Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

MONSTER

Madden NFL 24

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Madden NFL 24
Item: Madden NFL 24
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2023

GenresAction, Simulation, Sports, Strategy, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableAug 15, 2023

PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, PC

DeveloperEA Tiburon

Overview

Experience the newest iteration of FieldSENSE in Madden NFL 24. More realistic character movement and smarter AI gives you control to play out your gameplay strategy with the confidence to dominate any opponent.

Elsewhere

4.4

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics largely slam Madden NFL 24's Superstar Mode for its lackluster storytelling, calling it generic and underdeveloped. While some praise minor narrative shifts and player choices, the consensus is that the mode doesn't deliver a compelling experience. The shift from the richer Face of the Franchise to this simplified mode has left players feeling disappointed and unengaged, marking a missed opportunity for deeper storytelling in the game.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

40%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

60%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of various critics regarding the story elements in Madden NFL 24's Superstar Mode reveal a few positive notes amidst a predominantly critical consensus. Some reviewers, like Digital Chumps, acknowledge that the game features minor narrative shifts and dialogue choices that can enhance the career mode experience, albeit in a limited capacity. This suggests that there are attempts to introduce some level of interactivity and player choice, which could appeal to those who enjoy customizing their gaming experience. However, this positive aspect is overshadowed by the overall sentiment that the narrative elements are not sufficiently developed. The majority of critics express disappointment with the storytelling in Madden NFL 24. ComicBook and IGN both emphasize that the narrative elements in Superstar Mode feel limited and generic, lacking the depth and engagement that players might expect from a sports title. IGN Adria further criticizes the mode for being underdeveloped and lacking excitement, indicating that it serves more as a presentation point rather than a meaningful narrative experience. CGMagazine and GameCritics echo this sentiment, highlighting the removal of the more engaging Face of the Franchise mode and the resulting lack of depth in narrative options. Critics like GameSpot and LevelUp also note the blandness of the narrative, with GameSpot pointing out that the experience is primarily text-based and lacks the immersive qualities that players desire. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Madden NFL 24's Superstar Mode falls short in delivering a compelling narrative experience. While there are minor elements of interactivity noted by Digital Chumps, the overwhelming feedback from reviewers like IGN, GameSpot, and ComicBook suggests that the game lacks the depth and engagement necessary to captivate players. The transition from the previously more robust Face of the Franchise mode to the simplified Superstar mode has left many feeling that the story aspect of the game is uninspired and underwhelming. As a result, Madden NFL 24's narrative elements are perceived as a missed opportunity, failing to enhance the overall gaming experience for both newcomers and long-time fans of the franchise.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 impresses with improved player interactions, AI behavior, and new features like Skill-Based Passing 2.0, creating a more realistic experience. However, it suffers from notable glitches, inconsistent gameplay, and underdeveloped modes, leaving it feeling unfinished. Critics see promise, but the game needs further refinement to reach its potential as a seamless football simulation.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

38%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Madden NFL 24 has garnered a mixed yet generally positive reception among critics, with many praising its advancements over previous iterations. Reviewers from outlets like Game Informer and God is a Geek highlighted significant improvements in player interactions, tackling, and blocking logic, contributing to a more realistic on-field experience. Critics such as Gamers' Temple and IGN noted enhancements in AI behavior and animations, which have led to a more engaging gameplay experience. Additionally, the introduction of features like Skill-Based Passing 2.0 and the Tactical Blocking System has been well-received, with GameSpot and Windows Central emphasizing the more lifelike and enjoyable aspects of gameplay, particularly in how players move and react on the field. However, despite these improvements, several critics pointed out notable shortcomings that detract from the overall experience. Issues with AI decision-making, inconsistencies in gameplay, and glitches were frequently mentioned, with reviews from GamesRadar+ and Hardcore Gamer emphasizing the presence of warping players, dropped catches, and unresponsive mechanics. Critics like Impulsegamer and Gaming Age echoed concerns about the gameplay feeling over-complicated and lacking excitement, while others noted that some features felt underdeveloped or insufficient, particularly in modes like Franchise and Superstar. This sentiment was echoed by CGMagazine and Twinfinite, which pointed out that while there were improvements, certain gameplay elements still left much to be desired. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while Madden NFL 24 has made strides in gameplay, it remains a work in progress. Many reviewers, including those from ComicBook and Digital Chumps, acknowledged the excitement of on-field action but also highlighted the need for further polish and refinement. The balance of praise for new features and criticism of persistent issues indicates that while the game is enjoyable and offers a more authentic football experience, it still struggles with inconsistencies and technical problems that may hinder its potential. Thus, Madden NFL 24 stands as a title that shows promise but requires additional attention to fully realize its capabilities in delivering a seamless football simulation.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 impresses with stunning graphics and lifelike player animations, earning praise for its modern visuals and SAPIEN Technology enhancements. Critics laud the game's realism but express frustration over a lack of significant innovation since previous editions, citing familiar visuals and some glitches. Pre-game and post-game presentations feel generic, and inconsistencies in player gear detract from the immersive experience. Overall, while the game shines visually, it highlights a need for greater evolution in future releases.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

