Search for games

Type three or more characters to start searching

New Tales from the Borderlands cover image

Links

MONSTER

New Tales from the Borderlands

Name: Comprehensive Review and Analysis of New Tales from the Borderlands
Item: New Tales from the Borderlands
Author: MonsterCritic Editorial Team

2022

GenresAdventure, Action, Third Person Perspective, Single Player

AvailableOct 21, 2022

PlatformXbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PlayStation 5

DeveloperGearbox Software

Overview

Decide the fates of altruistic scientist Anu, her ambitious, "streetwise" brother Octavio, and the fierce, frogurt-slinging Fran. Claw and con your way through five thrilling chapters!

Elsewhere

5.6

Game analysis

Monster Scorecard

EXPAND ALL

Story and Narrative

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands offers engaging character dynamics and humor, praised for its relatable themes and unique protagonists. However, critics largely condemn its execution, citing poor pacing, incoherent plot, and inconsistent character development. While there are moments of charm, the overall narrative fails to resonate, leaving players disappointed in a franchise known for strong storytelling.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR STORY

Story Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

40%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

37%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

23%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the story and narrative.

The story of New Tales from the Borderlands has garnered a mix of positive feedback from several critics, highlighting its engaging character dynamics and humorous narrative style. Reviewers like Atomix praised the story as the strongest aspect of the game, showcasing an engaging narrative set on Promethea with unique protagonists. Similarly, Digital Trends noted the humor and relatability of the characters, emphasizing the exploration of themes such as sibling relationships and corporate greed. Critics like AusGamers and GamesRadar+ appreciated the character-driven narrative, suggesting that it effectively combines the franchise's signature humor with heartfelt moments, making players care about the characters' journeys. However, the overall sentiment among critics leans heavily towards the negative, with many pointing out significant flaws in the story's execution. Destructoid criticized the pacing and lack of character development, while Push Square found the plot incoherent and the stakes low, leading to an unsatisfying conclusion. Inverse echoed similar sentiments, describing the writing as hamfisted and the humor as exploitative. Many reviewers, including Wccftech and GamingTrend, noted that the story felt poorly structured and unfocused, with inconsistent character arcs that made it difficult to invest in the protagonists' journeys. The overall consensus among critics suggests that while New Tales from the Borderlands attempts to capture the charm and humor of its predecessor, it ultimately falls short in delivering a cohesive and engaging narrative. Critics like IGN France and Shacknews highlighted the inconsistencies and pacing issues that detracted from the overall experience, while others like GamingBolt acknowledged some entertaining moments but noted a lack of consistent engagement. Despite a few positive reviews that praised character growth and emotional depth, the majority of critics agree that the game struggles to resonate with players, leaving them wanting more from a franchise known for its vibrant storytelling.

TL;DR

story and narrative

Gameplay Mechanics

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands offers a narrative-rich experience with impactful dialogue choices and unique character gadgets, but critics largely find the gameplay lackluster. Many describe it as overly simplistic, reliant on quick-time events, and more akin to an interactive movie than a game. While the storytelling has its strengths, the overall experience is criticized for being linear and monotonous, failing to meet the expectations set by its predecessors. Ultimately, it struggles to balance engaging gameplay with its narrative ambition, leaving many players disappointed.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR GAMEPLAY

Gameplay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

68%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

26%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the gameplay mechanics.

In reviewing the gameplay of New Tales from the Borderlands, several critics highlighted some positive aspects, particularly the narrative-driven approach that allows for meaningful dialogue choices. For instance, GameSpot and SpazioGames noted that the decision-making elements can significantly impact the story, providing players with a sense of agency in shaping their experience. Additionally, Twinfinite appreciated the inclusion of unique character gadgets and mini-games, which, while not always successful, added a layer of variety to the gameplay. Critics like IGN Adria acknowledged the third-person perspective as enhancing control and environmental awareness, suggesting that the game does offer some engaging moments amidst its gameplay structure. However, the overwhelming sentiment among critics is one of disappointment regarding the gameplay's depth and engagement. Many reviewers, including GameOver.gr and Destructoid, criticized the gameplay for being overly simplistic, with a heavy reliance on quick-time events (QTEs) that detract from the overall experience. Critics such as Digital Trends and Jeuxvideo.com pointed out that the gameplay lacks innovation and often feels like an interactive movie rather than a true game, with minimal exploration and repetitive mechanics. The consensus is that the gameplay is monotonous, with many critics describing it as passive and lacking the engaging mechanics found in its predecessor, leading to a sense of frustration for players seeking a more interactive experience. Overall, the consensus among critics is that New Tales from the Borderlands fails to live up to the expectations set by previous titles in the genre. While there are some redeeming qualities, such as the narrative choices and character interactions, the gameplay is largely seen as linear and uninspired. Reviewers like PC Gamer and Hardcore Gamer echoed the sentiment that the QTEs and simplistic puzzles limit player engagement, making the experience feel scripted and unchallenging. As a result, New Tales from the Borderlands appears to struggle to find a balance between storytelling and gameplay, ultimately leaving many critics feeling that it does not innovate or elevate the genre as hoped.

