Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Playstation

Twitch

MONSTER

MLB The Show 25

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of MLB The Show 25
Item: MLB The Show 25
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2025

GenresThird Person Perspective, Simulation, Sports, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableMar 18, 2025

PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch

DeveloperSan Diego Studio

Overview

Forge your baseball journey in The Show

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25's Story mode earns praise for honoring Negro League legends with immersive storytelling and educational content, but critics are disappointed by its lack of depth and innovation. While the historical aspects shine, the repetitive gameplay and fewer narratives leave many feeling the mode falls short of its potential, calling for more engaging storytelling in future iterations.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

52%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

44%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The reviews of MLB The Show 25's Story mode, particularly its focus on the Negro Leagues, highlight several positive aspects that critics appreciate. Many reviewers, such as Atomix and Dot Esports, commend the game's effort to honor historical figures like James 'Cool Papa' Bell and Wilbur 'Bullet Joe' Rogan, enhancing the immersive experience with authentic recreations and educational content. Critics like CGMagazine and Vandal note the improved presentation and storytelling elements, including the incorporation of new audio recordings and narrated segments that celebrate the contributions of legendary players. The mode is described as an interactive museum experience, allowing players to engage with baseball's rich history while reliving significant moments, as highlighted by reviewers from Game Informer and GamingBolt. However, there is a notable undercurrent of disappointment among critics regarding the depth and innovation of the Storylines mode. Many, including ComicBook and Forbes, express that the mode feels lackluster compared to previous iterations, with fewer stories and a perceived lack of new content. Critics like GamersRD and Gaming Age point out that the absence of significant player narratives diminishes the excitement, while others, such as IGN and NintendoWorldReport, mention that the gameplay challenges have become repetitive and fail to offer significant advancements. This sentiment is echoed by GameBlast, who notes that the storyline mode is becoming increasingly shorter over time. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed, with a shared appreciation for the historical significance of the Negro Leagues and the educational aspects of the Storylines mode, as noted by reviewers from Shacknews and MeuPlayStation. However, the lack of depth and new narratives has left many feeling that the mode is not living up to its potential, as highlighted by the critiques from GameSpot and IGN Italia. While the game continues to honor baseball's past, the overall sentiment suggests a desire for more engaging and innovative storytelling that goes beyond what has been offered in previous versions.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 impresses with innovative mechanics like Ambush Hitting and Diamond Quest, earning praise for its engaging gameplay and accessibility across skill levels. Critics highlight improvements in pitching, batting, and fielding, making it strategically immersive. However, some feel the game lacks significant evolution and has lingering issues, particularly with Perfect/Perfect outs. Overall, it’s a strong entry, balancing realism and accessibility for both newcomers and veterans.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

80%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

20%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of MLB The Show 25 has garnered a largely positive reception from critics, with many praising the introduction of innovative mechanics that enhance the overall experience. Notable features such as Ambush Hitting, Diamond Quest, and improved defensive mechanics have been highlighted by reviewers like Atomix and COGconnected, who emphasize how these additions make the game more strategic and immersive. Critics from But Why Tho? and Eurogamer Portugal also noted that the new GOAT difficulty setting and refined gameplay systems cater to a wide range of skill levels, making the game accessible yet challenging. The gameplay is described as engaging and crisp, with enhancements in pitching, batting, and fielding mechanics that contribute to a rewarding experience, as indicated by GameSpot and Digital Chumps. Despite the overall praise, some critics pointed out that certain aspects of the gameplay feel underwhelming or lack significant evolution from previous iterations. For instance, Gameliner and Gaming Age suggested that while Ambush Hitting adds depth, its absence wouldn't have been missed, indicating a sense of minimal change. Additionally, Dot Esports mentioned persistent issues with Perfect/Perfect outs, which could detract from the player experience. Critics like Checkpoint Gaming noted that the game requires a considerable understanding of baseball, which may pose challenges for newcomers, potentially alienating less experienced players. In conclusion, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 delivers a solid gameplay experience with several noteworthy improvements, particularly in modes like Road to the Show and Diamond Dynasty. While some reviewers, such as Push Square and Meristation, felt that the game remains largely similar to its predecessors, the majority agree that the new mechanics and refinements contribute positively to the overall enjoyment. The game successfully balances realism and accessibility, appealing to both seasoned players and newcomers, as highlighted by critics like MeuPlayStation and Impulsegamer. Overall, MLB The Show 25 is regarded as a strong entry in the series, with gameplay that is both engaging and strategically rich.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 dazzles with stunning PS5 graphics and lifelike environments, earning praise for its immersive visuals. However, critics lament a lack of substantial upgrades from past titles, pointing to glitches and an aging engine that hinder the overall experience. While some elements shine, there's a widespread call for major enhancements to meet next-gen expectations, leaving fans craving more graphical innovation.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

