizes the “static and dull” backgrounds, while GameSpot notes that environments are “inconsistent at best,” with some areas like “derelict ancient cities” contrasting sharply with “boring catacombs.” Nintendo Life mentions “monochromatic moments,” and Switch Player points to repetitive environmental design, suggesting that the randomly generated passageways lack the personality of static rooms. PC PowerPlay and PC Games also criticize the level designs as “uninspired” or “lacking in hidden secrets.” Additionally, some reviewers, like IGN, acknowledge that while bosses are “monumental” and visually arresting, the randomly generated areas fail to match the creativity of the game’s pre-designed zones. These critiques highlight a tension between the game’s artistic ambition and its technical limitations in maintaining visual variety across all environments. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive, with the graphics and visual design being a defining strength of Sundered: Eldritch Edition. While some flaws exist—particularly in environmental repetition and consistency—the art style is universally celebrated as innovative and immersive. IGN, Game Informer, and Critical Hit all emphasize the game’s “gorgeous hand-drawn aesthetic” and “unique art direction,” while The Indie Game Website and DarkStation note how the visuals effectively convey the game’s dark, cosmic horror themes. Even critics who point out weaknesses, like GameSpot and Nintendo Life, acknowledge that the visual appeal is a major draw. The combination of hand-painted environments, dynamic animations, and striking boss designs creates a visually arresting experience that resonates with players, making the game’s art style one of its most memorable aspects. As Push Square puts it, the “mixture of organic and industrial elements” creates “exciting backdrops for combat,” reinforcing the idea that Sundered’s visuals are both beautiful and thematically cohesive.

The majority of critics praise the sound design and music of Sundered: Eldritch Edition for their atmospheric depth and thematic cohesion. COGconnected highlights how the music adds motivation and complements the game’s ancient religious themes, while TheXboxHub emphasizes the subtle yet effective score and terrifying voice-over that enhance immersion. GameCritics and IGN (PS4) commend the stirring, Limbo-like minimalist soundtrack that aligns with the game’s mood, with IGN Italia noting the orchestral elements that elevate the mysterious storyline. Push Square and Areajugones both praise the menacing, sombre score and subtle music that amplify the survival theme and sense of solitude. Additionally, AusGamers appreciates how the music intensifies during action sequences, creating a rewarding challenge, while Hardcore Gamer and USgamer highlight the evocative ambient tunes that heighten tension and immersion. However, some critics point to inconsistencies and technical shortcomings. PlayStation LifeStyle notes occasional hitches and lengthy load times, which detract from the audio experience. Nintendo Life criticizes the inconsistent soundtrack with forgettable tracks, though it acknowledges strong voice work and atmospheric sounds. NintendoWorldReport mentions the subdued nature of the music, while IGN (PC) humorously critiques the voice acting as “Shakespeare spoken through cabbage with a sore throat,” despite its Cthulhu-like presence. Nintendo Insider and Nintendo Life also note that the audio focuses more on horror elements than music, with no mention of a traditional soundtrack in some cases. These critiques suggest that while the sound design is effective, it occasionally lacks polish or memorability. Overall, the consensus leans toward appreciation for Sundered: Eldritch Edition’s atmospheric and immersive audio, though with some reservations. Most reviewers agree that the music and sound design effectively support the game’s dark, mysterious tone, as noted by COGconnected, TheXboxHub, and IGN (PS4). However, technical issues like load times (PlayStation LifeStyle) and inconsistent tracks (Nintendo Life) temper this praise. While some critics, such as PC Games, highlight the orchestral mood-setting, others like Nintendo WorldReport and Nintendo Insider feel the music remains background-focused. Despite these minor drawbacks, the majority of reviews emphasize that the sound design enhances the game’s oppressive atmosphere, making it a standout element for fans of horror and exploration.