51%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The overall sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of Madden NFL 24 is predominantly positive, with many critics praising the significant improvements made in player models, animations, and overall visual fidelity. Reviewers such as Game Informer and God is a Geek highlight the enhanced realism of player shapes and sizes, noting that the graphics make the game feel modern and lifelike. Critics from IGN and Windows Central also commend the visuals, stating that they are the best in the series and evoke the experience of watching a real NFL game. The introduction of SAPIEN Technology, which revamps player models and skeletons, has been particularly noted by TheXboxHub, contributing to a more immersive and visually appealing experience. Additionally, the improved lighting and textures have been acknowledged by several reviewers, including Hardcore Gamer and GGRecon, who emphasize the game's detailed environments. Despite the positive feedback, there are notable criticisms regarding the graphics and visual design of Madden NFL 24. Some reviewers, like MeuPlayStation and Shacknews, express disappointment that the visuals have not evolved significantly from previous iterations, suggesting a lack of innovation in the franchise. Critics such as COGconnected and GamingTrend point out that the visuals feel familiar and exhibit glitches, which detracts from the overall experience. Additionally, some reviews, like that of The Loadout, criticize the pre-game and post-game presentations as generic, lacking personality and atmosphere that could enhance immersion. The inconsistency in player gear and design, as mentioned by GameSpot, further highlights the need for more cohesive visual updates. In summary, while Madden NFL 24 has received commendations for its impressive graphics and animations, the consensus among critics reveals a mixed bag of sentiments. Many reviewers recognize the advancements made, particularly in player realism and environmental detail, as seen in the opinions of Gamers' Temple and Impulsegamer. However, there is a shared concern regarding the stagnation of visual innovation, with critics like Shacknews and MeuPlayStation calling for more substantial changes. Overall, the game is viewed as a visually appealing entry in the franchise, but the criticisms regarding its lack of evolution suggest that there is still room for improvement in future installments.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24's sound design and music receive mixed reviews; praised for atmospheric audio and a modern soundtrack featuring artists like Wiz Khalifa, but criticized for limited musical variety and repetitive commentary that detracts from immersion. While some appreciate the game's auditory strengths, others highlight significant shortcomings and a need for improvement.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

21%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

29%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Madden NFL 24 have garnered a mix of praise and criticism from various reviewers. On the positive side, Hardcore Gamer highlights that the audio effectively captures the NFL atmosphere, with dynamic commentary and impactful sound effects that enhance the gameplay experience. Critics like GGRecon commend the soundtrack, noting the inclusion of popular artists such as Wiz Khalifa and Jack Harlow, which adds a contemporary flair to the game. Additionally, LevelUp appreciates the organic crowd reactions, which contribute to a more immersive environment, while MeuPlayStation acknowledges the solid commentary, despite some concerns about its repetitiveness. However, several reviewers have expressed dissatisfaction with the soundtrack and commentary. Gamers' Temple criticizes the limited variety in music genres, suggesting that the game would benefit from a broader selection or access to NFL Films library tracks. Impulsegamer raises concerns about the vulgarity of the hip-hop tracks, indicating that not all players may appreciate the heavy emphasis on this genre. The Loadout echoes similar sentiments, pointing out the commercial-grade score and lack of musical diversity. Furthermore, critics such as GameSpot and ZTGD lament the stagnation of commentary quality, describing it as stale and repetitive, which detracts from the overall immersion expected in a sports title. Overall, the consensus among critics appears to be a mixed bag, with a notable divide between those who appreciate the modern soundtrack and immersive sound design and those who feel let down by the lack of variety and quality in the audio components. While Hardcore Gamer and GGRecon highlight the strengths of the audio experience, others like COGconnected and The Loadout emphasize the shortcomings in both the soundtrack and commentary. This dichotomy suggests that while Madden NFL 24 has made strides in certain areas of sound design, it still has significant room for improvement to meet the expectations of its diverse player base.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24's voice acting features real-life star quarterbacks, adding authenticity and enhancing the gaming experience for fans. However, critics slam the overall execution, citing lackluster performances, stale commentary, and unengaging narratives that detract from immersion. Despite a few bright spots, the consensus is disappointment, with many feeling the voice work falls short of expectations.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

