MonsterCritic
Phantom Fury cover image
Links
Steam Icon
Steam
Twitch Icon
Twitch

64

MONSTER

Star Icon

Phantom Fury

2023
GenresAdventure, Indie, Action, Shooter, Single Player, First Person Perspective
AvailableDec 31, 2023
PlatformXbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, PC, PlayStation 5
DeveloperSlipgate Ironworks
Overview

Shelly “Bombshell” Harrison is back in this highly interactive mix of first person action and road movie adventure. Embark on an adrenaline-fueled journey around the USA. Use an enormous arsenal of weapons and skills to battle treacherous soldiers and vile mutants, all while trying to save mankind.

Elsewhere
Score icon

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

62

TL;DR

Phantom Fury’s story splits critics: retro fans adore its 80s B-movie flair, bombastic action, and quirky charm, but most call it incoherent, shallow, and emotionally hollow—prioritizing style over substance with a plot that’s as confusing as it is forgettable.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

62

Positive Reviews (80-100)

21%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

43%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

36%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Phantom Fury receives mixed praise, with several reviewers highlighting its nostalgic appeal and genre-inspired flair. Critics like Movies Games and Tech commend its "classic straightforward plot with a sci-fi twist" and "nostalgic elements," while GamingBolt acknowledges "some deeper narrative threads" despite the absurdity of its over-the-top, 80s B-movie style. Try Hard Guides appreciates the "bombastic violence and quirky quips" that evoke a "classic American action movie feel," and GameSpew notes the blend of "road movie adventure elements" in Shelly 'Bombshell' Harrison’s mission to secure the Demon Core. These perspectives suggest that while the narrative may lack depth, its stylistic choices resonate with fans of retro action aesthetics, offering an entertaining framework for high-octane gameplay. However, the majority of critics panned the story for its lack of coherence and emotional engagement. CD-Action and GameCritics criticize it as "poorly conveyed" and "paper thin," respectively, while Gamer Escape dismisses it as "dumb" and reminiscent of "an edgy 90s action movie." GamingTrend calls the plot "nonsensical" with "caricature characters," and Hooked Gamers describes it as a "thread-bare narrative" with "confused execution." Even Ragequit.gr, who acknowledges some plot holes, notes that the missions "keep players interested until the end," implying the story’s weaknesses are overshadowed by gameplay. These critiques collectively point to a narrative that prioritizes spectacle over substance, leaving players disconnected from its characters and themes. The overall consensus among critics is that Phantom Fury’s story is a polarizing element, excelling in style but failing in depth. While Movies Games and Tech and GamingBolt appreciate its retro-inspired energy and action-driven pacing, the majority view it as a shallow framework for gameplay. Xbox Tavern and TheXboxHub note that the story "fades into the background," emphasizing that its strengths lie in its visuals and combat rather than narrative innovation. Despite some positive remarks about its nostalgic charm, the recurring criticism of its lack of coherence and emotional resonance suggests that Phantom Fury’s story is more of a backdrop for action than a compelling experience in itself.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Phantom Fury’s story splits critics: retro fans adore its 80s B-movie flair, bombastic action, and quirky charm, but most call it incoherent, shallow, and emotionally hollow—prioritizing style over substance with a plot that’s as confusing as it is forgettable.

72

TL;DR

Phantom Fury dazzles with blistering combat, inventive weapon variety, and immersive environmental play, but falters under repetitive mechanics, muddled design, and frustrating pacing that undermine its ambitious vision.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

72

Positive Reviews (80-100)

