Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Amazon

Steam

Twitch

MONSTER

GreedFall

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of GreedFall
Item: GreedFall
Author: Critik Editorial Team

2019

GenresFantasy, Adventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, RPG, Strategy, Single Player

AvailableSep 9, 2019

PlatformXbox One, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4, Xbox Series X, PC

DeveloperSpiders

Overview

Explore a fresh new world as you set foot - alongside many other settlers, mercenaries and treasure hunters - on a remote island seeping with magic, rumored to be filled with riches and lost secrets. GreedFall aims for a very unique visual identity, inspired by Baroque art from 17th Century Europe, depicting grandiose sceneries in muted warm colors and dark undertones. A grand journey filled with mystery follows, as you find yourself in the middle of ever-increasing tensions between the invading settlers and the locals, protected by supernatural beings, manifestation of the island's earthly magic. With a strong focus on its core RPG identity, GreedFall follows Spiders’ experience in building intricate worlds filled with mysteries to discover, weaving deep character interactions, and offering players great freedom to achieve quests and objectives in a multitude of different ways – through combat of course, but also through diplomacy, deception or stealth.

Elsewhere

6.9

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics have mixed opinions on the Story of GreedFall: Gold Edition. Some praise its immersive world-building and engaging narrative exploring themes like colonialism and politics. However, others criticize its rushed plot, lack of depth, and pacing issues. While some appreciate its political intrigue and character development, others find it lacking in originality and depth. Overall, GreedFall: Gold Edition offers a captivating setting and narrative but falls short in some aspects, leaving critics divided.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive (80-100)

70%

Mixed (50-79)

30%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Story of GreedFall: Gold Edition are mixed. Some critics praise the story for its intriguing premise and immersive world-building. They appreciate the exploration of themes such as colonialism, politics, and conflicts, as well as the character-driven narrative and good voice acting. Critics like RPGamer and GameStar highlight the detective-like narrative and the complex faction relationships, which add depth to the story. The Digital Fix and GameCritics also commend the weighty and branching narrative, with choices that have dynamic consequences. The narrative is described as engaging, captivating, and politically intriguing by critics such as PlayStation Universe, DualShockers, and Screen Rant. The story's ability to tackle heavy topics and its morally complex nature are also appreciated by IGN and GameCritics. However, there are also critics who express disappointment with the story of GreedFall: Gold Edition. Multiplayer.it and Critical Hit criticize the DLC for its rushed and anticlimactic story, lacking depth and pacing issues. Cubed3 and New Game Network mention the story's mediocrity and lack of originality, with the latter stating that the themes of discrimination and politics don't go much deeper below the surface. BaziCenter and Gaming Age point out the failure to establish the protagonist's role and motivation clearly. Jeuxvideo.com and Everyeye.it note that while the story initially engages the player with intelligent writing and well-developed characters, it loses momentum in the later stages of the game. Destructoid mentions that while the main story is nothing special, the interesting sidequests and settings carry the game. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that the story of GreedFall: Gold Edition has its strengths and weaknesses. The immersive world-building, exploration of themes, and character-driven narrative receive praise. However, the story is criticized for its rushed and anticlimactic nature, lack of depth, pacing issues, and lack of originality. While some critics appreciate the political intrigue, complex choices, and moral dilemmas, others feel that the story fails to fully delve into its themes. Despite these mixed opinions, it is evident that the story of GreedFall: Gold Edition has managed to engage players with its captivating setting and narrative elements, even if it falls short in certain areas.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Mixed opinions from critics on GreedFall's gameplay: praised for well-designed quest system and character customization, but criticized for clunky and repetitive combat lacking depth and variety. RPG mechanics are solid with meaningful character progression options, but some feel certain systems like stealth are lacking. Overall, while flawed, GreedFall offers an enjoyable experience for RPG fans appreciating quest design and character customization.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive (80-100)

30%

Mixed (50-79)

