MonsterCritic
Little Goody Two Shoes cover image
Links
Steam Icon
Steam
Twitch Icon
Twitch

79

MONSTER

Star Icon

Little Goody Two Shoes

2023
GenresAdventure, Action, Horror, RPG, Visual Novel, Single Player
AvailableOct 31, 2023
PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, PC, Nintendo Switch
DeveloperAstralShift
Overview

Little Goody Two Shoes is an tactical narrative RPG that tells the story of Elise, an ambitious girl stuck in a village too small for her big dreams. In this village of Kieferberg you’ll have to work toward your main goal - hiding an innocent witch from the merciless villagers. Lies, deception, strategic choices and treachery! In this bizarre fairy tale all choices matter in order to protect your reputation and get what you truly desire. All means justify the end, or do they?

Score icon

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

83

TL;DR

Critics raved for its haunting blend of fairy-tale whimsy and psychological horror, praising its morally complex narrative, genre-defying mix of romance, life-sim, and sapphic terror, and Elise’s dark journey through religious austerity and supernatural dread—though a few noted minor pacing issues and jarring tonal shifts.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

83

Positive Reviews (80-100)

89%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

11%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The majority of critics praised The Story of Little Goody Two Shoes for its rich narrative depth, thematic complexity, and innovative genre-blending approach. Cubed3 highlighted the story’s engaging exploration of ambition, temptation, and the cost of dreams, while GamingTrend lauded its "captivating and dark story" infused with occult mystery and moral dilemmas. Metro GameCentral celebrated its "strange and unconventional mix of genres," calling it "creepy, charming, and wonderfully unpredictable." PlaySense and PlayStation Universe emphasized the game’s fusion of fairy tales with psychological horror and resource management mechanics, respectively, while Destructoid noted its exploration of social persecution and personal identity through a "sapphic horror" lens. TheXboxHub and Eurogamer Germany praised the narrative’s tension and character-driven storytelling, with the latter highlighting Elise’s journey as a "fascinating and intriguing" tale rooted in religious austerity and supernatural elements. Multiple critics, including ZTGD and SpazioGames, underscored the game’s unique premise—Elise’s quest for wishes via mysterious red shoes—and its ability to balance whimsy with existential dread. While most reviews were overwhelmingly positive, a few critics pointed to minor flaws. Everyeye.it noted that while the story is "of good quality," it "lacks narrative flair," and Push Square mentioned the plot starts "slowly but picks up later." GGRecon described the game as beginning "seemingly wholesome" before shifting into a "surrealist environment full of eyes and inanimate objects coming to life," which could feel jarring to some. Noisy Pixel acknowledged the narrative’s "low-stakes adventure" despite its layered supernatural elements, and Digital Chumps suggested the branching paths and RPG mechanics occasionally felt disjointed. These critiques, however, were relatively rare and often framed as minor quibbles rather than major shortcomings. Overall, the consensus among critics was overwhelmingly positive, with nearly all praising the game’s storytelling, thematic ambition, and genre experimentation. The narrative’s exploration of morality, identity, and the consequences of desire resonated strongly, as did its multiple endings and player agency. Critics like PC Invasion and Siliconera emphasized the "excellent" and "well-written" story, while XboxEra and TierraGamer highlighted its engaging mix of horror, romance, and life-sim elements. Even those with minor reservations acknowledged the game’s strengths, reinforcing that The Story of Little Goody Two Shoes is a standout title in its niche, offering a haunting yet compelling experience that balances darkness with charm.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Critics raved for its haunting blend of fairy-tale whimsy and psychological horror, praising its morally complex narrative, genre-defying mix of romance, life-sim, and sapphic terror, and Elise’s dark journey through religious austerity and supernatural dread—though a few noted minor pacing issues and jarring tonal shifts.