53%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

27%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

20%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Phantom Fury receives praise for its dynamic combat mechanics, variety of weapons, and engaging environmental interactions. Critics like GameCritics highlight fast-paced action and clever item interactions, while Gamereactor UK notes modernized mechanics with a focus on interactivity and puzzles. GamingBolt appreciates the blend of 90s-era shooter inspiration with narrative-driven levels and diverse missions, and Movies Games and Tech commends the suspenseful gameplay, evolving stage design, and challenging boss battles. Ragequit.gr and Softpedia praise varied level design, puzzles, and a wide array of weapons, while GameSpew and PlayStation Universe celebrate the fluid movement dynamics and chaotic firefights. Even Xbox Tavern acknowledges the fun, fast-paced gameplay with well-designed arenas and a rewarding combat experience. These positives suggest the game excels in creating an immersive, action-packed environment for players who enjoy tactical engagement and creative problem-solving. However, several critics point to significant flaws that detract from the overall experience. CD-Action criticizes the gameplay as derivative and lacking originality, with frustrating level design and mechanics that hinder progression. GameCritics and Gamereactor UK highlight tedious backtracking, damage sponge enemies, and dull weapons, while Gamer Escape notes unnecessary interactivity that feels padded. Hooked Gamers points to unreliable hitboxes, weak weapons, and vague navigation, making combat unsatisfying. TheXboxHub laments poor gunplay and confusing level design without maps, and GamingTrend finds boss fights underwhelming despite the game’s otherwise strong mechanics. These critiques reveal a recurring issue with balancing innovation and accessibility, as well as design choices that frustrate players rather than engage them. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed but leans toward acknowledging Phantom Fury’s strengths while recognizing its shortcomings. While many praise its fast-paced combat, creative weapon variety, and interactive environments—highlighted by GameCritics, GamingBolt, and PlayStation Universe—others like CD-Action and TheXboxHub argue that these elements are undermined by repetitive mechanics, poor level design, and inconsistent difficulty. The game seems to polarize reviewers, with some celebrating its ambition and energy, while others find it frustratingly flawed. Despite this divide, the recurring emphasis on combat dynamics and environmental interactivity suggests that Phantom Fury has potential as a unique entry in the first-person shooter genre, even if it falls short of fully realizing its vision.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Phantom Fury dazzles with blistering combat, inventive weapon variety, and immersive environmental play, but falters under repetitive mechanics, muddled design, and frustrating pacing that undermine its ambitious vision.

73

TL;DR

Phantom Fury’s retro aesthetics charm with nostalgic low-poly visuals and cinematic environments, but technical glitches, uneven polish, and outdated mechanics sabotage its potential—a polarizing mix of creative ambition and shaky execution.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

73

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

33%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

17%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The reviews of Phantom Fury’s graphics and visual design highlight a mix of nostalgic charm and technical shortcomings. Critics like Gamer Escape and GamingBolt praise its deliberate low-poly, pixelated aesthetic, which evokes late-90s/early-2000s games while maintaining readability and environmental clarity. Gamereactor UK and GamingTrend commend the game’s expansive, cinematic environments and retro-inspired art direction, noting its homage to classic shooters with detailed textures and a "clean aesthetic for foreground objects" (as noted by PlayStation Universe). Try Hard Guides and Hooked Gamers highlight the blend of retro-callbacks with modern techniques, such as smooth animations, high-resolution models, and cartoony visuals that enhance the game’s appeal. These positives suggest a strong effort to balance nostalgia with contemporary design sensibilities. However, several critics point to significant flaws in execution. CD-Action and Softpedia criticize the game’s outdated feel, citing glitches, inconsistent polish, and "twitchy" enemy movements that detract from immersion. TheXboxHub and Xbox Tavern express disappointment with the "period look," noting issues like low-resolution textures, chunky models, and level routing problems that undermine the experience. While PlayStation Universe acknowledges a "clean aesthetic for foreground objects," it also highlights uneven polish in backgrounds, reflecting broader concerns about technical refinement. These critiques suggest that while the visual style is intentional, its implementation often falls short of expectations, particularly when compared to predecessors or modern standards. Overall, the consensus leans toward a mixed reception. While many critics appreciate Phantom Fury’s retro-inspired art direction and creative risks—such as GamingBolt’s "distinct aesthetic blending old-school sensibilities with modern technologies" and Movies Games and Tech’s praise for its "dated, pixelated visual style that works well with its retro theme"—others argue that these choices lack polish or coherence. The game’s visuals are seen as a double-edged sword: they evoke nostalgia effectively but struggle with technical consistency and modernization. As Gamereactor UK notes, the title has "expansive and complex environments" but requires more refinement to match its predecessor’s quality. This duality reflects a broader debate about whether Phantom Fury succeeds as a nostalgic homage or falters under the weight of its own stylistic ambitions.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Phantom Fury’s retro aesthetics charm with nostalgic low-poly visuals and cinematic environments, but technical glitches, uneven polish, and outdated mechanics sabotage its potential—a polarizing mix of creative ambition and shaky execution.

