Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree

The majority of critics praised Shadow of the Erdtree for its rich, enigmatic storytelling and deep lore expansion, emphasizing its alignment with Elden Ring’s signature atmospheric and player-driven narrative style. Reviewers like Atomix and But Why Tho? highlighted the DLC’s cryptic, minimalistic approach, which invites interpretation and rewards attentive players with hidden details and new insights into the game’s world. Checkpoint Gaming and GameMAG celebrated the intricate world design and character-driven stories, such as the compelling arc of Mikella, while Impulsegamer and Meristation noted the DLC’s focus on Miquella the Kind and its ties to the broader lore. PC Gamer and TechRadar Gaming commended the masterfully embedded storytelling, environmental details, and thematic depth, with GAMINGbible appreciating its exploration of dark themes like betrayal and power. The expansion’s ability to weave new mysteries while expanding on existing ones—such as the Golden Order’s origins or the Shadow Realm’s lore—was widely seen as a strength, with GamersRD and Metro GameCentral pointing to its narrative cohesion and world-building. However, some critics found the story’s complexity and ambiguity to be a drawback. Dot Esports and PCGamesN criticized the narrative for being obtuse, with confusing plot threads that required external resources like lore videos to fully grasp. MMORPG.com and TheSixthAxis called the ending underwhelming, with the latter lamenting a “lackluster” final boss and unsatisfying conclusion. Noisy Pixel and GameRevolution noted that the story sometimes took a backseat to combat and exploration, feeling abstract or disjointed. While Gamepressure acknowledged the melancholic atmosphere, they argued the DLC’s lore, though fascinating, didn’t significantly impact the base game’s characters or plot. Additionally, Hooked Gamers and LevelUp pointed to the narrative’s brevity, suggesting it felt more like an expansion than a self-contained story, with some questions left unresolved. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among reviewers leaned heavily toward admiration for Shadow of the Erdtree’s narrative ambition and depth. The DLC was widely seen as a successful extension of Elden Ring’s mythos, with PCGamesN and TheXboxHub noting its seamless integration into the game’s lore, while XboxEra and GamingBolt highlighted its engaging mysteries and character-driven quests. While a minority of critics found the story confusing or unsatisfying, the majority—such as GameCritics, Wccftech, and Slant Magazine—celebrated its atmospheric storytelling, thematic richness, and ability to deepen the game’s world. The DLC’s balance of mystery, lore expansion, and emotional resonance solidified its reputation as a standout addition to Elden Ring’s narrative, even if it left some players wanting more clarity or closure.

The majority of critics praised Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree for its gameplay enhancements, emphasizing its expansion of the base game’s core mechanics while maintaining the series’ signature depth. Atomix highlighted the introduction of new elements like a group of warriors to accompany the player and the Shadow Realm’s vertical, intricate exploration, which adds complexity and rewards customization. Checkpoint Gaming and GameMAG noted the addition of exclusive weapons, spells, and progression systems tied to the Shadow Realm, while Meristation and Metro GameCentral celebrated the diversification of combat styles and the inclusion of new weapon types, spells, and collectibles. Dot Esports and GameCritics underscored the challenging dungeons, formidable threats, and boss battles that blend familiarity with fresh mechanics, and MMORPG.com and PCGamesN commended the "rewarding combat systems" and "innovative encounters," respectively. The expansion’s emphasis on exploration—whether through dense environments, hidden fragments, or legacy dungeons—was frequently lauded as a key strength, with critics like Slant Magazine and TheXboxHub noting how it enriches the gameplay experience without straying from the franchise’s identity. While the consensus leaned overwhelmingly positive, some critics pointed to specific flaws or areas where the expansion felt less cohesive. TheSixthAxis criticized the Scadutree Fragments and Revered Spirit Ashes as poorly implemented, arguing they disrupted the game’s design flow and forced players into repetitive grinding for upgrades. Gamepressure and Game Revolution also noted that the heightened difficulty, while intentional, might alienate some players, with the latter mentioning the absence of a boss as punishing as Malenia. Additionally, while most praised the new mechanics, a few felt the expansion leaned too heavily on familiar systems without introducing groundbreaking innovations, though this was a minority view. These critiques, however, were often framed as minor quibbles rather than major drawbacks, with many acknowledging that the challenges and progression systems still added meaningful depth. Overall, the critical reception of Shadow of the Erdtree’s gameplay was overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers consistently highlighting its ability to elevate the Elden Ring experience without losing its essence. Critics like Dot Esports, MMORPG.com, and PC Gamer emphasized the expansion’s commitment to challenging combat, intricate level design, and rewarding exploration, while others, such as GamersRD and Wccftech, praised its substantial content and new regions that feel "like the base game" but with added layers. Even the negative feedback was tempered by recognition of the DLC’s ambition and the effort to deepen the game’s systems. The expansion’s success lies in its balance of accessibility and complexity, offering veteran players a fresh yet familiar challenge while expanding the world’s lore and mechanics. As TheNew York Times noted, it “heightens the challenge for experienced players,” and as Slant Magazine put it, it “adds spice to a perfect recipe,” reinforcing that Shadow of the Erdtree is seen as a worthy and enriching addition to the Elden Ring saga.

