Search for games

Type three or more characters to search...

Links

Amazon

Twitch

MONSTER

F1 24

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of F1 24
Item: F1 24
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2024

GenresSports, Single Player, Multiplayer, Racing

AvailableMay 31, 2024

PlatformPlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PC

DeveloperCodemasters

Overview

Get ready to ignite your passion for racing and get closer to the grid like never before with EA SPORTS™ F1® 24, the official videogame of the 2024 FIA Formula One World Championship™. Unleash Your Champion in pursuit of a legacy-defining F1® Career and feel at one with the car with the latest handling and physics, powered by EA SPORTS Dynamic Handling. ● Unleash Your Champion: Discover the all-new Driver Career mode with new gameplay rooted in the sport. ● EA SPORTS™ Dynamic Handling: Get to grips with more authentic handling. The latest physics gives you more control over how your personal driving style impacts your car’s performance and race strategy.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

F1 24 impresses with new career modes, offering deep customization and immersive gameplay, but critics slam the absence of a traditional story mode like Braking Point. While features like joint careers add excitement, many players feel the lack of a cohesive narrative detracts from the overall experience, leading to mixed reviews.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

71%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

29%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The reviews for the story elements of F1 24 highlight several positive aspects, particularly regarding the new career modes introduced in the game. Critics such as GameCritics and Shacknews commend the depth and customization available, allowing players to either create their own drivers or step into the shoes of real-world F1 stars. The expanded Driver Career mode is noted for its focus on decision-making and reputation, which adds a layer of immersion to the gameplay experience. Additionally, Metro GameCentral and TechRadar Gaming emphasize the introduction of unique elements such as joint careers and secret meetings with teams, which enhance the narrative experience and provide players with engaging, high-octane moments throughout their journey in the F1 world. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the absence of a traditional story mode, particularly the Braking Point storyline that was featured in previous entries. Critics like CGMagazine and PlayStation Universe express disappointment over this omission, suggesting that it detracts from the overall narrative experience that some players may have enjoyed in earlier games. Furthermore, PCGamesN points out that the lack of depth in the new story mode and disappointing tweaks to the Driver Career mode could leave some players feeling unfulfilled. This sentiment is echoed by IGN, which also laments the absence of a structured story mode that had become a hallmark of the franchise. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests a mixed reception towards the story elements of F1 24. While the new career modes and customization options are praised for their depth and engagement, the lack of a dedicated story mode, particularly the Braking Point feature, has left many players feeling that the game falls short of expectations. Critics like Daily Star and SpazioGames highlight the potential for personal journeys through the F1 circuit, yet the absence of a cohesive narrative experience remains a significant point of contention. Thus, while F1 24 introduces innovative gameplay mechanics, the departure from a traditional story mode has created a divide in the opinions of reviewers.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

F1 24 impresses critics with its revamped gameplay, especially the new Dynamic Handling system and enhanced career modes, striking a balance between realism and accessibility. However, some feel the handling lacks authenticity and leans too arcade-like, risking hardcore fans' satisfaction. Overall, it's a solid evolution for the franchise, appealing to both casual and dedicated players, but room for improvement remains.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

74%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

16%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

11%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of F1 24 has garnered a largely positive reception from critics, highlighting several significant improvements that enhance the overall racing experience. Many reviewers, such as CGMagazine and PlayStation Universe, praised the advancements in the handling model, particularly the new Dynamic Handling system, which aims to strike a balance between realism and accessibility. Critics like Metro GameCentral and Xbox Tavern emphasized the depth added to career modes, including features like driver recognition and enhanced physics models that contribute to a more authentic feel during races. Furthermore, TheSixthAxis noted the inclusion of new systems, such as driver meetings and objectives, which enrich the gameplay and add layers to the racing experience. However, not all feedback is entirely favorable, as some critics have pointed out shortcomings in the gameplay. For instance, COGconnected expressed concerns about the new handling system feeling off, resulting in cars wobbling and presenting challenges in cornering. Additionally, PCGamesN criticized the Dynamic Handling system for being overly forgiving, which could detract from the realism that hardcore racing fans seek. Critics like But Why Tho? also mentioned that while the new system makes the game more approachable for less experienced players, it may sacrifice some realism for seasoned drivers. This sentiment was echoed by Twinfinite, which noted that despite improvements, the gameplay still leans towards an arcade-like experience rather than a true simulation. Overall, the consensus among critics is that F1 24 represents a solid evolution in the franchise, with notable enhancements to gameplay mechanics and career modes. While many reviewers, including GameCritics and Daily Star, appreciated the balance between accessibility and realism, there remains a division in opinion regarding the effectiveness of the new handling system. The improvements in career mode and the introduction of engaging features have generally been well-received, but concerns about the potential for decreased realism and predictability in AI behavior indicate that there is still room for refinement. As a result, F1 24 appears to cater to both casual players and dedicated fans, though it may not fully satisfy those seeking a hardcore simulation experience.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

