Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Twitch

MONSTER

Elden Ring Nightreign

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Elden Ring Nightreign
Item: Elden Ring Nightreign
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2025

GenresAction, Third Person Perspective, RPG, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableMay 30, 2025

PlatformPlayStation 4, Xbox One, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, PC

DeveloperFrom Software

Overview

Nightreign is a standalone adventure within the ELDEN RING universe, crafted to bring a new gaming experience.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Elden Ring: Nightreign" offers engaging character backstories and a theme of perseverance, but critics slam its shallow narrative and lack of deep lore. While the character-focused approach adds some engagement, the story feels simplistic and less immersive than its predecessor, leaving fans of FromSoftware yearning for richer storytelling. Overall, it appeals to those seeking straightforward gameplay but falls short for those craving depth.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

25%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

69%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The overall sentiment regarding the story of "Elden Ring: Nightreign" reveals some positive aspects that critics have highlighted. Several reviewers, such as PC Gamer and IGN, noted that the game embodies the theme of perseverance against overwhelming odds, which is a hallmark of FromSoftware's titles. Critics like Gamer.no and Checkpoint Gaming appreciated the character-focused narrative, where each of the eight playable heroes, known as Nightfarers, has their own backstories that can be uncovered through gameplay. This element of character development adds a layer of engagement, as players can explore personal stories that enhance their experience within the game world. Additionally, some reviewers, including GameSpot and GIGA, praised the unique narrative structure that allows players to experience character arcs through specific tasks, providing a sense of progression. However, a significant number of critics expressed disappointment with the overall depth and integration of the story within the game. Reviewers like TheSixthAxis and Oyungezer described the narrative as weak and lacking the rich lore that fans have come to expect from FromSoftware. Many pointed out that the plot feels simplistic, often revolving around defeating the Nightlords to lift a curse, which lacks the complexity and environmental storytelling that characterized the original "Elden Ring." Critics such as Games.cz and LevelUp echoed this sentiment, emphasizing that the narrative does not build a deep mythology and is less immersive compared to previous titles from the studio. The reliance on familiar elements and the absence of extensive lore further detracted from the overall narrative experience. The consensus among critics is that while "Elden Ring: Nightreign" offers some engaging character backstories and a straightforward narrative, it ultimately falls short in terms of depth and richness. Many reviewers, including IGN Turkey and TierraGamer, noted that the game’s story is more direct and less intricate than its predecessor, with a focus on gameplay mechanics over narrative complexity. The general sentiment suggests that while the game may appeal to genre fans seeking a simpler experience, those looking for the deep, lore-rich storytelling typical of FromSoftware may find "Nightreign" lacking. Overall, the game presents an interesting premise but does not fully capitalize on the narrative potential within its alternate universe.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Elden Ring Nightreign impresses with its engaging cooperative mechanics and fast-paced gameplay, earning praise for teamwork and character diversity. However, solo play suffers from shallow mechanics and imbalance, frustrating solo gamers. Critics agree it shines best in multiplayer, making it a strong but flawed addition to the Elden Ring series.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