The majority of critics overwhelmingly praised the graphics and visual design of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, highlighting its ability to expand upon the game’s established aesthetic while introducing fresh, immersive elements. Reviewers like Atomix and But Why Tho? emphasized the expansion’s “eerie and beautiful environments” and “gorgeous designs for boss battles,” respectively, underscoring its commitment to the grimdark, atmospheric style that defines FromSoftware’s work. Checkpoint Gaming and Dot Esports lauded the “hauntingly beautiful and dangerous terrain” and “vibrant colors” of the Shadow Realm, noting how the new biomes and architectural designs—such as the “crumbling Golden Tree” mentioned by GamersRD—elevate the sense of wonder and exploration. The intricate level design, with its “complex three-dimensional labyrinths” (GameMAG) and “impressive environmental design” (GamersRD), was frequently cited as a standout feature, offering players a visually rich world that rewards curiosity and deepens the game’s storytelling through its haunting, detailed settings. Slant Magazine and Noisy Pixel also celebrated the “impressive and unique biomes” and “expansive, beautifully crafted world design,” reinforcing the consensus that the DLC’s visuals are a masterclass in creative world-building. While the general reception was positive, some critics pointed to technical and design-related shortcomings. Vandal and TechRadar Gaming noted performance issues, such as “rendering problems” and “rough textures up close,” which occasionally detracted from the experience, particularly in dense or complex areas. PC Invasion mentioned that while the new weapon archetypes and boss designs were exciting, certain rewards—like the Scadutree Fragments—felt underwhelming compared to the DLC’s visual grandeur. XboxEra also critiqued the texture work, suggesting that close-up details could be more refined. These issues, though minor, were seen as potential drawbacks for players prioritizing technical polish. Additionally, GamingBolt observed that the art style leaned more on “unreal attention to detail” than cutting-edge visuals, which might not appeal to those seeking hyper-realism, but this was framed as a deliberate choice rather than a flaw. Despite these critiques, the overall consensus among critics is that Shadow of the Erdtree delivers a visually stunning and cohesive experience that aligns with the high standards of the Elden Ring franchise. The expansion’s “exceptional” and “memorable” visual design, as noted by MeuPlayStation and GINX TV, was seen as a triumph, with its “grim yet visually striking open world” (PlayStation Country) and “stunning environmental design” (PCGamesN) standing out as key achievements. While a few reviewers, like Vandal and TechRadar Gaming, raised concerns about technical performance, these were often overshadowed by the praise for its art direction, level design, and atmospheric storytelling. The DLC’s ability to balance “terrifying elements” (Slant Magazine) with “captivating beauty” (GameCritics) solidified its reputation as a visual masterpiece, with many critics, including TheXboxHub and PC Gamer, affirming that it “continues the tradition of Elden Ring being a visually stunning game.” The minor technical issues and mixed reward design did little to dampen the enthusiasm for its artistic vision, which remains a defining strength of the expansion.