F1 24 impresses with stunning graphics and realistic design, hailed by critics as the best-looking F1 game yet. While details like lifelike driver models and vibrant tracks enhance immersion, some reviewers note a lack of groundbreaking improvements and inconsistencies in character design. Overall, it's a visually compelling experience, but players craving significant upgrades may be left wanting.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

67%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

33%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The overall sentiment regarding the graphics and visual design of F1 24 is predominantly positive, with many critics praising the high level of detail and realism that the game brings to the Formula 1 experience. GameCritics highlights the "top-notch" visuals that immerse players in the world of F1, while IGN refers to F1 24 as the "best-looking F1 game to date," noting significant improvements in driver likenesses and circuit updates. Critics like TheSixthAxis and COGconnected echo these sentiments, emphasizing the lifelike driver models and the vibrant, realistic designs of tracks such as Spa Francorchamps and Silverstone. The attention to detail in car behavior and environmental effects, as mentioned by Metro GameCentral, further enhances the visual experience, contributing to a sense of authenticity that many reviewers find compelling. However, there are some criticisms regarding the graphics that cannot be overlooked. PlaySense points out that while the game maintains solid graphics, it lacks groundbreaking improvements, with issues such as inconsistent character sizes in cutscenes affecting immersion. Shacknews notes that although driver models have improved, there are still "noticeable shortcuts," suggesting that some elements of the visual design may not meet the high standards set by other aspects of the game. Additionally, Twinfinite mentions only marginal improvements in visual details, indicating that some players may feel that the upgrades are not substantial enough compared to previous installments. This sentiment is echoed by TechRadar Gaming, which remarks on minimal updates beyond the Career mode, hinting at a lack of innovation in certain areas. In summary, while the graphics and visual design of F1 24 are generally well-received, with many critics praising the realism and detail, there are notable areas for improvement. The consensus among reviewers is that the game successfully enhances immersion through updated tracks and lifelike visuals, as highlighted by critics like Daily Star and GINX TV. However, the lack of significant upgrades and occasional inconsistencies in character design, as pointed out by PlaySense and Shacknews, suggest that while F1 24 is a strong entry in the series, it may not fully satisfy players seeking groundbreaking advancements in graphics. Overall, the critics agree that F1 24 offers an impressive visual experience, but there is room for further refinement in future iterations.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

F1 24's sound design shines with immersive engine sounds and realistic audio effects, winning praise from critics for enhancing the racing experience. However, the soundtrack is criticized as annoying, and limited driver commentary lacks depth, leading to repetitive audio. While it captures the essence of Formula 1, there's a clear need for more diverse and dynamic voice lines and commentary to elevate the overall experience.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

