Sid Meier's Civilization VI: Rise and Fall

The reviewers generally praise Sid Meier’s Civilization VI: Rise and Fall for its innovative narrative mechanics that deepen the storytelling experience. Hobby Consolas highlights the introduction of “momentos históricos” (historical moments) and “puntuación de época” (era score), which create a sense of epic significance to in-game achievements. IGN Spain commends the new era system, noting how it allows civilizations to enter golden or dark ages based on player actions, generating unique historical records. Multiplayer.it and PC Games both emphasize the “historical chronicle” feature and parchment-like overview, which document key events and reward diverse playstyles. Wccftech applauds the Ages system, which structures a civilization’s progression through distinct phases like Dark, Golden, or Heroic Ages, adding strategic depth and narrative cohesion. These elements collectively elevate the expansion’s storytelling, offering players a more immersive and dynamic historical journey. However, some critics point to uneven execution in the narrative framework. PCGamesN argues that while the expansion attempts to model empires’ rise and fall through mechanics like Era Scores and Dark Ages, the narrative feels inconsistent, with Golden Ages lacking the same impact as the challenges of Dark Ages. This critique suggests that the system’s potential is not fully realized, leaving certain aspects underdeveloped. Additionally, JeuxActu’s review introduces confusion, describing a story set in a 1980s Californian town with ghostly artifacts—a stark departure from Civilization VI’s historical scope. While this may reflect a misinterpretation or error, it underscores the risk of narrative elements feeling disjointed if not tightly integrated with the game’s core mechanics. Overall, the critics agree that Rise and Fall significantly enhances Civilization VI’s storytelling through its era-based systems and historical chronicles, creating a more layered experience for players. While some reservations exist about the balance between Golden and Dark Ages, the expansion is widely seen as a successful addition to the series. The praise from multiple outlets—such as Hobby Consolas, IGN Spain, and Wccftech—reflects a strong consensus that the narrative mechanics enrich the game’s strategic depth, even if minor flaws in execution remain. The mixed reactions highlight the complexity of blending historical simulation with storytelling, but the expansion largely succeeds in making each civilization’s journey feel more personal and impactful.

The gameplay of Sid Meier’s Civilization VI: Rise and Fall is widely praised for its enhanced strategic depth and innovative mechanics that expand the base game’s complexity. Critics consistently highlight the introduction of the era system, which introduces dynamic shifts between Golden, Dark, and Heroic Ages, creating a more nuanced progression curve. For instance, 3DJuegos emphasizes the tension between maintaining a golden age and avoiding dark ages, while GameSpot notes how the Ages system forces players to balance political, economic, and military strategies. The governor system also receives acclaim for its tactical flexibility, with Cubed3 and IGN Italia praising how specialized governors offer unique roles that cater to different playstyles, from scientific advancement to conquest. Additionally, the loyalty system and alliances add layers of diplomacy, as noted by Game Informer and PC Games, which appreciate the emphasis on non-military victories and long-term planning. These additions are seen as refining the core mechanics of Civilization VI, offering players more tools to shape their empires in creative ways. However, several critics point out that the expansion’s complexity can feel overwhelming or underdeveloped in parts. Eurogamer Italy and IGN note that some systems, like the loyalty mechanic, are criticized for being rigid or overly formalized, while Gamer.no and Riot Pixels describe certain features as “raw” or lacking impact. The era system, though praised for its dynamism, is occasionally seen as exacerbating the “Matthew effect,” where experienced players gain disproportionate advantages, as highlighted by Gamersky. Additionally, some mechanics like emergencies and policy cards are criticized for being heavy-handed or predictable, with Game Over Online and PC Gamer pointing out that their implementation sometimes feels clunky. The governor system also faces mixed reactions; while many appreciate its strategic potential, others, like Gamer.no, note limitations in customization and the restrictive nature of certain bonuses. These critiques suggest that while the expansion adds depth, it occasionally sacrifices polish for ambition. Despite these criticisms, the overall consensus among critics is overwhelmingly positive, with most agreeing that Rise and Fall significantly enriches Civilization VI’s gameplay. Reviewers like GRYOnline.pl and IGN Italia emphasize the seamless integration of new mechanics into the existing framework, calling them “natural” and impactful. The expansion’s focus on strategic variety—whether through diplomacy, governance, or long-term planning—is seen as a major strength, with Game Informer and PC Games highlighting how it encourages diverse playstyles. While some systems require refinement, the majority of critics, including 3DJuegos and Cubed3, view Rise and Fall as a successful expansion that deepens the series’ strategic appeal without alienating veteran players. The combination of innovation and familiarity ensures that the DLC is celebrated as a meaningful evolution of Civilization VI, even if it isn’t without its flaws.