64

TL;DR

Phantom Fury's sound design dazzles with immersive combat audio and quirky charm, but its forgettable, mismatched soundtrack undermines the experience, leaving critics divided between awe and frustration.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

64

Positive Reviews (80-100)

22%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

67%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

11%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Phantom Fury received a mixed but generally favorable reception, with several critics highlighting its immersive and impactful elements. Movies Games and Tech praised the "eccentric audio design" and "upbeat soundtrack," noting that the "gruff yet engaging voice acting" and "impactful sound effects" effectively complemented the gameplay. Similarly, GamingTrend acknowledged the "immersive elements" of the sound design, while Xbox Tavern commended the "battle music [that] effectively heightens excitement during encounters." These positive remarks underscored the game’s ability to create a dynamic auditory experience, particularly in combat scenarios, where satisfying weapon sounds and reactive audio cues were frequently noted. The voice acting, though occasionally criticized for being cheesy or mismatched, was seen as a contributing factor to the game’s overall atmosphere by some reviewers. However, several critics pointed out significant shortcomings, particularly with the soundtrack and its alignment with the gameplay. Gamer Escape described the music as "highly muted and forgettable," while Try Hard Guides lamented a "lackluster soundtrack" that could have benefited from an "80s synth-wave OST." Softpedia criticized the "generic soundtrack" and noted that enemy barks sometimes failed to match their actions, undermining immersion. Additionally, Ragequit.gr raised concerns about "low music volume" and problematic physics interactions, while TheXboxHub dismissed the sound design as "criticized," citing "limp guns" and "bored voice acting" that detracted from the experience. These critiques highlighted a disconnect between the game’s audio elements and its intended intensity, with many feeling the music lacked the energy or memorability to match the action-packed gameplay. Overall, while Phantom Fury showcased strengths in sound effects and certain aspects of its audio design, the soundtrack remained a contentious point among critics. The positive feedback from Movies Games and Tech and Xbox Tavern contrasted with the more critical takes from Gamer Escape, Try Hard Guides, and TheXboxHub, who found the music underwhelming or poorly integrated. This divergence suggests that while the game’s audio elements had moments of quality—particularly in combat and voice acting—the lack of a cohesive, impactful musical identity left many reviewers divided. The consensus leaned toward a middle ground: the sound design was functional and occasionally impressive, but the soundtrack’s failure to elevate the experience or match the game’s tone prevented it from being a standout feature.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Phantom Fury's sound design dazzles with immersive combat audio and quirky charm, but its forgettable, mismatched soundtrack undermines the experience, leaving critics divided between awe and frustration.

NA

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

47

TL;DR

Phantom Fury's launch was overwhelmed by severe technical issues across all platforms, with PC's instability and bugs overshadowing minor positives like PS5's controls—leaving its potential unfulfilled and players frustrated.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

47

Positive Reviews (80-100)

0%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

40%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

60%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Phantom Fury across its platforms received mixed feedback, with some positives noted despite widespread issues. On PC, Movies Games and Tech acknowledged minor bugs but called it a "raving success," suggesting the game’s core mechanics functioned well despite imperfections. For PS5, PlayStation Universe highlighted customizable controls and camera sensitivity adjustments as standout features, which could enhance player experience. While no explicit positives were mentioned for XBOX SERIES X, the absence of platform-specific praise might imply that technical issues overshadowed any potential strengths on that system. Overall, these points indicate that while some aspects of the game’s design were well-received, they were often overshadowed by broader technical challenges. However, the negatives across all platforms were more pronounced and consistent. On PC, multiple critics like CD-Action, GameCritics, and GamingTrend emphasized severe issues such as crashes, unresponsive enemies, and progression bugs, with Ragequit.gr detailing a laundry list of problems including physics glitches, invisible walls, and softlock bugs. The PS5 faced its own hurdles, as noted by GameSpew, who cited choppy gameplay and intrusive tutorial pop-ups, while the XBOX SERIES X version suffered from "numerous bugs and crashes" according to Xbox Tavern, including hard crashes and objective-tracking failures. These issues collectively painted a picture of a game in need of significant polish, particularly on PC, where technical instability was most frequently criticized. The overall consensus among critics is that Phantom Fury struggled with technical performance across all platforms, though the severity varied. PC received the harshest criticism, with multiple reviews highlighting systemic bugs and crashes that undermined gameplay. PS5 and XBOX SERIES X faced more targeted issues, such as control customization on PS5 and hardware-specific glitches on Xbox, but these were still significant enough to detract from the experience. While a few critics like Movies Games and Tech acknowledged the game’s potential, the overwhelming sentiment was one of frustration with its technical shortcomings. This suggests that Phantom Fury may have had strong creative ideas but failed to deliver a stable or polished product at launch, regardless of platform.