40%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

48%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

12%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The opinions on the graphics and visual design of MLB The Show 25 highlight several positive aspects that critics have noted. Many reviewers, such as Atomix and Impulsegamer, praised the game for its spectacular graphics, emphasizing realistic player movements and vibrant stadium environments that leverage the capabilities of the PS5. Critics like Digital Chumps also highlighted the stunning visuals of the PS5 Pro version, particularly noting improvements in load times, lighting, and player models. The overall presentation has been described as immersive and lifelike, with Dot Esports and MeuPlayStation acknowledging the high standard maintained throughout the series and the celebration of the franchise's evolution over 20 years. However, there are significant criticisms regarding the game's graphics that cannot be overlooked. Several reviewers, including ComicBook and Push Square, expressed disappointment with the lack of substantial improvements compared to previous titles, indicating a sense of stagnation in visual fidelity. Critics like Checkpoint Gaming and Eurogamer Portugal pointed out visual glitches and inconsistencies, such as texture issues and outdated player models, which detract from the overall experience. Furthermore, Gameliner and GamingBolt echoed concerns about the aging graphical engine, suggesting that it may be time for a significant overhaul to meet modern standards. The overall consensus among critics seems to reflect a mixed sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of MLB The Show 25. While many appreciate the realistic player models and immersive environments, there is a clear call for more significant advancements in visual fidelity. Critics like Forbes and Meristation articulated a desire for improvements that align with the expectations for a 2025 title, noting that the visuals lag behind what is anticipated from next-gen consoles. Ultimately, while the game showcases some impressive elements, the prevailing opinion is that it has not fully capitalized on the potential of current hardware, leaving many players wanting more in terms of graphical innovation.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 boasts immersive sound design and a diverse soundtrack that enhance gameplay, earning praise for realistic audio effects and crowd reactions. However, critics noted bugs in commentary, a lack of coherence in the soundtrack, and repetitive commentary lines as areas needing improvement. Overall, the sound design is a standout feature that elevates the gaming experience, despite some inconsistencies.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

69%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

31%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of MLB The Show 25 have received generally positive feedback from critics, highlighting the immersive audio experience that significantly enhances gameplay. Reviewers like Atomix and LevelUp praised the sound design for its ability to capture the essence of a baseball game, with realistic audio effects such as the satisfying ping of aluminum bats and authentic crowd reactions. Digital Chumps and GameSpot echoed this sentiment, noting how effective audio feedback during gameplay, especially the sounds of the ball hitting the bat, contributes to a more engaging experience. Additionally, the diverse soundtrack has been appreciated by critics like Gameliner, who found it enjoyable and well-suited for navigating menus, further enriching the overall atmosphere of the game. However, the reviews also pointed out several areas for improvement. Forbes mentioned noticeable bugs in the commentary, which detracted from the overall experience, while IGN Italia criticized the soundtrack selection for lacking coherence. Game Informer noted that while crowd reactions generally enhance the experience, some sounds, particularly the crowd's excitement, felt artificial. Critics like Gamesurf and GamingBolt also highlighted issues with repetitive commentary lines, which could detract from the immersion that the game aims to provide. These critiques suggest that while the sound design has strong elements, there are inconsistencies that need addressing. Overall, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 offers a solid sound design that effectively enhances the gameplay experience, with many praising its immersive qualities and attention to detail. Critics like Impulsegamer and Vandal emphasized the authentic atmosphere created by the sound effects, which contribute to the game's realism. Despite some criticisms regarding commentary bugs and soundtrack coherence, the general sentiment leans towards appreciation for the audio elements, indicating that the sound design is a noteworthy aspect of the game that successfully elevates the player's experience.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25's voice acting shines with engaging narration from Bob Kendrick, praised for enhancing storytelling and atmosphere. Critics highlight the charm of era-switching narrators and entertaining commentators. However, gaps in Road to the Show cutscenes, commentary inaccuracies, and repetitiveness are noted as drawbacks. While the voice work generally enriches the experience, there's room for improvement, especially in accessibility and refinement. Overall, a mixed but favorable reception.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