TL;DR

gameplay mechanics

Graphics and Visual Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands dazzles with vibrant visuals and improved cel-shading, earning praise for its hand-drawn aesthetic and enhanced character animations. Critics highlight its immersive graphics, yet some note flaws in secondary character animations and overall execution. While not reaching the heights of other contemporary games, the consensus is that it successfully captures the Borderlands style, making it a visually appealing addition to the franchise.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VISUALS

Visual Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

77%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

23%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the graphics and visual design.

The graphics and visual design of New Tales from the Borderlands have been met with generally positive feedback from critics, highlighting several key strengths. Many reviewers, such as CGMagazine and GameSkinny, praised the game for its gorgeous visuals and vibrant color palette, effectively capturing the hand-drawn aesthetic that the series is known for. Critics like PlayStation Universe and MondoXbox noted significant improvements in cel-shading graphics, character detail, and environmental design compared to previous Telltale titles. The use of performance capture technology has also been commended, with outlets like AusGamers and TheSixthAxis emphasizing how it enhances character animations and expressiveness, contributing to a more immersive experience. However, not all feedback has been positive, as several critics pointed out notable shortcomings. GameOver.gr criticized the overall execution of the game, suggesting that while the visuals are beautiful, they are overshadowed by other issues. Worth Playing and Gamer.nl highlighted problems with facial animations, indicating that while main character models look great, the body movements and expressions of secondary characters can appear over-animated or lifeless. Additionally, some reviewers, such as IGN France and Gamer.nl, mentioned that although the graphics have improved, they still do not reach the level of graphical excellence found in other contemporary titles, leading to a mixed perception of the game's visual fidelity. Overall, the consensus among critics is that New Tales from the Borderlands successfully retains the iconic Borderlands art style while making significant advancements in graphics and visual design. Many reviewers, including Digital Trends and Shacknews, noted the game's polished visuals and improved character animations, which enhance the storytelling experience. Despite some criticisms regarding facial animations and execution, the majority of critics agree that the game presents a visually appealing and engaging experience that aligns well with the franchise's established aesthetic. The combination of vibrant colors, detailed environments, and improved technology has left a positive impression, suggesting that the game is a worthy addition to the Borderlands universe.

TL;DR

graphics and visual design

Music and Sound Design

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands shines with exceptional voice acting that brings characters to life, earning praise for emotional depth. However, the soundtrack disappoints, feeling poorly integrated and lacking the memorable impact of previous games in the series. Critics highlight a divide: while voice performances are a standout, the music falls flat, suggesting missed opportunities to enhance the game's auditory experience. Overall, a mixed reception with strong voices but weak tunes.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR SOUND DESIGN

Sound Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

35%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

54%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

11%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the music and sound design.

The sound design and music of New Tales from the Borderlands have garnered a range of positive feedback from critics, particularly regarding the voice acting. Many reviewers, including Dexerto and GameSkinny, praised the strong performances that bring the characters to life, highlighting the emotional depth conveyed through the voice work. Critics such as COGconnected and Checkpoint Gaming also noted the impressive quality of the voice acting, emphasizing how it enhances the unique personalities of the characters. Additionally, some reviewers, like Hardcore Gamer and Wccftech, acknowledged the catchy soundtrack, which, despite some criticisms, contributes positively to the overall gameplay experience. The integration of musical numbers and montages, as mentioned by IGN, also adds a dynamic element to the storytelling. Conversely, there are significant criticisms regarding the soundtrack and its integration within the game. Push Square and TheSixthAxis highlighted that the music feels poorly integrated and lacks the expert execution seen in the original Borderlands title. Many critics, including MondoXbox and Gamer.nl, echoed sentiments that the soundtrack does not have the same impact or memorability as its predecessor, with some describing it as bland or lacking in memorable themes. The disconnect between the music and on-screen action was also noted by TheXboxHub, which detracted from the overall experience. Furthermore, GamersRD pointed out the limitation of having the game dubbed only in English, which could be cumbersome for non-English speakers. Overall, the consensus among critics is mixed, with a clear divide between the appreciation for the voice acting and the disappointment in the music and sound design. While the voice performances are widely regarded as exceptional, enhancing the narrative and character engagement, the music fails to resonate with many reviewers. Critics like Worth Playing and XboxAddict suggest that the soundtrack is adequate but lacks the strength of previous entries, indicating a missed opportunity to build on the franchise's musical legacy. As such, while the voice acting stands out as a highlight, the overall sound design and music leave room for improvement, suggesting that New Tales from the Borderlands may not fully capture the auditory essence that fans of the series have come to expect.