TL;DR

technical performance

Phantom Fury's launch was overwhelmed by severe technical issues across all platforms, with PC's instability and bugs overshadowing minor positives like PS5's controls—leaving its potential unfulfilled and players frustrated.

NA

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

replay value

Description unavailable

Overall verdict

Overall Verdict

64

MONSTER

Star Icon

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

64

Positive Reviews (80-100)

29%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

63%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

8%

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall reception of Phantom Fury highlights several positive aspects that resonate with fans of retro-inspired shooters. Critics like GamingBolt and Movies Games and Tech praise its "excellent gameplay," "fantastic art direction," and nostalgic homage to classic action movies, while Gamereactor UK notes its visually spectacular presentation and "impressive interactivity." Gamer Escape describes it as a "legacy throwback" offering "lightweight fun" for players seeking action-packed experiences, and Try Hard Guides appreciates its "delightful experience" that pays tribute to old-school cinema. These reviews emphasize the game’s charm, variety in gameplay, and ability to evoke nostalgia, with some highlighting its potential despite flaws. The enthusiasm for its aesthetic and core mechanics suggests a strong appeal to enthusiasts of the boomer shooter genre. However, several critics point to significant shortcomings that detract from the experience. CD-Action calls it a "disappointing attempt" failing to capture predecessors' essence, while GamingTrend labels it "middling" due to technical issues, obscure level design, and a weak story. Hooked Gamers criticizes its "confused" nature, "technical shortcomings," and "frustrating gameplay," and TheXboxHub deems it "disappointing" with "weak gunplay" and lack of engaging elements. Softpedia notes the game struggles to "communicate a clear identity," citing issues with AI and unnecessary object interactions. Even GameSpew and PlayStation Universe acknowledge technical problems and pacing issues, suggesting that while the core concept is solid, execution falls short in critical areas. The overall consensus among critics is mixed but leans toward cautious optimism tempered by frustration. While some praise its nostalgic value, art direction, and gameplay (as seen in GamingBolt and Movies Games and Tech), others highlight persistent technical flaws, unpolished mechanics, and design issues that undermine enjoyment. Ragequit.gr acknowledges "positive" aspects like encounter intensity and developer support but notes "technical issues" as barriers. Meanwhile, Xbox Tavern recommends it "with caveats," reflecting a split between those who appreciate its retro charm and those who find it unrefined. Ultimately, Phantom Fury seems to polarize critics, with its strengths in style and nostalgia offset by significant flaws that prevent it from being a definitive success.

TL;DR

Phantom Fury dazzles with nostalgic charm and vibrant style but stumbles on clunky mechanics and technical flaws, splitting critics between retro enthusiasts and those frustrated by its unpolished execution.

64

MONSTER

Star Icon

Reviews

49 reviews found

90

Movies Games and Tech

PC

Apr 23, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Phantom Fury is a fantastic blast from the past with engaging gameplay, nostalgic story elements, dated visuals that work well, and eccentric audio design. Despite minor bugs, it is a raving success and recommended for purchase.

Read full review

Full review

90

Try Hard Guides

PC

Apr 22, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Phantom Fury delivers a delightful experience that pays homage to classic American action flicks and stands out within its genre, despite some pacing issues and navigation challenges.

Read full review

Full review

80

GamingBolt

PC

Apr 24, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Phantom Fury is a refined boomer shooter with excellent gameplay, fantastic art direction, and a roaring good time, worth the attention of fans of old-school action movies.

Read full review

Full review

80

Softpedia

PC

Apr 30, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Phantom Fury is a boomer shooter with solid mechanics but struggles to communicate a clear identity. Development team should improve opponent AI and reduce unnecessary interactions with objects in the world.

Read full review

Full review

80

PlayStation Universe

PlayStation 5

Jun 6, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Phantom Fury is a fun shooter that may not innovate but provides a solid experience for fans of the genre, making it a worthwhile addition to a collection.

Read full review

Full review
Similar Games
Similar Games

Games you might also enjoy

left arrow
right arrow
Popular Right Now
Popular Right Now

Trending games the community is playing

left arrow
right arrow
Recently Reviewed
Recently Reviewed

Games with full Monster Scorecards

left arrow
right arrow

About

Contact Us

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Navigation

Home

Search

Games


Follow Us

© 2025 MonsterCritic