76%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

24%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Elden Ring Nightreign has garnered a largely positive reception among critics, who appreciate its innovative blend of roguelike and cooperative mechanics. Many reviewers, such as GamingBolt and VideoGamer, highlight the engaging gameplay loop that emphasizes teamwork and strategic decision-making, particularly during boss encounters. Critics like IGN and TechRadar Gaming commend the fast-paced action and the need for players to adapt quickly, which adds a layer of excitement to the experience. The game’s focus on character abilities and cooperative play is also praised, with critics noting that the unique character classes enhance the multiplayer experience, making it feel dynamic and rewarding. However, not all feedback is positive; several critics point out significant drawbacks, particularly concerning solo play. Oyungezer and IGN Turkey mention that the gameplay can feel shallow and lacks variety, especially for players who prefer to tackle challenges alone. The aggressive leveling system and penalties for dying, as noted by Gaming Age, can lead to frustration, particularly in solo modes. Additionally, the game’s reliance on cooperative mechanics may leave solo players feeling imbalanced and underwhelmed, as highlighted by multiple reviewers, including GameStar and Softpedia, who stress that the multiplayer focus detracts from the experience for those going it alone. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while Elden Ring Nightreign excels in providing a thrilling cooperative experience with its innovative gameplay mechanics, it struggles with balance and depth for solo players. The majority of reviewers, such as GIGA and Digital Chumps, agree that the game is best enjoyed in a team setting, where its strengths can truly shine. Despite the criticisms regarding solo play and occasional repetitiveness, the game is generally seen as a successful addition to the Elden Ring universe, offering a fresh take on the beloved formula that many players will find enjoyable, particularly in multiplayer scenarios.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Elden Ring Nightreign dazzles with stunning boss designs and breathtaking environments, praised by many critics for its high-quality art direction reminiscent of FromSoftware's standards. However, it faces backlash for recycling assets from the original game, leading to a perception of stagnation and lack of innovation. Performance issues further detract from the experience, resulting in mixed reviews overall. While visually appealing, it fails to offer the fresh experience fans hoped for.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Elden Ring Nightreign have received a variety of opinions from critics, with several praising the game's aesthetic qualities. Many reviewers, such as IGN Spain and CGMagazine, highlight the impressive boss designs and the breathtaking environments that contribute to an engaging visual experience. The art direction is often described as maintaining the high standards typical of FromSoftware, with Voxels and Softpedia noting the beautiful landscapes and detailed character designs that enhance immersion. Critics like TechRadar Gaming and Digital Chumps also commend the visually appealing atmosphere and the dynamic environmental changes, which add depth to the exploration experience. However, the game has faced substantial criticism for its reliance on recycled assets from the original Elden Ring, leading to a perception of diminished creativity in its visual design. Reviewers such as Games.cz and MMORPG.com point out that the lack of innovation and unique environments detracts from the overall aesthetic experience, describing it as less impressive than previous titles. Critics like Hobby Consolas and SpazioGames echo this sentiment, arguing that while the visuals maintain a high artistic quality, they lack significant freshness and risk. Additionally, performance issues, such as frame rate hiccups and texture loading problems, were noted by several reviewers, including Hey Poor Player and GRYOnline.pl, which further detracts from the visual experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed, with a general acknowledgment of the game's impressive art direction and engaging boss designs, yet a significant concern regarding the repetitiveness and lack of innovation in visual elements. While many reviewers appreciate the familiar aesthetics that fans of the original Elden Ring will recognize, the reuse of assets and environments has led to a sense of stagnation in the visual design, as highlighted by critics like Jeuxvideo.com and Pocket Tactics. Ultimately, Elden Ring Nightreign is seen as a visually appealing title that successfully captures the essence of its predecessor but falls short of delivering a fresh and innovative visual experience.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Elden Ring Nightreign" boasts highly praised sound design and music, enhancing gameplay with epic soundtracks and dynamic themes that adapt to player actions. Critics commend the immersive atmosphere and strong voice acting. However, concerns about a lack of contemplative moments, occasional monotony during combat, and the memorability of new tracks compared to past titles are noted. Overall, it reinforces FromSoftware's legacy, delivering a compelling audio experience despite minor drawbacks.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

79%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

21%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of "Elden Ring Nightreign" have garnered a largely positive reception from critics, with many praising its quality and effectiveness in enhancing the gameplay experience. Reviewers like BaziCenter and CD-Action highlight the soundtrack's epic and engaging nature, which aligns with the high standards set by FromSoftware. Critics such as Digital Chumps and TechRadar Gaming commend the dynamic themes that adapt based on player actions, particularly during boss encounters, contributing to the game's immersive atmosphere. Additionally, the voice acting has been noted as a strong point, with Atomix emphasizing its role in enriching the overall ambiance of the game. Despite the overwhelming praise, some critics have pointed out certain shortcomings. Atomix mentions the absence of contemplative moments in the sound design, which can alter the overall experience. Other critics, like TierraGamer and Vandal, have noted that while the music enhances boss encounters, it can sometimes feel monotonous or overshadowed by the intense focus required during combat. Merlin'in Kazanı also raised concerns about the memorability of new music tracks compared to previous titles, suggesting that while the sound design maintains quality, it may not reach the heights of earlier FromSoftware games. Overall, the consensus among critics is that the sound design and music in "Elden Ring Nightreign" are commendable and significantly enhance the gaming experience. The majority of reviewers, including IGN and Game8, agree that the soundtrack and audio contribute positively to the atmosphere, particularly during epic battles. While there are minor critiques regarding the reuse of elements and some tracks lacking memorability, the general sentiment remains that the audio experience is a strong aspect of the game, reinforcing the legacy of FromSoftware's previous works.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

