Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Playstation

Twitch

MONSTER

MLB The Show 25

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of MLB The Show 25
Item: MLB The Show 25
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2025

GenresThird Person Perspective, Simulation, Sports, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableMar 18, 2025

PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch

DeveloperSan Diego Studio

Overview

Forge your baseball journey in The Show

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 earns mixed reviews: praised for its historical focus, especially on the Negro Leagues, but criticized for a lack of new content and depth in the Storylines mode. While the game successfully honors baseball's legacy with immersive storytelling and authentic figures, many critics feel let down by the repetitive narratives and minimal innovation. Ultimately, it’s a missed opportunity to deliver a compelling narrative experience, leaving reviewers wanting more engaging content for future versions.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

47%

Mixed (50-79)

47%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The overall sentiment regarding the Story of MLB The Show 25 is mixed, with several critics praising the historical focus and educational aspects of the game. Reviewers like Atomix and Dot Esports commend the inclusion of the Negro Leagues, highlighting the immersive experience it provides through authentic recreations of legendary figures like James 'Cool Papa' Bell and Wilbur 'Bullet Joe' Rogan. Critics such as Impulsegamer and Vandal also appreciate the improved storytelling elements that enhance the historical context, with Vandal specifically noting the improved presentation and audio recordings that contribute to the game's documentary-like homage to significant players. The emphasis on honoring baseball's history and acknowledging past racial injustices resonates positively with many reviewers, as seen in the opinions of But Why Tho? and GamingBolt. However, despite the positive aspects, a significant number of critics express disappointment regarding the lack of new content and depth in the Storylines mode. Forbes and GamersRD point out that the addition of notable Negro League legends feels underwhelming, with Forbes stating that the Storylines addition is the lightest it’s ever been at launch. Critics like Gaming Age and IGN echo this sentiment, noting that the storylines seem less fleshed-out compared to previous years, with a lack of new challenges and player narratives leading to a sense of repetitiveness. The absence of significant advancements from prior iterations is a recurring theme, indicating a missed opportunity for innovation in the storytelling aspect of the game. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while MLB The Show 25 succeeds in its historical representation and educational value, it falls short in delivering a compelling and fresh narrative experience. Reviewers like GameSpot and IGN highlight the disappointment stemming from the lack of new individual player storylines and the overall feeling of diminishing returns. While the game maintains its commitment to honoring the legacy of the Negro Leagues, the critiques point to a need for more substantial and engaging content to elevate the Storylines mode in future iterations.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

TL;DR: MLB The Show 25 has been widely praised for its innovative gameplay features like Diamond Quest and Ambush Hitting, enhancing strategy and accessibility. Critics note improvements in fielding, batting, and popular modes, solidifying its reputation as a top baseball simulation. However, some issues like Perfect/Perfect outs and minimal overall changes were highlighted, leading to mixed feelings about the game's evolution. Despite this, it delivers a robust, engaging experience that balances realism with player enjoyment.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

76%

Mixed (50-79)

24%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of MLB The Show 25 has garnered widespread acclaim from critics, who have highlighted several innovative features and enhancements that elevate the overall experience. Reviewers such as Atomix and But Why Tho? praised the introduction of new mechanics like Diamond Quest and Ambush Hitting, which add layers of strategy and accessibility for players of varying skill levels. COGconnected noted improvements in fielding and batting mechanics, alongside a new pitch guessing system that contributes to a more authentic and rewarding gameplay experience. Many critics, including Eurogamer Portugal and GameSpot, emphasized the enhancements in popular modes like Road to the Show and Diamond Dynasty, which offer players greater control and engagement, further solidifying the game’s reputation for delivering a high-quality baseball simulation. Despite the overall positive reception, some critics pointed out certain drawbacks that could detract from the gameplay experience. Dot Esports mentioned ongoing issues with Perfect/Perfect outs, indicating that some mechanics may still feel unbalanced and affect player satisfaction. Additionally, GamersRD expressed that while new features are present, the overall changes felt minimal and did not significantly elevate the gameplay experience. This sentiment was echoed by Gaming Age, who described the gameplay as a minor update rather than a substantial evolution, suggesting that some players may desire more transformative changes. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 offers a robust and engaging gameplay experience, with many praising its innovations and refinements. The majority of reviewers, including IGN and Impulsegamer, acknowledged the balance between realism and accessibility, making it appealing to a wide audience. While some concerns regarding specific mechanics and the depth of changes were raised, the prevailing sentiment is that the game successfully builds upon its predecessor, providing players with a rich and immersive baseball experience that is both strategic and enjoyable.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25's graphics are a mixed bag; praised for realistic visuals and attention to detail on PS5, but criticized for minimal evolution from previous versions. While some highlight impressive aesthetics and quick load times, others argue it fails to meet 2025 expectations, showing little advancement over MLB The Show 24. The game impresses but underdelivers on the PS5's potential.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