71%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

29%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Madden NFL 24 has garnered some positive remarks, particularly regarding the inclusion of real-life star quarterbacks. Critics like Worth Playing highlight this aspect, noting that the presence of these familiar voices adds a layer of authenticity to the game. Additionally, LevelUp points out that interactions with real sports figures contribute to a sense of realism, which can enhance the overall gaming experience. This connection to actual players may resonate well with fans and adds a unique touch that distinguishes Madden NFL 24 from other titles in the sports genre. However, the negative aspects of the voice acting in Madden NFL 24 are more pronounced in the reviews. GamingBolt criticizes the narrative-focused mode for its lack of engaging voice work and drama, suggesting that it fails to captivate players. Twinfinite echoes this sentiment, describing the dialogue in Superstar Mode as "half-baked," indicating a lack of effort in delivering compelling performances. Furthermore, GameCritics mentions that while voice acting is present, it does not stand out, leading to a repetitive experience. GameSpot adds to this criticism by stating that the commentary is stale and often incorrect, which detracts from the game's atmosphere and immersion. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while there are some redeeming qualities in the voice acting of Madden NFL 24, particularly with the inclusion of real sports figures, the execution falls short in many areas. The general sentiment leans towards disappointment, with multiple reviewers, including GamingBolt and GameSpot, highlighting the lack of depth and engagement in the voice performances. This indicates that while the game may have potential, the voice acting does not significantly enhance the player's experience, leaving much to be desired in future iterations.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24's technical performance is a mixed bag, with some praising responsive gameplay on PS5 and Xbox Series X, but widespread criticism for slow menus, laggy loading times, and glitches across all platforms. While AI and online multiplayer saw improvements, persistent technical issues overshadow the game's strengths, suggesting major fixes are needed to enhance player enjoyment and immersion.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

47%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

50%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Madden NFL 24 has received a mixed reception across various platforms, with some positive aspects noted by critics. On the PS5, while many reviewers pointed out issues with the game's menus and loading times, some, like IGN Adria, remarked on the smooth and responsive gameplay experience, indicating that the on-field action remains enjoyable. Similarly, on the Xbox Series X, critics like CGMagazine acknowledged improvements in AI and gameplay smoothness, suggesting that the core gameplay experience is solid despite other shortcomings. The Xbox Series X also benefits from a generally robust online net code, as noted by Push Square, which enhances the multiplayer experience. However, the negatives are significant and prevalent across all platforms. On the PS5, critics consistently highlighted issues such as slow loading screens, laggy menus, and broken interfaces, particularly in Ultimate Team, with Game Informer and GamesRadar+ emphasizing the aggravating load times and sluggish navigation. The Xbox Series X reviews echoed these sentiments, with multiple critics, including TheSixthAxis and TheXboxHub, pointing out similar problems with slow menus, input lag, and various bugs that detracted from the overall experience. On the Xbox One and PC, critics like COGconnected and GamingTrend reported technical performance issues, including laggy menus and numerous glitches, indicating that these problems are not confined to a single platform. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Madden NFL 24 suffers from substantial technical performance issues across all platforms, overshadowing its gameplay strengths. The repetitive complaints about slow menus, loading times, and various glitches suggest that the game's technical foundation is not up to par, affecting players' enjoyment and immersion. Despite some positive remarks regarding gameplay smoothness and online performance, the overwhelming feedback indicates that significant improvements are needed to enhance the user experience, as highlighted by critics from multiple outlets. The game appears to be plagued by issues that could hinder its reception among fans, particularly those who value a seamless and polished gaming experience.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 shows promise with improved Franchise and Superstar modes and engaging mini-games, potentially boosting replay value. However, major drawbacks like shallow off-field features, a repetitive Ultimate Team mode criticized as a "microtransaction farm," and a lack of meaningful innovations leave critics disappointed. While hardcore fans might find some enjoyment, many casual players may see it as a cash grab with little incentive to return.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

85%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of Madden NFL 24 reveals a mix of positives that highlight the game's potential for engagement. Critics like Hardcore Gamer and PlayStation LifeStyle commend the improvements made to Franchise and Superstar modes, noting that these enhancements add long-term staying power to the game. The inclusion of various modes, such as mini-games and the ability to create teams, is seen as a positive aspect that could encourage players to return. Additionally, Push Square mentions the promise of daily live service content, which could keep the experience feeling fresh for players seeking longevity in their gameplay. However, the negatives surrounding the game's replay value are significant and cannot be overlooked. Many critics, including IGN and GameSpot, express concerns about the lack of depth and engaging features in off-field modes, which ultimately detracts from the overall replayability. The Ultimate Team mode, often highlighted as a key feature, is criticized for its repetitive nature and reliance on microtransactions, with critics like Shacknews and Gamereactor UK describing it as a "microtransaction farm." Furthermore, several reviewers, such as Twinfinite and Gaming Age, point out that the game feels like a rehash of previous iterations, lacking meaningful innovations that would entice players to invest time in it. The overall consensus among critics suggests that while Madden NFL 24 offers some enjoyable experiences, particularly in Franchise and Superstar modes, the game is hampered by repetitive gameplay and a lack of significant improvements. Many reviewers, including CGMagazine and MeuPlayStation, note that the absence of impactful changes may limit the game's replay value, making it feel like a cash grab rather than a fresh installment in the franchise. Consequently, while there are elements that could engage hardcore fans, the general sentiment leans towards disappointment, indicating that casual players may find little incentive to return after their initial experience.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