The voice acting in Elden Ring Nightreign is praised for enhancing the game's atmosphere and character depth, with critics highlighting its charm. However, limitations in dialogue and the absence of voice chat during multiplayer detract from the experience, raising concerns about player engagement. Overall, while the performances are effective, improvements in communication options are needed for a better gameplay experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

31%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

62%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Elden Ring Nightreign has garnered a generally positive reception among critics, highlighting its effectiveness in enhancing the game's narrative and atmosphere. Atomix praises the voice acting for capturing the essence of the game's characters, underscoring its significant contribution to the overall experience despite a smaller cast. Similarly, BaziCenter notes that the voice acting is well-implemented and positively impacts the game's atmosphere. Critics like Worth Playing describe the voice acting as charming, albeit occasionally bizarre, which aligns with the game's tone. Additionally, MondoXbox points out the inclusion of English voice acting and full localization in Italian, enhancing accessibility for a broader audience. However, several critics have raised concerns regarding the limitations of the voice acting. Checkpoint Gaming and Vandal both note that while the performances fit the game's tone, they lack depth due to minimal dialogue, which can detract from the overall experience. The absence of voice chat is a recurring theme, with Gamers Heroes and PlaySense highlighting how this limitation affects player coordination during gameplay, especially in a multiplayer context. ComicBook and Hey Poor Player echo this sentiment, emphasizing that the lack of in-game voice communication is a significant drawback for a title that focuses on multiplayer interaction. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while the voice acting in Elden Ring Nightreign is well-executed and contributes positively to the game's atmosphere and character development, it is hampered by limitations in dialogue and the absence of voice chat. Critics like Atomix and BaziCenter appreciate the charm and effectiveness of the performances, but others like Checkpoint Gaming and Vandal point out that the limited dialogue and communication options may hinder player engagement. Ultimately, the voice acting is seen as a strong aspect of the game, yet it is clear that improvements could enhance the overall player experience.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Elden Ring Nightreign delivers a mixed bag of performance across platforms. PS5 users enjoy smooth gameplay but face frame rate drops and matchmaking issues. Xbox Series X players report stable performance with minor glitches. PC gamers see solid performance on high-end systems, but encounter significant bugs and crashes. Overall, while the game shows potential, persistent technical issues threaten player enjoyment, calling for urgent fixes.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

79%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

13%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Elden Ring Nightreign varies across gaming platforms, with each offering a mix of positives and challenges. On the PlayStation 5, several critics, including CD-Action and IGN Turkey, noted that the game runs smoothly overall, with minimal frame drops and an acceptable performance level. Critics like Digital Chumps and Eurogamer highlighted that, despite some matchmaking issues, the game maintains a solid performance, indicating that many players experienced an enjoyable gameplay experience. On the Xbox Series X, reviewers such as Generación Xbox and SomosXbox praised the game's optimization, reporting stable frame rates and smooth gameplay, which contributes to a generally positive reception. Meanwhile, on PC, several critics, including Eurogamer Poland and Wccftech, noted that the game performs well on high-end hardware, with stable online play and minimal visual glitches, suggesting a strong foundation for PC players. However, there are notable negatives across all platforms that detract from the overall experience. On PlayStation 5, critics like BaziCenter and GRYOnline.pl pointed out significant performance issues, including frame rate drops and texture loading problems, particularly in online modes. Critics such as Gamepressure and Meristation echoed these sentiments, emphasizing that these technical problems can disrupt gameplay. On Xbox Series X, while the performance is generally stable, some critics, like Jeuxvideo.com, mentioned technical issues such as camera problems and an outdated menu system. On PC, the situation is more varied, with critics like IGN Portugal and Try Hard Guides reporting significant frame rate drops and bugs, including crashes and desyncing, which can severely impact gameplay. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while Elden Ring Nightreign offers a solid gaming experience across platforms, technical performance issues remain a significant concern. Many PlayStation 5 players reported frame rate drops and matchmaking problems, leading to a mixed reception, while Xbox Series X players enjoyed a smoother experience but still faced some minor technical hurdles. On PC, the performance is generally good, but persistent bugs and connection issues were frequently mentioned, indicating that the game may require further patches to enhance stability. Critics like Game Informer and TechRadar Gaming highlighted the need for improvements in matchmaking and network stability, reinforcing the idea that while the game has potential, it currently suffers from technical shortcomings that could affect player enjoyment.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Elden Ring: Nightreign" garners mixed but mostly positive reviews for its high replay value driven by roguelike mechanics and cooperative gameplay. Critics praise its procedural generation and multiplayer dynamics, but concerns arise over repetitive gameplay and limited end-game content. While the game excites roguelike fans, its long-term appeal may wane due to monotonous elements and frustrating RNG progression.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