67%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The opinions of the critics regarding the gameplay of GreedFall are mixed, with both positive and negative aspects highlighted. Several critics praise the game for its well-designed quest system that allows for different approaches and the ability to specialize in character skills and abilities (Jeuxvideo.com). The gameplay also offers a mix of real-time combat, strategy, and decision-making, with satisfying combat systems and a deep skill system for customization (Hardcore Gamer, GameSpew). The RPG mechanics are generally regarded as solid and enjoyable, with talent rolls, character progression, and a variety of combat approaches (We Got This Covered, GameSpot). The gameplay also incorporates elements of diplomacy, stealth, and exploration, providing players with multiple options for character progression and quest-solving (Everyeye.it, PlayStation Universe). However, there are several criticisms regarding the gameplay of GreedFall. The combat is a common point of contention among critics, with many describing it as clunky, repetitive, and lacking variety (Twinfinite, GamingTrend, Meristation). Some critics find the combat to be overly simple and lacking depth, with limited skill options and a scarcity of enemy types (Destructoid, DualShockers). The combat system is also criticized for being unpolished, with issues such as sluggishness, unbalanced character development, and repetitive encounters (Cultured Vultures, Riot Pixels). Additionally, some critics mention that the RPG mechanics could have been deeper, and certain systems, such as stealth, feel lacking (Press Start Australia, PC Gamer). Overall, the consensus among the critics is that while GreedFall offers some enjoyable aspects in its gameplay, such as the well-designed quest system and character customization options, it falls short in terms of combat mechanics and variety. The combat is often described as clunky, repetitive, and lacking depth, with limited skill options and a scarcity of enemy types. However, the RPG mechanics are generally regarded as solid, providing players with meaningful character progression and a variety of combat approaches. The gameplay also incorporates elements of diplomacy, stealth, and exploration, offering players multiple options for character progression and quest-solving. Despite its flaws, GreedFall manages to provide a satisfying gameplay experience for those who appreciate its RPG elements and quest design.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Reviewers have mixed opinions on GreedFall's graphics and visual design. While praised for stunning environments and artistic detail, criticisms point to technical issues, recycled assets, and rough animations. Overall, the game's visuals impress despite flaws, offering a visually appealing 17th-century world but falling short in execution.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive (80-100)

32%

Mixed (50-79)

64%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple reviewers regarding the graphics and visual design of GreedFall, it is evident that there is a mixed reception. Several critics praised the game's visual aspects, highlighting the stunning environments, beautiful landscapes, and distinct architectural styles of the cities. Critics such as Generación Xbox and GameSpew specifically commended the game's artistic design and well-crafted enemies. The attention to historical detail and the rich autumnal aesthetic were also appreciated by critics like RPG Fan and Cubed3. Additionally, the lush greenery and captivating European-inspired fantasy setting were mentioned positively by Daily Star and Riot Pixels. However, there were also several criticisms regarding the graphics and visual design of GreedFall. Many critics pointed out technical shortcomings, including uneven frame rates, poor collision detection, disappearing textures, and reused assets. Metro GameCentral and Games.cz specifically highlighted these technical problems, which affected the overall experience. Critics such as DualShockers and GamingTrend mentioned rough animations and frustrating invisible walls, while Softpedia and Everyeye.it criticized the recycled environments and repetitive character models. The lack of graphical variation and odd facial animations were also brought up by RPG Fan and Gameblog.fr. Overall, the consensus among critics is that GreedFall's graphics and visual design have both positive and negative aspects. While the game showcases stunning environments, beautiful landscapes, and distinct architectural styles, it also suffers from technical issues, recycled assets, and rough animations. The game's artistic design and attention to detail are often praised, but the execution falls short in certain areas. The visuals are generally considered impressive given the smaller budget of the studio, but there are noticeable flaws that prevent it from reaching its full potential. Despite the mixed opinions, it is evident that GreedFall's visual design manages to create a visually appealing world that captures the essence of the 17th century and offers a captivating experience for players.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics mostly praised GreedFall's sound design and music, highlighting the well-executed orchestral music that elevated the game's atmosphere and appeal. The soundtrack was commended for its variety and quality, enhancing key moments and combat. Voice acting received mixed reviews, with some lauding its quality and immersion, while others criticized accents and lip movements. Despite some flaws like lack of lip movement and unconvincing accents, the majority of critics found the sound design and music to be immersive and enhancing the overall experience in GreedFall.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive (80-100)

44%

Mixed (50-79)