42%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in MLB The Show 25 has garnered praise for its engaging and charismatic elements, particularly highlighted by critics such as Atomix and GameSpot. Atomix commends Bob Kendrick's narration in the Storylines mode, describing it as a "charismatic touch" that enriches the storytelling aspect of the game. Similarly, GameSpot echoes this sentiment, noting Kendrick's narration as captivating and educational, which adds depth to the overall experience. Additionally, GameBlast appreciates the ability to switch narrators from different eras, which adds a unique charm to the matches. Critics like Digital Chumps and GamingBolt also recognize the main commentators as engaging and entertaining, contributing positively to the immersive atmosphere of the game. However, the voice acting in MLB The Show 25 is not without its drawbacks. ComicBook points out the lack of voice acting in the Road to the Show cutscenes, which diminishes the overall presentation and engagement. Forbes mentions inaccuracies in the commentary, suggesting that while enjoyable, it could benefit from refinement. IGN Italia also notes that while returning commentators have new lines, they can become repetitive and verbose, which may detract from the experience. Furthermore, Vandal raises a concern about the game's English-only release, which could limit accessibility for non-English speaking players, although he acknowledges that the focus on gameplay somewhat mitigates this issue. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates a mixed but generally favorable view of the voice acting in MLB The Show 25. While many reviewers, including Atomix and GameSpot, celebrate the engaging narration and commentary that enhance the game's atmosphere, others like ComicBook and Forbes highlight significant areas for improvement, particularly in cutscenes and commentary accuracy. Despite these criticisms, the majority of reviewers agree that the voice acting contributes positively to the overall experience, with many appreciating the immersive qualities it brings to the game. This blend of strengths and weaknesses suggests that while MLB The Show 25 excels in certain aspects of voice acting, there are still opportunities for enhancement in future iterations.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 is technically solid on PS5, with praise for smooth performance and DualSense features, but suffers from visual glitches and AI issues. The Nintendo Switch version impresses with better performance than last year, but slow load times drag it down. Xbox Series X faces bugs and lag affecting online play. Overall, while enjoyable, the game needs refinement to truly shine across platforms.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

38%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

48%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

14%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of MLB The Show 25 has received a mixed but generally positive reception across various gaming platforms. On the PlayStation 5, many critics, including Atomix and GamingBolt, praised the game for its smooth performance, effective use of DualSense features, and polished presentation. Impulsegamer highlighted the high frame rates maintained even during intense gameplay, showcasing the console's capabilities. Additionally, Forbes and Game Informer noted that while there were some early glitches, most have been patched, leading to a more stable experience. On the Nintendo Switch, Gaming Age commended the game for running surprisingly well without noticeable issues, marking an improvement over the previous year's version. However, there are notable negatives that critics have pointed out across platforms. On the PS5, Checkpoint Gaming and COGconnected reported frequent visual glitches and technical issues, such as indecisive AI and hiccups in fielding, which detract from the overall experience. IGN Italia echoed these concerns, mentioning frame rate drops and bugs that indicate a need for improved stability. MeuPlayStation raised concerns about the dependency on online servers affecting performance, particularly at launch. On the Nintendo Switch, while there were positives, NintendoWorldReport highlighted technical shortcomings, particularly slow load times that negatively impacted modes like Diamond Dynasty. On the Xbox Series X, Shacknews noted bugs related to stadium selection and lag during online play, indicating that the experience may not be as seamless as desired. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while MLB The Show 25 demonstrates solid technical performance on the PS5, there are significant issues that need addressing, particularly regarding visual glitches and online stability. The Nintendo Switch version shows promise but suffers from slow load times, while the Xbox Series X has its own set of bugs that hinder performance. Critics like Dot Esports and Vandal suggest that despite these issues, the game manages to provide an enjoyable experience, though it may not fully leverage the capabilities of the current hardware across all platforms. As a whole, the reviews reflect a game that is well-developed but still requires further refinement to reach its full potential.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 boasts strong replay value, lauded for its diverse modes like Diamond Dynasty and Road to the Show, keeping both casual and hardcore players engaged. Critics praise continuous updates, though some worry about minimal new content for recent players and potential technical issues. Overall, the game offers a rich experience, but not without its caveats.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

79%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

21%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of MLB The Show 25 is overwhelmingly positive, with many critics praising the variety of modes and features that contribute to an engaging experience. Critics such as Atomix and Dot Esports highlight the game's multiple modes, including Diamond Dynasty, Road to the Show, and the newly introduced Diamond Quest, which provide ample opportunities for players to immerse themselves in different gameplay experiences. The continuous updates and improvements in these modes, as noted by CGMagazine and IGN, further enhance the game's replayability, making it appealing for both returning and new players. Many reviewers, including Game Informer and MeuPlayStation, emphasize that the depth and customization options available cater to a wide range of players, from casual fans to hardcore baseball enthusiasts. However, not all opinions are uniformly positive. Some critics, like GamersRD and Gaming Age, express concerns over the replay value, suggesting that the updates may not be substantial enough to justify a purchase for those who have recently acquired previous editions. GamersRD specifically points out that minimal updates and a lack of significant new content could deter players from returning to the game. Additionally, NintendoWorldReport mentions potential technical issues that could affect the enjoyment of certain modes, leading to a perception of repetitiveness that might diminish the overall experience for some players. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among the majority of reviewers is that MLB The Show 25 offers a strong replay value. The game's diverse modes and engaging mechanics, as reiterated by critics like Push Square and Vandal, suggest that players will find themselves returning to the game frequently. The enhancements in modes like Diamond Dynasty and the introduction of new gameplay elements have been positively received, indicating that the game is well-equipped to keep players engaged throughout the year. Overall, while there are some caveats regarding the depth of new content, the prevailing sentiment is that MLB The Show 25 provides a rich and rewarding experience for baseball fans.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

