Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

Links

Steam

Epic

Twitch

MONSTER

Commandos: Origins

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Commandos: Origins
Item: Commandos: Origins
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2025

GenresTop-Down Perspective, Strategy, Single Player, Multiplayer

AvailableApr 9, 2025

PlatformXbox Series X, Xbox One, PlayStation 5, PC, PlayStation 4

DeveloperClaymore Game Studios

Overview

In 2019, Kalypso Media Group announced that a new 'Commandos' title was in development and last year it revealed that newly formed Claymore Game Studios was working on a next-generation installment in the Commandos strategy series. Commandos: Origins tells the story of a newly founded British commando unit that grows into a brotherhood during its operations against strategic goals of the German Wehrmacht. The player will control different characters with different abilities from an isometric perspective of the playing field and use them strategically in such a way that the given mission goal is achieved. So you will work your way through the various missions based on historical locations and missions to the respective goal.

Elsewhere

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins offers a nostalgic nod to fans with its WWII setting and iconic characters, but critics lambast its shallow execution. The fragmented narrative and lack of character depth diminish emotional engagement, making it feel like a disjointed series of missions rather than a cohesive story. While the gameplay mechanics appeal, the game fails to deliver the rich narrative experience many players crave.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

31%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

55%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

14%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The overall sentiment regarding the story of Commandos: Origins reflects a shared appreciation for its historical setting and the nostalgic elements it brings to fans of the original series. Critics like Generación Xbox and Gamepressure highlight the game’s focus on the origins of the Commandos during World War II, emphasizing the introduction of iconic characters like Jack O'Hara and the Green Beret. The narrative backdrop, while primarily serving as a vehicle for gameplay, is noted for its potential to evoke nostalgia, particularly by critics such as Vandal and Shacknews, who appreciate the return to the roots of the franchise. The game’s setting and premise resonate well with those familiar with the Commandos series, providing a familiar context for players. However, the negatives largely overshadow the positives, as many critics express disappointment in the story's execution. Eurogamer Germany and CD-Action point out that the narrative is superficial and lacks depth, with minimal character interactions and a fragmented structure that leaves missions feeling disconnected. Critics like Game8 and Gameliner echo this sentiment, describing the story as a "token narrative" that fails to engage players or leave a lasting impression. The absence of a cohesive storyline and reliance on loading screens for information rather than cutscenes further detracts from the overall experience, as noted by Gamesurf and IGN Deutschland, who criticize the lack of a continuous narrative thread. In conclusion, the consensus among critics is that while Commandos: Origins has a promising premise rooted in historical context and nostalgia, it ultimately falls short in delivering a compelling and engaging story. The game is characterized by a series of disjointed missions that prioritize gameplay over narrative depth, leading to a lack of emotional investment in the characters and their journeys. As highlighted by multiple reviewers, including Shacknews and Cultura Geek, the game's narrative shortcomings may disappoint players seeking a rich story experience, despite its strategic gameplay elements. Overall, Commandos: Origins seems to cater more to fans of the gameplay mechanics than to those looking for a robust narrative.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins impresses with its strategic planning, stealth mechanics, and character abilities, earning praise for teamwork and replayability from critics. However, it suffers from frustrating gamepad controls, bugs, and linear gameplay that dampen the experience. While it remains true to its roots, the game lacks innovation and can feel slow and overly precise. A solid tactical outing, but not a game-changer for the franchise.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