46%

Mixed (50-79)

38%

Negative (0-49)

15%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of MLB The Show 25 have garnered a largely positive reception from several critics, particularly those who played the game on the PS5. Reviewers such as Atomix and Impulsegamer highlighted the game's impressive visual fidelity, praising the realistic player movements, detailed stadium environments, and the effective use of lighting and shadow effects. Digital Chumps noted that the PS5 Pro version showcases stunning visuals, including quick load times and flawless player models, further enhancing the overall gaming experience. Additionally, GameSpot commended the attention to detail in recreating college uniforms, contributing to the immersive atmosphere that fans of the series have come to expect. However, not all opinions were favorable, as several critics pointed out significant shortcomings in the graphics. Eurogamer Portugal and Forbes expressed disappointment with the minimal improvements over previous iterations, suggesting that the visuals lag behind what is expected from a 2025 title. GamersRD echoed this sentiment, stating that the graphics show no significant advancements compared to MLB The Show 24, with animations and player models appearing largely unchanged. Critics like IGN Italia also noted technical performance issues that detracted from the overall visual experience, indicating that while there are some advancements, they are not enough to warrant a PS5 Pro purchase. Overall, the consensus among critics presents a mixed view of MLB The Show 25's graphics and visual design. While some reviewers, like Dot Esports and Vandal, acknowledged the game's impressive visuals and attention to detail, the recurring theme of minimal evolution from previous titles suggests a need for further development. The contrasting opinions highlight a divide between those who appreciate the game's aesthetic and those who feel it falls short of modern expectations, particularly in light of the advancements in gaming technology. As a result, MLB The Show 25 appears to be a visually appealing game with notable strengths, but it also faces criticism for not fully capitalizing on the capabilities of the PS5.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25's sound design is largely praised for its immersive audio, realistic crowd noise, and engaging narration by Bob Kendrick, enhancing the authentic baseball experience. Critics celebrate the diverse soundtrack and satisfying sound effects, though some note bugs in commentary and a lack of coherence in the music selection. Despite these issues, the game's audio elements significantly enrich gameplay, solidifying its reputation as a standout title in the genre.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

78%

Mixed (50-79)

22%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of MLB The Show 25 have garnered a largely positive reception among critics, highlighting the game's immersive audio effects and the overall atmosphere it creates. Reviewers like Atomix and Impulsegamer commend the game for its authentic crowd noise and realistic sound effects, which contribute to a gameplay experience that feels akin to being at a real baseball game. The diverse soundtrack, featuring well-known artists, is noted by Atomix as enhancing the overall experience, while GameSpot emphasizes the captivating narration by Bob Kendrick, which adds depth to the storytelling aspect of the game. Additionally, the satisfying sounds of the ball hitting the bat, particularly the distinctive ping of aluminum bats, are frequently mentioned by critics such as Dot Esports and Digital Chumps, further enhancing player immersion. However, not all aspects of the sound design received unqualified praise. Forbes raises concerns about noticeable bugs in the commentary, which detracts from the overall experience, despite the appreciation for mode-specific commentary in franchise mode. IGN Italia criticizes the soundtrack selection for lacking coherence, suggesting that while the quality of the sound design is high, the musical elements do not always align well with the gameplay. Furthermore, GamingBolt notes that while the natural commentary and crowd excitement create an infectious atmosphere, some lines can repeat, which may lead to a sense of redundancy during extended play sessions. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 excels in its sound design, creating an immersive and authentic baseball experience. While there are notable criticisms regarding the commentary bugs and the coherence of the soundtrack, the strengths in audio effects and the atmosphere generated by crowd sounds and effective narration largely overshadow these shortcomings. Critics like GameSpot and Impulsegamer highlight the game's ability to capture the essence of baseball through sound, making it a significant component of the overall gameplay experience.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25's voice acting, especially Bob Kendrick's narration in Storylines mode, is praised for enhancing storytelling and immersion. Critics like Atomix and GameSpot commend the engaging delivery, while others, like Forbes and IGN Italia, point out issues with commentary inaccuracies and repetitiveness. Despite these flaws, the overall reception is positive, highlighting the voice acting as a strong asset with room for improvement in future versions.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

50%

Mixed (50-79)