17%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

73%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding Madden NFL 24 is mixed, with several critics acknowledging some positive aspects of the game. Many reviewers, such as God is a Geek and Hardcore Gamer, praised the gameplay and graphics, noting improvements in on-field action and realism. Critics like Gamers' Temple highlighted that the fundamental gameplay has seen enhancements, making it more enjoyable for players. Additionally, some reviews, such as those from PlayStation LifeStyle and New York Daily News, noted that the game is a solid effort and a turnaround from the previous year, suggesting that it provides a dependable football experience that may appeal to dedicated fans. However, the critiques of Madden NFL 24 are substantial and consistent across multiple reviews. Critics like GamesRadar+ and Impulsegamer expressed disappointment in the lack of innovation, with many describing the game as a rehash of previous iterations. The user interface and menu systems received significant criticism, with Game Informer and Push Square pointing out that slow menus and tedious minigames detract from the overall experience. Furthermore, reviewers like Twinfinite and XboxEra noted persistent technical issues, bugs, and a sense of familiarity that hinder the game's potential, suggesting that the franchise may be in need of a major overhaul. In summary, while Madden NFL 24 has made strides in gameplay and graphics, the consensus among critics is that it falls short of delivering a truly innovative experience. Many reviewers, including those from IGN and Shacknews, believe that the game feels like a mediocre entry in the franchise, with significant room for improvement in various areas. The overall sentiment suggests that while the game may satisfy longtime fans, it lacks the freshness and depth that new players might seek, leading to calls for a potential hiatus in annual releases to allow for a more substantial evolution of the series.

TL;DR

TL;DR: Madden NFL 24 has improved gameplay and graphics but is criticized for lacking innovation and facing technical issues. While some fans may enjoy the solid yet familiar experience, many reviewers see it as a mediocre entry that demands a major overhaul. Calls for a hiatus in annual releases are growing, as the game fails to offer the freshness new players desire.

MONSTER

Reviews

61 reviews found

GameCritics

Xbox Series X

Nov 16, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite criticisms, Madden NFL 24 is a significant improvement in gameplay authenticity, earning a solid rating.

Read full review

PlayStation LifeStyle

PlayStation 5

Aug 22, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 is a solid football game with compelling new modes and improvements, making it more than just a roster update.

Hardcore Gamer

PlayStation 5

Aug 22, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game lacks consistency and needs more polish, but it is getting closer to properly replicating an NFL broadcast. The gameplay has noticeable changes and improvements, but also introduces new issues. The visuals are highly detailed and realistic, but there are optimization issues. The audio captures the NFL atmosphere. The game offers a variety of modes and customization options. The overall experience is enjoyable, but there are bugs that may be addressed with patches.

Read full review

VideoGamer

PlayStation 5

Aug 17, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review states that Madden 24 is dependable and satisfying, comparing it to Kirk Cousins.

Read full review

Xbox Tavern

Xbox Series X

Aug 23, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 is a solid game that delivers a realistic and immersive football experience.

Read full review

LevelUp

Xbox Series X

Sep 1, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 shows improvements in gameplay and AI but remains far from its best version, providing a decent experience for fans.

Read full review

Gamers' Temple

PlayStation 5

Sep 11, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review gives the game a final rating of 76% and suggests that while the on-field gameplay is better than ever, everything surrounding it is in need of an overhaul.

God is a Geek

PlayStation 5

Aug 28, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review overall praises the gameplay and graphics of Madden NFL 24, but criticizes the lack of improvement in some modes and the slow menus. It suggests that the game is becoming untouchable gameplay-wise.

Read full review

The Games Machine

PlayStation 5

Aug 27, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review states that Madden NFL 24 has some interesting aspects, particularly in terms of graphics and physics, but it falls short in terms of AI and menu management. The review does not provide a specific overall score.

Read full review

IGN Adria

PlayStation 5

Sep 18, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 is seen as an evolution of the franchise, offering a polished experience but lacking significant innovations compared to its predecessor. It's recommended for newcomers to the series.