Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

MONSTER

Madden NFL 24

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Madden NFL 24
Item: Madden NFL 24
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2023

GenresAction, Simulation, Sports, Strategy, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableAug 15, 2023

PlatformXbox Series X, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, PC, PlayStation 5

DeveloperEA Tiburon

Overview

Experience the newest iteration of FieldSENSE in Madden NFL 24. More realistic character movement and smarter AI gives you control to play out your gameplay strategy with the confidence to dominate any opponent.

Elsewhere

4.4

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics are largely disappointed with Madden NFL 24's narrative depth in the Superstar mode, calling it uninspired and simplified compared to previous titles like Longshot. While some minor dialogue choices and live-action video podcasts offer slight engagement, the overall storytelling falls flat, leaving players craving the richer narratives of earlier games.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

40%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

60%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

In reviewing the opinions of various critics regarding the story elements of Madden NFL 24, it is important to highlight a few positive aspects that some reviewers have noted. Digital Chumps pointed out that the game features minor narrative shifts with dialogue choices that enhance the career mode experience, suggesting that there are some elements that can engage players, albeit in a limited fashion. This indicates that while the narrative may not be robust, there are attempts to provide players with choices that could enhance their immersion in the game. Additionally, the presence of live-action video podcasts, as mentioned by GameSpot, could be seen as a unique approach to storytelling within the confines of the game, even if the overall execution fell short. However, the overwhelming sentiment from critics is one of disappointment regarding the narrative depth in Madden NFL 24's Superstar mode. ComicBook and IGN both described the narrative elements as limited and uninspired, with IGN specifically noting the lack of depth compared to previous iterations like Longshot or Face of the Franchise. Critics such as CGMagazine and GameCritics echoed this sentiment, highlighting the removal of more engaging story modes and the resulting simplification of the narrative. Many reviewers, including LevelUp and MondoXbox, criticized the mode for lacking a compelling storyline, with LevelUp stating that it focuses more on player creation than on an engaging narrative experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Madden NFL 24's story elements are underwhelming, failing to meet the expectations set by previous titles in the franchise. The critiques from multiple sources, including IGN and GameSpot, emphasize a shared belief that the Superstar mode lacks the depth and engagement necessary to captivate players. The general sentiment is that while there are some minor narrative features present, they do not contribute significantly to an engaging gaming experience, leaving many players longing for the more robust storytelling options that were available in earlier iterations of the series.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 boasts notable gameplay improvements, such as enhanced player physics and FieldSENSE tech, winning praise for its realism, AI behavior, and strategic features like Skill-Based Passing 2.0. However, critics point out significant flaws, including AI issues, glitches, and a lack of innovation compared to Madden NFL 23. While the game shows promise, persistent technical problems hinder the overall experience, leaving fans split on its execution.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

57%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

38%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Madden NFL 24 has garnered a mix of praise and criticism from various reviewers, highlighting several notable improvements. Critics like God is a Geek and IGN Adria commend the game for its refinements, particularly in player physics and the new FieldSENSE technology, which enhances realism and engagement on the field. Many reviewers, including Gamers' Temple and GameSpot, note improvements in animations, player interactions, and AI behavior, contributing to a more lifelike experience. The introduction of features such as Skill-Based Passing 2.0 and the Tactical Blocking System has also been recognized as a significant step forward, making gameplay feel more strategic and rewarding. Additionally, the franchise mode has been highlighted for its balance and enjoyment, as noted by Digital Chumps and CGMagazine. However, the gameplay is not without its flaws, as numerous critics have pointed out various inconsistencies and issues that detract from the overall experience. Reviewers like ComicBook and Hardcore Gamer express concerns about AI decision-making and gameplay clunkiness, indicating that these elements can disrupt the flow of the game. Other critiques include glitches, warping players, and dropped catches, as mentioned by GamesRadar+ and Impulsegamer, which undermine the realism that the game aims to achieve. Additionally, some critics, such as Gaming Age, argue that the gameplay feels too similar to its predecessor, Madden NFL 23, and lacks significant innovations, which could disappoint long-time fans. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while Madden NFL 24 has made strides in improving its gameplay, it still grapples with various technical issues and inconsistencies. Many reviewers appreciate the enhancements in player animations and AI, but they also highlight the need for further polish and refinement. Critics like New York Daily News and Windows Central acknowledge the solid core gameplay but emphasize that the experience is marred by bugs and performance issues that need to be addressed. As a result, Madden NFL 24 presents a mixed bag of exciting improvements alongside persistent challenges, leaving the community divided on its overall execution.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 impresses with significant visual upgrades, praised for realistic player models and stunning graphics that enhance immersion. Critics laud its visuals as the best in the series, but some point out outdated career mode graphics and recurring glitches. While it sets a high standard, inconsistencies and lack of major evolution leave some players wanting more.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