56%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The opinions of the critics regarding the Sound Design and Music of GreedFall are generally positive. Many critics praised the game's music, describing it as well-executed, atmospheric, and enhancing the overall experience. The orchestral music was particularly highlighted for its ability to elevate the adventure and add to the game's appeal. Critics such as Gameblog.fr and RPGamer commended the soundtrack for its variety and quality, with Gameblog.fr specifically mentioning the tribal sound in the open lands and the industrial instrumentation in the towns. The music was also noted for effectively enhancing key moments and combat, as mentioned by Multiplayer.it and LaPS4. The voice acting in the game received mixed opinions, with some critics praising it as high quality and immersive, while others found it to be average or inconsistent. Eurogamer Italy and JeuxActu mentioned the high quality of the English voice acting, while Metro GameCentral and RPG Fan pointed out issues with lip movements and accents. However, overall, the voice acting was generally considered to be solid, with some standout performances and interesting characters, as noted by PlayStation Country and Meristation. On the negative side, some critics expressed disappointment with certain aspects of the sound design and music in GreedFall. Vgames and Xbox Tavern criticized the lack of lip movement in characters during dialogue, which affected the immersion. IGN and GameSpew mentioned issues with the fictional accents used for the native characters, finding them artificial or off-putting. Additionally, IGN Spain and RPG Fan noted that the accents of the native characters were not convincing. Xbox Tavern and GameWatcher mentioned poor voice acting in the supporting cast of NPCs, detracting from the overall experience. While these criticisms highlight some flaws in the sound design and voice acting, they were not widespread and did not significantly impact the overall consensus of the critics. Overall, the majority of critics had positive opinions about the Sound Design and Music of GreedFall. The well-executed music, atmospheric soundtrack, and immersive sound design were widely praised. The orchestral music, tribal sound, and industrial instrumentation were specifically mentioned as enhancing the game's appeal and adding to the overall experience. The voice acting, although receiving mixed opinions, was generally considered to be of solid quality, with some standout performances and interesting characters. While there were some criticisms regarding lip movements, accents, and supporting cast voice acting, these issues did not overshadow the overall positive reception of the sound design and music in GreedFall.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics have mixed opinions on the voice acting in GreedFall. Some praised its believability and emotional depth, while others criticized odd word choices and forced accents. Overall, the majority of reviewers found the voice acting to be strong, enhancing the immersive world and storytelling despite some flaws.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive (80-100)

43%

Mixed (50-79)

57%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in GreedFall has received a mix of positive and negative reviews from critics. Several reviewers, such as PlayStation Universe and RPGamer, praised the voice acting for its ability to bring believability and emotion to the characters. They commended the performances for adding depth to the immersive world building and bringing the story to life. Additionally, RPG Fan and TheSixthAxis noted that the voice acting helped sell the fantasy tropes and effectively conveyed the motivations of the characters. These positive reviews highlight the strong performances and the impact they had on the overall experience of the game. However, there were also some negative opinions regarding the voice acting in GreedFall. Gameplanet and Vgames criticized the odd word choices and lack of movement in the characters' lips, respectively. Push Square mentioned a lack of humor and distinct flavor in the dialogue, while PC Gamer and IGN pointed out that the forced and unnatural accents of the native characters were a drawback. These criticisms suggest that there were elements of the voice acting that did not meet the expectations of some reviewers, whether it be in terms of delivery, dialogue, or accents. Overall, the consensus among the critics leans towards the positive side. The majority of reviewers praised the voice acting in GreedFall for its strong performances, believability, and contribution to the immersive world and storytelling. While there were some negative aspects mentioned, such as odd word choices and forced accents, these criticisms were not prevalent enough to overshadow the overall positive reception of the voice acting. The positive reviews from critics like RPGamer, TheSixthAxis, and RPG Site further support the overall consensus that the voice acting in GreedFall was well done and enhanced the gaming experience.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

GreedFall's technical performance divides critics. While some praise smooth gameplay on PS4 and PC, others criticize issues like blurry textures, glitches, and rough animations. PS5 and some PC users had a better experience. Overall, opinions vary on technical issues like bugs, controls, and graphics, with room for improvement noted by many critics.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive (80-100)

18%

Mixed (50-79)

71%

Negative (0-49)

11%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

In terms of the technical performance of GreedFall, the opinions of the critics vary depending on the gaming platform. On the positive side, some critics found the game to run smoothly without any major faults. PlayStation Country and GamingTrend both played the game on PS4 and mentioned that it ran very well without any significant performance issues. GameCrate, who played on PC, also praised the smooth gameplay experience with no bugs or technical issues. The Games Machine highlighted that the Gold Edition on PlayStation 5 had solid performance compared to the standard console version, with improved loading times and better fluidity. However, there were several negative aspects mentioned by the critics regarding the technical performance of GreedFall on different platforms. Many critics playing on PS4, such as BaziCenter, Gameplanet, Games.cz, PlaySense, and DualShockers, reported technical issues including blurry textures, non-existent lip-syncing, long loading times, character glitches, and rough animations. Jeuxvideo.com, who played on Xbox One, also mentioned technical shortcomings such as invisible walls, outdated facial animations, and rigid controls. On PC, GameSpot, Cultured Vultures, and JeuxActu criticized the game for suffering from bugs, primitive systems, spelling errors, rough patches in moment-to-moment gameplay, issues with controls and gamepad support, dialogue options not appearing, crashes, and interface errors. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that GreedFall has mixed technical performance across different gaming platforms. While some platforms, such as PS4 and PC, experienced significant technical issues like bugs, glitches, and performance limitations, other platforms, like PS5 and PC (according to GameSpace and GameWatcher), offered a relatively stable and smooth experience. The critics' opinions highlight the need for improvements in areas such as graphics, animations, controls, loading times, and overall technical polish. It is worth noting that some critics, like RPG Fan and GamePro Germany, found the technical issues to be relatively minor and not significantly impacting the overall gameplay experience.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Critics have mixed opinions on the replay value of GreedFall. Positives include multiple resolutions, diverse combat options, and companion quests enhancing replayability. Negatives include limited skill trees and repetitive quests. Overall, the game offers decent replay value with its rich storytelling, exploration, and variety of content, despite some drawbacks.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive (80-100)