64%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

30%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

The gameplay of Commandos: Origins has been largely praised by critics for its emphasis on strategic planning, stealth mechanics, and the utilization of unique character abilities. Reviewers such as Eurogamer Germany and Generación Xbox highlight the game's focus on teamwork and tactical decision-making, which requires players to observe their surroundings carefully and devise intricate strategies to succeed in challenging missions. Critics like Cultura Geek and Shacknews appreciate the game's encouragement of experimentation, allowing players to approach objectives in multiple ways, thus enhancing replayability. The inclusion of a difficulty selector, as noted by Generación Xbox, further caters to a range of player skill levels, making the game accessible yet challenging. However, several critics have pointed out notable flaws that detract from the overall experience. TheXboxHub and TheSixthAxis mention issues with gamepad controls that hinder gameplay, while others like CD-Action and GameMAG criticize the presence of bugs and AI problems that disrupt immersion and gameplay flow. Additionally, some reviewers, including Games.cz and GameStar, express concerns about the linearity and repetitiveness of the gameplay, suggesting that it lacks the depth and innovation expected from a strategy title. The balance of character abilities has also been questioned, with Ragequit.gr noting that some elements feel diluted, making the game easier than anticipated. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while Commandos: Origins successfully retains the core elements of strategic stealth gameplay that fans of the series have come to love, it is marred by technical issues and a lack of innovation. Many reviewers, including IGN and PCGamesN, appreciate the meticulous and demanding nature of the gameplay, but they also acknowledge that the experience can feel slow and overly precise at times. Despite its challenges, the game offers a solid tactical experience that rewards careful planning and execution, but it may not fully satisfy those seeking a fresh take on the franchise.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins showcases impressive modern visuals that pay tribute to the original series, earning praise for its immersive environments and detail from some reviewers. However, it faces significant criticism for technical flaws like poor animations, performance issues, and lackluster graphics compared to prior titles. While it aims to blend nostalgia with contemporary design, the execution falls short, leaving critics divided on its overall visual impact.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

38%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

55%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of Commandos: Origins have garnered a mix of praise and criticism from various reviewers, reflecting a range of perspectives on the game's aesthetic execution. Critics such as Generación Xbox and TheXboxHub commend the game for its modern visuals that pay homage to the original series, highlighting the high detail and immersive environments that evoke the harshness of war. BaziCenter and Shacknews also emphasize the game's artistic quality and the detailed environments, which contribute to an engaging gameplay experience. The use of Unreal Engine 5 has been noted by several reviewers, including Oyungezer and Vandal, who appreciate the vibrant and expansive maps that enhance the overall visual appeal. On the flip side, there are significant criticisms regarding the graphics and visual design. Eurogamer Germany and GamingBolt point out issues with animations and performance modes, suggesting that while the visuals are acceptable, they fall short of expectations in terms of technical execution. CD-Action and Gamepressure are particularly harsh, labeling the graphics as subpar compared to previous entries in the series, with a lack of charm and dull maps that fail to impress. Additionally, several reviewers mention problems such as texture loading issues and minor visual glitches, which detract from the overall experience, as highlighted by IGN and Hobby Consolas. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Commandos: Origins presents a visually appealing experience with a blend of modern and nostalgic elements, but it is marred by technical shortcomings and inconsistencies. While some reviewers celebrate the detailed environments and artistic direction, others express disappointment with the game's performance and graphical fidelity. The game's ambition to modernize the visuals while retaining the essence of the original series is evident, yet the execution leaves room for improvement, as noted by critics like GamingBolt and GameMAG. Ultimately, Commandos: Origins offers a visually engaging experience that is both praised and critiqued, reflecting the complexities of modern game design.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins features strong voice acting and a fitting soundtrack, but its sound design is plagued by major flaws. Critics praised the performances and some musical elements, highlighting their role in enhancing the game's atmosphere. However, many found the music inconsistent and lacking tension, with severe audio issues noted, such as complete silence during quickloads. Overall, while there are commendable aspects, the audio experience falls short of expectations, underscoring the need for improvement in future games.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

27%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

40%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

33%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of Commandos: Origins have garnered a mixed reception from critics, with some positive aspects highlighted across various reviews. Notably, the voice acting has received praise for its quality, particularly from Generación Xbox, which noted that excellent performances enhance the game's narrative. Additionally, GameWatcher recognized the original soundtrack by Dynamedion as well-received, effectively complementing the game's atmosphere. Some critics, like Shacknews, appreciated how the soundtrack enhances the overall experience without overpowering the gameplay, particularly during stealth and strategy elements. Hobby Consolas also noted the effective military-themed music and Spanish voice acting, capturing the essence of the original game. On the downside, many critics pointed out significant issues with the sound design and music. BaziCenter criticized the music for failing to match the game's excitement and not enhancing tension during gameplay. CD-Action echoed this sentiment, stating that the music was out of sync with the game's atmosphere and lacking the quality of previous installments. Furthermore, GameStar highlighted severe sound issues, including complete audio loss during quickloads, which detracted from the overall experience. Critics like Games.cz and Oyungezer also expressed disappointment with the sound design, mentioning unmemorable music and minimal ambient sounds, which failed to leave a lasting impression. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates that while there are some commendable elements in the sound design and music of Commandos: Origins, significant flaws overshadow these positives. The quality of voice acting received praise, but the music and sound design were often deemed inconsistent or lacking in impact. Critics like IGN France acknowledged some sound issues that did not significantly detract from the experience, suggesting that while the game has potential, it falls short in delivering a cohesive audio experience. The mixed reviews suggest that the game's sound elements may not meet the expectations set by its predecessors, leaving room for improvement in future installments.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