50%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in MLB The Show 25 has garnered a largely positive reception from critics, particularly highlighting the contributions of Bob Kendrick in the Storylines mode. Atomix praises Kendrick's narration for adding a charismatic touch that enhances the storytelling aspect, a sentiment echoed by GameSpot, which notes that his captivating and educational delivery adds depth to the game. Additionally, Digital Chumps acknowledges the main commentators as engaging and entertaining, which contributes positively to the overall experience. The commentary is generally described as flowing naturally, with Impulsegamer emphasizing its role in enriching the atmosphere during gameplay, further supporting the immersive experience that the game aims to deliver. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the voice acting as well. Forbes points out issues with inaccuracies in the commentary, suggesting that while it remains enjoyable, there are moments that detract from the overall quality. IGN Italia mentions that the returning commentators, despite having new lines, can become repetitive and verbose, which may hinder the freshness of the experience. Furthermore, Vandal raises a concern about the game's exclusive English voice acting, which could limit accessibility for non-English speaking players, although they note that this is less impactful given the game's focus on gameplay rather than narrative. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while MLB The Show 25 features strong voice acting that enhances the gaming experience, particularly through the contributions of Bob Kendrick and the main commentators, there are areas for improvement. The commentary's repetitiveness and inaccuracies are acknowledged, suggesting that while the voice acting is a strong asset, it is not without its flaws. Critics like Digital Chumps and IGN Italia highlight the duality of the experience—engaging yet occasionally flawed—indicating that the voice acting contributes positively to the game but also leaves room for refinement in future installments.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 shines on PS5 with smooth performance and great DualSense features, but faces issues like AI indecision and frame rate drops. Critics praise its overall polish, despite some bugs. In stark contrast, the Nintendo Switch version disappoints with slow load times and significant performance issues, making it a less favorable choice. Players should temper expectations based on their platform.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

36%

Mixed (50-79)

45%

Negative (0-49)

18%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In analyzing the technical performance of MLB The Show 25 across different gaming platforms, the PlayStation 5 emerges as the clear frontrunner in terms of positive feedback. Reviewers such as Atomix and Impulsegamer highlight the game's smooth performance and effective utilization of the DualSense features, which enhance the overall gameplay experience. Critics like GamingBolt and Vandal also commend the polished presentation and smooth controls, indicating that the game runs well even during intense gameplay moments. Overall, the PS5 version is characterized by a stable experience, with Forbes noting that it performs well overall despite some minor bugs in audio. However, the PS5 version is not without its criticisms. COGconnected points out issues like indecisive AI and occasional hiccups in fielding, which detract from the overall experience. IGN Italia raises concerns about frame rate drops and bugs, suggesting a need for improvements in stability. While But Why Tho? acknowledges that glitches and visual artifacts are present, they are deemed less disruptive than in previous iterations. This mixed bag of technical performance highlights that, despite the PS5's advantages, there are still areas that require attention. In contrast, the Nintendo Switch version suffers significantly in terms of technical performance. NintendoWorldReport notes serious shortcomings, particularly slow load times that negatively impact gameplay, especially in modes like Diamond Dynasty. This starkly contrasts with the generally favorable reception of the PS5 version. The overall consensus among critics indicates that while the PS5 offers a solid and enjoyable experience, there are notable technical issues that need addressing. The Switch version, on the other hand, appears to struggle more considerably, suggesting that players may need to manage their expectations depending on the platform they choose.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 gets predominantly positive reviews for its replay value, with critics praising new modes like Diamond Quest and enhancements in gameplay. Despite concerns about minimal updates and technical issues potentially impacting longevity, most reviewers agree the game's variety keeps players engaged, making it a solid choice for both casual and competitive fans.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

65%

Mixed (50-79)

35%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of MLB The Show 25 is predominantly positive, with many critics praising the game's variety of modes and engaging gameplay. Reviewers like Atomix and Dot Esports highlight the introduction of new modes, such as Diamond Quest and enhancements in Diamond Dynasty and Road to the Show, which provide players with diverse experiences and challenges. Critics like IGN and GameSpot specifically mention how the randomized challenges in Diamond Quest contribute to a fun and engaging experience, ensuring that players have ample opportunities to return to the game. Furthermore, Forbes emphasizes that the wealth of modes and options guarantees high replay value, appealing to both competitive and casual players alike. However, not all opinions are favorable, as some critics express concerns about the replay value being less compelling for certain audiences. GamersRD raises a valid point about the minimal updates and lack of significant new content, suggesting that this could hinder the game's longevity and justify the purchase for some players. Similarly, Gaming Age notes that while the game introduces new modes, it may not be enough to entice players who have recently purchased previous editions, potentially affecting its replay value. Additionally, NintendoWorldReport mentions technical issues that could lead to certain modes becoming tedious, which may detract from the overall experience. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among reviewers leans towards a positive outlook on the replay value of MLB The Show 25. Most critics agree that the game offers a rich variety of modes and experiences that cater to different player preferences, with many, including Impulsegamer and Eurogamer Portugal, asserting that the enhancements in gameplay mechanics significantly boost replayability. While there are concerns about repetitiveness and the appeal for players of previous editions, the majority of reviewers seem to believe that the engaging nature of the new modes and the continuous updates will keep players coming back for more, solidifying MLB The Show 25 as a worthwhile title for baseball fans.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive (80-100)