52%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions regarding the replay value of "Elden Ring: Nightreign" present a mixed but generally positive sentiment, particularly highlighting the game's roguelike elements and cooperative gameplay. Many critics, such as Vandal and Eurogamer, emphasize the high replay value stemming from the game's procedural generation and randomized elements, which encourage players to explore different strategies and character builds. The thrill of multiplayer experiences is also noted by critics like GamingBolt and Pocket Tactics, who appreciate how the game fosters a sense of camaraderie and competition among players. Additionally, the addictive nature of the gameplay loop is frequently mentioned, with reviewers like PlaySense and Game Informer noting that the desire to improve with each attempt can lead to extended play sessions. Conversely, several critics express concerns regarding the game's long-term replayability, citing issues such as repetitive gameplay and a lack of meaningful progression. Oyungezer and SpazioGames point out that the reliance on RNG for character progression can lead to frustration and boredom, particularly when players are required to restart from the beginning after each run. Critics like Meristation and BaziCenter also highlight the absence of substantial end-game content, which may deter players from continuing after defeating main bosses. The potential for encounters and environments to become monotonous over time is a recurring theme, with reviewers like PCGamesN and Hey Poor Player noting that while the game has its engaging moments, it may struggle to maintain excitement in the long run. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates that "Elden Ring: Nightreign" possesses significant replay value due to its engaging mechanics and cooperative elements, but it is tempered by concerns over repetitive gameplay and a lack of depth in end-game content. While many reviewers, such as GIGA and COGconnected, appreciate the variety and excitement offered by the game's structure, others like Gaming Age and Try Hard Guides caution that the experience may not sustain interest indefinitely. Ultimately, the game seems to appeal strongly to those who enjoy roguelike experiences and multiplayer interactions, but it may leave others wanting more in terms of content variety and progression.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

68%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

32%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment towards "Elden Ring: Nightreign" reveals a mix of appreciation for its innovative approach and enjoyment of its cooperative gameplay. Critics like IGN and GamersRD highlight the game's successful evolution of the franchise, noting its thrilling multiplayer experience and strong combat mechanics. Gamers Heroes and ComicBook also commend the game for capturing the essence of its predecessor while introducing new gameplay elements. The cooperative aspect is frequently praised, with reviewers such as Worth Playing and GIGA emphasizing that the game shines when played with friends, providing an engaging and challenging experience that appeals to dedicated fans of the genre. However, the game is not without its criticisms. Many reviewers express disappointment regarding its departure from the traditional single-player experience that fans have come to expect from FromSoftware titles. Critics like Oyungezer and Merlin'in Kazanı point out that "Nightreign" fails to meet the high expectations set by previous entries in the series, particularly in terms of depth and lore. The game's design choices, which some find frustrating, are highlighted by MGG and TheSixthAxis, who note that it may alienate casual players and those seeking a more narrative-driven experience. Additionally, technical issues, such as network problems and a lack of content variety, are mentioned by several critics, including Checkpoint Gaming and Try Hard Guides. Overall, the consensus among critics is that "Elden Ring: Nightreign" presents a unique and ambitious multiplayer experience that caters primarily to hardcore fans of the genre. While it introduces fresh mechanics and a cooperative focus, many reviewers caution that it may not satisfy those looking for a traditional Souls experience, as indicated by Eurogamer and IGN Deutschland. The game is characterized as a mixed bag; it offers thrilling moments and engaging gameplay for groups, but its limitations in depth, narrative, and technical stability could deter a broader audience. As such, "Nightreign" is recommended mainly for those willing to adapt to its new direction, particularly in a cooperative setting.

TL;DR

"Elden Ring: Nightreign" impresses with its innovative multiplayer and combat mechanics, earning praise for its cooperative gameplay. However, it diverges from traditional single-player experiences, leaving some fans disappointed in depth and lore. Critics note technical issues and a lack of content variety, suggesting it's best suited for hardcore fans willing to embrace its new direction. Overall, it's a mixed bag: thrilling for groups, but potentially alienating for those seeking a classic Souls experience.

MONSTER

Reviews

217 reviews found

100

VG247

May 28, 2025