"Commandos: Origins" voice acting receives mixed reviews—while some praise the Spanish performances for their charm and nostalgia (Generación Xbox, Hobby Consolas), others criticize them for being mediocre or awkward (GamingBolt, Game8). The divide highlights a split in audience reception, leaving some players satisfied and others underwhelmed.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

14%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

86%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The opinions regarding the voice acting in "Commandos: Origins" reveal a mix of positive sentiments from several critics. Generación Xbox commends the Spanish voice acting, highlighting its well-executed nature and its contribution to an enjoyable gaming experience. Similarly, Vandal appreciates the Spanish voice acting, noting its positive impact despite some minor audio issues. Hobby Consolas also praises the voice acting for successfully imitating the original performances, which adds a nostalgic touch to the game. TheSixthAxis points out the charm brought by the Sapper's clipped English accent, suggesting that certain performances can enhance character engagement and overall enjoyment. However, not all reviews share the same level of enthusiasm. GamingBolt describes the voice acting as adequate but lacking in standout moments, indicating a sense of mediocrity. Game8 takes a more critical stance, labeling the voice acting as awkward and of low quality, which detracts from the immersive experience. Gamesurf echoes this sentiment by stating that while the voice acting is adequate, it lacks personality, resulting in a flat overall experience. This divergence in opinions highlights a significant gap in the perceived quality of the voice performances. In summary, the overall consensus among critics is mixed. While some, like Generación Xbox and Hobby Consolas, find the voice acting to be well-executed and nostalgic, others, such as Game8 and GamingBolt, express disappointment in its lack of impact and quality. This division suggests that while certain aspects of the voice acting resonate positively with some players, others may find it falls short of expectations, leading to a varied reception in the gaming community.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins delivers a mixed bag of technical performance across platforms. The Xbox Series X and PS5 versions have their strengths, with generally smooth gameplay, but are not free from glitches. The PC version, however, is plagued with game-breaking bugs, poor optimization, and frustrating AI, making it the least favorable choice. Critics agree that substantial technical issues hinder overall enjoyment, suggesting players should wait for patches to fully appreciate the game.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

57%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

43%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of Commandos: Origins varies significantly across different gaming platforms, with some positive notes especially for console players. On the Xbox Series X, critics like Eurogamer Germany found that the game runs well with only minor glitches, suggesting a generally stable experience. Similarly, BaziCenter reported smooth gameplay on the PS5, indicating that the console version has its strengths. While the Xbox Series X has received mixed feedback, it appears to fare better than the PC version, which several critics have noted as having a more polished experience compared to the issues faced on PC. However, the negatives are quite pronounced across all platforms, particularly on PC. Many reviewers, including CD-Action and Gameliner, pointed out numerous bugs, crashes, and performance issues that significantly detract from gameplay. The PC version is often described as plagued by game-breaking bugs, poor optimization, and frustrating AI behavior, as noted by GameMAG and Gamepressure. On the PS5, while BaziCenter acknowledged some positives, other critics like GamingBolt and TheSixthAxis highlighted significant technical issues such as screen tearing and poor frame rates, indicating that the PS5 version also suffers from its share of problems. The Xbox Series X, while performing relatively better, is still criticized for crashes and performance inconsistencies, as mentioned by Generación Xbox and TheXboxHub. Overall, the consensus among critics is that Commandos: Origins has a mixed technical performance across all platforms. While the Xbox Series X and PS5 versions show some promise, they are not without their flaws, and the PC version appears to be the most troubled, with many reviewers citing a lack of thorough quality assurance. Despite some improvements through updates, as noted by Generación Xbox and IGN France, the game still faces substantial technical challenges that hinder the overall experience. Critics like Ragequit.gr and Hobby Consolas emphasize that the technical issues present a significant barrier to enjoyment, suggesting that players may need to wait for further patches to fully appreciate the game.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins garners mixed reviews on replay value. Critics praise its strategic depth and cooperative multiplayer, highlighting the potential for varied gameplay and skill refinement. However, concerns about linearity, technical issues, and repetitive missions dampen enthusiasm. While fans of tactical games may find satisfaction, those seeking narrative cohesion and diverse experiences might be left wanting. Overall, a solid choice for strategy enthusiasts but not without significant drawbacks.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

