Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Playstation

Twitch

MONSTER

MLB The Show 25

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of MLB The Show 25
Item: MLB The Show 25
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2025

GenresThird Person Perspective, Simulation, Sports, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableMar 18, 2025

PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch

DeveloperSan Diego Studio

Overview

Forge your baseball journey in The Show

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25's "Storylines: The Negro Leagues" mode is lauded for its authentic, educational portrayal of baseball's rich history and cultural legacy, with praised storytelling, real-player quotes, and emotional depth—yet critics panned its reduced narrative scope, repetitive missions, and dated mechanics, calling it the weakest iteration yet despite its meaningful intent.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

52%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

44%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The Story of MLB The Show 25 has been praised by several critics for its educational and historical value, particularly with the inclusion of the "Storylines: The Negro Leagues" mode. Reviewers like Atomix and CGMagazine highlight the authentic recreations of historical figures such as James "Cool Papa" Bell and Wilbur "Bullet Joe" Rogan, emphasizing the immersive experience and the effort to honor baseball's rich past. The mode, narrated by Bob Kendrick, offers a unique way for players to engage with the legacy of Negro League players, as noted by CGMagazine, while also providing a sense of cultural and emotional depth, as mentioned by MeuPlayStation. Additionally, some critics, like GameBlast and GamingBolt, appreciate the mode's storytelling, with GamingBolt specifically commending the use of real-life quotes and animated illustrations that bring the players' stories to life. IGN Italia and Vandal also acknowledge the documentary-like approach and improved presentation, reinforcing the game's commitment to celebrating baseball history. However, several critics express disappointment with the mode's depth and content, noting that it feels less substantial than in previous years. ComicBook and GamersRD criticize the lack of new player narratives and the reduced number of stories, suggesting that the mode has become an afterthought or lacks the excitement of earlier iterations. Forbes and GameSpot point out that the Storylines addition is the lightest it has ever been at launch, with some missions being too brief and repetitive, as highlighted by Game Informer. Push Square also critiques the storytelling for relying on dated text message conversations, which can feel out of place in an otherwise modern game. Additionally, Gaming Age and IGN note that the mode lacks new ideas and feels less fleshed-out, with only a few notable players included, which diminishes the overall impact. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among critics is that the Storylines mode, especially its focus on the Negro Leagues, remains a significant and meaningful addition to MLB The Show 25. While some reviewers feel it has lost some of its former depth, many still recognize its value as an educational and historical experience. Critics like Gameliner and Gamesurf emphasize that the mode continues to be a highlight of the series, and MeuPlayStation and Vandal commend the emotional and cultural depth it adds. The mode is seen as a step forward in acknowledging baseball's past, even if it doesn't fully meet expectations in terms of content or innovation. Overall, it is viewed as a commendable effort that, while not perfect, contributes positively to the game's narrative and historical representation.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 shines with immersive mechanics like Ambush Hitting and dynamic difficulty, but its minor updates and flaws—unbalanced hitting, distracting throws—hold it back, though critics still hail it as a stellar, accessible baseball sim.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