50%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

50%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of F1 24 have garnered a generally positive reception among critics, particularly highlighting the immersive audio effects and the attention to detail in engine sounds. GameCritics praised the impressive sound design, noting how the roar of engines and immersive audio effects enhance the racing experience, especially when combined with the haptic feedback and adaptive triggers of the PS5's DualSense controller. Similarly, COGconnected emphasized the authenticity of the engine sounds and the fantastic radio chatter, which contributes to a realistic racing atmosphere. Daily Star also noted the inclusion of hundreds of real-life audio driver samples that mark key moments in a race, further enhancing the realism and immersion. Overall, many critics agree that the sound design effectively captures the essence of Formula 1 racing. However, the critiques are not without their shortcomings, particularly regarding the audio elements beyond the engine sounds. PlayStation Universe described the soundtrack as annoying and soft, suggesting players might want to turn it off entirely. IGN pointed out that while there are voice bites from real drivers, they are limited and lack depth, with basic commentary that fails to capture the excitement of significant championship scenarios. Critics like Shacknews echoed this sentiment, noting the need for more diverse voice snippets and improvements in commentary related to official drivers. Additionally, while the in-game voice lines from real drivers were appreciated, But Why Tho? highlighted their repetitive nature, indicating a missed opportunity for more dynamic audio experiences. The overall consensus among critics is that while F1 24 excels in sound design, particularly with engine sounds and immersive audio effects, there are notable areas for improvement, especially regarding the diversity and depth of voice lines and commentary. Critics like TechRadar Gaming and PCGamesN acknowledged the thrilling and accurate racing experiences facilitated by improved sound design, but also pointed out that the audio experience could benefit from further enhancements. As such, while the game successfully immerses players in the racing world through its sound design, it still has room to grow in creating a more engaging and varied auditory experience.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Analysis Unavailable

Summary unavailable

TL;DR

voice acting

Description unavailable

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

F1 24 is largely praised for its technical performance across platforms, especially on PS5, where improvements and bug fixes enhance the racing experience. While minor glitches exist, they don't overshadow the overall stability and smooth gameplay. Xbox Series X faces mixed reviews due to Dynamic Handling issues, and PC shows solid performance but has some graphical fidelity concerns. Overall, critics see promising advancements over the previous game, indicating a bright future for the franchise despite the need for further updates.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

40%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

60%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of F1 24 has received generally positive feedback across different gaming platforms. On the PlayStation 5, critics such as CGMagazine and GameCritics have noted improvements from the previous installment, with CGMagazine highlighting the resolution of a force feedback bug and GameCritics emphasizing a smooth and immersive racing experience devoid of significant technical issues. Metro GameCentral also reported that early beta issues regarding strange car behavior were resolved by launch, suggesting that the developers were proactive in addressing concerns. PlaySense found that while there were minor graphical glitches and skipped name displays, these did not detract from the overall smooth performance, reinforcing the positive sentiment. Similarly, TheSixthAxis acknowledged some bugs, such as penalties not being enforced, but deemed them not disastrous, indicating that the game is largely stable. However, there are some negatives associated with the technical performance of F1 24. On PlayStation 5, PlaySense pointed out minor issues that, while not game-breaking, still impacted the experience. TheSixthAxis mentioned bugs related to AI and penalties, suggesting that the game may require further updates to fully resolve these issues. On the Xbox Series X, IGN praised the reliable performance of the Codemasters engine, but Xbox Tavern raised concerns about the new Dynamic Handling model, which negatively affected performance and immersion, indicating that a patch might be necessary. On PC, while Impulsegamer celebrated the game's performance across various systems, PCGamesN noted that textures appeared blurry and rough around the edges, which could detract from the visual quality. Shacknews also reported no significant technical issues, but the overall lack of specific praise for PC performance may indicate room for improvement. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that F1 24 has made strides in technical performance across all platforms, with most reviewers expressing satisfaction. The PlayStation 5 version is generally viewed as stable with minor issues, while the Xbox Series X version has a mixed reception due to handling model concerns. The PC version is praised for its scalability and performance, although some graphical fidelity issues were noted. Despite these minor setbacks, the majority of critics agree that F1 24 delivers a solid racing experience, with many improvements over its predecessor, hinting at a promising future for the franchise as developers continue to refine the gameplay and technical aspects.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

F1 24 boasts strong replay value with diverse game modes and engaging online races, earning praise for its multiplayer and in-depth career options. Critics highlight innovations like the Challenge Career and two-player Driver Career modes as major pluses. However, some reviewers lament the game's similarity to its predecessor and a lack of significant updates, raising concerns about limited multiplayer appeal and uninspired content in features like the Podium Pass. Overall, it's a hit for solo players but may disappoint those seeking fresh multiplayer experiences.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

