Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Amazon

Steam

Twitch

MONSTER

Pentiment

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Pentiment
Item: Pentiment
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2022

GenresAdventure, RPG, Mystery, Single Player

AvailableNov 14, 2022

PlatformPC, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X

DeveloperObsidian Entertainment

Overview

A 16th-century narrative adventure set in Upper Bavaria, following Andreas Maler, a journeyman artist working in the bygone scriptorium of Kiersau Abbey during a time of great social unrest. While finishing his masterpiece, Andreas inadvertently becomes entangled in a series of murders that take place over 25 years. Peasants, thieves, craftsmen, monks, nuns, nobles, and even saints must be investigated and interrogated to expose the truth.

Elsewhere

8.5

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Pentiment has earned acclaim for its rich narrative and historical depth, exploring complex themes like morality and truth within a 16th-century murder mystery. Critics praise its engaging character, Andreas Maler, and the impact of player choices. However, some highlight issues with pacing and a frustrating, abrupt ending, while others find its slow, dialogue-heavy style off-putting. Overall, it’s a standout title that marries historical intrigue with compelling storytelling, despite its narrative shortcomings.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

95%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of Pentiment has garnered significant praise from critics, who highlight its rich narrative and historical depth. Many reviewers, such as GameSpot and Pure Xbox, commend the game for its exploration of complex themes such as morality, societal dynamics, and the subjective nature of truth, all framed within a murder mystery set in 16th-century Bavaria. The protagonist, Andreas Maler, serves as a compelling lens through which players engage with the intricacies of history, as noted by PCGamesN and Attack of the Fanboy. Critics appreciate the game's emphasis on player choices and their consequences, which adds layers to the narrative, making it feel personal and impactful. The attention to historical detail and character development is also frequently mentioned, with reviewers like IGN Italia and New Game Network praising the way the story intertwines personal and collective experiences over a span of 25 years. Despite the overall positive sentiment, some critics have pointed out notable shortcomings in Pentiment's storytelling. A common criticism is the pacing and resolution of the narrative, with several reviewers, including GameSpot and Adventure Game Hotspot, expressing dissatisfaction with the abrupt ending that leaves unresolved questions. Critics like Vandal and Jeuxvideo.com also mention that while the story is rich in historical context, it can occasionally feel verbose and may lose player engagement at times. Furthermore, some players may find the slow-paced, dialogue-heavy nature of the game challenging, as highlighted by Push Square, which could deter those who prefer faster-paced gameplay. In summary, the consensus among critics is that Pentiment offers a compelling and intricately woven narrative that effectively explores historical and philosophical themes. While there are critiques regarding pacing and resolution, the majority of reviewers agree that the story is engaging and thought-provoking. Critics like Windows Central and Hardcore Gamer emphasize the game's ability to captivate players through its unique storytelling approach and character-driven plot. Overall, Pentiment stands out as a noteworthy title that successfully combines historical intrigue with a murder mystery, despite its minor narrative flaws.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Pentiment impresses with its narrative depth and player choice, immersing players in a rich historical setting. Critics praise its RPG elements and unique time management mechanics that enhance engagement but also highlight slow pacing and repetitive tasks that can frustrate some players. While the game shines for those who love character-driven stories, it may disappoint those seeking action or traditional gameplay, making its appeal highly subjective.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