80%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

20%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The majority of critics praised the gameplay of MLB The Show 25 for its innovative mechanics and enhanced strategic depth, highlighting features like Ambush Hitting, Diamond Quest, and improved defensive systems as standout additions. Atomix and COGconnected emphasized the game’s shift toward a more immersive and authentic experience, with the new pitch guessing system and refined fielding mechanics adding layers of realism. CGMagazine and Forbes noted that elements such as Swim Slide and better infield animations made hitting, fielding, and baserunning more dynamic, while Dynamic Difficulty (as mentioned by Game Informer and Meristation) catered to both casual and hardcore players. The first-person camera in Road to the Show and the GOAT difficulty setting (cited by But Why Tho? and MeuPlayStation) were also lauded for boosting engagement and accessibility. Critics like Vandal and GameBlast appreciated the originality brought by modes like Diamond Quest and the reworked progression systems, which added variety and kept the core experience feeling fresh and rewarding. However, some reviewers pointed out that the gameplay felt like a minor update rather than a revolutionary leap. Gameliner and GamersRD noted that while Ambush Hitting added depth, the overall changes were not substantial enough to excite long-time fans. Dot Esports and IGN mentioned persistent issues, such as unbalanced hitting mechanics and Perfect/Perfect outs that disrupted immersion. Dexerto found certain mechanics, like the throw meter, distracting, and Gaming Age (on Switch) criticized pitching inconsistencies in home run derbies, suggesting the Switch version lagged behind the PS5 in polish. Additionally, GamingBolt and GameSpot observed that the game sticks closely to its established formula, with new features like the roguelike mode in Diamond Dynasty (as noted by Gaming Age and Shacknews) feeling more like incremental tweaks than major overhauls. These critiques often centered on the game’s reliance on familiar systems despite its improvements. Despite the mixed feedback, the overall consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with the gameplay being described as stellar (GameSpot), high-level (IGN Italia), and very good (as emphasized by the user). While some felt the changes were subtle, the majority agreed that the new mechanics—such as Ambush Hitting, improved defensive AI, and customizable difficulty—elevated the experience without alienating core fans. Impulsegamer and Gamesurf highlighted the balance between realism and accessibility, and Vandal celebrated the game’s variety of styles and challenges. The criticisms, though valid, were often framed as nitpicks rather than deal-breakers, with many acknowledging that MLB The Show 25 successfully modernizes its formula while maintaining the depth that defines the series. The Switch-specific issues, as noted by Gaming Age and NintendoWorldReport, further underscored that the game’s strengths were platform-agnostic, reinforcing its status as a top-tier baseball simulation.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 shines with PS5 Pro's "stunning visuals" and lifelike details, but its aging engine and minimal upgrades spark backlash, with critics calling out texture glitches, outdated models, and muted colors. The Switch port is a disaster, lagging far behind. While some praise its polish and legacy, others demand a "graphical leap" for 2025—leaving the game stuck in neutral, visually competent but unrevolutionary.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

40%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

48%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

12%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The Graphics and Visual Design of MLB The Show 25 received praise from several critics for its realistic player animations, detailed stadiums, and immersive presentation. Atomix and But Why Tho? highlighted the "spectacular" graphics and "lifelike" gameplay, emphasizing that the absence of a PS4 version allowed the PS5 to showcase its full potential. Digital Chumps commended the PS5 Pro version for its "stunning visuals," including improved load times, lighting, and flawless player models, while Impulsegamer noted "vibrant stadium environments" and "realistic lighting and shadow effects" that leverage the console's capabilities. GameBlast and GameSpot also celebrated the accurate representation of players, both current and historical, as well as the attention to detail in recreating college uniforms and broadcast suites. These reviews suggest that the game maintains a high standard for the franchise, with many critics acknowledging its visual polish and consistency with past titles. However, several critics pointed out notable shortcomings, including minimal improvements over previous iterations and technical inconsistencies. Checkpoint Gaming and Forbes criticized visual glitches like texture issues and "outdated player models," while Gameliner and Gamesurf noted the aging graphical engine, which they argue has not evolved significantly in nearly two decades. ComicBook and GamingBolt expressed frustration over the lack of a "graphical leap," with IGN Italia and Meristation pointing to muted colors and unmet expectations for a 2025 release. LevelUp and Vandal mentioned minor issues like cloud rendering and close-up character models needing refinement, while Gaming Age and NintendoWorldReport highlighted the Switch version's technical limitations, calling its visuals "pretty ugly" and underscoring a stark contrast to more powerful platforms. These critiques collectively suggest that while the game is visually competent, it falls short of pushing the boundaries of next-gen hardware. The overall consensus among critics is mixed, reflecting a divide between those who appreciate the game's incremental improvements and those who feel it lacks innovation. While Dot Esports and MeuPlayStation praised its "visually impressive" presentation and celebration of the franchise's 20-year legacy, others like Push Square and GamerRD argued that the visuals have "stagnated" compared to prior years. The PS5 version, particularly the Pro variant, is seen as the standout, with Digital Chumps and Impulsegamer highlighting its strengths, but even this faces criticism for not fully utilizing hardware capabilities. Meanwhile, the Switch port is widely panned for its subpar graphics. Critics generally agree that the game is visually solid but not revolutionary, with a clear need for more substantial upgrades to keep pace with modern standards and justify the next-gen leap.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 nails immersive, lifelike audio with authentic bat pings, crowd noise, and Bob Kendrick’s narration, but its jarring soundtrack mixing, artificial crowd reactions, and repetitive lines snag its polish—minor flaws in an otherwise stellar sonic experience that champions baseball’s realism.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