The Sound Design and Music of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree received overwhelmingly positive acclaim from critics, with many highlighting its atmospheric depth and emotional resonance. Reviewers like Atomix praised the expansion’s use of classic choirs and ambient sounds intertwined with melodic moments, creating an immersive audio experience that complements the game’s dark fantasy world. Checkpoint Gaming emphasized the distinct, haunting scores for each area, which effectively build tension and anticipation, while Dot Esports called the orchestral soundtrack "among the best in FromSoftware's history," particularly noting its impact during boss encounters. GamersRD and PC Gamer both lauded the dynamic and immersive sound design, with the latter pointing to music that "sets the mood for different encounters" and the former noting how religious themes in the soundtrack enhance the intensity of boss battles. Impulsegamer and Noisy Pixel described the melancholy and beautiful music as "breathtaking" and "chilling," respectively, while XboxEra and GamingBolt drew comparisons to the iconic Bloodborne and celebrated the "gorgeous" and "grand" musical choices that elevate the new areas and their epic scale. These comments collectively underscore a strong focus on how the audio elements deepen the game’s atmosphere and emotional weight. While the majority of reviews were laudatory, there were few, if any, explicit criticisms of the sound design or music. Some reviewers, such as Gamepressure and TheXboxHub, noted the technical excellence of the audio, with the latter specifically mentioning the absence of performance issues despite the game’s intense particle effects. However, no critic directly pointed out flaws or repetitive elements, which might suggest that the expansion’s audio design was consistent with the original Elden Ring’s tone and style. A few reviews, like GamingBolt and Vandal, focused on the music’s evocative qualities, with the former linking it to Bloodborne and the latter calling the orchestral work "epic" and "fitting" for the dark fantasy theme. These observations, while positive, also hint that the soundtrack’s success lay in its ability to maintain the series’ established identity rather than introducing radical new elements, which could be seen as a neutral or even slightly cautious perspective. Still, the lack of significant negative feedback indicates a near-unanimous approval of the audio direction. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Shadow of the Erdtree’s sound design and music are exceptional, seamlessly enhancing the game’s world and narrative. The expansion’s ability to blend orchestral grandeur with atmospheric details—such as the "melancholy score" of the Shadow Realm (Impulsegamer) and the "impressive sound design" that "enhances the overall experience" (Meristation)—was widely recognized as a key strength. PC Gamer and XboxEra highlighted the dynamic and immersive qualities, while GamersRD and Vandal praised the thematic depth and adaptability of the music to match the game’s evolving encounters. With all major outlets celebrating the audio as a pillar of the expansion’s success, it’s clear that the soundtrack and sound design not only met but exceeded expectations, solidifying Elden Ring’s reputation for audio excellence in the dark fantasy genre. The lack of critical drawbacks further reinforces the idea that this expansion’s audio work is a standout achievement, aligning with the high standards set by FromSoftware’s previous titles.