58%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

37%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The overall sentiment regarding the replay value of F1 24 is predominantly positive, with many critics highlighting the diverse range of game modes that contribute to its longevity. CGMagazine emphasizes the appeal of online races, which provide repeatable content, while GameCritics praises the deep career modes and multiplayer options that cater to both solo players and social racing experiences. Additional modes such as the Challenge Career and F1 World, as noted by PlayStation Universe and Metro GameCentral, offer players daily and weekly objectives, enhancing engagement. The inclusion of a two-player Driver Career mode, highlighted by TheSixthAxis and But Why Tho?, further enriches the gaming experience, allowing friends to collaborate in their racing journeys. However, there are notable criticisms regarding the replay value that temper the overall enthusiasm. Some reviewers, such as COGconnected and PCGamesN, point out that F1 24 feels too similar to its predecessor, lacking significant innovations that would enhance replayability. Additionally, PlaySense mentions that while various game modes are available, certain aspects, like the Podium Pass, lack engaging content, and customization options are limited. IGN also raises concerns about arbitrary elements in the gameplay, such as mid-race objectives and secret meetings, which may detract from the overall experience. Twinfinite notes that players focused primarily on multiplayer may find the replay value limited, as many changes are geared towards career modes. In summary, while the critics generally agree that F1 24 offers a robust array of game modes and features that enhance replay value, there are significant caveats regarding the game's innovation and depth. The presence of multiple career modes and online options is praised, yet some critics like COGconnected and PCGamesN express disappointment over the lack of engaging updates and the game's similarity to its predecessor. Overall, the consensus suggests that F1 24 provides ample replay opportunities, particularly for those invested in single-player and career modes, but may leave some multiplayer-focused players wanting more.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

44%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

53%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding F1 24 from various critics showcases a range of positive aspects that highlight the game’s strengths. Many reviewers, such as GameCritics and Metro GameCentral, commend the immersive gameplay and detailed simulation elements, which contribute to an authentic racing experience. The game’s presentation is frequently praised, with IGN noting improved graphics and a stable handling model. The enhancements in the career mode are a recurring theme, with critics like Shacknews and PlaySense emphasizing the depth and engagement it brings to the gameplay. Additionally, the incorporation of real drivers into the career mode, as highlighted by the Guardian, adds a layer of realism that resonates well with fans of the sport. However, the reviews also reveal several notable criticisms that detract from the game's overall appeal. Critics like Xbox Tavern and COGconnected express concerns about the handling model, which some describe as poorly implemented, hindering the game's potential. The lack of significant gameplay innovations is a common point of contention, as seen in IGN's assessment that the game may not justify an upgrade for players of previous titles. Moreover, some reviewers, including PCGamesN and TechRadar Gaming, point out issues with AI behavior and the absence of standout new gameplay modes, which could leave players wanting more. In summary, while F1 24 is recognized for its solid core gameplay, immersive career mode, and impressive visuals, critics are divided on its overall value as a new installment in the series. The consensus suggests that the game successfully caters to Formula 1 fans and casual players, as noted by CGMagazine and PlaySense, but it may not meet the expectations of hardcore sim racing enthusiasts looking for significant advancements. The mixed feedback indicates that while F1 24 is a commendable entry, it falls short of being a definitive must-have upgrade for all players, as highlighted by several critics throughout their reviews.

TL;DR

TL;DR: F1 24 impresses with immersive gameplay, stunning visuals, and a robust career mode featuring real drivers, earning praise from critics like GameCritics and IGN. However, it faces criticism for a flawed handling model, lack of major innovations, and AI issues, leaving hardcore sim fans underwhelmed. While it's a solid game for casual players and F1 enthusiasts, it doesn't quite deliver a must-have experience for everyone.

MONSTER

Reviews

87 reviews found

Metro GameCentral

PlayStation 5

May 28, 2024