21%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

64%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

14%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

The opinions regarding the replay value of Commandos: Origins reveal a generally positive sentiment among several critics, especially those who appreciate the game's strategic depth and variety. Eurogamer Germany highlights the encouragement of experimentation and the inclusion of cooperative multiplayer, which enhances the overall replayability. Similarly, Generación Xbox notes the multiple missions and secondary objectives that cater to players eager to refine their skills. Critics like IGN and Shacknews emphasize the game's potential for extensive gameplay hours and the encouragement to explore different strategies, which collectively suggest a robust replay value for fans of tactical gameplay. However, not all reviews are as enthusiastic. Some critics express concerns about the game's replayability being diminished by technical issues, linearity, and a lack of cohesive narrative. For instance, Gamepressure points out that the linear stages and absence of non-linear gameplay reduce engagement, while Gameliner and Multiplayer.it suggest that the repetitive nature of missions and lack of incentives for alternative solutions limit the desire to replay. Oyungezer further criticizes the absence of engaging achievements and strategic depth, indicating that these factors may detract from the overall replay value. Overall, the consensus among critics indicates that Commandos: Origins offers a mixed bag in terms of replay value. While many reviewers, such as PCGamesN and GamingBolt, appreciate the game's complexity and the various ways to approach missions, others like Slant Magazine and CD-Action caution against potential drawbacks that could hinder replayability. Ultimately, the game seems to cater well to fans of the genre who enjoy tactical challenges, but it may not resonate as strongly with those seeking a more cohesive narrative or varied gameplay experiences.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

36%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

60%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment surrounding Commandos: Origins is predominantly positive, with many critics praising its return to the franchise's roots and its engaging gameplay mechanics. Reviewers such as Eurogamer Germany and TheXboxHub highlight the game's enjoyable and challenging nature, suggesting that it successfully captures the essence of the original series. Critics like Shacknews and IGN laud it as a love letter to the original games, emphasizing its strategic depth and nostalgic appeal. The game is also recognized for its intricate level design and modern visuals, which enhance the tactical experience. Generación Xbox notes that, despite some initial technical challenges, updates have improved the overall experience, making it a worthy addition to the franchise. However, Commandos: Origins is not without its flaws, with many critics pointing out significant technical issues that detract from the overall experience. Reviewers such as CD-Action and Gameliner express disappointment, labeling it a missed opportunity due to bugs and a lack of narrative cohesion. Critics like TheSixthAxis and GameStar mention frustrating controls and technical shortcomings that hinder gameplay, while Gamepressure and GameMAG describe the game as mediocre, lacking innovation and depth. The consensus among several critics is that while the game has solid foundations, it suffers from a lack of polish and can be tedious at times, which may deter new players. The overall consensus among critics is that Commandos: Origins is a commendable return for the franchise, appealing primarily to long-time fans while facing challenges that could limit its broader appeal. Many reviewers, including PCGamesN and SECTOR.sk, recognize its potential as a strategic game but caution that significant technical issues need to be addressed for it to fully meet expectations. While some critics recommend it for its nostalgic value and engaging gameplay, others, like Game8 and Ragequit.gr, suggest waiting for patches and improvements before diving in. Ultimately, the game is seen as a solid, albeit flawed, entry in the real-time tactics genre, with a mix of enjoyment and frustration that reflects its ambitious yet imperfect execution.

TL;DR

Commandos: Origins earns mixed reviews, praised for its nostalgic gameplay and strategic depth but criticized for significant technical issues and frustrating controls. While it effectively captures the franchise's essence, bugs and lack of polish may deter new players. It's a solid comeback for fans, but potential buyers might want to wait for patches before diving in.

MONSTER

Reviews

59 reviews found

100

SECTOR.sk

Apr 9, 2025