81%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

19%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment towards MLB The Show 25 is predominantly positive, with many critics praising the game for its significant improvements and engaging gameplay. Atomix highlights the title as a standout entry that celebrates two decades of the franchise, emphasizing its innovations and appeal to baseball fans despite a high price point. Critics like Digital Chumps and LevelUp echo this sentiment, noting the game's refined gameplay and immersive experience, which solidifies its position as a premier baseball simulation. Additionally, Eurogamer Portugal and Forbes commend it as one of the best entries in recent years, with Forbes even labeling it the best baseball video game ever made. The variety of modes and quality improvements are frequently cited as strengths, making it a must-play for both fans and newcomers alike. However, there are notable criticisms that temper the overall enthusiasm. Several reviewers, including Checkpoint Gaming and Gaming Age, point out the steep learning curve and the game's niche appeal, which may limit its audience. Critics like Dot Esports and IGN mention persistent issues, particularly in the Franchise mode and the Negro League storyline, suggesting that certain aspects feel stagnant or underdeveloped. Furthermore, some reviews, such as from GamingBolt and GamersRD, express concerns about the game's risk of stagnation due to minimal visual improvements and a lack of groundbreaking features, indicating that while the game is solid, it may not be as revolutionary as some fans had hoped. In summary, the consensus among critics is that MLB The Show 25 is a strong and solid installment in the franchise, building on its legacy with meaningful improvements and engaging gameplay. While many reviewers, including CGMagazine and Game Informer, regard it as a worthy update, they also acknowledge the presence of technical issues and areas needing enhancement. Overall, MLB The Show 25 is seen as a must-have for baseball enthusiasts, but with caveats regarding its accessibility and certain gameplay elements that may not resonate with all players.

TL;DR

MLB The Show 25 is widely praised for its significant improvements and engaging gameplay, marking a strong entry in the franchise's two-decade history. Critics commend its variety of modes and immersive experience, with some calling it the best baseball game ever. However, concerns about a steep learning curve, stagnant features, and issues in Franchise mode temper the excitement. While it's a solid choice for baseball fans, some elements may alienate casual players.

MONSTER

Reviews

55 reviews found

Digital Chumps

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered a solid upgrade with improved gameplay, innovative features, and stunning visuals, making it a top choice for baseball fans.

Read full review

Impulsegamer

PlayStation 5

Mar 25, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a refined and immersive baseball experience that solidifies its position as the premier baseball simulation, making it a must-have for fans.

Read full review

GameBlast

PlayStation 5

Apr 9, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game is highly rated at 9.0, indicating strong overall performance despite some drawbacks.

Read full review

Forbes

PlayStation 5

Mar 21, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered the best baseball video game ever made, with a score of 9 out of 10, despite some areas needing improvement.

Read full review

But Why Tho?

PlayStation 5

Mar 19, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 successfully builds on its legacy with minor improvements, making it an excellent addition to the franchise that fans will enjoy.

Read full review

LevelUp

PlayStation 5

May 21, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB: The Show 25 is praised as the most complete entry in the franchise, offering a rich experience for baseball fans and newcomers alike, making it one of the best sports titles of the year.

Read full review

Shacknews

Xbox Series X

Mar 30, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is considered the best in the series, with meaningful improvements and a wealth of content despite some technical issues.

COGconnected

PlayStation 5

Mar 25, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a solid installment that builds on its predecessors, with improvements in gameplay and modes, despite some minor technical issues.

Read full review

IGN

PlayStation 5

Mar 20, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 offers solid gameplay improvements and engaging modes, but some areas, particularly the Negro League storyline, feel stagnant, making it a worthwhile but imperfect upgrade.

Read full review

Atomix

PlayStation 5

Mar 24, 2025

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

MLB The Show 25 is a standout title that celebrates two decades of the franchise with significant improvements and innovations, making it a must-play for baseball fans despite its high price point.

Read full review