51%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

46%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The overall sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of Madden NFL 24 is predominantly positive, with many critics praising the significant improvements made in this iteration. Reviewers from Game Informer and God is a Geek highlighted the revamped player models that now better replicate the shapes and sizes of real players, contributing to a more immersive experience. Critics like IGN and Impulsegamer emphasized that Madden NFL 24 is the best-looking entry in the series, with impressive graphics and animations that enhance realism, making it feel akin to watching a real NFL game. Additionally, Hardcore Gamer noted the superb realism in player and coach faces, improved lighting, and detailed environments, while GGRecon and GamesRadar+ echoed sentiments about enhanced lighting and textures, further underscoring the advancements in visual fidelity. However, not all feedback is entirely positive, as some critics pointed out notable shortcomings. Digital Chumps criticized the career mode visuals for feeling outdated and reminiscent of early PlayStation 4 graphics, suggesting a disparity between on-field and off-field graphics. MeuPlayStation and COGconnected expressed concerns about the lack of significant evolution from previous years, implying that while the graphics are visually appealing, they do not represent a substantial leap forward. Additionally, some reviews, such as those from Shacknews and GamingTrend, mentioned persistent glitches and a lack of attention to detail, which detracts from the overall visual experience. The overall consensus among critics indicates that while Madden NFL 24 showcases impressive advancements in graphics and visual design, particularly in player models and animations, there are still areas that require improvement. Many reviewers, including TheXboxHub and Windows Central, acknowledged the introduction of SAPIEN Technology and FieldSENSE, which enhance realism and visual quality. However, the mixed feedback regarding the career mode and some recurring issues suggests that while the game is visually striking, it may not fully meet the expectations of all players. Ultimately, Madden NFL 24 appears to be a visually appealing title that sets a high standard for the franchise, yet it still grapples with some inconsistencies and areas needing refinement.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24's sound design is a mixed bag: praised for its immersive NFL atmosphere and dynamic commentary, but criticized for a lack of musical variety and repetitive commentary. While some appreciate the hip-hop soundtrack featuring popular artists, others find it too limited and not appealing to all players. Overall, the game has strengths but requires significant audio improvements to fully satisfy its audience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

21%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

29%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Madden NFL 24 have garnered a mixed response from critics, with some positive aspects highlighted across various reviews. Hardcore Gamer commended the audio for effectively capturing the NFL atmosphere, noting that sound varies by location, which enhances immersion. The inclusion of dynamic commentary was also praised, alongside the modern hip-hop soundtrack featuring artists like Wiz Khalifa and Jack Harlow, as mentioned by GGRecon. Furthermore, some reviewers, such as LevelUp, pointed out improvements in crowd reactions, suggesting that the audio design has received thoughtful attention, contributing positively to the overall gaming experience. However, the critiques regarding the sound design and music are equally significant. Several reviewers expressed dissatisfaction with the soundtrack's lack of variety, with Gamers' Temple and The Loadout both calling for a broader range of music genres and criticizing the commercial-grade score. Impulsegamer noted the soundtrack's "arguable vulgarity," suggesting that the heavy focus on hardcore hip-hop may not appeal to all players. Additionally, multiple critics, including GameCritics and GameSpot, highlighted issues with repetitive and stale commentary, which detracts from the immersive experience expected in a sports game. The absence of pre-snap calls and crowd chants, as pointed out by Worth Playing, further emphasizes the shortcomings in the audio experience. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates a divide between appreciation for the game's atmospheric sound design and disappointment in the soundtrack's limited variety and repetitive commentary. While some reviewers like Hardcore Gamer and GGRecon recognize the strengths in capturing the NFL vibe and featuring popular artists, others, such as COGconnected and ZTGD, lament the lack of diversity and quality in both the music and commentary. This mixed feedback suggests that while Madden NFL 24 has made strides in certain areas of sound design, significant improvements are needed to elevate the overall audio experience and meet the expectations of its player base.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24's voice acting features real-life star quarterbacks, adding some authenticity and immersion for fans. However, critics slam the overall execution, citing uninspired performances and stale commentary that detracts from the game's narrative experience. The positive aspects are overshadowed by a lack of depth and engagement, making the voice work a missed opportunity for enhancing gameplay and storytelling.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