Summary unavailable

The technical performance of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree received mixed but generally manageable feedback across different platforms. On the PS5, critics like Dot Esports, GamersRD, and Meristation noted that the performance was largely consistent with the base game, with some minor issues such as occasional frame rate dips and minor bugs, but nothing that significantly impacted the overall experience. Impulsegamer also highlighted that while there were some problems with story progression and map traversal, the game remained stable, and potential fixes were expected in future patches. On PC, Gamepressure praised the stability and high graphics settings, while others like GamingBolt and Vandal pointed out performance challenges, particularly at higher resolutions and with visual effects. Meanwhile, on the Xbox Series X, TheXboxHub and XboxEra reported no major slowdown or stuttering, and the expansion was stable with no online disconnects, though some performance issues were noted on powerful PCs. However, the negatives were more pronounced on certain platforms. On PS5, Meristation mentioned that frame rate issues were more frequent than in the base game, and Metro GameCentral pointed out a texture loading glitch and unclear instructions for starting the expansion, which could confuse players. On PC, GamingBolt, GINX TV, Vandal, and Wccftech all reported performance issues, including frame rate drops, freezes, and visual "popping," which affected the gameplay experience, especially during intense moments like boss fights. Additionally, GAMINGbible noted that optimization problems on PC had persisted for a long time since the game's release. On the Xbox Series X, while most reviewers found the performance acceptable, some, like TechRadar Gaming, mentioned occasional visual oddities and performance dips, particularly in dense areas, which could be a concern for some players. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that Shadow of the Erdtree is technically sound on consoles, particularly the Xbox Series X, where the performance was described as stable and smooth. On PS5, while there were some minor technical issues, they were not severe enough to detract from the core experience. However, on PC, the expansion faced more consistent performance challenges, with several critics like GamingBolt and Vandal highlighting the need for optimization improvements. Despite these issues, many reviewers acknowledged that the problems were likely to be addressed through patches, and the game remained playable and enjoyable across all platforms. The technical performance, while not perfect, was generally seen as a minor concern compared to the game's broader strengths.

The majority of critics overwhelmingly praised the replay value of Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree, highlighting its rich array of new content, challenges, and systems that encourage multiple playthroughs. Atomix emphasized the expansion’s vertical exploration and complex map design, which enhance its longevity, while But Why Tho? noted the abundance of optional bosses, exploration, and puzzles. Checkpoint Gaming and Impulsegamer pointed to exclusive character progression systems and diverse weapon options, respectively, as key drivers for replayability. GamersRD and Slant Magazine celebrated the dense new region, increased difficulty, and unique surprises like the enhancement system, while Metro GameCentral and PC Gamer praised the intricate level design and hidden areas that reward thorough exploration. Critics like MMORPG.com and PCGamesN highlighted the substantial gameplay hours and variety of builds, with some calling it a “game in its own right” (TechRadar Gaming) and others noting its ability to “warrant multiple playthroughs” (GameCritics). The expansion’s emphasis on customization, discovery, and challenging encounters clearly resonated with reviewers, positioning it as a standout addition to the original game’s legacy. However, some critics raised concerns about specific aspects that could detract from the replay experience. GINX TV noted that endgame content and exploration felt less rewarding after completing mainline bosses, with certain areas seeming “empty” and contributing to a “ceiling” effect. Game Revolution and PC Invasion observed that the DLC might feel short or easy for high-level players, though they acknowledged its value for those at the recommended level. MeuPlayStation criticized the lack of new trophies, which they argued diminished guidance for uncovering missed content, while TheXboxHub mentioned the absence of new achievements despite the expansion’s enjoyment for completionists. Additionally, PC Invasion and Game Revolution pointed out that some rewards, particularly for maxed-out builds, felt underwhelming. These critiques suggest that while the expansion is content-heavy, its replay value may vary depending on player skill and expectations. Despite these reservations, the overall consensus among critics is that Shadow of the Erdtree delivers exceptional replay value, with its depth and innovation outweighing minor shortcomings. TheXboxHub and XboxEra emphasized the sheer volume of new challenges, weapons, and enemies that keep players engaged, while Gamepressure and Noisy Pixel highlighted how the expansion’s unique progression systems and lore encourage returning to the game. Even critics like GINX TV and PC Invasion, who noted limitations, acknowledged the DLC’s quality and the original game’s enduring appeal. The expansion’s ability to introduce fresh mechanics, hidden secrets, and diverse playstyles—such as the multiple endings mentioned by Impulsegamer or the “independent experience” described by Noisy Pixel—solidifies its status as a worthwhile addition. While not flawless, the majority of reviewers agree that Shadow of the Erdtree significantly extends the life of Elden Ring, making it a compelling reason for fans to revisit its world repeatedly.