48%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

51%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Pentiment has garnered praise for its narrative-driven approach and the depth of player choices. Critics like Generación Xbox and Pure Xbox highlight the game's ability to immerse players in a richly detailed historical setting, allowing for meaningful interactions with characters and the environment. The incorporation of RPG elements, as noted by AusGamers and Hey Poor Player, adds layers to character development and decision-making, giving players a sense of agency that can significantly influence the narrative. Additionally, the unique time management mechanic, mentioned by Attack of the Fanboy and PC Gamer, creates a sense of urgency that can enhance the investigative experience, making players feel more engaged in their quest for truth. However, the gameplay has also faced significant criticism for its slow pacing and perceived lack of interactivity. Reviewers such as ZTGD and GameSpot describe the moment-to-moment gameplay as tedious, with repetitive tasks that can detract from the overall enjoyment. Many critics, including Xbox Achievements and Hobby Consolas, point out that the gameplay primarily revolves around dialogue and exploration, which can feel limiting and monotonous, especially for those expecting more traditional adventure mechanics. The emphasis on reading and conversation, as noted by Power Unlimited and GamingTrend, may not appeal to all players, leading to a sense of frustration with the game's slower moments. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that Pentiment offers a unique narrative experience that excels in character development and storytelling but struggles with pacing and engagement. While some reviewers appreciate the depth of decision-making and the immersive historical context, others find the gameplay lacking in dynamism and excitement. The game may resonate well with players who enjoy narrative exploration and character-driven stories, as indicated by critics like Digital Trends and Checkpoint Gaming, but those seeking action or traditional gameplay mechanics might find it less satisfying. Ultimately, Pentiment presents a distinct blend of storytelling and player choice, though its appeal may vary significantly depending on individual player preferences.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Pentiment dazzles with its unique, charming aesthetic inspired by illuminated manuscripts, earning widespread acclaim for its immersive storytelling and historical detail. Critics praise its beautiful, hand-drawn style, though some note issues with stiff animations and environmental detail. Overall, the game's visuals are a standout feature, enhancing the experience despite minor execution flaws.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

93%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The overall sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of Pentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with a significant majority of critics praising its unique aesthetic. Many reviewers, such as Wccftech and Digital Trends, highlight the game's inspiration from illuminated manuscripts and woodcuts, which contributes to a charming and immersive experience. Critics like Guardian and CGMagazine commend the attention to detail, noting how the visuals enhance storytelling and evoke the historical context of the 16th century. The art style is described as beautiful and distinct, with clever use of typography to reflect characters' social status and educational backgrounds, as pointed out by GameSpot and Inverse. The hand-drawn aesthetic and vibrant colors, as noted by TheXboxHub and Push Square, further elevate the game's visual appeal, creating an engaging atmosphere that resonates with players. However, despite the overall acclaim, several critics pointed out notable shortcomings in the game's visual execution. Common criticisms include stiff character animations and a lack of fluidity in movement, as mentioned by AusGamers and Wccftech. Some reviewers, such as Slant Magazine and Areajugones, noted that while the artistic style is charming, it can sometimes sacrifice clarity and pacing, which may detract from the overall experience. Additionally, a few critics, like New Game Network and Vandal, remarked that certain environments lack detail, indicating that while the artistic direction is strong, the technical execution may not meet the expectations of all players. In summary, the consensus among critics is that Pentiment features a highly creative and visually appealing design that successfully immerses players in its historical narrative. While there are some criticisms regarding animation fluidity and environmental detail, the unique art style and attention to historical accuracy are widely celebrated. Critics like MeuPlayStation and GamingBolt encapsulate this sentiment by emphasizing how the game's visuals enhance the storytelling experience, making Pentiment a standout title in terms of graphics and visual design within its genre. Overall, the game's artistic approach has resonated with many players and critics alike, solidifying its place as a visually distinctive and engaging experience.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Pentiment's sound design is praised for its immersive, historically accurate qualities, with critics applauding ambient sounds and period music that enhance its atmosphere. The quill scratching effect adds authenticity, but the game faces criticism for a lack of voice acting and a limited musical score, leading to awkward silences and a less engaging narrative. While the minimalist audio approach can deepen immersion, it often feels sparse, with some sound effects becoming repetitive. Overall, the game strikes a balance between artistic choices and the need for a richer auditory experience, leaving critics divided on its effectiveness.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