TL;DR

music and sound design

Voice Acting

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

The voice acting in New Tales from the Borderlands is largely praised for its strong performances and character portrayals, enhancing the game's charm and humor. Critics highlight memorable voices that enrich the narrative, though some note issues with theatricality and the exclusive English voiceovers, which may alienate non-English speakers. Overall, the consensus is positive, marking voice acting as a standout feature despite some criticisms.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR VOICE ACTING

Acting Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

78%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

18%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the voice acting.

The voice acting in New Tales from the Borderlands has garnered significant praise from a majority of critics, highlighting the strong performances and effective character portrayals. Reviewers from outlets like Dexerto and Games.cz emphasized that the cast brings the material to life, with performances that enhance the overall experience. Critics such as Checkpoint Gaming and Digital Trends echoed this sentiment, noting that the voice actors effectively convey the unique personalities of the characters, contributing to the game's charm. Additionally, IGN and its regional counterparts praised the voice acting as a strong point, with memorable performances that bolster the humor and immersion of the narrative. However, not all feedback has been overwhelmingly positive. Some critics, like GameOver.gr, criticized the voice acting for being overly theatrical and exaggerated, suggesting that it detracts from the overall experience. Additionally, GamersRD pointed out that the game’s exclusive English voice acting may alienate non-English speakers, potentially diminishing their enjoyment. TheXboxHub also offered a more lukewarm perspective, describing the voiceovers as unremarkable, with only specific characters, like the sentient robots, standing out. This mixed feedback indicates that while many appreciated the performances, there were notable concerns regarding delivery and accessibility. Overall, the consensus among critics leans towards a favorable view of the voice acting in New Tales from the Borderlands. Despite some dissenting opinions regarding theatricality and language limitations, the majority of reviews highlight the quality of the performances and their contribution to character development and narrative engagement. Critics like COGconnected and Player 2 noted that the voice acting not only enhances comedic timing but also enriches the overall atmosphere of the game. This positive reception suggests that, while there are areas for improvement, the voice acting remains one of the standout features of the game, successfully capturing the essence of its characters and story.

TL;DR

voice acting

Technical Performance

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands shines on PS5 and PC with smooth performance and no major bugs, earning mostly positive reviews for visuals and loading times. However, the Xbox Series X version is plagued by issues like environment loading and voiceover sync problems, marking a stark contrast. While PS5 is the standout platform, PC receives some minor critique, revealing significant disparities in performance that suggest more work is needed, especially for Xbox users.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE

Tech Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

42%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

56%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the technical performance.

The technical performance of New Tales from the Borderlands has garnered predominantly positive feedback across various platforms. On the PlayStation 5, critics such as CGMagazine, GamersRD, and PlayStation Universe reported a seamless experience with no performance issues, improved texture loading times, and overall great visuals. Worth Playing echoed these sentiments, highlighting a bug-free playthrough. Similarly, the PC version received commendations from multiple reviewers, including CD-Action and Digital Trends, who noted smooth performance and the absence of major technical issues, attributing this success to the use of Unreal Engine 4. Other critics like Shacknews and Press Start Australia praised the game for solid frame rates and swift loading times, reinforcing the game's technical stability across the board. However, the Xbox Series X version faced notable criticisms, with Gaming Age reporting performance issues such as incomplete environment loading and voiceover sync problems. This contrasts sharply with the positive feedback from the PS5 and PC versions. On PC, while many reviewers praised the overall performance, some, like GamesRadar+ and IGN Italia, pointed out specific technical issues, including screen slowdowns and bugs on the Steam Deck. Additionally, GamingTrend mentioned a glitch affecting save functionality, which could detract from the overall experience for some players. These inconsistencies highlight a disparity in performance across platforms, particularly for Xbox users. Overall, the consensus among critics suggests that New Tales from the Borderlands delivers a solid technical performance, particularly on PS5 and PC. The PS5 experience stands out as the most polished, with multiple reviewers confirming its stability and lack of issues. Meanwhile, the PC version is largely well-received, though it faces some minor criticisms regarding specific glitches and performance hiccups. The Xbox Series X version, however, appears to lag behind, with significant performance issues reported by some critics. This variation in performance across platforms indicates that while the game has made strides in technical execution, there are still areas for improvement, particularly for Xbox players.