The reviews of Sid Meier’s Civilization VI: Rise and Fall highlight several positive aspects of its graphics and visual design, with critics praising its attention to detail and thematic elements. 3DJuegos commends the “extraordinary” visual representation of civilizations and leaders, emphasizing the meticulous craftsmanship in both visuals and sound design. Cubed3 notes the innovative use of “visual portraits” to depict a civilization’s history through achievements, while Game Over Online applauds the GUI redesign for its “brilliant” information density, though it acknowledges potential screen clutter. GRYOnline.pl celebrates the “beautiful, hand-drawn timeline,” which adds a unique artistic flair, and JeuxActu appreciates the pixel art style evoking classic LucasArts adventures, with vibrant colors like neon pink enhancing the 80s atmosphere. PCGamesN also highlights how visual shifts during Dark Ages (desaturated tones) and Golden Ages (heavenly glows) deepen thematic immersion, showcasing the expansion’s ability to use aesthetics as narrative tools. However, some critics point to specific shortcomings in the visual design. Gamer.no criticizes the governor icons for being “too child-friendly” and lacking distinctiveness, which detracts from their effectiveness in conveying complex systems. JeuxActu notes that the lack of perspective in the pixel art style creates navigation challenges, as environmental elements can feel confusing or disorienting. Additionally, Game Over Online’s mention of potential GUI clutter suggests that while the interface is improved, its complexity may overwhelm some players. These critiques highlight a tension between artistic expression and functional clarity, with certain visual choices prioritizing nostalgia or thematic cohesion over practical usability. Overall, the critics’ opinions reflect a broad appreciation for Rise and Fall’s visual design, particularly its creative use of art styles and thematic storytelling. While there are valid concerns about specific elements like governor icons and spatial clarity, these issues do not overshadow the expansion’s strengths. Reviewers such as 3DJuegos and GRYOnline.pl emphasize the artistic ambition and attention to detail, while others like JeuxActu and PCGamesN acknowledge the balance between nostalgia-driven aesthetics and narrative depth. The consensus suggests that Rise and Fall succeeds in enhancing the visual experience of Civilization VI, even if some aspects require refinement to fully align with player expectations.

Summary unavailable

Summary unavailable

The technical performance of Sid Meier’s Civilization VI: Rise and Fall on PC is generally praised for its stability and smooth operation, with many critics noting minimal major issues. Multiplayer.it highlights that the expansion maintains the base game’s technical quality, emphasizing minor tweaks and consistent performance on recommended hardware. GameSpot acknowledges that while AI inconsistencies persist, they are described as "minor compared to the expansion’s overall improvements," and Stevivor notes the game remains "generally stable despite these flaws." These positives underscore the game’s ability to run reliably without significant crashes or graphical hiccups, even with added mechanics. The technical foundation of the PC version is seen as robust, allowing players to focus on gameplay rather than performance hurdles. However, the AI behavior across PC platforms is a recurring point of criticism, with multiple reviewers highlighting persistent flaws that detract from immersion and balance. 3DJuegos and Games.cz both mention issues like "illogical decisions" and "AI failing to understand player actions," while Riot Pixels sarcastically describes the AI as "suffering from idiocy." Impulsegamer points to long load times that persist from the base game, and Vandal notes minor technical quirks like "occasional camera movements during gameplay." Critics like Cubed3 and Gaming Nexus also critique the AI’s inability to coordinate effectively in global emergencies or maintain alliances, suggesting design flaws that impact strategic depth. These issues, though not catastrophic, are seen as significant enough to disrupt the experience for many players. The overall consensus among critics is that Rise and Fall delivers a technically solid PC experience despite its AI shortcomings. While Multiplayer.it and GameSpot emphasize the lack of major bugs or performance issues, the AI problems—ranging from unpredictability to illogical behavior—are widely acknowledged as the expansion’s most notable technical flaw. PC Games and Wccftech stress that these AI inconsistencies "detract from the experience despite improvements," but they are not severe enough to overshadow the game’s broader strengths. Most reviewers agree that the technical performance is adequate, with the primary criticism centered on the AI’s design rather than core stability or graphical fidelity. This balance of praise and critique reflects a game that functions well technically but struggles to fully integrate its new mechanics without hiccups.

The majority of critics praise Sid Meier’s Civilization VI: Rise and Fall for its robust replay value, emphasizing how new mechanics, civilizations, and strategies create a dynamic experience that encourages multiple playthroughs. Reviewers like 3DJuegos, Game Informer, and GameSpot highlight the expansion’s introduction of systems such as Loyalty, Golden Ages, and the Ages mechanic, which add layers of complexity and variability to gameplay. GamesBeat and Hobby Consolas note that features like Emergencies, diverse leaders, and narrative-driven mechanics provide fresh paths to victory, while IGN Italia points to the game’s ability to sustain engagement over hundreds of hours through its balanced strategies and evolving challenges. The expansion’s focus on varied playstyles—ranging from diplomacy to cultural dominance—ensures that each session feels distinct, appealing to both veteran and new players seeking depth. However, some critics argue that the expansion’s impact on replayability is more nuanced or limited by certain design choices. Games.cz and IGN Spain suggest that while new content adds variety, the core gameplay remains repetitive, with late-game mechanics feeling less engaging. Game Over Online expresses ambiguity, noting that the expansion prolongs mid-game competition but doesn’t strongly incentivize repeated play. Similarly, PCGamesN mentions that some systems, like Loyalty and Governor roles, feel incomplete or overly structured, potentially diminishing long-term appeal for players seeking innovation. Multiplayer.it also frames certain additions as “filler,” implying that the expansion’s novelty may not fully translate to lasting engagement for all audiences. Overall, the consensus leans toward a positive assessment of Rise and Fall’s replay value, with most critics acknowledging its ability to enrich the base game through new mechanics and content. While Wccftech and Vandal emphasize the expansion’s substantial additions—such as eight new civilizations and enhanced diplomacy—as key drivers of long-term engagement, others like Gamer.nl and Gaming Nexus note that the complexity may not appeal to all players. The critical divide centers on whether the expansion’s incremental changes are enough to justify repeated play or if they fall short of revolutionary innovation. Despite these differences, the majority agree that Rise and Fall successfully extends the series’ legacy by offering a rich, adaptable experience that rewards exploration and experimentation.