54%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Pentiment have garnered praise for their immersive qualities and historical accuracy. Many critics, such as IGN and Hobby Consolas, highlight the effectiveness of the ambient sounds and the subtle musical themes that enhance the game's atmosphere. The sound of a quill scratching on parchment, noted by multiple reviewers including RPG Fan and Stevivor, adds a tactile dimension to the auditory experience, creating a sense of authenticity that aligns well with the game's book-like presentation. Furthermore, the incorporation of period-appropriate music, as mentioned by critics like CGMagazine and Games.cz, is appreciated for its ability to transport players to the Middle Ages, enriching the narrative and emotional impact during key moments. However, several reviewers have pointed out significant drawbacks, particularly the lack of voice acting and a more robust musical score. Critics such as Xbox Achievements and Game Informer express disappointment over the minimal use of music, which can lead to moments of awkward silence. The absence of voiceovers is frequently mentioned, with ZTGD and Universo Nintendo noting that this choice detracts from character engagement and narrative depth. Additionally, the repetitive nature of certain sound effects, like the quill scratching, was highlighted by PCGamesN and GameSpew as potentially distracting, suggesting that the overall sound design may lack the dynamism some players might expect. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while Pentiment excels in creating an immersive auditory experience through its sound design, it suffers from a lack of variety in music and the absence of voice acting. Reviewers like TrueAchievements and AusGamers acknowledge that the minimalist approach to sound can enhance immersion but also leaves the game feeling sparse at times. Critics appreciate the unique presentation of dialogue through text and the effective use of ambient sounds, yet many agree that a more pronounced musical score could have significantly elevated the overall experience. The balance between the game's artistic choices and the desire for a richer auditory landscape remains a point of contention, reflecting a nuanced reception of its sound design and music.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Pentiment's unique dialogue presentation, using typography instead of traditional voice acting, has split critics. Some praise its creative aesthetic and immersive storytelling, while others argue the lack of voiceovers can detract from player engagement, making it feel dry. Overall, the game’s innovative approach is lauded, but its accessibility may not resonate with all players, highlighting a divide in reception.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

17%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

77%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Pentiment has garnered a range of opinions, with several critics highlighting the positive aspects of the game's unique approach to dialogue presentation. Reviewers such as TrueAchievements and VG247 commend the absence of traditional voice acting, viewing it as a creative decision that enhances the game's aesthetic and aligns with its manuscript theme. The use of typography to convey character emotions and social statuses has been praised, with critics like Game Informer and Generación Xbox noting how the font styles effectively reflect the characters' backgrounds and intentions. This innovative method of storytelling has been described as engaging and immersive, contributing to the overall narrative richness of the game. On the other hand, a significant number of critics express concerns regarding the lack of voice acting, suggesting that it may detract from the immersive experience for some players. COGconnected and Player 2 point out that the absence of voiced dialogue can lead to a feeling of dryness in the gameplay, potentially alienating those who prefer auditory engagement in their gaming experiences. Additionally, critics like XboxAddict and SECTOR.sk acknowledge that while the text-based dialogue is well-crafted, it may not resonate with all players, particularly those who might find the reading aspect cumbersome or less engaging than voice-acted interactions. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards an appreciation of Pentiment's unconventional approach to dialogue, despite some reservations about its impact on immersion. While many reviewers recognize the artistic merit of using text and typography—such as in the opinions of GameSpew and IGN Italia—there remains a notable divide in player experience, with some finding the lack of voice acting a drawback. Critics like RPG Fan and Universo Nintendo encapsulate this sentiment, suggesting that while the game's design choices are commendable, they might not appeal universally, indicating a mixed reception that balances innovation with potential accessibility issues.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Pentiment impresses with polished performance across platforms, especially on Xbox Series X, despite some crashes and bugs. PC offers smooth gameplay but suffers from minor graphical issues, while the Nintendo Switch maintains decent performance with minor frame drops and longer load times. Overall, the game’s immersive narrative and visuals overshadow its technical shortcomings, making it a solid experience for players.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