71%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

29%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in Madden NFL 24 has received some positive remarks, particularly regarding the inclusion of real-life star quarterbacks' voices, as noted by Worth Playing. This aspect adds a layer of authenticity to the game, potentially enhancing the overall immersion for players who appreciate the connection to actual sports figures. Additionally, LevelUp highlights that these interactions with real athletes contribute to a sense of realism, which is an important factor in a sports simulation game. Such elements can resonate well with fans, providing a familiar touch that may enhance their gaming experience. However, the criticisms surrounding the voice acting are significant and widespread among reviewers. GamingBolt points out that the narrative-focused mode suffers from a lack of engaging voice work and drama, which detracts from the storytelling experience. Twinfinite echoes this sentiment, describing the dialogue in Superstar Mode as "half-baked" and suggesting that the performances feel uninspired, as if the actors were "phoning it in." GameCritics and GameSpot further emphasize that while voice acting is present, it fails to stand out, resulting in a somewhat repetitive experience. GameSpot’s criticism of the commentary being stale and often incorrect indicates a failure to enhance the game's atmosphere, which is crucial for a sports title. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that while there are some positive elements in the voice acting of Madden NFL 24, particularly with the inclusion of real sports figures, the overall execution leaves much to be desired. Many reviewers, including GamingBolt and GameSpot, highlight a lack of depth and engagement in the performances, leading to a disappointing narrative experience. The voice acting appears to be a missed opportunity for the game, as it does not significantly elevate the gameplay or storytelling, which is essential in a title that aims to immerse players in the world of professional football.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 showcases smooth gameplay on PS5 and Xbox Series X, but major technical flaws, including long loading times, glitchy menus, and input lag, plague all platforms. Critics express disappointment over persistent bugs and stability issues, overshadowing the potential for a great gaming experience. Overall, the game struggles to improve upon its predecessors, leaving players frustrated.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

47%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

50%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In analyzing the technical performance of Madden NFL 24 across various platforms, there are a few positives worth noting. On the PS5, some critics, such as IGN Adria, highlighted that the gameplay itself is smooth and responsive, which indicates that the core mechanics of the game are functioning well despite other issues. Similarly, on the Xbox Series X, GameCritics noted that on-field performance is generally seamless, suggesting that once players are in the game, the experience is enjoyable. For PC, while the reviews from GamingTrend pointed out glitches, the overall gameplay experience was not as heavily criticized as the technical aspects, which implies some level of satisfaction with the core gameplay. However, the negatives for each platform are quite pronounced and consistent across the board. For PS5, critics like ComicBook and Game Informer pointed out significant issues with loading screens, broken menus, and slow navigation, particularly in the Ultimate Team mode, which severely impacts the user experience. On the Xbox Series X, critics such as TheSixthAxis and TheXboxHub echoed similar sentiments, mentioning sluggish menus, slow loading times, and input lag, which detract from the overall enjoyment of the game. The Xbox One and PC versions also face technical challenges, with COGconnected noting laggy menus in MUT and GamingTrend highlighting numerous glitches and stability issues, including bizarre visual problems. Overall, the consensus among critics across all platforms is one of disappointment regarding the technical performance of Madden NFL 24. While there are moments of enjoyment, especially during gameplay, the persistent issues with menus, loading times, and glitches overshadow the positive aspects. Critics like Shacknews and The Loadout have indicated that the game suffers from bugs and visual glitches reminiscent of previous iterations, suggesting a lack of significant improvement in technical stability. This has led to a general sentiment that, despite the potential for a solid football experience, the technical shortcomings prevent Madden NFL 24 from reaching its full potential across all platforms.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 faces mixed reviews regarding replay value. Critics praise improved Franchise Mode and fresh content, but many slam the lack of depth in Ultimate Team and repetitive mini-games. Described by some as a "lazy cash grab," the game struggles to offer substantial innovations, leaving players questioning its long-term appeal. Enjoyable on-field action contrasts with underwhelming off-field modes, leading to a cautious outlook overall.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

85%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of critics regarding the replay value of Madden NFL 24 reveal a mixed sentiment, with some positive aspects highlighted. Many reviewers, such as PlayStation LifeStyle and Hardcore Gamer, commend the improvements made to Franchise Mode and the return of fan-favorite modes like Superstar. Critics like Push Square note that the game offers a variety of single-player options and promises daily live service content, which could keep the experience feeling fresh. Additionally, the inclusion of mini-games and the ability to create teams are seen as features that enhance replayability, as noted by IGN Adria and Gfinity. However, the negatives surrounding the replay value of Madden NFL 24 are significant and frequently mentioned. Several critics, including ComicBook and IGN, express concerns about the lack of depth and engaging features in off-field modes, particularly Ultimate Team and Superstar Mode. The repetitive nature of mini-games, as pointed out by GameSpot and TheXboxHub, is another common complaint, suggesting that they may quickly lose their appeal. Critics like Gaming Age go so far as to describe the game as a "lazy cash grab," indicating that the absence of significant changes may deter players from returning for extended play. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while there are some improvements and enjoyable modes in Madden NFL 24, the game suffers from a lack of substantial innovations and engaging content that would encourage long-term replayability. The Ultimate Team mode, often criticized for its reliance on microtransactions and a repetitive experience, appears to be a major point of contention. Critics like Digital Chumps and Gamers' Temple highlight the dichotomy between the fun on-field gameplay and the underwhelming off-field modes, leading to a cautious outlook on the game's replay value. Thus, while some players may find enjoyment in the various modes, many reviewers suggest that the overall experience may not be compelling enough to warrant repeated play.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