69%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

31%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music in MLB The Show 25 receive widespread praise for their immersive and authentic qualities, with multiple critics highlighting specific elements that elevate the gameplay experience. Atomix commends the "immersive audio effects" and "diverse soundtrack including various well-known artists," while Digital Chumps and Dot Esports emphasize the satisfying realism of in-game sounds, such as the "distinctive ping of aluminum bats" and the "satisfying ping of aluminum bats" that enhance immersion, particularly in modes like Road to the Show. GameSpot and LevelUp also note the "captivating narration by Bob Kendrick" and "realistic audio effects," including the crack of the bat and crowd reactions, which create a lifelike atmosphere. Impulsegamer and Vandal further applaud the "authentic crowd noise" and "authentic sounds from matches," reinforcing the game’s ability to replicate the intensity of real baseball. These positive remarks collectively underscore the developers’ success in crafting a soundscape that feels dynamic and engaging, especially for fans of the sport. However, some critics point to notable flaws in the music and sound design, particularly regarding consistency and authenticity. Game Informer critiques the "artificial" quality of crowd excitement, suggesting it detracts from the realism, while Gamesurf and IGN Italia both mention the soundtrack’s "inconsistent" genre mixing and "lack of coherence," respectively. GamingBolt notes that "some lines can repeat," which may disrupt the immersion during extended play sessions. Additionally, Forbes points out "noticeable bugs" in the commentary, though they acknowledge the value of mode-specific voices. These criticisms indicate that while the audio elements are strong, certain aspects—such as the musical selection and repetitive commentary—fall short of expectations, creating a mixed impression for some reviewers. Overall, the consensus among critics leans positive, with the majority celebrating the game’s realistic and immersive sound design, particularly its attention to detail in in-game audio and crowd reactions. While the soundtrack’s diversity and genre variety are appreciated by some (e.g., Gameliner), others (like Gamesurf and IGN Italia) find it jarring or incoherent. Similarly, commentary issues are mentioned but often overshadowed by the praise for its naturalism and atmosphere. The critiques about artificial sounds and repetitive lines are seen as minor drawbacks rather than deal-breakers, as the core audio elements—such as the bat’s ping and authentic crowd noise—remain a standout feature. Collectively, the reviews suggest that MLB The Show 25 delivers a robust auditory experience that enhances its baseball authenticity, even if some aspects of the music and commentary require refinement.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25’s voice acting shines with charismatic narration, immersive commentary, and era-specific charm, earning praise for storytelling and authenticity. But repetition, uneven quality, and missing voice work in key modes (like Road to the Show) let down fans seeking polish, while regional and narrative gaps highlight missed potential. A standout feature, but flaws undermine its ambitions for a fully immersive baseball experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