41%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

59%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Pentiment has garnered a generally positive reception across various gaming platforms. On the Xbox Series X, critics like Attack of the Fanboy and Generación Xbox praised the game for its polished presentation and stable performance, with minimal bugs reported. PlaySense highlighted the game's high-quality visuals in 4K, while XboxEra noted its smooth operation across platforms. On PC, reviewers such as Game Rant and LevelUp found the game technically sound, with smooth animations and stable gameplay, while Meristation emphasized its well-polished nature and accessibility features. The Nintendo Switch version also received favorable comments, with Nintendo Life and Vandal noting that the game performs well in both docked and handheld modes, maintaining a clean visual presentation despite some minor issues. However, there are notable negatives associated with each platform. On the Xbox Series X, Checkpoint Gaming reported frequent crashes, particularly during Quick Resume, which could disrupt the gaming experience. JeuxActu pointed out technical issues like script errors and translation inconsistencies that detracted from immersion. On PC, while many reviews were positive, some critics, including SECTOR.sk, mentioned graphical glitches and frame rate drops, indicating that the game's performance could be impacted by its development constraints. For the Nintendo Switch, while the performance was generally stable, critics like Universo Nintendo noted minor frame rate drops and longer loading times compared to other platforms, which could affect the overall experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Pentiment delivers a solid technical performance across all platforms, with some minor issues that do not significantly hinder gameplay. The Xbox Series X version is generally regarded as the most polished, although it suffers from occasional crashes and minor bugs. The PC version is stable but has some complaints regarding controls and minor technical issues. The Switch version performs adequately, though it lacks the speed and efficiency of its counterparts. Despite these drawbacks, the game's immersive narrative and artistic style seem to shine through, making it a worthwhile experience for players across all platforms.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics praise Pentiment for its branching narrative and character choices that encourage replayability, but the game suffers from slow pacing, limited save options, and minimal impact of choices, leading to a mixed consensus. While it offers rich storytelling, many suggest it’s better as a one-time experience rather than something to replay extensively.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

59%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

38%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of various critics regarding the replay value of Pentiment highlight several positive aspects that contribute to its appeal. Many reviewers, such as PC Gamer and Gfinity, emphasize the game's branching narrative and character choices, which encourage players to explore different paths and outcomes in subsequent playthroughs. Critics like But Why Tho? and Attack of the Fanboy note that the game's depth and intricacy, along with the impact of player decisions, make it highly replayable. The choose-your-own-adventure format, as mentioned by Game Rant, allows players to experience various outcomes, while the exploration of character backgrounds and relationships adds layers to the narrative, making it enticing for players to revisit the game. However, there are notable criticisms concerning the game's replay value that detract from its overall appeal. Critics like PC Invasion and MeuPlayStation point out the limitations imposed by the lack of save options, which can discourage players from engaging in multiple playthroughs. The slow pacing and absence of a New Game Plus feature, highlighted by Launcher, further contribute to a sense of redundancy in replaying the game. Additionally, some reviewers, including Hardcore Gamer and Adventure Gamers, express concerns that the choices made throughout the narrative do not significantly alter the gameplay experience, leading to a feeling of unsatisfaction in terms of the payoff from different choices. Overall, the consensus among critics presents a mixed view of Pentiment's replay value. While many acknowledge the potential for multiple playthroughs due to the branching narrative and player choices, there are significant concerns regarding the game's pacing, lack of save options, and the limited impact of choices on gameplay. Critics like VGC and XboxEra suggest that although the game encourages exploration of different outcomes, the experience may be more impactful as a one-shot rather than a game that invites extensive replaying. Thus, while Pentiment has elements that could support replayability, the limitations identified by various reviewers create a nuanced picture that may deter some players from returning to the game multiple times.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