84%

Mixed (50-79)

16%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment surrounding MLB The Show 25 is largely positive, with many critics praising the game for its significant improvements and innovations. Reviewers such as Atomix and Impulsegamer highlight the title as a standout entry that not only celebrates the franchise's two-decade legacy but also introduces refined gameplay and immersive experiences. Critics like Dexerto and Digital Chumps emphasize the game's advancements across various modes, with Digital Chumps specifically noting the stunning visuals that enhance the overall presentation. Eurogamer Portugal even goes as far as to declare it the best in the series in the last five years, showcasing a consensus that the game successfully builds upon its predecessors while providing enjoyable gameplay and new features. However, despite the many accolades, there are notable criticisms that temper the overall enthusiasm for MLB The Show 25. Several reviewers, including Dot Esports and GamersRD, point out persistent technical issues and a lack of substantial updates or new features, which may leave some players feeling that the game is merely a roster update rather than a groundbreaking release. IGN mentions that certain areas, particularly the Negro League storyline, feel stagnant, while Gaming Age echoes this sentiment by suggesting that the game might not be as appealing for those who have played recent installments. These critiques indicate that while the game is solid, it may not fully meet the expectations of all fans, especially those seeking significant innovations. In conclusion, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 is a commendable installment in the franchise, offering a refined and enjoyable baseball simulation experience. While many reviewers celebrate its improvements and engaging modes, there are valid concerns regarding technical shortcomings and a perceived lack of groundbreaking content. Critics like Forbes and Vandal affirm its status as a top choice for baseball fans, but the mixed reviews on certain aspects suggest that the game, while strong, still has room for growth. Overall, MLB The Show 25 is recommended for fans of the series, particularly those who may not have played in a while, but it may not be a must-have for everyone due to its incremental nature.

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 is largely praised for its significant improvements and engaging gameplay, with critics calling it a standout entry in the franchise. However, it faces criticism for technical issues and a perceived lack of substantial new features, leading some to feel it’s just a roster update. While it’s recommended for series fans, it may not be a must-have for everyone due to its incremental updates.

MONSTER

Reviews

50 reviews found

Digital Chumps

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered a solid upgrade with improved gameplay, innovative features, and stunning visuals, making it a top choice for baseball fans.

Read full review

Impulsegamer

PlayStation 5

Mar 25, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a refined and immersive baseball experience that solidifies its position as the premier baseball simulation, making it a must-have for fans.

Read full review

Forbes

PlayStation 5

Mar 21, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered the best baseball video game ever made, with a score of 9 out of 10, despite some areas needing improvement.

Read full review

But Why Tho?

PlayStation 5

Mar 19, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 successfully builds on its legacy with minor improvements, making it an excellent addition to the franchise that fans will enjoy.

Read full review

COGconnected

PlayStation 5

Mar 25, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a solid installment that builds on its predecessors, with improvements in gameplay and modes, despite some minor technical issues.

Read full review

IGN

PlayStation 5

Mar 20, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 offers solid gameplay improvements and engaging modes, but some areas, particularly the Negro League storyline, feel stagnant, making it a worthwhile but imperfect upgrade.

Read full review

Atomix

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a standout title that celebrates two decades of the franchise with significant improvements and innovations, making it a must-play for baseball fans despite its high price point.

Read full review

IGN Italia

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is one of the best sports series available, successfully revitalizing key game modes while still having room for graphical improvements.

Read full review

Dot Esports

PlayStation 5

Mar 17, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a solid entry in the series, with enjoyable gameplay and new features, though it faces criticism for some persistent issues and a lackluster Franchise mode addition.

Read full review

Dexerto

PlayStation 5

Mar 18, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The overall verdict is positive, stating that MLB The Show 25 is one of the best installments in years, with significant improvements across various modes.

Read full review