Summary unavailable

The technical performance of Sundered varies significantly across platforms, with the Nintendo Switch receiving the most positive feedback. Critics like Cubed3 and Nintendo Life praised the Switch version for running smoothly without frame drops, highlighting its stability in both handheld and docked modes. PlayStation LifeStyle noted that while technical issues existed on PS4, they did not significantly impact the experience, suggesting some tolerance for minor flaws. On PC, Destructoid acknowledged developers’ responsiveness to feedback, though this was framed more as a post-launch support measure than a reflection of initial performance. These positives indicate that Sundered’s technical execution is least problematic on the Switch and somewhat manageable on PC, despite its flaws. However, the negatives are starkly evident across all platforms. On PS4, multiple critics—BaziCenter, GameCritics, IGN Italia, and God is a Geek—highlighted persistent issues like frame drops, long loading times, crashes, and glitches that disrupted gameplay. Even after patches, GameCrate noted lingering hiccups, while New Game Network emphasized how lag during intense action sequences affected combat timing. The Nintendo Switch, despite its smoother performance, faced criticism for "abysmal" load times between areas (NintendoWorldReport) and occasional stutters or crashes (The Indie Game Website). On PC, issues like infinite enemy spawns (Areajugones) and boss fight bugs (Destructoid) were reported, with Game Informer and Everyeye.it citing similar problems. These flaws collectively suggest that Sundered’s technical foundation was inconsistent, particularly on PS4 and PC. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Sundered struggles with technical stability across all platforms, but the Nintendo Switch emerges as the most polished experience despite its own quirks. While Cubed3 and Nintendo Life celebrated the Switch’s performance, others like Push Square noted that even patched issues (like frame drops) were overshadowed by the game’s demanding combat mechanics. On PS4, the combination of loading times, crashes, and glitches (GameCritics, IGN Italia) created a frustrating experience, while PC users faced bugs and instability (Areajugones, Destructoid). Despite some post-launch improvements, the technical shortcomings—particularly on PS4 and PC—undermine the game’s potential, leaving the Switch as the most viable option for players seeking smoother performance.

The majority of critics highlight strong positive aspects of Sundered: Eldritch Edition’s replay value, emphasizing its procedural generation, skill tree depth, and multiple endings. COGconnected notes the co-op mode adds replayability, while TheXboxHub and TrueAchievements praise randomized layouts, unlockable areas, and choices that influence gameplay and outcomes. GameCrate and God is a Geek highlight how skill trees and moral decisions encourage different playstyles, with IGN and PlayStation LifeStyle pointing to the game’s ability to offer unique experiences through shifting level design and character progression. The Eldritch Edition’s emphasis on exploration, such as unlocking shortcuts (Video Chums) and branching decision paths (Cubed3), further reinforces its appeal for repeat plays. Critics like Push Square and Nintendo Life also commend the expansive unlock systems and diverse builds, suggesting that the game’s mechanics are designed to reward persistence and experimentation. However, several critics point out notable drawbacks that may limit replayability for some players. GameGrin outright calls the game “repetitive and uninspiring,” while Destructoid and IGN Italia note that the semi-procedural level design and frequent deaths can lead to frustration. ZTGD and Hardcore Gamer criticize the grind in mid-game progression and uneven enemy placement, which might deter players from revisiting the world. Additionally, some reviewers, like COGconnected and GameSpot, mention that while procedural generation adds variety, certain layouts become familiar over time, reducing long-term engagement. The lack of explicit guidance during key decisions (GameCrate) and the need for backtracking (GamingTrend) also surface as potential drawbacks, suggesting that the game’s replayability hinges on players’ tolerance for its challenges. Overall, the consensus among critics is largely positive, with most agreeing that Sundered: Eldritch Edition offers substantial replay value through its dynamic systems and narrative depth. While some critiques about repetition and difficulty exist, they are often balanced by praise for the game’s innovation in roguelike mechanics and player agency. IGN, GameSpot, and PC Games all emphasize how the combination of randomized elements, skill progression, and moral choices creates a compelling loop that justifies multiple playthroughs. Even critics like GameGrin, who found the game repetitive, acknowledge its potential for dedicated fans. The game’s ability to reward exploration, experimentation, and perseverance—whether through co-op (COGconnected), branching endings (TrueAchievements), or skill customization (GameCrate)—suggests that its replay value is robust enough to appeal to a wide range of players despite its flaws.