88%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

12%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

Pentiment has garnered a largely positive reception among critics, who have praised its rich narrative, unique art style, and engaging character development. Many reviewers, such as GameSpot and Destructoid, highlighted the game's intriguing exploration of historical themes, with Game Informer noting its respect for the historical era it recreates. Critics like Hey Poor Player and TrueAchievements emphasized the game's standout narrative and the depth of player choice, while others, such as RPG Fan and Digital Trends, commended its exceptional writing and thematic depth. The visual design has also received accolades, with multiple reviewers, including Jeuxvideo.com and God is a Geek, describing it as visually stunning and a compelling homage to the Renaissance. However, despite the game's many strengths, several critics pointed out notable weaknesses that may limit its appeal. The pacing of Pentiment was a common concern, with MeuPlayStation and PCGamesN mentioning that its slow tempo could deter players who prefer more action-oriented gameplay. Critics like ZTGD and XGN found the game to be potentially boring for those not invested in its historical context, while others, such as JeuxActu and GameSpew, noted issues with gameplay structure and repetition in dialogue. These critiques suggest that while the game excels in narrative and artistic presentation, its gameplay mechanics and pacing may not resonate with a broader audience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Pentiment is a unique and thought-provoking title that stands out for its narrative depth and artistic design. While some reviewers expressed concerns about pacing and gameplay limitations, the majority of opinions lean towards a favorable view, highlighting its appeal to fans of narrative-driven games and historical fiction. Critics like Power Unlimited and Meristation encapsulated this sentiment by describing it as a creative masterwork and a must-play for those who appreciate storytelling in video games. Thus, despite its flaws, Pentiment is regarded as a significant contribution to the genre, marking a successful endeavor by Obsidian Entertainment.

TL;DR

Pentiment shines with a rich narrative and stunning Renaissance art style, earning praise for its character depth and historical exploration. Critics laud its storytelling, but note pacing issues and potential boredom for those less invested in its themes. While some gameplay mechanics may not appeal to all, it stands as a must-play for fans of narrative-driven games, marking a strong effort by Obsidian Entertainment.

MONSTER

Reviews

168 reviews found

100

Nintendo Life

Nintendo Switch

Feb 27, 2024

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is highly recommended as a unique and impressive game that combines a rich historical setting with an engaging murder mystery.

Read full review

100

SomosXbox

Xbox Series X

Nov 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is a standout title that combines a compelling narrative, unique visual design, and engaging gameplay, making it a must-play for any gamer.

Read full review

100

CD-Action

Nov 16, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is described as one of the smartest and most engaging adventure games in history, worthy of attention and remembrance for decades.

Read full review

100

TheGamer

Nov 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is an exceptional game that combines a compelling narrative, unique visual design, and engaging gameplay, leaving a lasting impact on players. It is highly recommended for its artistic achievement and emotional depth.

Read full review

100

Hey Poor Player

Xbox Series X

Nov 22, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is highly praised for its engaging story, unique visual style, and the depth of player choice, earning a perfect score.

100

But Why Tho?

Xbox Series X

Nov 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is a special work of art that consistently engages players and leaves a lasting impression.

100

Gamer.no

Xbox Series X

Nov 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is hailed as one of the best games ever played by the reviewer, praised for its storytelling, character depth, and unique presentation. It stands out as a remarkable narrative experience.

Read full review

100

XboxAddict

Xbox Series X

Nov 15, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is hailed as one of the best games of the year, praised for its narrative depth, historical context, and character development. It may not be for everyone, but those who appreciate story-driven experiences will find it exceptional.

Read full review

100

Screen Rant

Xbox Series X

Nov 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is a milestone for narrative-based games and a high bar for competitors. It's a reinvention of narrative gaming that asks thought-provoking questions. While it may not be for everyone, it's a captivating and subjective experience worth playing.

Read full review

100

Gfinity

Nov 14, 2022

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Pentiment is a compelling narrative-driven game that excels in storytelling, character development, and immersive design, making it a standout title in the RPG genre.

Read full review