Loading...
Loading...
89
MONSTER
Scarlet Hollow is a horror-mystery game with sharp writing, dark humor, and hand-drawn art from Ignatz Award-winning graphic novelist Abby Howard.
Game analysis
Monster Scorecard
Scorecard In Progress
We're gathering and analyzing critic reviews to generate a comprehensive Monster Scorecard with detailed breakdowns for story, gameplay, graphics, sound, and more.
Actively collecting reviews
Reviews
6 reviews found93
92
92
90
Noisy Pixel
Mar 3, 2025
Scarlet Hollow is a masterfully written horror visual novel that blends eerie storytelling with deep player choice. With a richly detailed world, compelling characters, and a haunting atmosphere, it offers an immersive supernatural mystery experience. Though still incomplete, its branching narrative and impactful decisions make it a must-play for fans of narrative-driven horror.
Read full review
80
CGMagazine
Oct 30, 2020
Scarlet Hollow proves not all horror games need jump scares or hyper violent animations for them to work. Its execution in a horror visual novel works well through old-school mysteries and slow buildup in its short time. Its chills come from an old-school suspense and discovering that not everything is as it seems when players sink further into a brief episodic tale.
Read full review
Games you might also enjoy
Trending games the community is playing
Games with full Monster Scorecards