33%

Mixed (50-79)

64%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions of the critics regarding the replay value of GreedFall are varied, with some positive and negative aspects highlighted. In terms of positives, several critics mention the game's multiple resolutions for missions and classless customization, which provide incentive for replaying the game (COGconnected). The reputation system and ability to shape the future of factions through choices also contribute to the replay value (IGN Italia, Vandal). The game's diverse combat options, player choices, and multiple endings are also praised for offering high replay value (GamePro Germany). Additionally, the companion quests and the ability to grow, expand, and destroy relationships with NPCs add further replay value to the game (We Got This Covered). On the negative side, some critics point out limitations that may impact the replay value of GreedFall. For instance, the skill trees are considered small, which may restrict the variety of playstyles available (SpazioGames). The repetitive quests and lack of depth in the role-playing element are also mentioned as potential drawbacks (Cubed3). The loot system is described as hit or miss by some critics (God is a Geek), and the need for frequent backtracking is seen as a drawback by others (JeuxActu). Overall, the consensus among the critics is that GreedFall offers a decent amount of replay value. The game's quest building and crafting system, along with the major main and side quests, are praised for their role in the story and intricate companion quests (RPGamer). The game's exploration, perk checks, and different companions with their own agendas are also highlighted as contributing factors to the replay value (GameGrin). The significant amount of content, including side quests and a meaty main storyline, is seen as reminiscent of fully featured RPGs (Worth Playing). While some critics mention certain limitations and drawbacks, the overall sentiment is that GreedFall provides enough depth, choices, and content to warrant multiple playthroughs (GameWatcher, Generación Xbox, TheXboxHub).

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive (80-100)

35%

Mixed (50-79)

65%

Negative (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

In analyzing the opinions of multiple videogame reviewers regarding the overall verdict of GreedFall, it is evident that the game has received a mixed reception. Several critics have praised GreedFall for its strengths, including its intriguing world-building, well-crafted visuals, engaging storytelling, and immersive experience. Critics such as Meristation, GameCrate, and Gamer.no have highlighted the game's intricate political and social narrative, captivating story, and complex quests, making it a standout RPG in Spiders' portfolio. Additionally, critics like TheXboxHub and GameSpew have commended the game for its fantastic world-building, brilliant writing, and impressive graphics. These positive aspects contribute to the overall appeal of GreedFall and showcase the ambition and potential of the game. However, there are also several criticisms and negative aspects that have been pointed out by reviewers. Some critics, such as Destructoid and GameSpot, have mentioned that GreedFall falls short in certain areas. They have highlighted issues with the gameplay becoming boring, lack of nuance or innovation, and limitations in combat and role-playing. Other critics, like Push Square and Press Start Australia, have mentioned technical performance issues, shallow combat, and lack of depth in certain aspects of RPG design. These criticisms indicate that GreedFall has some flaws and design issues that prevent it from reaching its full potential. Overall, the consensus among the critics is that GreedFall is a game with both strengths and weaknesses. While it has received praise for its world-building, storytelling, and immersive experience, it falls short in terms of combat, technical performance, and originality. Despite its flaws, critics such as RPGamer and Game Informer acknowledge that GreedFall is a step forward for Spiders and offers an enjoyable RPG experience with its richly presented world, morally complex narrative, and engaging character-driven stories. The game's potential for improvement and its appeal to RPG enthusiasts are also recognized by critics like Softpedia and IGN Spain. Ultimately, the overall sentiment towards GreedFall is that it is a competent game but not a must-play, with room for improvement in certain areas.

TL;DR

GreedFall has received mixed reviews from critics. It's praised for its world-building, storytelling, and visuals but criticized for boring gameplay, lack of innovation, and technical issues. While it shows promise, it falls short in some aspects, making it a decent RPG but not a standout must-play title.

MONSTER

Reviews

112 reviews found

100

Daily Star

Sep 15, 2019