73

TL;DR

Little Goody Two Shoes dazzles with its bold genre blend—resource management, puzzles, dating sims, horror—but falters with repetition, frustrating trials, and tedious systems. Despite clunky mechanics and odd save points, its creative depth and replayable charm make it a standout, niche experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

73

Positive Reviews (80-100)

26%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

74%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Little Goody Two Shoes is widely praised for its eclectic blend of genres and mechanics, creating a unique and engaging experience. Critics highlight the game’s ability to seamlessly integrate elements like resource management, puzzle-solving, dating simulations, and survival horror into a cohesive framework. Cubed3 emphasizes the balance between exploration, puzzles, and resource management, while GamingTrend notes the structured daily routines that include chores, dates, and mini-games. Metro GameCentral applauds the effective integration of the horror angle, and PlaySense praises the one-week time structure with distinct phases like morning, afternoon, and night. TheXboxHub and Siliconera commend the retro-style arcade minigames and varied activities, while RPG Site and Worth Playing appreciate the mix of dating sims, visual novels, and life simulation that offers replay value through multiple endings. These elements collectively create a rich, layered experience that appeals to fans of diverse gameplay styles. However, several critics point out notable drawbacks. Push Square criticizes the repetitive nature of daily tasks, while Destructoid and Nintendo Life highlight frustrations with trial-and-error puzzles during the "Witching Hour" segment, which can feel overly challenging or arbitrary. Noisy Pixel and SpazioGames note that managing health bars, resources, and limited supplies can become tedious, and some mini-games rely on chance or random mechanics, as mentioned by TheXboxHub. GamingTrend suggests the game could benefit from more side quests and exploration content, while Destructoid criticizes odd save points and instant-kill sequences that disrupt immersion. These issues, though not universal, indicate areas where the gameplay’s complexity occasionally clashes with its accessibility. Overall, the critics agree that Little Goody Two Shoes is a standout title for its innovative fusion of genres and thoughtful design, despite some flaws. The game’s structured daily progression, varied activities, and emphasis on player choice are frequently cited as strengths, with Metro GameCentral and PlaySense lauding its balance and creativity. While criticisms about repetition, puzzle difficulty, and resource management persist, they are often framed as minor drawbacks in an otherwise compelling experience. The consensus leans toward appreciation for the game’s ambition and execution, with many reviewers acknowledging its potential to appeal to a broad audience despite its niche mechanics. As Eurogamer Germany notes, the consequences of decisions and the interplay between systems add depth, reinforcing the game’s unique charm.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Little Goody Two Shoes dazzles with its bold genre blend—resource management, puzzles, dating sims, horror—but falters with repetition, frustrating trials, and tedious systems. Despite clunky mechanics and odd save points, its creative depth and replayable charm make it a standout, niche experience.

89

TL;DR

Little Goody Two Shoes dazzles with a nostalgic 90s anime-inspired art style, vibrant hand-painted visuals, and whimsical charm, earning universal acclaim for its magical, eerie aesthetic—though minor critiques on menus and design quirks failed to dim its glowing reputation.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

89

Positive Reviews (80-100)

96%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

4%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Little Goody Two Shoes have been overwhelmingly praised by critics, with many highlighting its nostalgic, hand-painted aesthetic and meticulous attention to detail. Reviewers consistently lauded the game’s 90s anime-inspired art style, noting its "spellbinding" color palette, "vibrant colors," and "lovely character designs" that evoke a sense of magical whimsy. Cubed3 emphasized the "nostalgic color palette" and "hand-painted setting," while GamingTrend called the visuals an "artistic and bewitching" selling point. TheXboxHub compared the game’s visuals to "animated Disney films from the 1930s and classic Japanese anime," and Push Square highlighted its ability to "recreate the vibe" of Sailor Moon and Pokémon. Many critics, including Digital Chumps and RPG Fan, praised the intricate details in environments, characters, and cutscenes, with some noting the blend of "90s top-down RPG design" and modern techniques. The game’s ability to balance charm with eerie undertones—such as "unsettling bright colors at night," as noted by Nintendo Life—further enhanced its immersive appeal. While the majority of reviews celebrated the visual design, a few critics pointed out minor flaws or mixed reactions. Everyeye.it remarked that while the hand-painted landscapes and forests were praised, the game’s menus and map felt "too simplistic." SpazioGames noted that the 90s shoujo manga-inspired character designs might feel "jarring" to some players, and ZTGD mentioned the occasional shift between cutscenes and in-game models could disrupt immersion. Additionally, some reviewers, like TierraGamer, observed a "vaporwave" aesthetic that, while unique, might not resonate with all audiences. These critiques were relatively isolated, however, and did not overshadow the general enthusiasm for the game’s visual identity. Overall, the consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive, with nearly every review highlighting the game’s exceptional art direction as a standout feature. The nostalgic 90s anime influence, combined with hand-painted textures, dynamic environments, and a blend of whimsy and horror, created a visually striking experience that resonated across platforms. Critics like Destructoid and Siliconera called the visuals "a contender for the game’s best part" and "visually appealing," respectively, while Nintendo Life praised its "gorgeous European fairy-tale aesthetic." Even the minor criticisms were framed as niche or subjective, underscoring the broad appeal of Little Goody Two Shoes’s artistic vision. The game’s ability to evoke nostalgia while delivering a cohesive and immersive visual narrative has cemented its reputation as a visually remarkable title in the indie gaming landscape.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Little Goody Two Shoes dazzles with a nostalgic 90s anime-inspired art style, vibrant hand-painted visuals, and whimsical charm, earning universal acclaim for its magical, eerie aesthetic—though minor critiques on menus and design quirks failed to dim its glowing reputation.