TL;DR

technical performance

Replay Value

Expand for full analysis

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands teases replay value with branching narratives and multiple endings, but critics largely agree that its linear structure and limited choices diminish the incentive to revisit. While some aspects like collectibles provide depth, the game ultimately feels like a one-time experience with minimal impact from player decisions, leaving many reviewers unimpressed.

SCORE DISTRIBUTION FOR REPLAY VALUE

Replay Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

10%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

57%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

33%

Based on analyzing reviews that specifically scored or critiqued the replay value.

In reviewing the opinions of various critics regarding the replay value of New Tales from the Borderlands, a few positive aspects emerge. Some reviewers, such as MondoXbox and WellPlayed, highlight the game's potential for replayability through multiple endings and the ability to revisit episodes, which can encourage players to explore different choices and outcomes. Critics like Eurogamer Italy and SpazioGames also mention that the game allows for exploration of various story branches, which could entice players to engage with the narrative again. Additionally, some reviewers, such as PC Gamer, point out that features like character bonding ratings and collectibles can add layers to the experience, suggesting that there is some merit in revisiting the game. However, the overwhelming sentiment among critics leans towards a lack of significant replay value. GameOver.gr and Games.cz emphasize the limited choices and superficial consequences, making it unlikely for players to want to revisit the game after their initial playthrough. Critics like Softpedia and Destructoid express that the game feels like a one-time experience, with little incentive to replay due to its linear structure and minimal impact from player decisions. The repetitive nature of gameplay and the disappointment in narrative depth, as noted by Push Square and Gamer.nl, further contribute to the overall perception that the game does not offer a compelling reason to engage in multiple playthroughs. Overall, the consensus among critics is that while New Tales from the Borderlands has some elements that could offer replay value, such as branching narratives and multiple endings, these features are overshadowed by the game's linearity and the lack of meaningful choices. Many reviewers, including Atomix and AusGamers, agree that the impact of decisions feels limited, leading to a general feeling that the game may not be worth revisiting. Critics like IGN Spain and New Game Network reinforce this sentiment, suggesting that the game is more of a one-time experience rather than one that encourages exploration through multiple playthroughs.

TL;DR

replay value

Overall Verdict

MONSTER

OVERALL SCORE DISTRIBUTION

Monster Score

Positive Reviews (80-100)

25%

Mixed Reviews (50-79)

67%

Negative Reviews (0-49)

Based on analyzing all available reviews that scored and critiqued the game.

The overall sentiment regarding New Tales from the Borderlands showcases a mixed bag of opinions, with several critics highlighting positive aspects of the game. Many reviewers, including SpazioGames and GamesRadar+, appreciate the humor and engaging narrative that the game brings to the table. Critics like Cognconnected laud the writing and character development, emphasizing that the game is "immensely entertaining" and well-acted. Additionally, Everyeye.it notes that the game successfully revives the series, offering humor and engaging characters that resonate with fans. The visuals and voice acting have also been praised across various reviews, with IGN Adria mentioning the game's impressive presentation and enjoyable gameplay. However, the negatives are pronounced and form a significant part of the critical discourse. Many reviewers express disappointment, particularly in comparison to the original Tales from the Borderlands. Critics such as Push Square and Destructoid describe the game as a "spectacular misfire" and "highly negative," respectively, pointing out the lack of charismatic characters and unfunny jokes that ultimately ruin the experience. GamingTrend and Shindig echo similar sentiments, criticizing the game's poor narrative and unlikable characters. The consensus among several critics is that the game feels rushed and lacks the charm and depth of its predecessor, with PC Gamer stating that it ultimately feels like a mixed experience. Overall, the consensus among critics leans toward disappointment, particularly for those familiar with the original title. While some reviewers like Gaming Age and Player 2 recommend the game for fans, suggesting it captures the essence of the series, the majority express concerns about its shortcomings. Critics like IGN France and Jeuxvideo.com highlight the game's messy story and repetitive gameplay, indicating that it falls short of expectations. In conclusion, while New Tales from the Borderlands has its moments of humor and engaging elements, it struggles to deliver a coherent and compelling experience, leaving many fans and critics feeling let down.

TL;DR

New Tales from the Borderlands delivers a split verdict: while some praise its humor, engaging narrative, and impressive visuals, many critics slam it as a disappointing sequel that lacks the charm and depth of the original. Key flaws include unlikable characters, unfunny jokes, and a rushed, messy story. Despite a few recommendations for die-hard fans, the overall sentiment leans towards frustration, leaving players feeling let down by a game that could have been much more.

MONSTER

Reviews

114 reviews found

COGconnected

Oct 20, 2022