42%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in MLB The Show 25 receives generally positive feedback, with several critics highlighting its strengths. Atomix and GameSpot praise Bob Kendrick’s narration in the Storylines mode, noting its "charismatic" and "captivating" qualities that enhance storytelling and add depth to the experience. Gamesurf and GamingBolt commend the high-quality commentary, emphasizing its immersive and natural flow, particularly during Storylines, which they argue elevates the game’s atmosphere. GameBlast appreciates the era-specific narrators, calling their inclusion "charming" and a unique touch that enriches match experiences. Additionally, Game Informer acknowledges that initial commentary glitches were addressed, improving the overall polish and enjoyment. These critiques underscore the voice acting’s role in creating an engaging and authentic baseball simulation, especially for fans of the sport’s lore and narrative elements. However, some criticisms point to notable shortcomings. ComicBook criticizes the absence of voice acting in Road to the Show’s cutscenes, calling it a "detraction" that makes the mode feel less immersive. Forbes notes "inaccuracies in commentary," which, while not ruining the experience, raise concerns about consistency. IGN Italia and Digital Chumps highlight issues with repetition and uneven quality, with the latter pointing out that minor league commentators "are less impressive" compared to their major league counterparts. IGN Italia also mentions that returning commentators, while familiar, can become "verbose" and "repetitive," which might frustrate players seeking fresh content. These critiques suggest that while the voice acting is largely effective, certain aspects—such as pacing, originality, and regional inclusivity—fall short of expectations, particularly in non-English markets or specific game modes. Overall, the consensus leans toward appreciation for the voice acting’s contributions to MLB The Show 25, but with acknowledged flaws. The majority of critics, including Atomix, GameSpot, and Gamesurf, emphasize its strengths in storytelling and immersion, while others like ComicBook and IGN Italia point to gaps in execution. The game’s focus on gameplay over narrative, as noted by Vandal, may mitigate some of these issues for casual players, but for those invested in the simulation’s authenticity, the repetitive lines and occasional inaccuracies are significant drawbacks. Despite these critiques, the voice acting remains a standout feature, with its charm and educational value (as praised by GameSpot) and era-specific flair (from GameBlast) offering a compelling experience that aligns with the series’ dedication to realism and fan engagement.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 offers a generally solid technical foundation across platforms, but performance gaps spark debate. The PS5 shines with smooth gameplay and DualSense polish, though glitches and optimization hiccups linger. The Switch impresses with improved stability but faces load-time issues. The Xbox Series X struggles with bugs and lag, lagging behind its rivals. While praised for its polish, the game’s technical execution remains a mixed bag, with platform-specific flaws tempering an otherwise strong launch.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

38%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

48%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

14%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of MLB The Show 25 on the PlayStation 5 (PS5) is largely praised for its smooth gameplay and effective utilization of the DualSense controller’s features, as highlighted by Atomix and GamingBolt, who noted polished presentation and stable controls. CGMagazine and Impulsegamer emphasized consistent frame rates and high performance during intense moments, showcasing the PS5’s capabilities. Game Informer and LevelUp pointed to a generally stable experience, with early issues like commentary glitches being patched, while Forbes and Vandal acknowledged minor audio bugs and the absence of significant graphical upgrades for the PS5 Pro, but overall deemed the technical foundation solid. On the Nintendo Switch, Gaming Age commended the game’s surprising performance, citing no loading delays or graphical hiccups, a marked improvement from previous iterations, though NintendoWorldReport noted technical shortcomings like slow load times, particularly in modes like Diamond Dynasty. Meanwhile, Shacknews reported bugs on the Xbox Series X, such as issues with stadium selection and online lag, though these were not as severe as other platform-specific concerns. On the PS5, critics like Checkpoint Gaming and COGconnected raised concerns about frequent visual glitches and AI/fielding inconsistencies, respectively, while IGN Italia and Meristation criticized frame rate drops and underutilization of hardware, suggesting stability and optimization gaps. MeuPlayStation highlighted dependency on online servers, which could impact performance at launch, and Gamesurf pointed to lag in online multiplayer despite a strong technical base. For the Switch, while Gaming Age praised its performance, NintendoWorldReport’s critique of slow load times and mode-specific issues revealed lingering technical challenges. The Xbox Series X faced its own hurdles, with Shacknews noting bugs in online play and stadium mechanics, though these were less pervasive than the PS5’s issues. Overall, the game’s technical execution appears to vary significantly across platforms, with the PS5 and Switch receiving mixed feedback and the Xbox version facing more noticeable problems. The overall consensus among critics suggests that MLB The Show 25 delivers a technically sound experience on the PS5, with most reviewers agreeing on smooth performance and effective use of hardware, albeit with minor bugs and optimization issues. The Switch’s performance, while improved, still has room for growth, as reflected in the contrasting assessments by Gaming Age and NintendoWorldReport. The Xbox Series X version, though less frequently reviewed, shows signs of instability, as noted by Shacknews. While Vandal and GamingBolt emphasized the game’s stability and polish, others like IGN Italia and Gamesurf called for better optimization and fewer technical hiccups. Despite these critiques, the game is generally seen as well-developed, with Gameliner and GamerRD acknowledging its solid foundation. The technical performance, therefore, appears to be a mixed bag, with platform-specific challenges tempering an otherwise positive reception.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