81

TL;DR

Critics hailed Little Goody Two Shoes's sound design as a masterclass in atmosphere, blending whimsical melodies, eerie ambiance, and dynamic shifts to elevate its horror-meets-Shojo anime vibe—though some noted minor hiccups in voice repetition and narrative alignment.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

81

Positive Reviews (80-100)

72%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

28%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Little Goody Two Shoes received widespread acclaim for their creativity, atmosphere, and emotional resonance. Critics consistently praised the soundtrack’s diversity, with Metro GameCentral highlighting its “surprisingly good” quality and sharp writing, while PlaySense noted its “impressive” nature, including “catchy tunes and even musical numbers.” TheXboxHub emphasized how the “whimsical tune and effective sound design” enhanced the game’s horror elements, and XboxAddict lauded the “lovely” music that “fits the Shojo anime style,” with melodies adapting to different environments. ZTGD praised the “diverse” score that shifts with the game’s mood, while Destructoid and Digital Chumps highlighted how the music complements visuals and evokes a “remarkable cozy and dread-filled experience.” The blend of classical countryside instruments, cute vocals, and eerie ambient tracks—reminiscent of games like Ar Tonelico or Atelier, as noted by Hey Poor Player—further underscored its unique charm. While the majority of reviews celebrated the soundtrack, some critiques pointed to minor shortcomings. XboxEra mentioned that “voice acting can become repetitive,” a point echoed by Everyeye.it, which noted that while voice work was generally strong, “some tracks are considered less successful.” RPG Site and Worth Playing both cited limited voice acting, with the latter noting that the music “matches the mood without feeling overwhelming.” Additionally, While Siliconera praised the soundtrack’s variety, including “creepy atmospheric tracks” and “full-on musical productions,” a few critics suggested that certain elements—such as vocal tracks or specific compositions—might not fully align with the game’s narrative depth. These critiques, however, were relatively minor compared to the overall enthusiasm for the audio design. The consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive, with nearly all highlighting the soundtrack’s ability to enhance the game’s atmosphere and emotional tone. The music’s versatility—from serene village themes to dissonant forest tracks, as noted by RPG Site—demonstrates a strong alignment with the game’s narrative shifts. Critics like Nintendo Life and SpazioGames emphasized how the “creepy and cute tones” tie everything together, while Noisy Pixel and But Why Tho? praised the immersive audio experience and thoughtful transitions between elements. Despite minor reservations about voice acting repetition or select tracks, the overwhelming praise for the sound design’s creativity, emotional impact, and thematic cohesion solidifies Little Goody Two Shoes as a standout in its genre.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Critics hailed Little Goody Two Shoes's sound design as a masterclass in atmosphere, blending whimsical melodies, eerie ambiance, and dynamic shifts to elevate its horror-meets-Shojo anime vibe—though some noted minor hiccups in voice repetition and narrative alignment.

65

TL;DR

Voice acting in Little Goody Two Shoes earns praise for its quality and atmospheric impact, but repetitive dialogue irks critics, undermining immersion and creating frustration despite competent performances.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

65

Positive Reviews (80-100)