17%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

73%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

10%

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding Madden NFL 24 reflects a mix of appreciation for its gameplay improvements and disappointment in its lack of innovation. Many critics, including IGN and Hardcore Gamer, praised the gameplay and graphics, noting that the on-field action has seen significant enhancements. For instance, IGN described the game as showing promise with its gameplay, while Hardcore Gamer highlighted the noticeable changes and improvements in gameplay authenticity. Several reviews also acknowledged the return of popular modes like Superstar mode, which adds some appeal for dedicated fans. Critics such as Gamers' Temple and PlayStation LifeStyle noted that the game offers a solid football experience, with compelling new modes and improvements that elevate it beyond a mere roster update. Conversely, the negatives surrounding Madden NFL 24 are pronounced and consistent across numerous reviews. Many critics, including Game Informer and GamesRadar+, pointed out significant shortcomings in user interface design, slow menus, and a sense of repetitiveness that detracts from the overall experience. Critics like Gaming Age and Impulsegamer went so far as to label the game a "lazy borderline rerelease," emphasizing the need for more substantial innovations. Additionally, technical issues, bugs, and performance problems were frequently mentioned, with critics like SomosXbox and The XboxHub expressing frustration over the game's lack of polish and the persistence of old issues. This sentiment was echoed by multiple reviewers who suggested that the game feels outdated compared to other sports titles on the market. The overall consensus among critics indicates that while Madden NFL 24 has made strides in gameplay, it ultimately falls short of delivering a fresh and engaging experience. Many reviewers, including ComicBook and Digital Chumps, described the game as "serviceable" but criticized it for failing to meet the expectations of fans seeking a deep football simulation. The sentiment that the series is in need of a significant refresh was echoed by IGN, who noted that many off-field elements lack excitement. Critics like Twinfinite and Worth Playing suggested that taking a break from annual releases might benefit the franchise, as Madden NFL 24 is seen as adequate but plagued by a lack of innovation and persistent issues. Overall, while there are commendable aspects, the prevailing sentiment is that Madden NFL 24 does not quite live up to the potential of its franchise.

TL;DR

Madden NFL 24 impresses with gameplay and graphics improvements, earning praise for its authenticity and returning modes. However, critics widely slam its outdated user interface, performance issues, and lack of true innovation, labeling it a "lazy" update. The consensus is that while the game is serviceable, it fails to meet fan expectations and needs a significant refresh to stay competitive.

MONSTER

Reviews

61 reviews found

GameCritics

Xbox Series X

Nov 16, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Despite criticisms, Madden NFL 24 is a significant improvement in gameplay authenticity, earning a solid rating.

Read full review

PlayStation LifeStyle

PlayStation 5

Aug 22, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 is a solid football game with compelling new modes and improvements, making it more than just a roster update.

Hardcore Gamer

PlayStation 5

Aug 22, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The game lacks consistency and needs more polish, but it is getting closer to properly replicating an NFL broadcast. The gameplay has noticeable changes and improvements, but also introduces new issues. The visuals are highly detailed and realistic, but there are optimization issues. The audio captures the NFL atmosphere. The game offers a variety of modes and customization options. The overall experience is enjoyable, but there are bugs that may be addressed with patches.

Read full review

VideoGamer

PlayStation 5

Aug 17, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review states that Madden 24 is dependable and satisfying, comparing it to Kirk Cousins.

Read full review

Xbox Tavern

Xbox Series X

Aug 23, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 is a solid game that delivers a realistic and immersive football experience.

Read full review

LevelUp

Xbox Series X

Sep 1, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 shows improvements in gameplay and AI but remains far from its best version, providing a decent experience for fans.

Read full review

Gamers' Temple

PlayStation 5

Sep 11, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review gives the game a final rating of 76% and suggests that while the on-field gameplay is better than ever, everything surrounding it is in need of an overhaul.

God is a Geek

PlayStation 5

Aug 28, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review overall praises the gameplay and graphics of Madden NFL 24, but criticizes the lack of improvement in some modes and the slow menus. It suggests that the game is becoming untouchable gameplay-wise.

Read full review

The Games Machine

PlayStation 5

Aug 27, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

The review states that Madden NFL 24 has some interesting aspects, particularly in terms of graphics and physics, but it falls short in terms of AI and menu management. The review does not provide a specific overall score.

Read full review

IGN Adria

PlayStation 5

Sep 18, 2023

AI-generated summary • May contain inaccuracies • See full review for precise details

Madden NFL 24 is seen as an evolution of the franchise, offering a polished experience but lacking significant innovations compared to its predecessor. It's recommended for newcomers to the series.