PRAISED FOR REPLAY VALUE MLB The Show 25 dazzles with Diamond Dynasty, Road to the Show, and Diamond Quest—a mix of deep customization, competitive modes, and randomized challenges that keep fans hooked. Critics like IGN and GameSpot call it a sports genre standout, ideal for veterans and newcomers. But Gameliner and GamingBolt flag repetitive gameplay and minimal new content for some, while NintendoWorldReport notes technical hiccups. Still, the consensus? It’s a must-play for baseball lovers, with updates and variety ensuring years of returns.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

79%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

21%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The majority of critics overwhelmingly praised the replay value of MLB The Show 25, highlighting its diverse array of game modes and features. Reviewers like Atomix and But Why Tho? emphasized the inclusion of modes such as Diamond Quest, Diamond Dynasty, and Road to the Show, which provide varied experiences for both casual and competitive players. CGMagazine and Checkpoint Gaming noted that the game’s customization options and continuous updates ensure long-term engagement, while COGconnected and ComicBook pointed to improvements in Diamond Dynasty and progression systems as key drivers of replayability. IGN and IGN Italia specifically praised the randomized challenges in Diamond Quest and the depth of Diamond Dynasty, which keep players invested. These elements collectively create a robust foundation for sustained play, appealing to baseball fans and series veterans alike. However, a smaller subset of critics raised concerns about the game’s replay value. Gameliner questioned the lack of significant new content and minimal updates, suggesting it may not justify the purchase for some. GamingBolt noted that while the game offers good replay value for fans, it could feel repetitive for others, and NintendoWorldReport mentioned technical issues in certain modes that might detract from the experience. Additionally, Gaming Age argued that the new modes might not be compelling enough for players who recently bought previous editions. These critiques, while valid, were less prominent compared to the widespread enthusiasm for the game’s core features. Despite these minor criticisms, the overall consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 delivers strong replay value. GameSpot, Digital Chumps, and MeuPlayStation all highlighted the game’s ability to cater to a wide audience, from casual players to hardcore enthusiasts, through its extensive modes and competitive elements. While some critics acknowledged room for improvement, the majority agreed that the game’s depth, innovation, and variety make it a compelling choice for baseball fans. The emphasis on modes like Diamond Dynasty and Road to the Show, combined with ongoing updates, positions MLB The Show 25 as a standout title in the sports genre, ensuring players return for years to come.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