17%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

83%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Little Goody Two Shoes receives mixed but generally positive feedback from critics, particularly highlighting its quality and atmospheric contributions. Everyeye.it praises the Japanese and English dubs as "of good quality," emphasizing that the vocal performances are well-executed despite their limited scope. Similarly, RPG Fan notes that the voice acting is "limited but nice," effectively setting the tone for the game’s narrative and character interactions. Worth Playing acknowledges the presence of both Japanese and English voice-overs, suggesting that while the amount of dialogue is minimal, it serves key moments well. These reviews indicate that the voice work, though not expansive, is competent and contributes to the game’s charm, particularly in its ability to convey mood through subtle performances. However, several critics express frustration with the repetition of phrases, which detracts from the overall experience. XboxAddict finds the voiceovers "annoying due to repetitive phrases," leading them to disable audio entirely in favor of text. XboxEra echoes this sentiment, noting that while the voice acting is a "nice touch," repeated lines "can become tiresome." RPG Site also mentions that the limited voice acting includes "a handful of frequently uttered phrases," which may feel repetitive over time. These critiques suggest that the game’s reliance on recurring dialogue, even if intentional for stylistic or narrative reasons, risks undermining immersion and player engagement, particularly in longer play sessions. The overall consensus among critics is that Little Goody Two Shoes’s voice acting is decent but uneven, with its strengths offset by notable flaws. While Everyeye.it and RPG Fan appreciate the quality and atmospheric value of the vocal work, others like XboxAddict and XboxEra find repetition a significant drawback. The limited scope of dialogue—highlighted by Worth Playing and RPG Site—means that the voice acting serves more as a supplementary element than a core feature. Ultimately, the reviews reflect a balanced perspective: the voice work is competent and occasionally effective but suffers from overuse of certain lines, which may frustrate players seeking more dynamic or varied audio experiences.

TL;DR

voice acting

Voice acting in Little Goody Two Shoes earns praise for its quality and atmospheric impact, but repetitive dialogue irks critics, undermining immersion and creating frustration despite competent performances.

NA

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

technical performance

Description unavailable

79

TL;DR

Little Goody Two Shoes dazzles with 10+ endings and branching choices that reward exploration, but repetitive minigames and lackluster puzzles test patience—its narrative depth and player agency shine brightest, making it a must-play for story-driven gamers despite flaws.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

79

Positive Reviews (80-100)

70%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

30%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The majority of critics highlight the strong replayability of Little Goody Two Shoes, driven by its branching narrative and multiple endings. Over ten distinct outcomes, shaped by player choices, romantic interests, or hidden pathways, are frequently cited as a major draw. GamingTrend emphasizes that "saving often and being diligent" enhances the experience, while Destructoid notes that optional side stories and love interest routes add depth. Similarly, Noisy Pixel praises features like a speed-up function and quest guides, which ease exploration of different paths. Critics like PlayStation Universe and TheXboxHub argue that the game’s structure "encourages replayability to explore different outcomes," with Nintendo Life pointing out that the 10-hour campaign offers enough content to justify multiple playthroughs. The emphasis on player agency—whether through dialogue options, character routes, or exploration—creates a sense of discovery that many find rewarding. However, some critics caution against potential drawbacks. Cubed3 explicitly states that replaying can feel "tedious" due to the need to repeat events and minigames, which may test patience. Hey Poor Player notes that while there are 10 endings, "no mention of additional replay value" suggests limited incentives beyond that. Additionally, Everyeye.it critiques the puzzle-solving mechanics as underwhelming despite the game’s content volume. These concerns reflect a tension between the game’s ambition and its execution, with some players potentially finding the repetitive elements less engaging than the narrative variety. While most praise the choices and endings, the lack of substantial post-game content or unique mechanics beyond the core loop is a recurring point of critique. Overall, the consensus leans heavily toward positive assessments of Little Goody Two Shoes’s replay value, with critics like Destructoid, Noisy Pixel, and RPG Fan celebrating its "mind-boggling amount of content" and strategic depth. While some, such as Cubed3 and Everyeye.it, point to limitations in repetition or execution, the majority view the game as a compelling experience that rewards exploration. The combination of multiple endings, character-driven choices, and optional content creates a foundation for replayability, even if certain aspects—like minigames or puzzles—may not fully satisfy all players. Ultimately, the game’s strengths in narrative variety and player agency outweigh its flaws, making it a standout example of how choice-based design can enhance long-term engagement.

TL;DR

replay value

Little Goody Two Shoes dazzles with 10+ endings and branching choices that reward exploration, but repetitive minigames and lackluster puzzles test patience—its narrative depth and player agency shine brightest, making it a must-play for story-driven gamers despite flaws.

Overall verdict

Overall Verdict

79

MONSTER

Star Icon

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

79

Positive Reviews (80-100)

71%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

29%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

0%

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The majority of critics praised Little Goody Two Shoes for its innovative storytelling, visual artistry, and genre-blending creativity. Reviewers like Cubed3 highlighted its "storytelling and visual artistry," while GamingTrend called it "captivating, gorgeous, charming, and delightful to play." Metro GameCentral lauded its "highly inventive mix of genres" and described it as "creepy, charming, and wonderfully unpredictable." The game’s unique blend of horror, romance, and life-sim elements resonated with many, with XboxEra noting its "gorgeous visuals, strong life sim mechanics, and well-paced narrative," and Destructoid praising its "sapphic horror, fairytale setting, and retro shojo art style." The game’s atmospheric design and multiple endings also stood out, as noted by PlaySense, who called it a "unique indie game with an intriguing story," and Siliconera, which described it as a "charming game that impresses with its artwork, music, and storytelling." While the overall reception was overwhelmingly positive, some critics pointed to specific flaws. PlayStation Universe noted that the pacing in certain events could be improved, while Everyeye.it suggested the adventure, survival, and dating sim aspects needed more refinement. GGRecon criticized the game for diverting too much from traditional horror elements, and Hey Poor Player mentioned "frustrating moments in gameplay," though they still gave it a 4/5. Eurogamer Germany highlighted increasing difficulty and limited help options as potential drawbacks, while Nintendo Life acknowledged "a few frustrations" that slightly detracted from the experience. Additionally, Multiplayer.it pointed to a "slow start" as a minor issue, though they praised the game’s "well-crafted narrative and variety of gameplay systems." Despite these critiques, the consensus among critics was firmly positive, with most agreeing that Little Goody Two Shoes is a standout title worth experiencing. Cubed3, GamingTrend, and XboxEra all emphasized its unique charm and technical execution, while Noisy Pixel called it a "remarkable achievement in the RPG Maker-style horror genre." Even critics who noted flaws, like SpazioGames (which described it as a "small gem") or PC Invasion (which praised its "well-crafted art and branching narrative"), acknowledged its strengths. The game’s ability to balance unsettling horror with whimsical storytelling, coupled with its visual and narrative depth, earned it widespread acclaim. As But Why Tho? noted, it’s a "must-play for fans of shoujo anime," and Worth Playing highlighted its appeal to those seeking something "different and subversive." Overall, the game’s inventive approach and emotional resonance solidified its reputation as a memorable indie experience.

TL;DR

Boldly blends horror, romance, and life-sim with stunning visuals and sapphic twists; though pacing stumbles, its whimsical charm and emotional depth secure indie acclaim.

79

MONSTER

Star Icon

Reviews

43 reviews found

95

RPG Fan

PC

Nov 28, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Little Goody Two Shoes is a visually interesting and immersive game with a rich atmosphere, romantic elements, and scary moments. It is recommended for narrative game lovers who enjoy overcoming fear.

Read full review

Full review

90

Noisy Pixel

PC

Oct 30, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Little Goody Two Shoes is a remarkable achievement in the RPG Maker-style horror genre, pushing boundaries and setting a high standard for indie game development. It offers a captivating and multifaceted adventure with a well-developed narrative and unique systems.

Read full review

Full review

90

Destructoid

PC

Nov 22, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Little Goody Two Shoes is a special game that stands out with its mix of sapphic horror, fairytale setting, and retro shojo art style. It has a compelling narrative, visually appealing art direction, and a cozy yet dread-filled atmosphere. Despite some minor frustrations with gameplay, it is a game that deserves a strong audience.

Read full review

Full review

90

Multiplayer.it

PC

Oct 30, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Little Goody Two Shoes is praised for its surprising and well-crafted narrative, variety of gameplay systems, and excellent pixel art visuals. The slow start is mentioned as a minor drawback.

Read full review

Full review

90

PC Invasion

PC

Nov 7, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Impressive game with well-crafted art, engaging gameplay, and a branching narrative. Offers a chance to learn about oneself and rewards the player. Recommended.

Read full review

Full review
Similar Games
Similar Games

Games you might also enjoy

left arrow
right arrow
Popular Right Now
Popular Right Now

Trending games the community is playing

left arrow
right arrow
Recently Reviewed
Recently Reviewed

Games with full Monster Scorecards

left arrow
right arrow

About

Contact Us

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Navigation

Home

Search

Games


Follow Us

© 2025 MonsterCritic