80%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

20%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment toward MLB The Show 25 is overwhelmingly positive, with critics praising its substantial improvements and immersive gameplay. Reviewers like Atomix and Digital Chumps highlight the game as a standout title celebrating two decades of the franchise, emphasizing its "stunning visuals," "innovative features," and "authentic baseball experience." CGMagazine and Game Informer commend its "quality improvements" and "engaging gameplay," while Gameliner and LevelUp note its strong presentation, soundtrack, and diverse modes, calling it a "must-play for baseball fans" and the "most complete entry in the franchise." Forbes even hails it as "the best baseball video game ever made," awarding it a 9/10, and IGN Italia praises its revitalized game modes, positioning it as one of the top sports series available. These reviews collectively underscore the game’s refinement, depth, and dedication to simulating the sport with precision, making it a compelling choice for enthusiasts. However, several critics point to notable drawbacks that temper the enthusiasm. Checkpoint Gaming and Gaming Age note its "niche appeal" and "steep learning curve," suggesting it may not attract casual players. ComicBook and Eurogamer Portugal criticize "graphical shortcomings" and "lackluster Franchise mode additions," while Dot Esports and IGN mention persistent issues and "stagnant" elements like the Negro League storyline. GamersRD argues the game "falls short in updates and new features," making it less appealing for its price, and NintendoWorldReport highlights the technical limitations of the Switch version, which hinder its full potential. GamingBolt also warns of the risk of stagnation due to minimal visual upgrades and "familiar mechanics," indicating that while the core experience is strong, some areas feel underdeveloped or repetitive. Despite these critiques, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 remains a top-tier baseball simulation, justified by its refinements and content. Forbes and GameBlast acknowledge its imperfections but still rate it highly, with Forbes calling it the best in the series and GameBlast giving it a 9.0. Shacknews and Vandal emphasize its "polished" and "superior" qualities, while Meristation and Push Square stress its "well-rounded experience" and "refinements" that maintain its status as a leading sports title. Although some reviewers, like Gameliner and Impulsegamer, argue it’s a "must-have" for fans, others, such as COGconnected and Gamesurf, suggest it’s a "solid upgrade" rather than a revolutionary leap. The general agreement is that while not flawless, the game’s strengths in gameplay, modes, and authenticity outweigh its flaws, solidifying its place as a must-play for baseball enthusiasts.

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 is a polished, authentic baseball sim with stunning visuals, innovative modes, and near-perfect gameplay, hailed as the best in the series. But its steep learning curve, graphical hiccups, stagnant features, and technical flaws on Switch limit its appeal. While critics debate its "must-have" status, its depth and refinement cement it as a top-tier pick for fans, despite missed opportunities for revolutionary upgrades.

MONSTER

Reviews

56 reviews found

Forbes

PlayStation 5

Mar 21, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered the best baseball video game ever made, with a score of 9 out of 10, despite some areas needing improvement.

Read full review

LevelUp

PlayStation 5

May 21, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB: The Show 25 is praised as the most complete entry in the franchise, offering a rich experience for baseball fans and newcomers alike, making it one of the best sports titles of the year.

Read full review

GameBlast

PlayStation 5

Apr 9, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is highly rated at 9.0, indicating strong overall performance despite some drawbacks.

Read full review

But Why Tho?

PlayStation 5

Mar 19, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 successfully builds on its legacy with minor improvements, making it an excellent addition to the franchise that fans will enjoy.

Read full review

Impulsegamer

PlayStation 5

Mar 25, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a refined and immersive baseball experience that solidifies its position as the premier baseball simulation, making it a must-have for fans.

Read full review

Digital Chumps

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered a solid upgrade with improved gameplay, innovative features, and stunning visuals, making it a top choice for baseball fans.

Read full review

Shacknews

Xbox Series X

Mar 30, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered the best in the series, with meaningful improvements and a wealth of content despite some technical issues.

IGN

PlayStation 5

Mar 20, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 offers solid gameplay improvements and engaging modes, but some areas, particularly the Negro League storyline, feel stagnant, making it a worthwhile but imperfect upgrade.

Read full review

COGconnected

PlayStation 5

Mar 25, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a solid installment that builds on its predecessors, with improvements in gameplay and modes, despite some minor technical issues.

Read full review

Atomix

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a standout title that celebrates two decades of the franchise with significant improvements and innovations, making it a must-play for baseball fans despite its high price point.

Read full review